SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
Capital bill roundup

Saturday, May 31, 2008

* Funding

To pay for the construction plan, lawmakers were considering Gov. Rod Blagojevich’s multibillion-dollar proposal to expand gambling and lease of the state lottery.

Included in the mix was the possibility of adding three new casinos, including one in Chicago, one in its suburbs and one in a downstate city.

* Opposition from casinos

The Illinois Casino Gaming Association opposed both the House and Senate bills, saying they add too much gambling to an already-shrinking market.

* House Speaker Madigan ain’t happy, either

Madigan reiterated the reason behind lawmakers’ hesitation: “It’s all about trust. It’s all about trust and whether people are prepared to trust Gov. Blagojevich and trust his record of broken promises.”

* Another Lottery shell game?

The state would lease out its rights to upward of 80 percent of the state lottery proceeds for nearly 65 years in exchange for at least $10 billion upfront, with $3 billion set aside for education and $7 billion for construction projects.

So, how much does the lottery bring in annually?

The answer: $600 million. […]

But whoever ends up with the lottery, will likely make at least three times that much over the course of this deal.

80 percent of $600 million is $480 million. Multiply that by the possible length of the lease (65 years) and you get $31.2 billion.

So the state’s giving up $31.2 billion for $10 billion now.

- Posted by Rich Miller        


35 Comments
  1. - Capital Bill - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 8:31 am:

    Blagoof dropped in a unrequested $150 hospital construction program last night that sent heads spinning. Admin announced program was supported by the Hospital Assoc.
    Surprise
    So What
    None of those who need to vote for this mess seemed too excited. Insiders say The President blasted Blagoof for the bungle.


  2. - Champaign Mike - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 8:57 am:

    Lottery lease sounds like a great deal for the buyer. The State, lottery players and the people of Illinois get screwed. Sounds to me like Blago, Emil and GTECH will be laughing all the way to the bank. But, then again, what else is new??


  3. - jj - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 9:02 am:

    “Capital Bill” is funny - you guys are working overtime trying to kill this thing through the media.

    Must be a sign of weakness…


  4. - Six Degrees of Separation - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 9:05 am:

    To be fair, the $600 million increments of that $31.2 billion that would be traded for upfront cash probably won’t be worth much in today’s dollars in the year 2070 or thereabouts…assuming state lottery revenues are stagnant for the next 65 years in actual dollars.

    However, if the state could keep the lottery and grow its revenues to keep up or ahead of inflation, the trade doesn’t look as good.


  5. - Six Degrees of Separation - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 9:07 am:

    the $600 million increments

    …which are actually $480 million increments minus the share retained by the state.


  6. - jj - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 9:15 am:

    “So the state’s giving up $31.2 billion for $10 billion now.”

    Rich - $10 billion, at 5% interest, over 65 years, is $238 billion.

    Just inflation alone (3% a year), would make that $10 billion worth $68 billion in 2073 dollars.


  7. - Bill - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 9:24 am:

    In order for the state to grow lottery revenue it would have to expand the distribution system, have more games with smaller payouts, and greatly increase marketing to increase sales. These are things that the state has been unable or unwilling to do but which a private operator could accomplish fairly easily. Sales have been flat for a few years now and, I predict, will continue to be flat or drop unless the above are done. The state should not be in this business in the first place. Add in the cost savings from its somewhat bloated and unefficient operation and the lease is a good deal for the state.


  8. - Champaign Mike - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 9:50 am:

    jj, I must say, I love your reasoning:

    Rich - $10 billion, at 5% interest, over 65 years, is $238 billion.

    You are so right jj, we all know that money will sit in the bank and earn interest. Gosh, what were we thinking.

    I have to get to the bank before noon. I am going to write a check for $10 billion and let Blago invest it for me.

    jj you have to be kidding.


  9. - Disgusted - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 9:54 am:

    I wish I could understand why the elected inhabitants of the Statehouse can’t understand that not only do we need money to pay bills, we need to stop wasting money. I never hear or read that anyone of these people have come up with any cost-saving ideas for this state. I guarantee if you asked the rank and file state employees, they could come up with dozens. But no one asks them and if they take it to a supervisor, it either is pooh-poohed or they slap their name on it and take credit. Then it all falls into the dark hole of committees. Selling state assets and borrowing to fulfill commitments is fool-hardy. It’s the payday loan concept in state government. Just stop the unnecessary spending and use some creative and workable ideas to reduce costs. The taxpayers do this at home every day. Surely these so-called leaders, all of whom are supposedly educated people, can do the same and save this state from bankruptcy.


  10. - jj - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 10:05 am:

    Champaign Mike -

    I was pointing out the foolishness in John Patterson’s math and reasoning.

    He was using 2073 dollars vs. 2008 dollars. That’s just ridiculous to do and shows a complete lack of understanding of finances and money in general.

    You can’t possibly be defending him…


  11. - Six Degrees of Separation - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 10:42 am:

    Champaign Mike,

    You are correct that the state is not going to “invest” $10 bn. and let it mature over 65 years in a financial instrument. However, capital projects like buildings, if bought, do have a capital value and may appreciate considerably in value over that course of time. Some items, like roads, bridges and transit facilities, have a tendency to deteriorate over time but could provide serviceability throughout the investment period if built stoutly enough, and promote the general economy and welfare of the state.


  12. - Michelle Flaherty - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 10:45 am:

    It’s not like the state’s using the lottery lease to pay down debt or balance the budget. It’s using it to buy MORE stuff.


  13. - Six Degrees of Separation - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 10:57 am:

    Michelle-

    Also to be fair, a lot of the capital program is to buy new stuff to replace worn out or obsolete stuff that doesn’t function well anymore.

    Not defending capital projects of questionable value, or questionable methods of financing here.


  14. - Louis G. Atsaves - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 11:31 am:

    The bottom line is that none of our elected Senators and Representatives will have a clue on what they are ultimately voting on, other than their leadership and budget negotiators.

    What a system.


  15. - Little Egypt - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 11:35 am:

    How about the “downstate” casino go to Benton and leave IDOT’s Traffic Safety in Springfield. Now that would surely get Gary Forby re-elected.


  16. - wordslinger - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 11:41 am:

    The lottery is a cash cow. Suckers willingly give you money every day. Why would you give that up for a one-time bump? Rather than leasing, why not just pledge a portion to a Revenue Bond issue for capital projects?


  17. - Gregor - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 11:44 am:

    Rod and his finance team have been watching too many J.G. Wentworth commercials.


  18. - Arthur Andersen - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 12:30 pm:

    Don’t pick on Patterson. He’s a journalist, not a financial analyst.

    The way real numbers crunchers crunch a deal like this is to figure out what the value of the stream of payments is worth today compared to the value of the asset. According to AA’s handy financial calculator: 65 annual payments of $480 million at the State’s borrowing rate of 6% reveals 80% of the Lottery is worth: (drum roll)

    ~$7,818,780,000.00~

    Oops.

    On one hand, this back of the envelope calculation assumes no change in revenue. Also, there are numerous qualitative factors that could affect the actual value of the Lottery to a private operator.

    On the other hand, as the Speaker said, it’s all about trust. Is there anyone left who trusts Filan’s fiscal follies?


  19. - zatoichi - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 12:42 pm:

    The assumption in the gambling and lottery issues is that they will keep growing and bringing in more money from people facing other rising expenses in their life. The potential dollars sound great and easy to talk about. Where are the customer projections of the number of butts in the seats needed to actually generate those dollars? There are enough people to consistently fill 3 additional casinos and drop lots more money? They talking 3 Trump/Wynn style LV mega casinos or more boats at the dock? And that guy with the $5 lottery pop at the store…he’ll still be buying 3 of those in 3 years when the price goes to $10 while gas is $7 a gallon and cigs are $15 a pack, right?. Please. Must be orange koolaid in the glass next to that Excel spreadsheet. Got Blue Moon in mine.


  20. - Professor of Finance - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 12:49 pm:

    You ALL FAIL!

    Apparently you missed the class, or were sound asleep, during the lecture on PRESENT VALUE.

    Whomever would be submitting a bid would be paying in 2008 dollars, not in 2073 dollars. So the investor would value the stream of future receipts in those (2008) dollars.

    Using the numbers cited, an 80% interest in a $600M per year stream of future earnings for 65 years at 5% interest yields a Present Value of $9.197 billion (rounded). That is what an investor would be willing to pay in 2008 dollars.

    The discount rate (5% in this example) would typically take into account alternate investment opportunities, risk and inflation, among other factors. As such, one could obviously argue for a higher discount rate. So let’s assume a 9% rate, rather than 5%. At a 9% discount rate, a rational investor would be willing to pay up to about $5,314 billion (again rounded). So if Blago can net $10 billion, that’s a great deal for the State.

    Homework Question for bonus points (since you all failed the first exam): What is the discount rate that would give you a $10 billion net present value?


  21. - Professor of Finance - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 12:53 pm:

    Amendment;

    Just saw Arthur Andersen’s post. At least someone was awake during that class. A+ to AA!


  22. - Arthur Andersen - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 2:00 pm:

    Professor: 4.53%.


  23. - jj - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 2:15 pm:

    Lottery just passed 43-8-3.

    That landslide just made that ledge Madigan is standing on even smaller…


  24. - Bill - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 2:56 pm:

    They must have read AA’s and the Professor’s comments.


  25. - plutocrat03 - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 3:26 pm:

    My question is far simpler than future time value of money.

    What revenue will plug the $480 million ANNUAL hole when we divert 80% of the lottery revenue?


  26. - Rich Miller - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 3:31 pm:

    plutocrat03, the state will retain partial ownership, and put some of the sales proceeds in a trust fund.


  27. - SIUPROF - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 3:33 pm:

    The way to make this work is to invest enough of the 10 Billion to produce the 480 million per year they are giving up-Then no harm done.


  28. - some former legislative intern - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 3:34 pm:

    Pluto hits it right on the head…what will replace the lottery money that is currenty used in the annual budget?


  29. - Rich Miller - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 3:35 pm:

    I just did.


  30. - Just Me - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 7:10 pm:

    “The way to make this work is to invest enough of the 10 Billion to produce the 480 million per year they are giving up-Then no harm done.

    Can’t be done. If you could make $480 million per year for investing $10 billion in the stock and bond market, for doing essentially nothing, why would you pay Illinois $10 billion for the chance to get the same stream from the lottery, where you will actually have to run the lottery, possibly with the interference of the State? If you wouldn’t do that, how could the state get $480 million per year from investing only PART of the $10 billion?

    The only way this can work is the way Bill described it — the new lottery owners would have to expand games and marketing. He claims the State can’t do that, which may be true, but it begs the question of whether some of the expansion would be in areas we don’t want to go. Which raises two questions — why should we let them expand into areas we don’t want to go ourselves, and why should they pay us $10 billion when there is a possibility that the state won’t let them expand the way they would want to?


  31. - A real financial analyst - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 8:06 pm:

    SIUPROF–But then the money invested can’t be used to service the bonds for the capital program, or for paygo capital. You have to invest about $8B at current rates to generate the $480M annually, and as a previous post said, at a 6% discount rate the deal is only worth about $7.8B. Why bother?

    Rich–You can’t turn 20% into 100% that easily, the $480M is lost to the GRF. If you put part of the sales proceeds into a fund and use the interest to make up the rest, you won’t have much left for capital.

    The whole thing is a bet that the State is not competent to get full value from the Lottery and someone else can do a lot better. Has anyone seen the basis for the $10B estimate–not just the level of Lottery winnings a private operator might achieve, but that those expectations are reasonable (like, some comparables?)

    And we’re gonna issue 30-year debt on this basis?

    This whole thing just seems like rectal extraction.


  32. - A real financial analyst - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 8:08 pm:

    And don’t even get me started on the goofy math in the gaming bill.


  33. - NoGiftsPlease - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 8:43 pm:

    The problem with the “trust fund” idea is that it is too similar to the “pension fund” idea. The state promises to deposit funds for a specific purpose but when the time comes for that to happen, many sleights of hand can and will take place and it the funds will be diverted. You can’t fool us too many times.


  34. - Arthur Andersen - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 8:51 pm:

    Thank you very much, real financial analyst.

    Fortunately, this eleven-figure shell game has met its just fate.


  35. - plutocrat03 - Saturday, May 31, 08 @ 9:33 pm:

    I’m glad others pointed out the circular reasoning about using the 10B to generate what is lost.

    Another aspect to consider is that we are living in an age of budget sweeps and redirections. How long would it be before some governor or legislator would want to tap into that reserve fund?


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* Bost claims poll shows him up by 4
* More than just unclear on the concept
* Quinn: "Everybody in? I'm driving"
* The sleep gap
* DCCC releases second Bost "rant" ad
* Yesterday's blog posts

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............


Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

          
        * Moto X 2014 vs Samsung Galaxy S5 (Video)
        * Ask the iTunes Guy: When is it better to store apps and music in the cloud?
        * Sony SmartEyeglass to enter tech eyewear market
        * How not to unbox your shiny new iPhone 6
        * Wasteland 2 review: The post-apocalyptic role-playing game you've been waiting for
        * Star Wars Commanders is here, ready to beat Clash of Clans?
        * Hey, where's my iPhone 6? Find out with these tracking tools

        * Square Enix Unveils Shinra Technologies Cloud Gaming Business
        * How Can I Get My Boss to Listen to My Ideas?
        * Chinese Man Intends To Rent Girlfriend To Raise Funds For New iPhone 6
        * Alibaba IPO excitement surges; share price indications on the rise
        * Ubergizmo’s Digitall Fall and Numa Presents Fashion & Tech Event in Paris
        * Look What Facebook’s Video Boom Does to the Internet
        * SYBER Vapor Extreme Console Features New GeForce GTX 980 Graphics Card

        * Updates: Former White Sox playing meaningful September baseball
        * Hot corner belongs to Gillaspie on South Side
        * Predicting Jose Abreu's place in the American League MVP vote
        * Royals offense unflappable, even against Chris Sale
        * Konerko, White Sox stop at the Trop to face Rays
        * Sale roughed up by Royals, loses AL ERA lead
        * Royals 6, White Sox 2: Chris Sale roughed up


        Main Menu
        Home
        Illinois
        YouTube
        Pundit rankings
        Obama
        Subscriber Content
        Durbin
        Burris
        Blagojevich Trial
        Advertising
        Updated Posts
        Polls

        Archives
        September 2014
        August 2014
        July 2014
        June 2014
        May 2014
        April 2014
        March 2014
        February 2014
        January 2014
        December 2013
        November 2013
        October 2013
        September 2013
        August 2013
        July 2013
        June 2013
        May 2013
        April 2013
        March 2013
        February 2013
        January 2013
        December 2012
        November 2012
        October 2012
        September 2012
        August 2012
        July 2012
        June 2012
        May 2012
        April 2012
        March 2012
        February 2012
        January 2012
        December 2011
        November 2011
        October 2011
        September 2011
        August 2011
        July 2011
        June 2011
        May 2011
        April 2011
        March 2011
        February 2011
        January 2011
        December 2010
        November 2010
        October 2010
        September 2010
        August 2010
        July 2010
        June 2010
        May 2010
        April 2010
        March 2010
        February 2010
        January 2010
        December 2009
        November 2009
        October 2009
        September 2009
        August 2009
        July 2009
        June 2009
        May 2009
        April 2009
        March 2009
        February 2009
        January 2009
        December 2008
        November 2008
        October 2008
        September 2008
        August 2008
        July 2008
        June 2008
        May 2008
        April 2008
        March 2008
        February 2008
        January 2008
        December 2007
        November 2007
        October 2007
        September 2007
        August 2007
        July 2007
        June 2007
        May 2007
        April 2007
        March 2007
        February 2007
        January 2007
        December 2006
        November 2006
        October 2006
        September 2006
        August 2006
        July 2006
        June 2006
        May 2006
        April 2006
        March 2006
        February 2006
        January 2006
        December 2005
        April 2005
        March 2005
        February 2005
        January 2005
        December 2004
        November 2004
        October 2004

        Blog*Spot Archives
        November 2005
        October 2005
        September 2005
        August 2005
        July 2005
        June 2005
        May 2005

        Syndication

        RSS Feed 2.0
        Comments RSS 2.0
        WordPress

        Loading


        * Illinois jobless rate declines in August..
        * COD president gets faculty 'no confidence' vote..
        * Rauner Doesn't Like The Idea Of Gambling, Airpo.....
        * Judge: Libertarian Gubernatorial Candidate Can .....
        * Steinem To For Campaign For Quinn..


        * 16-year-old victim of Old Town shooting identified
        * Crestwood officials OK tainted water settlement
        * Fake tweets stir debate about parody, lawsuit
        * Highland teachers accept new contract, end strike
        * GOP's Rauner not a fan of gambling, airport slots
        * Police commander indicted for alleged battery
        * Report: 6 SIU students arrested in sex assaults
        * 2 Illinois women die from West Nile virus
        * Emanuel backs away from naming school after Obama
        * Economy remains slow in rural parts of 10 states

        * Sangamon Co. judge: Libertarian candidate for governor can stay on ballot
        * Illinois’ jobless rate continues 6-month decline
        * GOP’s Rauner no fan of gambling, airport slots
        * GOP’s Rauner no fan of gambling, airport slots
        * Jeb Bush headlining Chicago fundraiser for Rauner
        * Rochester resident to lead State Board of Elections
        * GOP appeal seeks to knock Libertarian gubernatorial candidate off ballot
        * Jesse White to focus on technology, highway safety if re-elected
        * Rauner’s ethics reform plan targets lobbyists, lawmakers
        * White to focus on technology, highway safety in fifth term

        * Drugmaker Horizon defies Democrats' effort to halt overseas moves
        * Gloria Jean's Coffees tries a comeback
        * At McDonald's, the simple joy of a dividend increase
        * Oracle's Ellison, a CEO with Chicago roots, cedes post
        * Peak6 Investments sells off hedge fund


        * Tech devotees camp out to answer the iPhone’s call
        * Apple fanatics camp out to answer the iPhone’s call
        * Teen fatally shot, cop shoots himself in foot on Near North Side
        * Teen victim identified in fatal shooting; officer responding to call shoots self in foot
        * 16 suburban firefighters stranded in Mexico after hurricane
        * Rauner needs to turn over new leaf on medical pot
        * Ald. Munoz: Democratic Party support for Emanuel in mayor’s race premature
        * Drug dealer held accountable in Chicago cop’s murder, gets 35 years in prison
        * Chicago Scots gather to await results of independence vote
        * Firefighter recounts harrowing aftermath of hurricane in Mexico


        * 4 people in custody for slaying of boy, 9, police say
        * Boy, 16, fatally shot in Old Town; responding cop accidentally shoots himself
        * Iowa man charged in road rage stabbing in suburban Volo
        * Jimmy Fallon announces 'Tonight Show' return to Chicago
        * Woman, boyfriend confess in slaying of her mother in Bali
        * CTA: Fewer people are trespassing on CTA rail tracks
        * Cops: Man grabbed boy, girl during recess on West Lawn playground
        * Man grabs, hugs kids at Southwest Side school
        * Arrests made after two sexual assaults at Southern Illinois University
        * Independence vote captivates crowd at Scottish bar in Chicago


        * Listen to State Week - September 12, 2014
        * African Drumming At Southwind Park On Saturday
        * Investors gather in Chicago seeking cannabis businesses
        * Climate, Space Create Challenges For Local Food
        * Can A Governor Really Create Jobs?
        * How do you find high school dropouts?
        * Governor's Race Has A Third Contender; Judge Keeps Libertarians On Ballot
        * Humanities Film Series Kicks Off In Jacksonville
        * Court Ruling Could Impact Governor's Race
        * Indicted police commander suspended from duty 11 times, records show


        * Sangamon Co. judge: Libertarian candidate for governor can stay on ballot
        * Our Opinion: Anchor’s cancer struggle hits home
        * Bob Gilligan: Advisory questions seek voter input — sort of
        * Illinois’ jobless rate continues 6-month decline
        * GOP’s Rauner no fan of gambling, airport slots
        * Esther Cepeda: Pity the vanishing bobolink
        * Jeb Bush headlining Chicago fundraiser for Rauner
        * Christopher Mooney: Evidence in policymaking — no cure-all, but better than the alternative
        * Eugene Robinson: Hillary Clinton needs to tell us her vision
        * George Will: Obama needs Congress to approve this war


        * Paper GM Kilpatrick promoted in company
        * Third annual 'Giving Heart Memorial Ride' set for Sept. 20
        * Davenport's Donchez to become top cop in Overland Park
        * Illini Scrapbook
        * Southern Illinois Irish Festival kicks off this weekend
        * Illini Scrapbook, 9/19/14
        * Upcoming Services (Sept. 19, 2014)
        * Street closures listing
        * 'The Nats' roll back in time -- and into the region
        * Donna Pepper 9/19/2014


        * Get to know the Naperville couple whose cafe provides perfect blend of food, love
        * Suburbanites storm Apple for new iPhone 6
        * Search for ambush suspect centers on dense woods
        * Sierra Leone begins 3-day Ebola lockdown
        * Convicted Florida felon kills his 6 grandchildren

        * Representative Jan Schakowsky Statement on...
        * Rep. Jan Schakowsky discounts threat from ...
        * Representative Jan Schakowsky Statement on...
        * Schakowsky backs striking workers at Juno ...
        * U.S. Rep. Schakowsky Gearing Up For Novemb...
        * Statement by Representative Jan Schakowsky...
        * FAA Rejects Call For New O'Hare Noise Stud...
        * Representatives Quigley, Duckworth, Schako...
        * Representative Jan Schakowsky Statement on...
        * Representative Jan Schakowsky Statement in...

        * READ IN: Kilt-Lifter Edition...
        * READ IN: Kilt-Lifter Edition...
        * READ IN: Kilt-Lifter Edition...
        * READ IN: Kilt-Lifter Edition...
        * READ IN: Kilt-Lifter Edition...

        * Senators, Energy CEOs Call for Long-Term E......

        * Chicago’s Marshall High School and Zombie education reform.
        * Highland teachers end historic strike.
        * The College Football Report Top Ten: Go Blue Hose! Boo Charlie Weis! Why Not Pitt?
        * The [Friday] Papers
        * Today is the day the new iPhones are available in stores
        * Gutierrez: More danger from plane passengers than border crossers
        * Enyart "let down" Illinois' 12th CD, new NRCC ad says
        * Learning Disabilities Association (LDA) of Illinois opposes SB16.
        * Supreme Court catches up on a little paperwork in re: Judge Freddrenna Lyle
        * George Wallace High School.


        * Quinn Misleads Public on IDOT Again
        * Governor Quinn Visits Chicago’s Hydro, Inc. as Illinois’ Unemployment Rate Continues to Drop - State Jobless Rate Reaches Lowest Level in Six Years
        * Rauner Launches New TV Ad: 100 Years
        * 100 Years
        * Bruce Rauner Announces Ethics Blueprint




            Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller