SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
This just in… Illinois Supreme Court consolidates pension cases in Sangamon County

Monday, Mar 3, 2014

* 10:42 am - The Illinois Supreme Court has ruled that all four pension reform lawsuits are to be consolidated and will be heard by a Sangamon County judge. The ruling is here.

Discuss.

- Posted by Rich Miller        


40 Comments
  1. - facts are stubborn things - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 10:47 am:

    proper venue


  2. - Anonymous - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 10:48 am:

    out with the new in the old?


  3. - I B Strapped - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 10:51 am:

    Thanks Rich for posting that.


  4. - G'Kar - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 10:59 am:

    Did the SUAA file their suit in Champaign County Friday?


  5. - veritas - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 11:02 am:

    Any knowledgeable insight regarding what this means going forward?


  6. - Obamas Puppy - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 11:04 am:

    Surprising


  7. - Norseman - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 11:05 am:

    At least 3 out of the 4 litigants are happy. IRTA was against consolidation and they wanted Cook as the venue.


  8. - Roadiepig - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 11:05 am:

    I agree with facts are stubborn things - get it out of the Cook county court system and hear it in Springfield. Should move it along to the Supremes quicker, with less likelihood of different results for each separate case. Good for all on both sides of the issue.


  9. - Langhorne - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 11:19 am:

    Makes sense to consolidate. Who is representing the state? Someone from lisa’s office, or expensive outside counsel?

    My crystal ball (purchased years ago) reveals these fears: if the decision throws out the pension bill, we may end up w the cullerton “health care or annual adjustment coercive approach”, then another lawsuit.

    If the decision tells the state to “pay up”, that may be used by some to push a progressive income tax, which would require all dem votes–esp difficult bec it is a CA, also requiring voter ok. More likely would be expansion of sales tax base, or expansion of income tax base, going after retirement income.

    The whole thing gets murkier if rauner wins. No easy choices


  10. - A guy... - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 11:27 am:

    That’s the second most important thing with regards to this case. Stay tuned for the most important.


  11. - Former Merit Comp Slave - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 11:30 am:

    A guy……Maag ruling?


  12. - Liberty First - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 11:36 am:

    hmm, the ruling says Supreme Court Rule 384 (commonality) is applied in part. So it sounds like the constitutional question will be considered as a framework to guide law and lawsuits in the future. I would interpret this as a win for employees and pensioners given past court rulings.


  13. - Norseman - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 11:47 am:

    === - G’Kar - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 10:59 am:

    Did the SUAA file their suit in Champaign County Friday? ===

    If they haven’t they might as well drive to Springfield to file.


  14. - girllawyer - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 12:26 pm:

    So how is it decided which of the 3 Sangamon County judges assigned to the individual cases gets the consolidated case? Does anyone know? Does the Chief Judge of Sangamon County (Graves) decide?


  15. - Capitol View - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 12:27 pm:

    judicially activate retired associate judge Stu Shiffman to take on the case in the Sangamon County court!


  16. - G'Kar - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 12:28 pm:

    SUAA claims their law suit is substantially different from the others because SURS already has a self managed plan as an option and they are the only one with a Money Purchase Plan that will lose value under SB 1.


  17. - RNUG - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 1:01 pm:

    Although you can never be sure, I expected at least 3 of the 4 to be consolidated in Sangamon County. As others have noted, it will get to the Supremes quick than goign through Cook. We all know it will be a landmark decision and it’s better it doesn’t start with a political taint to it.


  18. - Toure's Latte - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 1:11 pm:

    and away we go. I look forward to the commentary here.


  19. - wordslinger - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 1:13 pm:

    RNUG, as far as “political taint” goes, I’m pretty sure all judges are elected, lol. Given the electorate in Sangamon, the taint might go your way.


  20. - Mouthy - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 1:37 pm:

    Yea! says the SERS retiree…


  21. - VanillaMan - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 1:59 pm:

    This may force some of our statewide elected officials into visiting Illinois’ capital city.


  22. - Anonymous - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 3:06 pm:

    girllawyer, they usually split civil by odd case numbers go to one, evens to the other. and the chief judge picks the fun ones :)


  23. - RNUG - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 3:14 pm:

    - wordslinger - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 1:13 pm:

    Yeah, all the judges are elected but the ones here in Sangamon County haven’t been painted with quite the same tar brush as the Cook County ones.


  24. - RNUG - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 3:20 pm:

    As most of you know, I’ve thought this whole “pension reform” was a political game to be able to blame the ISC for atax increase.

    I got to thinking over lunch if a Sangamon County Judge were to find the law unconstitutional and the State then appeals to the Supreme Court, that the ISC could just decide it was already properly decided and not take the case, in effect affirming the trial level decision and opting out of (Madigan’s?) “blame game”. So the case could end up being decided with a wimper instead of a bang.


  25. - wordslinger - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 3:24 pm:

    –Yeah, all the judges are elected but the ones here in Sangamon County haven’t been painted with quite the same tar brush as the Cook County ones.–

    I haven’t noticed any lack of politics in Sangamon County, lol.

    No biggie. Whatever gets it to the Supremes the fastest is a-ok with me.

    And as someone in the private sector who enters into a lot of contracts — and lives up to my end of them — I’m confident they’ll do the right thing.


  26. - I B Strapped - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 3:50 pm:

    RNUG @3:20-Works for me!


  27. - Me1 - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 4:03 pm:

    After reading all the comments, bottom line, is this consolidation and the Springfield site good or bad for us petitioners?


  28. - Demoralized - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 4:09 pm:

    ==is this consolidation and the Springfield site good or bad for us petitioners==

    If you think judges are influenced by politics, the cynical person would say it’s good because these judges are elected in a county that is heavily populated with state employees.


  29. - gesquire - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 4:14 pm:

    RNUG@3:20
    Plus consolidating in Sangamon Co. gets a Cook County judge off the hook.


  30. - Walker - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 4:26 pm:

    I doubt any location bias and believe we will get a good ruling in either place.

    If there were any bias, it would be in favor of the plaintiffs in Springfield, surrounded by state employees.


  31. - Mama - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 4:36 pm:

    Remember we lost in the Sangamon Co court with the Insurance Premiums lawsuit. I hope we get a different judge this time around.


  32. - gesquire - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 4:46 pm:

    If that judge is assigned, I think the plaintiffs might ask for a change of judge.


  33. - RNUG - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 6:22 pm:

    Honestly, even though I prefer Sangamon, I don’t think the venue will make much difference other than the speed of the case. Of course, the judge can make a difference primarily on how much he already knows (as opposed to has to research) about the issues (contract modification, state pension constitutional law) but, again, that will also be more about how fast the case moves. While IL case law isn’t 100% in favor of the retirees, it is probably tilted somewhere between 90% and 95% that way.

    The Kanerva / Maag trial level ruling, IMO, went out of the way to find a justification for ruling in favor of the State; someday we’ll know if that decision was right or wrong.

    I don’t think whatever judge gets assigned to the “pension reform” case will be able to find a loophole … but that’s why we have lawyers and judges, to find the loopholes … so we have to wait and see on that one also.


  34. - enquiring mind - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 9:49 pm:

    Probably a silly question, but does this mean that there will be one judgment which will be effective for both retirees & active employees or could a judge rule differently for retirees under the old plan vs. active retirees which will retire under the new plan?


  35. - Just The Way It Is One - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 10:05 pm:

    Just as I voted for in a recent Q. of the Day, and, I believe, the Majority of those polled did so concur. Good. Wherever. Let’s get on with it, and I hope the Court acts expeDITIOUSly, seeing how much is obviously at stake for Illinois Government, not to mention the thousands of employees and their families awaiting this critical, initial, Trial-Court level Ruling, because as we all know, there’ll be more to COME after that “Lead-off Man/Hitter” is through with his at-bat at it…!


  36. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 10:44 pm:

    RNUG:

    This case is kinda like a Cubs home game: probably not much to see, but we will watch just in case anything exciting happens, at least as long as there is beer.

    Truthfully, the arguments on both sides have been aired pretty publicly, and we aren’t really expecting much in the way of facts that we don’t already know.

    The similarities to medical malpractice are pretty eerie.

    I do not think the Supreme Court would pass on the case out of politics, but if it is their intent to strike it down they should not dally.

    Someone mentioned passing the Cullerton bill if this one crashes…do not bet on it…that one passed overwhelmingly with union support…I doubt the unions will support it if this one is struck by the courts.


  37. - RNUG - Tuesday, Mar 4, 14 @ 1:07 am:

    YDD,

    I agree the old Cullerton bill would probably be DOA after a retiree win. And to be clear, it was the union leaders, not necessarily the rank and file, supporting that bill.


  38. - RNUG - Tuesday, Mar 4, 14 @ 1:35 am:

    - enquiring mind - Monday, Mar 3, 14 @ 9:49 pm:

    Painting with just a broad brush, there are a whole bunch of differently situated classes involved in the various lawsuits. Just to name the obvious: ERI / non-ERI, retired / still employed, normal / level-payment, SURS normal vs cash balance, and one category I don’t think anyone has included - no longer working for the State but vested and eligible for a pension once they reach the required age. Each one of those categories have a different level of diminishment attached. You start slicing and dicing all that up, it could take a while to reach a decision and even longer to write it.

    Ideally, it will be a simple ruling the law is unconstitutional, period, due to diminishment and the pension clause protection, which, IMO, should be able to be arrived at fairly quickly.

    But if a court buys into the financial emergency / police powers argument or a court buys the consideration offset argument, that could lead to the slicing and dicing where you have to get into the minutia of each situation. Going that route could end up with a 200 page ruling which, any time it gets that complicated, usually makes for bad case law and just invites future lawsuits.

    So, to directly answer your question, I could envision a judge reaching different decisions for different classes, but I don’t see it being too practical in this case. I’m guessing the court will be pragmatic and just issue one broad decision.


  39. - facts are stubborn things - Tuesday, Mar 4, 14 @ 7:09 am:

    I suspect the court will be eager to send a message to the other branches of government, that the IL Constitution is not to be disregarded. I think Arizona ruling is a likely result in Illinois.


  40. - Vanthony - Tuesday, Mar 11, 14 @ 6:06 pm:

    I’m one of those different “classes”. Worked briefly in the private sector, paying social security, then several years in SERS, and then retired with about 30 years in TRS. So I collect my pension from SERS & TRS, plus a whopping $244 a month from Social Security. Sofar I think I understand everything and how it effects me, but now comes Medicare and TRAIL and the health insurance issues. Thank God for my union and competent state employees, and hopefully honest judges.


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* IFT endorses Quinn
* Right and wrong
* Question of the day
* Department of Insurance says insurers can't discriminate "based on gender identity"
* Today's quotable
* Rauner group files appeal in term limits case
* Inversion politics
* $300,000 a week in July
* About those new polls
* Today's number: 59 percent
* Yesterday's blog posts

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............


Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

          
        * LG G Vista arrives with Verizon Wireless
        * iWatch launch dates, Sony Xperia Z3 compact, HTC event & more – Pocketnow Daily
        * The One-Horse Race: 85% Of The 300M Smartphones Shipped In Q2 Were Android
        * ZAGG Rugged Folio for iPad mini review (Video)
        * Chartboost, Chukong Link Up To Bring Mobile Game Cross-Promotion To Chinese Developers
        * Modbook launches Kickstarter campaign for Modbook Pro X Mac tablet
        * T-Mobile welcomes very affordable Samsung Galaxy Avant

        * HTC One M8 With Windows Phone May Launch August 19th
        * Neverwinter MMORPG hitting Xbox One in 2015
        * Laser Etched Hyrule Map Looks Stunning
        * Samsung Gear 3 To Launch This Fall With A Circular Design (Rumor)
        * Killer Instinct Classic 2 Could Debut On Xbox One
        * Call Of Duty: Advanced Warfare Atlas Editions Announced
        * New World Record In Data Transfer Achieved

        * Personal stats nice, but Abreu wants to win
        * First inning dooms Noesi, White Sox in Detroit
        * Tigers 7, White Sox 2: Detroit mauls Hector Noesi
        * White Sox try to lock up series win with Danks
        * Nate Jones undergoes Tommy John surgery
        * First inning dooms Noesi, White Sox in Detroit
        * Personal stats nice, but Abreu wants to win


        Main Menu
        Home
        Illinois
        YouTube
        Pundit rankings
        Obama
        Subscriber Content
        Durbin
        Burris
        Blagojevich Trial
        Advertising
        Updated Posts
        Polls

        Archives
        July 2014
        June 2014
        May 2014
        April 2014
        March 2014
        February 2014
        January 2014
        December 2013
        November 2013
        October 2013
        September 2013
        August 2013
        July 2013
        June 2013
        May 2013
        April 2013
        March 2013
        February 2013
        January 2013
        December 2012
        November 2012
        October 2012
        September 2012
        August 2012
        July 2012
        June 2012
        May 2012
        April 2012
        March 2012
        February 2012
        January 2012
        December 2011
        November 2011
        October 2011
        September 2011
        August 2011
        July 2011
        June 2011
        May 2011
        April 2011
        March 2011
        February 2011
        January 2011
        December 2010
        November 2010
        October 2010
        September 2010
        August 2010
        July 2010
        June 2010
        May 2010
        April 2010
        March 2010
        February 2010
        January 2010
        December 2009
        November 2009
        October 2009
        September 2009
        August 2009
        July 2009
        June 2009
        May 2009
        April 2009
        March 2009
        February 2009
        January 2009
        December 2008
        November 2008
        October 2008
        September 2008
        August 2008
        July 2008
        June 2008
        May 2008
        April 2008
        March 2008
        February 2008
        January 2008
        December 2007
        November 2007
        October 2007
        September 2007
        August 2007
        July 2007
        June 2007
        May 2007
        April 2007
        March 2007
        February 2007
        January 2007
        December 2006
        November 2006
        October 2006
        September 2006
        August 2006
        July 2006
        June 2006
        May 2006
        April 2006
        March 2006
        February 2006
        January 2006
        December 2005
        April 2005
        March 2005
        February 2005
        January 2005
        December 2004
        November 2004
        October 2004

        Blog*Spot Archives
        November 2005
        October 2005
        September 2005
        August 2005
        July 2005
        June 2005
        May 2005

        Syndication

        RSS Feed 2.0
        Comments RSS 2.0
        WordPress

        Loading


        * Governor candidates assess overseas tax breaks .....
        * College of DuPage Gone Wild ! - Edgar County Wa.....
        * Quinn rips Rauner for supporting "unpatriotic" .....
        * Create a custom date range - RedEye Chicago..
        * Rail car builder adding 90 workers in Rochelle .....
        * Governor candidates assess overseas tax breaks..
        * Quinn Supports Refugee Kids..
        * Quinn: Workers' compensation rate to fall in 2015..


        * Ore. authorities search for missing man
        * Notorious Chicago officers top misconduct list
        * Quinn: Workers' compensation rate to fall in 2015
        * Governor candidates assess overseas tax breaks
        * Chicago mayor proposes hike in hourly minimum wage
        * Quinn signs epinephrine law for Illinois schools
        * Charges upgraded to murder after Palatine fight
        * Body of missing Chicago man found in Lake Michigan
        * Man seeks withdrawal of plea in fatal stabbing
        * Police search for trucker after fatal I-70 wreck

        * Teen collapses at Quinn campaign event
        * Quinn: Workers' compensation rate to fall in 2015
        * 'Headlines' in Rauner campaign ad don't match up
        * Quinn signs epinephrine law for Illinois schools
        * Governor candidates differ on overseas tax breaks
        * Quinn: State will 'prevail' in Shakman lawsuit
        * Illinois Medicaid restricts use of hepatitis drug
        * Quinn OKs ballot question on tax hike for incomes over $1M
        * Lawsuit against Quinn back in court in October
        * Illinois to ask voters about taxing millionaires

        * Emanuel proposes hike in hourly minimum wage
        * Quinn: Illinois workers' comp rates to fall 5.5 percent in 2015
        * Allstate's second-quarter profit rises 41% on sales gains
        * Japanese firm Nippon Sharyo expands Illinois rail car plant
        * Boeing to build largest Dreamliner in South Carolina plant


        * One killed in multi-vehicle crash in Edgewater involving CTA bus
        * Police questioning person for fatal Edgewater crash involving CTA bus
        * Cop killer removed as baseball coach, but league official says past was no secret
        * Cop killer removed as baseball coach, league's board quits over uproar
        * Secretive  aldermen pull down blinds
        * Deadlocked committee delays vote on City Council budget analyst
        * Man gets 20-year sentence in Wicker Park choking, stabbing case
        * Convicted killer’s hearing for new trial pushed back to Friday
        * VA manipulated vets’ appointment data in Chicago, elsewhere, audit finds
        * Man dead, off-duty police officer wounded in Bucktown shooting


        * 6 wounded in South Side shootings
        * Cops in SOS unit amassed citizen complaints
        * Alderman pushes watchdog restrictions week after being probed
        * Person in custody after Edgewater Beach accident leaves 1 dead, 3 injured
        * Man gets 20 years in '12 attack of Wicker Park flower shop employee
        * Gutierrez is Texas-bound to see how immigrant minors are being treated
        * As CHA socks away millions, HUD calls on agency to expand vouchers
        * As CHA socks away millions, HUD calls on agency to expand vouchers
        * Evanston bans plastic bags in bigger stores starting next year
        * New law lets more school workers use emergency injection on students


        * CPD leaves commander in post despite assault allegation, DNA match
        * Business, Labor Leaders Urge Quinn Administration To Finish Fracking Rules
        * Inspector General Discloses Political Hiring Investigation
        * Listen to State Week - July 25, 2014
        * State Police Cancels New Trooper Training, Citing Budget
        * Clout On The Business Side of Medical Marijuana
        * Inspector General Finds Old Metra Practice Could Lead To Fatigued Conductors
        * State Fair Officials Fined For Violating Gift Ban...For Beer Tickets
        * Governor Approves 'Millionaire's Tax' As Advisory Referendum
        * Authorities Investigating Downtown Bomb


        * Our Opinion: Dangerous pedestrian crossing getting the attention it deserves
        * The GOP as the party of reform
        * John Cooney: Lawsuit abuse is a myth spun by big business
        * Quinn: Workers' compensation rate to fall in 2015
        * Quinn signs epinephrine law for Illinois schools
        * Travis Akin: Lawsuit reform could improve Illinois’ business climate
        * George Will: A middle course on foreign policy
        * Eugene Robinson: Absent on immigration reform
        * Governor candidates differ on overseas tax breaks
        * Quinn: State will 'prevail' in Shakman lawsuit


        * Making kachina dolls
        * Voice of the Reader: Generosity built roof
        * Patsy Bankson
        * Margaret Morgan
        * Debra Taylor
        * Bonita Davis
        * David Christensen
        * Marilyn Bundren
        * Dale Aden
        * Roy Goolsby


        * Some good (shutout), some bad (another tie)
        * Cubs keep dealing, acquire lefty Doubront from Boston
        * No trades yet, but plenty of White Sox news
        * Cougars drop fifth straight
        * Arlington Heights pub offers up ‘Pint with Peggy' night

        * Case files against Sandi and Jesse Jackson...
        * Mystery Loan Lets Ex-Representative Jesse ...
        * Mystery loan lets Jacksons keep both homes...
        * Case files against Sandi and Jesse Jackson...
        * Mystery Loan Lets Ex-Representative Jesse ...
        * Mystery loan lets Jacksons keep both homes...
        * Rep. Lipinski Helps Pass VA Reform Bill - ...
        * Congressman Dan Lipinski to host 3 events ...
        * House passes Lipinski bill for Herbie John...
        * Renaming of Mount Greenwood post office in...

        * Governor candidates assess overseas tax br......
        * Senator, FutureGen CEO talk project...
        * Think companies can flee the U.S. risk-fre......
        * Congressional Democrats Introduce Bill to ......
        * Congressional Democrats Introduce Bill to ......

        * Colonies court hearing to go into sixth day...
        * Kirk pushes Obama for stiffer sanctions on......
        * Hatch, Markey Introduce Legislation to Pro......
        * Rep. Gutierrez decries plan to deport immi......
        * President Obama: Be Even Bolder on Global ......

        * E-15 Fuel Proposal Runs Out Of Gas In Committee
        * The Gas Guzzler
        * Ten minute drawing. What’s that noise?
        * No ten minute drawings for the next few days.
        * U.S. Economy Grew At Strong 4 Percent Rate In Spring
        * Chicago City Council Roundup: Minimum Wage Bump, Phone Tax Hike & New Moratorium
        * Terror Threats At Chemical Plants Underestimated
        * Chgo Lawmakers Poised To Reduce IG's Purview Over Campaign Finance Probes
        * Chicago SRO Press Conference At City Hall
        * Anti-War Activists State 'Die-In' Against Boeing At City Hall


        * Pat Quinn: Patronage Will Prevail
        * Governor Quinn and Company Officials Open Nippon Sharyo Expansion in Rochelle - Passenger Rail Car Manufacturing Plant Expansion Creating 90 New Jobs
        * Governor Quinn Signs Legislation to Expand Life-Saving Measures in Illinois Schools - Expands Epinephrine Law to Protect Illinois’ Students in Life-Threatening Emergencies
        * Governor Quinn Announces Historic Workers’ Compensation Rate Reductions - Savings from 2011 Reforms Expected to Save $450 Million for Businesses Across Illinois
        * Pat Quinn’s Reality Check




            Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller