SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
Question of the day II

Monday, Apr 7, 2014

* Today’s question is more of a caption contest, so let’s do a serious one now. The Daily Herald has a story on the Northeastern Illinois Public Transit Task Force report from last week

“Hiring based on political considerations is corrosive to good government,” the task force stated.

The report also focused on the RTA, refuting advice from Chairman John Gates to give the agency greater authority over the CTA, Metra and Pace.

Task force members pointed out hiring Madigan’s son-in-law Jordan Matyas in 2011 as an RTA lobbyist and later chief of staff at a time when there was talk in Springfield of abolishing the agency.

“We cannot credibly vouch … that the answer to decades of patronage that involved dozens of officials from both parties is to place (Metra) under the more rigorous oversight of an agency who chose to select the speaker’s son-in-law as chief lobbyist,” the task force concluded.


Former US Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald was the task force’s ethics chairman. Fitzgerald has never been a big MJM fan, to say the least.

* Gates responded

Asked about the harsh task force language concerning the RTA, Gates said, “It was a really cheap shot.”

He insisted Matyas was selected months after a bill was defeated that would have given the governor appointing authority over the RTA chair.

Matyas “came in through the front door,” was one of at least two candidates he interviewed and “ has done a terrific job,” Gates told reporters after an address to the City Club of Chicago.

* The Question: “Hiring based on political considerations is corrosive to good government.” Agree or disagree? Take the poll and then explain your answer in comments, please.

survey tool

- Posted by Rich Miller        

  1. - Smoggie - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 2:52 pm:

    Did Gates actually make that claim with a straight face?

    Jordan’s record consists of having a pretty bad reputation when he was a lawyer.

    He get engaged and then miraculously finds himself in positions of authority.

    In the current position there were allegations of some sort of abusive behavior where, it was reported, he needed “additional training.”

    Sure, he family ties did not matter at all.

    Jordan is Example A for everything we need to know about the results of political hiring.

  2. - VanillaMan - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 2:54 pm:

    When a government hires, everything is political.

    Claiming that it is corrosive shows an attitude found only in textbooks and classrooms - not reality.

  3. - Oswego Willy - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 2:56 pm:

    The Rutan decision, I believe still allows for “exempt” hires, so by allowing some to exist in the first place and after doesn’t sound too corrosive.

    It’s cute that “All” are bad. Are “All” good? No. Are “All” bad? Again, no.

  4. - Bill White - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:01 pm:

    Hiring based on political considerations is inevitable.

    What is most corrosive to good government is to spread the illusion that political considerations can be ignored. Those who most loudly assert to be free from “political considerations” are often the most political people of all.

    The pervasiveness of politics needs to be acknowledged and a system of checks and balances established.

  5. - wordslinger - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:02 pm:

    –Former US Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald was the task force’s ethics chairman. Fitzgerald has never been a big MJM fan, to say the least.–

    But he never laid a glove on him in 11 years, with the IRS and FBI on his team. C’mon, man, if you sent the FBI and IRS after me, I’d get life in front of a firing squad.

    Give it up, Ahab.

    To the question, no. To pretend there is not subjectivity in hiring is silly.

    I’m sure that Fitz would agree that all those attorney generals he served under, and all those U.S. attorneys he served with, didn’t get their gigs because they were at the tops of their class.

    Did that make them “corrosive?”

  6. - VanillaMan - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:03 pm:

    Sounds like the task force found themselves far more ethical, far more informed and far more intelligent than the subjects with whom they were tasked.

    Self anointed saints always find sinners.

  7. - Big Muddy - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:03 pm:

    Incest does not give positive results.

  8. - OneMan - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:04 pm:

    So torn on this one I didn’t answer…

    But, when it comes down to it is the implication that the idea of politically removed civil service doesn’t work. That all government hiring is influenced by politics?

  9. - Demoralized - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:07 pm:

    I voted disagree. You can’t eliminate politics in hiring in many positions (i.e. senior positions). Those in charge should be entitled to have the people on staff they want in those positions. As long as they can do the job then I’m good with it. It’s not like it’s some unique thing to the public sector. The private sector does the same thing.

  10. - Precinct Captain - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:07 pm:

    I disagree that hiring based on political considerations is inherently corrosive to good government. However, it can be corrosive to good government when decisions are made to put political allies in positions of power that they are unable to execute or lack experience for.

    If politics is “activities that relate to influencing the actions and policies of a government or getting and keeping power in a government,” then hiring based on political considerations (keeping power via appointment of allies) cannot be inherently corrosive to good government. Thus, only bad management, coercion, theft, etc. are inherently corrosive to good government.

  11. - the Patriot - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:12 pm:

    It is bad. You hire the best people for the job period.

    Edgar did the best at getting qualified people. he raised minimum education standards for people in technical positions. He still gave preference to republicans, no doubt about it, but they had to…for the most part be qualified. You will never get this 100% right. Ryan, the Blago, and Quinn have eliminated any thought of qualifications.

    The fact is the democrats are in power so they get the heat on this, but republican legislators still make their play for patronage jobs when they can…the opportunities are just fewer for the minority party.

  12. - Chicago Cynic - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:15 pm:

    I voted yes, but it’s really too narrowly tailored. Politics can be one consideration, but it should never be the primary consideration. Our world exists in shades of gray and this is just a smidge too black and white.

  13. - A guy... - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:16 pm:

    couldn’t cast a vote. If it’s only based on political considerations; yes. If political considerations only got one to the interview and didn’t preordain the job; no.

  14. - DuPage - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:16 pm:

    Politics should not be used either way. It should not be used as a qualification to be hired. At the same time it should not disqualify anyone who otherwise can do the job.

  15. - Carl Nyberg - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:17 pm:

    Having people with strong social connections to other people in the organization promotes cohesiveness.

    The organization will move with more unity of purpose.

    This can be a good thing or a bad thing.

    That said, I find the practice of government agencies hiring lobbyists to be… open for abuse. Lobbyists can’t be held accountable for passing or blocking legislation. So, it seems like a way to funnel money to people who are insiders.

  16. - phocion - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:18 pm:

    Too broad a question. There are political types who are hired to ensure policy is followed. Then there are the vast majority of the public employee workforce who should be allowed to do their jobs without political consideration. If the second arena becomes polluted by political considerations in hiring, then it is corrosive.

  17. - D.P.Gumby - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:19 pm:

    Neither answer is possible because both answers are correct. Depends too much on the individual. RFK as Atty General was both, for example.

  18. - Anon. - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:20 pm:

    I voted no, because at the policy level political considerations have to matter. The governor, for example, should be able to hire his own people for the top spots in his agencies. There is a level of employment at which technical competence should matter more than political considerations, but even then, I see nothing inherently wrong with hiring a competent IT person who is a member of the governor’s party ahead of an equally competent person who is not.

  19. - fed up - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:20 pm:

    Word, I take it you know that the IRS and FBI looked into Madigan, at Fitzgerlds urging and found nothing.

    im sure their are many people that the feds never got around to because even they have limits to their resources

  20. - Rich Miller - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:21 pm:

    ===because even they have limits to their resources===

    Yeah. That’s it. They ran out of resources.

  21. - bored now - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:23 pm:

    i voted yes. we elect leaders to represent us in governance, not to serve as job placement consultants…

  22. - Carl Nyberg - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:23 pm:

    The whole “best person for the job” is silly.

    You can’t tell on the front end who will excel at a job and who will just perform “middle of the pack”. And someone who might be great working for supervisor A might not be as good working for supervisor B.

    If there was a system of telling who would excel at a job, everybody would use it. But we don’t have that system.

    It reflects ignorance of the real world to pretend it’s self-evident who the best candidate for positions are.

    Why was “Always On My Mind” a huge hit for Willie Nelson but not so for Elvis Presley? Smart money is that Presley could get more mileage out of a song than Nelson. But in this case, the reverse was true.

  23. - Darienite - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:25 pm:

    Phocian gave the best comment. My vote was ‘agree’, considering rank and file public employees.

  24. - Wensicia - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:26 pm:

    Political considerations to the exclusion of everything else, yes.

  25. - Darienite - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:29 pm:

    ==I see nothing inherently wrong with hiring a competent IT person who is a member of the governor’s party ahead of an equally competent person who is not.==
    So (and ignore Rutan for the sake of arguement) you don’t have a problem when the opposing party’s candidate gets elected and replaces all IT people if the registered with the other party? I

  26. - April Fool - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:36 pm:

    What are “political considerations” anyway? People who do political work? The kid of a campaign donor? A politician’s neighbor’s son or daughter?

    The fact of the matter is that there are people that are hired based on “political considerations” that are very good at their job, and there are people that are hired based on “political considerations” that are complete knuckleheads.

    Similarly I have seen people who aren’t political who are very good at their jobs and also people who aren’t political who are knuckleheads.

    To get ahead, its not just about what you know, but who you know as well - and this isn’t unique to Illinois or government.

  27. - steve schnorf - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:39 pm:

    Dariente, Illinois is a state with a fairly highly politicized government. Still, do you know anyone, anytime, who has actually done what you suggest? Straw man! I voted “No”.. Hiring incompetent people is far more corrosive.

  28. - wordslinger - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 3:55 pm:

    –im sure their are many people that the feds never got around to because even they have limits to their resources–

    The U.S. Attorney for Northern Illinois, for 11 years?

    You don’t think Madigan was at the top of the list for these egomaniacs the whole time, and every resource would have been committed to take him down?

    You can’t be serious.

  29. - steve schnorf - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 4:05 pm:

    Assertions that are overly broad are frequently wrong. Had the statement said “Unfettered political hiring” there probably wouldn’t be so much blowback on here, where the blog entries trace a different trajectory than the poll numbers

  30. - Anon 1 - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 4:10 pm:

    I have never worked at or heard of a place of employment that always hired “The best person for the job”.

    In the business world friends and relatives get hired all the time. The difference is those people will much more likely lose their job or be moved around for non-performance.

  31. - Just Me - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 4:14 pm:

    I would like someone to ask Mr. Gates if anyone from the Speaker’s Office, or anyone associated with the Speaker, ever recommended the Speaker’s son-in-law. I would also be curious why only two people were interviewed for such an important position.

    After last week’s revealing of the Speaker’s long influence in hiring at Metra it is a very fair question.

  32. - roscoe tom - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 5:00 pm:

    Tell me everyone that serves in the US Attorney’s Office doesn’t have a “letter of recommendation” from “someone” or a call that speaks to how “wonderful and brillant” they are and I will once again believe in the Easter Bunny.

  33. - illini67 - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 5:01 pm:

    The Illinois DNR is a good example. One high level employee was put on unpaid leave, another was demoted and then resigned, one more was being paid by the state while traveling to fishing competitions and yet another was forced to repay $7200 in bogus travel expenses. All political appointees if I am not mistaken!

  34. - Walker - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 5:13 pm:

    Straight up: I had a major difficulty giving any credence to the task force report, because Fitzgerald had anything to do with it.

    I took a breath and read it, and some of their findings were worthwhile, especially on structure and authority, when they didn’t waste their time with the hiring distractions.

  35. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 5:19 pm:

    I’m with Schnorf.

    Hiring based solely on political considerations is generally a bad idea.

    But lets be honest, Mr. Fitzgerald:

    Nearly every lawyer at every law firm in America got their foot in the door because they knew somebody.

    If your accusation is true, the corrosion on our legal system is far worse. In fact, it is nothing but rust.

  36. - vibes - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 5:21 pm:

    I’m w/ Schnorf: “Hiring based ONLY on political considerations” is of course corrosive. Hiring blind to political considerations, as Mr. Fitzgerald believes is possible, simply ignores human nature and compromise.

    That said, I always thought the RTA hire was boneheaded and politically blind on its own, as it opened them up for just that kind of cheap shot.

  37. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 5:43 pm:

    @vibes -

    We can have a reasonable debate on that one.

    Madigan is Fitzgerald’s Moby Dick. Blago wasn’t enough to satisfy his sense of accomplishment, and his senses wax and wane.

  38. - Anonymous - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 6:25 pm:

    Clout over time erodes good government.

  39. - Just The Way It Is One - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 7:12 pm:

    Usually, but not necessarily. Sometimes hiring the right person, who also happens to support one or the Official’s politically and, even more so, as to his/her certain positions or stances on some politically-unresolved issue, may lead to an excellent hire with experience, background, and/or dedication to a subject or cause, which ultimately may further and help achieve progress in the People’s best overall interest/general welfare as to the enactment or implementation of said particular, public policy positions…!

  40. - Bobo - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 9:05 pm:

    It should not be even a question. If anybody ever worked for the City of Chicago during Richard M’s heyday when the Daley volunteers ran roughshod over everybody and everything then you would know how silly the question is.

    Political hiring has made this State and big City a cesspool of under performing and worthless slackers. It has gone on for generations.

  41. - Pot Calling Kettle; Come in Kettle - Monday, Apr 7, 14 @ 11:12 pm:

    Who was Fitzie’s first hire at US Atty office? Maggie Hickey - a political hire from the office of US Sen Peter Fitzgerald - the guy who gave Fitzie his job. When I do it, that’s ok - but when you do it, that’s CORRUPTION!

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.

* Pressure builds on Alvarez, McCarthy
* Final day to file!
* SEIU claims court victory on health insurance
* Question of the day
* So long, Kurt!
* Will "right to work" pop up again?
* A little bit of what's at stake this week
* More poison pills
* Time heals most wounds
* NYT looks at Griffin, Rauner
* LaQuan McDonald case: Three suggestions for state action
* Yesterday's blog posts

Visit our advertisers...







Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

* Google Granted Patent That Enables Self-Driving Cars To Interact With Pedestrians
* Samsung Gear S2 smartwatch not playing nicely with encrypted Androids?
* Karalux unveils the 24K gold BlackBerry Priv!
* Google Street View captures effects of climate change
* LucidCam Hits Its $100K Campaign Goal, Team Partners With Sephora On VR Content
* Oppo takes the wraps off the long-rumored A53 in China
* Adobe launches new Premiere Clip application for Android

* Non-tender deadline looks familiar for White Sox
* Detroit Tigers make AL Central's first big splash with Jordan Zimme...
* South Side Sox' SB Nation MLB Awards voting results
* Starting Pitcher Rankings: Chris Sale and Jose Quintana maintain st...
* Scouting profile: Adam Engel
* Alex Avila will try to shed limitations with White Sox
* White Sox program provides kids real chance


Main Menu
Pundit rankings
Subscriber Content
Blagojevich Trial
Updated Posts

November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005


RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0


* Judge orders Illinois to pay home health worker.....
* Judge orders Illinois to pay $13M owed for home.....
* Judge orders Illinois to pay $13M owed for home.....
* Judge orders Illinois to pay $13M owed for home.....
* Sharpton calls for special prosecutor in Chicag.....
* Cities, counties struggle during Illinois budge.....
* City governments feel pinch in Illinois' budget.....
* Cities, counties struggle during Illinois budge.....
* Cities, counties struggle during Illinois budge.....
* Cities, counties struggle during Illinois budge.....

* Judge orders Illinois to pay home health workers' insurance
* 3rd man charged with murder in Chicago triple homicide
* Cities, counties struggle during Illinois budget mess
* 1st weekend of Illinois firearm deer hunt beats last year
* Police investigate break-ins at 4 Champaign-Urbana hotspots
* Urbana chef taps family members for his kitchen staff
* Chicago police: Man steals van with 2-year-old girl inside
* Man in custody after bodies found in Lake County home
* Report: SAFB considered for new spy agency office since 2005
* Chicago announces expansion of police body-camera program

* Judge orders Illinois to pay home health workers' insurance
* Cities, counties struggle during Illinois budget mess
* 'Pot doctors' pushing boundaries in Illinois, other states
* Burger King manager: Police erased video of Chicago shooting
* Local free community college plans may be template for U.S.
* Rauner faces challenges in move to block refugees
* Vendor Payment Program suspended due to budget impasse
* Rauner pardons man found innocent of 1999 attack
* Springfield jobless rate falls again, to 5.1 percent
* Springfield police chief sees problems with body cam law

* Suspect in custody for U of C threats that closed campus
* Suspect arrested for U of C threat that closed campus
* IMF adds China's yuan to basket of top currencies
* Obama's Chicago fundraisers slower to step up for Clinton
* Deere cutting 220 workers in Moline

* Cop who shot Laquan McDonald due back in court
* Is Anita Alvarez losing her Hispanic political base?
* Sports Illustrated: Blackhawks whiff on Stadium Series jerseys
* THE WATCHDOGS: How Midway clout king got out of property taxes
* Trump scraps endorsement event after black pastors object
* Chicago Teachers Union plans strike vote on Dec. 9: report
* Obama visits Bataclan, site of French terror attack
* Niklas Hjalmarsson skates swiftly and carries a big stick
* Bears may offer suite life at ground level
* Officials see uptick in historic renovations in Springfield

* Student with gun, ammunition arrested at Barrington High School
* 1 in custody in threat at University of Chicago linked to Laquan McDonald shooting
* Bond set at $1.5M for cop in Laquan McDonald shooting
* South Side shooting wounds man
* Tribune Publishing statement: Not in discussions to sell company
* Teen charged with shooting at Fuller Park that killed 3, wounded 2
* Winter overnight parking ban starts Tuesday
* Holiday toll: 8 killed, 20 wounded over Thanksgiving weekend
* Squad car crashes during chase of stolen van with girl, 2, inside
* No injuries when part of building collapses in Back of the Yards

* Cities, counties struggle during Illinois budget mess
* James Durkin: Compromise needed to restore Illinois' standing
* Bernard Schoenburg: Book on Blagojevich impeachment lets reader 'be right there'
* Andy Shaw: It's time to crack down on no-bid contracts
* 'Pot doctors' pushing boundaries in Illinois, other states
* Burger King manager: Police erased video of Chicago shooting
* Kristina Rasmussen: Relying on one another, not the government
* Charles Krauthammer: The Syrian immigration cul-de-sac
* Rob Elliott: EPA ethanol ruling affects more than energy policy
* Local free community college plans may be template for U.S.

* Police evacuate Eastlawn in Rantoul for nearby incident
* Cyber Monday sales still on top, but losing some luster
* Dec. 1 Scott Richey chat
* Police seeking Champaign bank robber
* 11-30-15 Monday Morning Quarterbacks
* Thorne tears meniscus
* Illinois assistant leaving
* Chicago police officer who fatally shot teen due in court
* The Latest: Student leader says few details given on threat
* Ford to book $600 million 4th quarter expense for new labor contract

* Student in custody after bringing gun to Barrington High School
* Winthrop Harbor teen pleads guilty in fatal crash
* Bills defense depleted by injuries to Carrington, Bradham
* Chiefs LB Justin Houston has knee strain, outlook unclear
* The Latest: 6 nations call for a price on carbon dioxide

* House lawmakers overcome hurdle on key tra...
* Rodney Davis talks funding with Bloomingto...
* The agency that fought Illiana gets a new ...
* Rep. Dold takes educational cruise down Ch...
* Lawmakers decry high turnover rate of VA h...
* CBD Oil, and politics
* Simon considering state Senate bid
* Killer Congressman Tom MacArthur trying to...
* Shutdown? State may not notice
* Rep. Bob Dold

* Tightening L-1 Rules in Grassley/Durbin Bi......
* Durbin Pushing for Spending Bill - Alton D......

* Manchin, Kirk introduce bill targeting gov......

* EXTRA: What is point of $1M bond?
* Resign.
* The John Arnold behind pension theft and Pay for Success.
* Morning Minute: Pending home sales headed slightly higher in October
* Chicago To Expand Police Body Camera Program
* Advocates Meet With Rauner's Office, Call For Acceptance Of Syrian Refugees
* Report: CTU To Hold December 9 Strike Authorization Vote
* Teen Viral Sensation Says McDonald Shooting Proves Cops, Conservatives Are Racists
* Harris runs to split black vote, defeat Zopp, and position Duckworth against Kirk
* GOP Hindu-American Political Arm Emerges for 2016 Elections

* Emergency Management Officials, National Weather Service Encourage Winter Preparedness - November is Winter Weather Preparedness Month in Illinois
* Keep Your Family Safe This Winter - November through February are leading months for carbon monoxide related incidents
* Governor Takes Bill Action
* Illinois Department of Labor Director Hugo Chaviano Awards Governor’s Award for Contributions in Health and Safety to the Illinois Refining Division of Marathon Petroleum Company LP
* State Regulator Elected Treasurer of Interstate Medical Licensure Compact

Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller