SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
Problems with MJM’s millionaire’s tax

Monday, Mar 31, 2014

* Eric Zorn

One thing — really the only thing — I don’t like about Democratic House Speaker Michael Madigan’s proposed constitutional amendment to add a 3 percent state tax on all income over $1 million is that it’s not indexed for inflation.

“We thought about it,” said Steve Brown, Madigan’s spokesman. “But we decided this is a cleaner proposal, simpler to understand, easier to get through the legislature without arguing about whose inflation index we’re going to use and so on.”

Yes. And a clever if crude way to gain popular support for the introduction of needed progressivity in our income tax system.

But constitutional amendments are designed to last a long time, and $1 million 10 years from now will not be worth as much as $1 million today.

Think of it this way: If we’d put such an added tax into the revised state constitution when it was ratified in 1970, it would have targeted only people earning more than the equivalent of $6.1 million a year in 2014 dollars, according to the inflation calculator at the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics website.

That same calculator says that a person earning $165,000 a year in 1970 had the same purchasing power of a person earning $1 million a year today.

Agreed. It’s so difficult to change the Constitution that hard and fast numbers should never be used.

* But I’d add two more real problems with Madigan’s proposal:

1) The language leaves to the General Assembly the task of defining the word “income.” In Madigan’s proposal, the wording could be legislated to mean gross income, without any adjustments for expenses whatsoever. That would indeed leave some farmers and small business owners in danger of being hit with the surcharge, as Bruce Rauner and others have warned.

2) If voters approve the idea in November, the tax hike is retroactive to January 1st of this year. That’s an awful big first bite.

- Posted by Rich Miller        

  1. - Bill White - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:01 am:

    What about a 3% tax on net income that exceeds the annualized minimum wage (2000 hours) by a factor of 50?

    $10 / hr x 2000 = $20,000

    $1,000,000 / $20,000 = 50x


    That would give high earners incentive to raise the minimum wage to track inflation.

  2. - wordslinger - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:01 am:

    Those are big problems, especially the inflation factor. Leads you to believe it was rushed out there solely for political effect.

  3. - OneMan - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:01 am:

    1 — How much flexibility would/could they end up with in terms of defining income? Could it vary by source, so that lets say rental income is included but proceeds from insurance not be included or whatever.

  4. - Ahoy! - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:04 am:

    I would also add that the Constitution should not be used as a political tool.

  5. - Reality Check - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:08 am:

    All the more reason the Harmon resolution should be passed and placed on the ballot instead. It would give the GA the ability to pass either Harmon’s revenue-neutral rate structure, the millionaire’s surcharge or both.

  6. - OneMan - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:10 am:

    Bill White — I think the problem with that is you are making a constitutional mandate dependent on a legislative mandate. Not real sure that is a good idea either.

  7. - Allen Skillicorn - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:10 am:

    Politically brilliant, fiscally foolish.

  8. - Nieva - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:11 am:

    I sure hope I don’t hit the lottery!

  9. - A guy... - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:11 am:

    This is what happens when “for populist purposes” you target one category of tax payers. The myth that high income people don’t pay taxes or their “fair share” is alive and well.

  10. - Bill White - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:13 am:

    Perhaps the surcharge is intended to go down in flames to soften the blow from the 5% becoming permanent.

    So says Captain Obvious . . .

  11. - Walter Mitty - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:14 am:

    Ahoy…. You have said it all… I look forward to the time all of the cheerleader’s to tax small businessmen and succesful providers, to cheer when the Convention ends up on the ballot to change state retiree benefits…. Because there is no funding issues for the pension obligation and the majority of the public in these times would not support that concept… snark. We can opine all we want about this ain’t Texas or Wisconsin.. People are hurting….

  12. - Bogart - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:17 am:

    You mean this proposal is similar to Blago’s Gross Receipts Tax on LLC’s and S-Corps? The same Tax Madigan killed. My - how far thinking Rod was.

  13. - VanillaMan - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:23 am:

    More political crap from the crap masters.

  14. - Bogart - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:23 am:

    Oh - and by the way - Blago’s Gross Receipts Tax proposal only applied to firms/individuals with Gross Receipts over $2 million. So, Madigan’s proposal is even more regressive.

  15. - Arizona Bob - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:25 am:

    My guess is that by the time it’s done it’ll be written in such a way that will allow “progressive” taxes at any income level.

    Good consitutional provisions make the general case so that they’re flexible enough to be implemented in a functional fashion.

    This reads more like a statute than a constitutional ammendment.

    If you want a progressive tax, fight that battle by removing the “flat rate” provision from the Illinois Consititution.

    Of course, that’s what the aim of Quinn and his ilk are looking for, but they haven’t got the guts, or the persuavive argument, to get it passed.

  16. - Bogart - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:25 am:

    And finally, Blago’s GRT didn’t require a Constitutional amendment, just a simple majority bill. If they are serious, why not a GRT for firms with over $1m in gross receipts.

  17. - 47th Ward - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:26 am:

    More tremendous insight from VMan.

  18. - VanillaMan - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:28 am:

    This is what we get when we let politicians politicize our government problems. No solutions, just more politics. It is amazing Illinois functions as well as it has with these kinds of people running our state government.

    If the guys in charge fail to fix our problems, then they shouldn’t complain when voters vote in new guys to be in charge. Quinn and Madigan have been playing politics while Illinois suffers.

    If Quinn won’t make this work, then voters will choose Rauner. Quinn and Madigan are in charge and they are showing themselves unable to handle this.

  19. - OneMan - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:31 am:

    Also on the political plus side, money spent fighting this is money that can’t be spent on Rauner.

  20. - langhorne - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:34 am:

    the state cant pay its bills. and we have cut funding for education, along with pretty much everything else. so, instead of dealing with these problems head on, w a progressive income tax, or an assortment of other changes, MJM wants another flat tax. but only on millionaires. and only for education.

    theres no such thing as a free lunch. give the schools the nice windfall. then have them take over funding of teacher pensions.

    or do a lottery swap. give them new money, and take away more of the old money.

  21. - Anon - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:37 am:

    When the personal income tax was first created in 1970, the personal exemption was $1,000. That would be equal to $6,050 in today’s dollars. That would mean a family of four would not pay any income taxes on their first $24,200 of income. I’m for using CPI for all these numbers in statute (minimum wage for example) but I’m opposed to using it for just when it benefits the wealthier and not using it when it would benefit those less fortunate. (I know the personal exemption is now indexed to inflation, but at $2,100 it is so low, its negligible.)

  22. - bigdaddygeo - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:43 am:

    MJM should raise the tax rate to a number that will pay for the backlog of bills and fund unfunded pension liabilities. Any other number or discussion is just more smoke.

  23. - Gene Debs - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:47 am:

    Mitty…We have a problem with demand in this country, and it’s causing unemployment. If successful providers were, in fact, successfully providing jobs, we would not need more revenue.

    If the Bush tax cuts and deregulation had provided the economic miracle as promised, people wouldn’t be hurting. We still have those tax cuts in place stalling the recovery.

    Belt tightening translates to layoffs and high unemployment, especially at the federal level. Putting more money into the pockets of low income workers is called for, not protecting the bloated assets of so called “providers”.

    Pension reductions will hurt the economy and would have virtually no influence on the Illinois debt level. In addition they will hopefully be ruled probably unconstitutional and recognized as counter productive.

    Everyone lower than the 70th percentile of wage earners has lost buying power since the Reagan years. They are also bearing the greater burden of taxation in Illinois. They have to choose between taxes and groceries. They can’t save for retirement. They should be upset.

    The federal deficit isn’t causing a recession; rather it’s undue belt tightening at fault.

  24. - wordslinger - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:48 am:

    –If the guys in charge fail to fix our problems, then they shouldn’t complain when voters vote in new guys to be in charge–

    Who’s complaining? Except you that is. You seem to have problems with those the voters choose.

    But you’re informed insight is always….. what it is.

  25. - Walker - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:50 am:

    Our current constitution sets in stone all kinds of numbers, tax ratios, specific guarantees for key groups, and political stances. None of them belong in there. It’s a mess.

    If it were a cleaner generic document about rights, responsibilities, structure, and government operations, then none of these amendments would be necessary. They would appropriately be legislative and executive decisions.

  26. - VanillaMan - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:52 am:

    Who is complaining?
    Wow - from the guy who thought the Tea Party was a non-issue that would be gone by now.


  27. - VanillaMan - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:54 am:

    @ Gene Debs

    LOL! Where have you been the past six years?

  28. - John A Logan - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:55 am:

    “Who’s complaining?”

    That will go down in history with Bill’s comment after Blagojevich got arrested.

  29. - phocion - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:55 am:

    ==Who’s complaining? Except you that is. You seem to have problems with those the voters choose.==

    WS,VM isn’t the only one complaining.

  30. - wordslinger - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:56 am:

    VMan, I’m with you — like you, I have no idea what you’re talking about. It’s like Esperanto.

  31. - Walter Mitty - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 10:59 am:

    Gene… Thanks… The issue is, when not if it ends on a ballot to open the consitution to change the unfunded pensions, I will be happy. Someone who is 20 years in a system that will not be funded for me…I say protect those retired and hurt folks like me that can still earn. Otherwise, they will pull the rug out when all the games are done being played…

  32. - PERPLEXED - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 11:11 am:

    “But we decided this is a cleaner proposal, simpler to understand, easier to get through the legislature without arguing about whose inflation index we’re going to use and so on.”

    They didn’t seem to have this problem when they committed the pension theft and implement a formula to slash the colas for future years. Seems to have common theme when it comes to who the recipients of the changes are.

  33. - Demoralized - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 11:17 am:

    ==The myth that high income people don’t pay taxes or their “fair share” is alive and well.==

    Keep on defending those rich guys @A guy.

  34. - 47th Ward - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 11:51 am:

    ===It’s like Esperanto===

    Hey, man, you don’t talk to the VanillaMan. You listen to him. The man’s enlarged my mind. He’s a poet warrior in the classic sense. I mean sometimes he’ll… uh… well, you’ll say “hello” to him, right? And he’ll just talk right past you. He won’t even notice you. And suddenly he’ll grab you, and he’ll throw you in a corner, and he’ll say, “Do you know that ‘if’ is the middle word in life? If you can keep your head when all about you are losing theirs and blaming it on you, if you can trust yourself when all men doubt you”… I mean I’m… no, I can’t… I’m a little man, I’m a little man, he’s… he’s a great man! I should have been a pair of ragged claws scuttling across floors of silent seas…

  35. - Oswego Willy - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 11:56 am:

    I guess that does make - VanillaMan - Col. Kurtz…

    Although Col. Kurtz never “complained” except about not getting into Jump School.

  36. - Rich Miller - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 12:08 pm:

    Let’s move along, people. All of you. Thanks.

  37. - OneMan - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 12:22 pm:

    Ironically that bastion of conservative thinking The West Wing covered the fair share thing…

  38. - Anon - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 12:55 pm:

    == Of course, that’s (graduated income tax) what the aim of Quinn and his ilk are looking for, but they haven’t got the guts, or the persuavive argument, to get it passed. ==

    They don’t have the votes since it takes a three-fifth majority to put it on the ballot, and Franks is opposed, as well as a few other Dems who are quiet about it. All Repubicans are opposed. Consequenlty. since politics is the art of the possible, one takes what one can get.

  39. - Duck - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 1:11 pm:

    Madigan tax also does not include expanded brackets for married couples in addition to not being tied to inflation.

  40. - Grandson of Man - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 3:15 pm:

    “That same calculator says that a person earning $165,000 a year in 1970 had the same purchasing power of a person earning $1 million a year today.”

    So over time, without indexing, a similar thing will happen with the Madigan surcharge. With the CTBA progressive tax, earnings over $150,000 would get a tax increase, but everyone else would get a tax decrease.

    We Illinoisans reject the progressive tax but might accept the regressive millionaire tax, in which no one under $1 million would get a tax decrease. Is something wrong with this picture?

    Perhaps we might want to change our state motto.
    Illinois: Something is Wrong With Us.

  41. - Gene Debs - Monday, Mar 31, 14 @ 3:47 pm:

    I could have been clearer about debt. The fiscal deficit of Illinois is causing plenty of pain. The state never brings in enough revenue to pay for the services it has to provide the citizens.

    Illinois’ flat tax structure is unfair and burdensome on most of its citizens. When low income people have no cash reserves, State tax increases eat up cash that should go back into the local economy.

    On the federal level it’s a different story. US Government debt is fundamentally different from household debt. The federal government has a progressive tax. It can expand the money supply. It can borrow at low interest. There is no good reason for federal belt tightening when unemployment is this high, but that is what has been done.

    In 2000 there was a federal surplus, but Bush thought tax cuts were going to bring prosperity. Then he invaded Iraq, and the spending was on. Once they left office, the Republicans drank the deficit kool aid. “Cut spending and shrink government” suddenly became their mantra, their solution to the mess they created.

    Here we are now with plenty of pain to go around, and guess who wants to shred the social safety net and cut unemployment benefits or food stamps, so the poor won’t become dependent. Let’s be careful not too put any money into the hands of people who will spend out of necessity.

    “Compassionate” conservatives.

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.

* Jak Tichenor named interim Simon Institute director
* Board of Elections states the obvious to the clueless
* Vote Yes On Safe Roads Amendment
* Pay Now coalition asks Supremes to review state employee pay issue
* Question of the day
* Vote no because driverless cars!
* ILGOP ups ante on anti-Bradley ad, shows Dem comparing MJM to Lincoln
* Creamer tries to explain away the undercover video
* Caption contest!
* A bit much
* Munger puts Rauner's $1 million contribution to good use
* IDES says Illinois lost 800 manufacturing jobs last month
* IDOC moves to reform solitary confinement rules
* A massive game of "chicken"
* Why was that anti-Bradley ad taken down by YouTube?
* By popular demand, here's that Madigan/Trump/Clinton photo
* Good for the goose...
* About last night...
* Yesterday's blog posts

Visit our advertisers...






Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

* This is not a drill: Android 7.0 Nougat rolls out for Moto G4 and G4 Plus in India
* GSM unlocked Moto Z Play available from multiple US retailers now, headphone jack and all
* Alcatel brings ‘new’ quartet of low-cost unlocked Android phones to the US
* ZTE Axon 7 Max may be announced on October 27
* iPhone 7 Plus modems analyzed, Qualcomm deemed better than Intel
* Apple sues accessories maker for counterfeit chargers on Amazon
* Project CSX vote gives SpiderPhone the win for ZTE to build and sell

* International draft stands to benefit White Sox
* Davidson reflects on 'whirlwind' 2016 season
* Starting pitcher rankings: White Sox have four of them
* Podcast: 2016 Chicago White Sox Infield Review
* White Sox Rumors: Sox hire Chris Getz as new Director Of Player Dev...
* Source: Getz to oversee Sox player development
* Awakening from denial: A Sox fan's journey through dark Cub-winning...


Main Menu
Pundit rankings
Subscriber Content
Blagojevich Trial
Updated Posts

October 2016
September 2016
August 2016
July 2016
June 2016
May 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005


RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0


* Election Spending Examined - Alton Daily News..
* Illinois Budget Lawsuit - WPSD Local 6..

* EXCHANGE: Urbana man uses irony as he recalls Vietnam
* Retiring Wrigley Field scoreboard operator has seen it all
* Judge: Illinois inmate's hunger strike is protected speech
* Wooded Island in Jackson Park reopening after improvements
* 4 artists to have works displayed at Chicago rail stations
* Chicago suburb raises legal age to buy tobacco to 21
* Celebrities among those long-suffering Chicago Cubs fans
* Illinois senators aim to ban campaigning by agency directors
* Most Syrian refugees arriving in US are kids; schools adapt
* Man admits buying cigarettes in Missouri to sell in Chicago

* SIU injury-prevention program reinstated through stopgap budget
* Survey: 386 state jobs could relocate to Springfield
* SIU injury-prevention program reinstated through state's stopgap spending plan
* Illinois unemployment rate holds at 5.5 percent
* Loose ceiling beam in Coliseum led to closure
* Proposal would ban agency directors from campaign ads
* Illinois State Fair Coliseum closed due to structural deficiencies
* State fairgrounds Coliseum temporarily closed due to structural deficiencies
* Illinois agency: YouTube glitch behind training video porn
* Corrections officers call for increased safety at Logan County prison

* What United's CEO needs for the holidays
* Chicago has a new 800-pound gorilla in health care
* Illinois secure in election readiness despite database hack
* Full of Obamacare patients, Rush Oak Park eyes new $30 million ER
* Southwest Michigan is for lovers—of wine and craft beer

* Crews battle 5-alarm fire in Little Village
* 55-year-old man with dementia reported missing from Park Manor
* Man grazed in South Side shooting
* Here comes Game 6 at Wrigley in NLCS, both a thrill and a terror
* Three-and-Out: Rookie RB Jordan Howard struggles again for Bears
* Optics illusion? Lackey growls, young Cubs shrug it off, win 2
* Cubs beat Dodgers to reach brink of first World Series since 1945
* Russell’s second big blast in 2 games lifts Cubs
* 16-year-old boy wounded in Bronzeville drive-by shooting
* A Game 5 victory, and now the Cubs get to climb Mt. Kershaw

* Unique Northwestern program helps lawyer fighting to keep ability to speak
* Morning Spin: Preckwinkle cagey on Emanuel's police performance
* 'Front Page' on Broadway with Nathan Lane: No need for rewrite!
* Willson Contreras says he is an 'emotional player' after Game 5 incidents
* Cubs, Javier Baez survive injury scare during NLCS Game 5 win
* NLCS Game 5: Cubs 8, Dodgers 4
* NLCS drama shifts back to Wrigley with Cubs on verge of World Series
* Cubs gain one-game edge in NLCS with 8-4 victory over Dodgers
* Teen among 3 wounded in city shootings
* Jon Lester's intensity sets tone as Cubs sit at doorstep of history

The widget AQL4JYGHIY powered by Feed Informer does not exist.

* SIU injury-prevention program reinstated through stopgap budget
* Survey: 386 state jobs could relocate to Springfield
* Our View: For circuit judge, Cadagin, Troemper are endorsed
* SIU injury-prevention program reinstated through state's stopgap spending plan
* Illinois unemployment rate holds at 5.5 percent
* Loose ceiling beam in Coliseum led to closure
* Proposal would ban agency directors from campaign ads
* Bernard Schoenburg: Judge candidates investing in their own campaigns
* Eugene Robinson: Can we please just fast-forward to Election Day?
* Ray LaHood and Ed Rendell: Vote 'yes' on roads amendment

* Downtown church incubating an urban ministry
* Prayer day set for local law enforcement
* 40 years after Murphysboro teen's death, friends endow scholarship in his name
* Adventure camps 'explode' for conservation district
* Andrew Harpstrite
* Brenda Bennett
* J.D. Dungey
* William Smith
* Arvel 'A.J.' Lawrence
* Prentice Thomas Sr.

* South Africa to withdraw from International Criminal Court
* Russians seek answers to central Moscow GPS anomaly
* An inside look at Garfield creator's Ball State art class
* Cyprus police: boat with 83 migrants aboard towed to harbor
* Who is Evan McMullin, third-party candidate surging in Utah?

* House lawmakers overcome hurdle on key tra...
* Rodney Davis talks funding with Bloomingto...
* The agency that fought Illiana gets a new ...
* Rep. Dold takes educational cruise down Ch...
* Lawmakers decry high turnover rate of VA h...
* CBD Oil, and politics
* Simon considering state Senate bid
* Killer Congressman Tom MacArthur trying to...
* Shutdown? State may not notice
* Rep. Bob Dold

* US Sen. Dick Durbin urges big pharma actio......
* The Daily Northwestern : U.S. Sen. Dick Du......

* Duckworth outraises Kirk in last quarter -......

* Bucktown Man Arrested After Mugging Woman At Gunpoint, Resisting Arrest
* Peter Out
* The Jerk Stop Celebrates Its Grand Opening With 20% Off Your First Order
* Transportation coalition spends nearly $3M on ads for guaranteed public funding
* Transportation coalition spends over $2M on ads for guaranteed public funding
* A Whiter Shade of Pale
* Gutierrez gets ready to move on immigration reform
* Scenes from Illinois REALTORS®’ media spokesperson training
* Illinois REALTORS® Global Working Group gains NAR recognition
* Foster: In case you missed it, Hillary Clinton is for open borders

* Illinois Partners with State of Telangana, India to Strengthen Smart State Initiatives - State to state agreement to accelerate opportunities and service to citizens
* Illinois EPA Announces Vehicle Emissions Testing Network Updates - New Contract to Offer More Efficient, Less Expensive Tests
* Annual Training Underway For Gas Station Owners, Service Technicans
* Governor Rauner Announces Recommendations from Health Care Fraud Elimination Task Force Report
* Annual Training Underway For Gas Station Owners, Service Technicians

      Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller