SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
County Teasurer ruling darkens pension bill future

Friday, Apr 25, 2014

Posted by Barton Lorimor (@bartonlorimor)

* If you’re counting on the state pension bill to survive the Constitutionality test, thi certainly doesn’t help…

In a case with implications for the upcoming legal battle over pension reform, an Illinois appellate court in Springfield ruled that constitutional protections prevent the state from reducing mandated payments to county treasurers.

The pension protection clause of the Illinois Constitution, which says that workers’ retirement benefits can’t be diminished, is at the heart of lawsuits challenging statewide pension changes enacted late last year.

While the county treasurers’ case relies on other language in the constitution, the appellate court’s decision yesterday is analogous, using the same legal arguments and precedents that teachers and other state workers are pressing in court against pension reform.

“It supports the arguments we have been making and will continue to make,” said John Fitzgerald, partner in Chicago law firm Tabet DiVito & Rothstein LLC, which represents retired teachers and school administrators, both active and retired, in a suit challenging the pension law.

Under Illinois law, county treasurers are supposed to get an annual $6,500 stipend from the state. The treasurers sued when their annual stipends were reduced to $4,196 in the year ended June 30, 2010.

The state even pointed to a shortage in the General Assembly’s appropriation, but that argument didn’t get them anywhere.

* A pension round-up…

* Sun-Times: Reject firefighter staffing bill: Why then, we can only wonder, is the Illinois Legislature seemingly so eager to get behind a bill that would give labor unions more say in how many firefighters and paramedics a town must hire? The bill would take hiring decisions, in part, out of the hands of those best positioned to decide right — elected officials, village managers and other professional staff. And the bill would drive up costs for dozens of already cash-strapped suburbs and towns. (Want to guess how often the firefighters union in a typical town thinks there are enough firefighters?) The bill in Springfield — already passed by 63-44 in the House and headed for Senate — would make firefighter staffing levels part of labor contract negotiations. The Senate should pour water all over this one. Drown it.
http://chicago.cbslocal.com/2014/04/24/study-firefighters-more-susceptible-to-cancer/

* Mayor Emanuel criticized for proposed property tax hike

* Argus: For mayors, governors, opposites attract

- Posted by Barton Lorimor        


33 Comments
  1. - Archimedes - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 12:00 pm:

    The appellate decision is not unlike the previous ISC decision where Blago attempted to short the judges during their term.

    In reading the comments to the article in Crains, I am amazed at how people still don’t understand the problem. The unfunded liability of $96 billion is money owed for pension credit for service already performed - you can never change that without offer and acceptance. You can’t change the constitution in the present (some propose an amendment altering the pension clause) and eliminate the debt incurred from past service - that is prohibited by State and Federal constitutions (no ex post facto law).


  2. - VanillaMan - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 12:13 pm:

    There will need to be another way to handle this debt load. Between the sacred cows surrounding it and the state constitution protecting it, there will need to be another way of handling this debt.

    What if we had a governor who understood high finance, instead of patronage? Hmmmm….


  3. - PublicServant - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 12:15 pm:

    What if we had a governor and legislature who understood the State and Federal Constitutions? Hmmmmmm…


  4. - PublicServant - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 12:18 pm:

    ===There will need to be another way to handle this debt load.===

    Pay it by eliminating the State’s structural deficit might be legal, but I’m not a lawyer.


  5. - Norseman - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 12:32 pm:

    This is another sideshow for the main event. As Archimedes points out, there has been a Supreme Court ruling that dealt with this type of issue.


  6. - Precinct Captain - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 12:34 pm:

    “What if we had a governor who understood high finance, instead of patronage? Hmmmm….”

    But Bruce Rauner is a salesman, not an analyst, as he himself says, so who are you referring to? Third party candidates?


  7. - Norseman - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 12:37 pm:

    === What if we had a governor who understood high finance, instead of patronage? Hmmmm…. ===

    What if we had a General Assembly and Chief Executive who could read the constitution and understand that it’s meant to be followed? If they had, they could have worked on a real solution to the problem.


  8. - Frenchie Mendoza - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 12:57 pm:

    If this is the case — and it’s no surprise of course given the language in the constitution — how can Rauner with a straight fae continue to claim that he’ll force all *current* employees into 401k?

    Obviously, he’s using the claim to gain votes — but he can’t be serious about actually doing it. And if he is — if he is serious — he’s mad. If a 401K is *not* a diminishment, I don’t know what is.


  9. - Mason born - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 1:13 pm:

    Frenchie

    I’ve always wondered if the Forced is more i’ll offer you a deal you can’t refuse.


  10. - Frenchie Mendoza - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 1:15 pm:

    I suspect he’s considered the I’ll-fire-all-state-employees-and-then-rehire-them under new retirement rules.


  11. - dupage dan - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 1:25 pm:

    First Arizona and now this. Can Quinn still call this an up day? If you are a state employee (include me in that) how can you have many positive thoughts about him? If you are a retired state employee how can you consider voting for him? I know folks can say Rauner hates unions and all that. But with Quinn, there are real statements. Real actions. Not just words but deeds.


  12. - PublicServant - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 1:36 pm:

    DD, I always vote, so I’m not staying home. I loathe the idea of voting for Quinn, but I’d rather vote FOR the goof I know, rather than the alternative, when the alternative is attempting to make a mockery of our democracy by buying the office. That, to me, is the most important consideration. Secondly, when you vote, you can’t vote against someone, you have to vote for someone. Even if I could get by the his attempt to purchase the office, there’s nothing, absolutely nothing to vote FOR in him.


  13. - Cowboy - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 1:45 pm:

    Related to Archimedes above - another of those often-overlooked issues that is quite relevant to “the problem” - do an Internet search for “Illinois legislator compensation” and see what you find. Then compare with every state that shares a border with Illinois. And who are the next highest? Oops - Michigan and Wisconsin. Is there a pattern here related to fiscal messes at the state level?


  14. - UIC guy - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 1:48 pm:

    @Frenchie If he gives people the choice between 1. losing their jobs but keeping the (pre-December 2013) retirement benefits already ; and 2. being rehired under a much less favorable retirement plan (backdated to when they started working for the state) —if that’s the choice then we’re going to see a huge rush for the exits.

    @PublicServant: I’m with you on this. Many votes you have to hold your nose to cast, and voting for Squeezy would take a tighter squeeze than most, but what’s the alternative?

    @ Everyone: any news/rumors about Maag?


  15. - Geronimo - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 1:49 pm:

    Maybe all the blatant defiance of the constitution along with (the 2) farcical candidates explains,in part, why Illinoisans feel so negatively about our state. Where are the decent, moral politicians?


  16. - dupage dan - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 1:51 pm:

    PS === when the alternative is attempting to make a mockery of our democracy by buying the office ===

    You mean like when Quinn blew $50 million bucks on a fubar crime program just before the last election?

    I understand the frustration, believe me. I have been in state service 24 years and am tired of it. The only difference I see here, frankly, is that Quinn is actually DOING it, while Rauner is just SAYING it. Folks say all kinds of things in order to get elected and then - POOF - they get into office and things can change. Problem is, not always for the better. The bird in the hand is inedible. The bird in the bush will kill you. Nice choice, huh?


  17. - AFSCME Steward - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 1:56 pm:

    Cowboy

    “Then compare with every state that shares a border with Illinois. And who are the next highest? Oops - Michigan and Wisconsin. Is there a pattern here related to fiscal messes at the state level?”

    Michigan doesn’t share a border with Illinois.


  18. - anon - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 1:57 pm:

    Illinois Supreme Court usually announces opinions a few days in advance. Go to home page on website and click on “anticipated Opinions” on the left. No Maag yet but keep checking. http://www.state.il.us/court/default.asp


  19. - anon - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 1:59 pm:

    If Maag rules that health benefits are not constitutionally protected, the line of authority relied on in the treasurer case will not apply.


  20. - Norseman - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 2:01 pm:

    === I suspect he’s considered the I’ll-fire-all-state-employees-and-then-rehire-them under new retirement rules. ===

    LOL. Nice snark.


  21. - Norseman - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 2:08 pm:

    === If Maag rules that health benefits are not constitutionally protected, the line of authority relied on in the treasurer case will not apply. ===

    Please explain. Before I agree or disagree, I want to understand your point.


  22. - Skeptic - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 2:23 pm:

    “Michigan doesn’t share a border with Illinois.” If I’m not mistaken, it does. You just have to get wet to see it.


  23. - anon - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 2:32 pm:

    In stating that the separation of powers doctrine could not stop the courts from issuing an order requiring the State to pay the treasurer stipend despite lack of appropriation, the court limited its holding to matters protected by the constitution. In other words, if an adverse ruling in Maag is based on a finding that health benefits do not fall within the pension clause or another provision of the Illinois constitution, that opinion may have little impact on the pension litigation.


  24. - Geronimo - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 2:33 pm:

    Good point, dupage dan about Quinn actually DOING damage to state employees and Rauner just talking about it. How cooperative would the legislature be with Rauner in office vs. Quinn? A factor to consider when having to choose between 2 poisons.


  25. - Old Shepherd - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 2:33 pm:

    Regarding the treasurers, in Harlan v. Sweet the Supreme Court determined that treasurers’ stipends are indeed to be considered compensation. I’m no attorney, but I don’t see how Maag changes anything regarding the line of authority on the treasurers’ case.


  26. - Tsavo - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 2:44 pm:

    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/04/25/koch-brothers-pension-reform_n_5213416.html?utm_hp_ref=politics

    Check out this article about the pension seminar.


  27. - Cowboy - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 2:45 pm:

    AFSCME Steward - Michigan shares a border with Illinois via a water border in Lake Michigan.


  28. - anon - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 2:56 pm:

    Just checked and the Illinois Supreme Court is not hearing arguments next week. Would love to know whether any of the justices are attending the Koch Brothers pension theft propaganda fest. Reporters? How about a FOIA request for their schedules? Would be a bombshell article if anyone attended.


  29. - Walter Mitty - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 3:20 pm:

    Insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.

    Albert Einstein

    See Illinois voting in the same politicians.


  30. - I B Strapped - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 3:25 pm:

    Public Servant @ 1:36- Don’t wish to be argumentative but I’ve read and re-read your comment and I don’t see the positive reason to vote FOR an incompetent GOOF, who I feel has Bleeped me! I don’t think I could possibly vote for Rauner either as a friend of my enemy may not be my friend. So, IMHO, dare I say it- It’s a Hot, Steaming Mess.


  31. - Norseman - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 3:36 pm:

    - anon - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 2:32 pm

    Thank you for the explanation.


  32. - RNUG - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 4:00 pm:

    - anon - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 2:32 pm: &
    - Norseman - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 3:36 pm:

    Regardless of any Pension Clause protection or lack thereof, I suspect any Maag / Kanerva ruling will center on contract law since one of the trail level findings said there was no contract. If the ISC finds there is or may be a presumption of a contract (as found by Appellate in Marconi v Joliet), then I would think the Constitution’s Contract Clause should apply.


  33. - forwhatitsworth - Friday, Apr 25, 14 @ 4:00 pm:

    Has anyone ever heard of Ralph Martire?


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* Rauner oppo watch
* Zorn nails it again
* *** UPDATED x1 *** If at first you don't succeed...
* Lower ratings for ABC 7 debate
* Question of the day
* Bloomberg to spend $1.9 million on Dold
* Stand down... mostly
* BLS: A strong couple of months
* *** UPDATED x1 *** SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Fundraising reports by targeted legislative districts
* Rate Sheila Simon's new TV ad
* Poe set to begin transplant process, faces "extended" recovery
* Rauner runs new TV ad touting newspaper endorsements
* *** UPDATED x2 - "Comical" - "No interest" *** Despite shout-outs, Neely says she and Rauner haven't talked
* Grimm on 150 - Minimum wage battles in other states - The return of "Matt the Welder" - Rauner on "right to work"
* A bevy of new congressional TV ads
* Quinn tax hike dodge count: 4
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Supplement to today’s edition: Crosstabs, cable TV buys, ads
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
* Today's number: 165
* A grand good morning to you all!
* Yesterday's blog posts

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............

...............

...............


Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

          
        * Apple breaks records, Nexus Ambient Display, Microsoft Lumia & more – Pocketnow Daily
        * HERE beta version now available for other Android devices
        * HTC EYE update rolls out for T-Mobile One M8, Verizon tomorrow
        * iPad Air 2 Review: The Best Tablet Available, Now More Portable And Powerful
        * iPad Mini 3 Review: Apple’s Small Tablet Stays Mostly The Same
        * Arq Dock 2.0: a gadget stand and charger in one
        * The new money: using Apple Pay in the real world (Video)

        * Apple Pay Found To Be Usable In Overseas With Some Tweaking
        * Apple Pay Rewards Program To Launch This Holiday Season [Rumor]
        * Maps Connect Web Portal Helps To Make Apple Maps More Accurate
        * Oppo N3 Teased Again On Facebook, Shows Off Fingerprint Scanner
        * Onyx Smartwatch Will Use An E-Ink Display For Better Battery Life
        * iPad Air 2′s A8X Chip Found To Be Of The Triple-Core Variety
        * Google To Roll Out Improved Anti-Piracy Search Algorithm

        * World Series Game 1: Notes and discussion
        * The e-gus off-season plan
        * Reading Room: A wild card of a World Series
        * Following same path as '59 White Sox, KC eyes title
        * larry's Offseason Plan
        * Abreu wins Sporting News' AL Rookie of the Year honors
        * Jose Abreau wins the Sporting News AL Rookie of the Year


        Main Menu
        Home
        Illinois
        YouTube
        Pundit rankings
        Obama
        Subscriber Content
        Durbin
        Burris
        Blagojevich Trial
        Advertising
        Updated Posts
        Polls

        Archives
        October 2014
        September 2014
        August 2014
        July 2014
        June 2014
        May 2014
        April 2014
        March 2014
        February 2014
        January 2014
        December 2013
        November 2013
        October 2013
        September 2013
        August 2013
        July 2013
        June 2013
        May 2013
        April 2013
        March 2013
        February 2013
        January 2013
        December 2012
        November 2012
        October 2012
        September 2012
        August 2012
        July 2012
        June 2012
        May 2012
        April 2012
        March 2012
        February 2012
        January 2012
        December 2011
        November 2011
        October 2011
        September 2011
        August 2011
        July 2011
        June 2011
        May 2011
        April 2011
        March 2011
        February 2011
        January 2011
        December 2010
        November 2010
        October 2010
        September 2010
        August 2010
        July 2010
        June 2010
        May 2010
        April 2010
        March 2010
        February 2010
        January 2010
        December 2009
        November 2009
        October 2009
        September 2009
        August 2009
        July 2009
        June 2009
        May 2009
        April 2009
        March 2009
        February 2009
        January 2009
        December 2008
        November 2008
        October 2008
        September 2008
        August 2008
        July 2008
        June 2008
        May 2008
        April 2008
        March 2008
        February 2008
        January 2008
        December 2007
        November 2007
        October 2007
        September 2007
        August 2007
        July 2007
        June 2007
        May 2007
        April 2007
        March 2007
        February 2007
        January 2007
        December 2006
        November 2006
        October 2006
        September 2006
        August 2006
        July 2006
        June 2006
        May 2006
        April 2006
        March 2006
        February 2006
        January 2006
        December 2005
        April 2005
        March 2005
        February 2005
        January 2005
        December 2004
        November 2004
        October 2004

        Blog*Spot Archives
        November 2005
        October 2005
        September 2005
        August 2005
        July 2005
        June 2005
        May 2005

        Syndication

        RSS Feed 2.0
        Comments RSS 2.0
        WordPress

        Loading


        * Gov. Quinn issues statement on positive economi.....
        * Haine calls on Gov. Quinn to deny clemency to c.....
        * Pat Quinn - The Bugle..


        * Family, friends remember women slain in Indiana
        * Indiana man was violent long before 7 killings
        * Police: Indiana man confesses to all 7 killings
        * Expert: PTSD could be factor in activist's past
        * Former President Clinton stumps for Quinn, Durbin
        * Ballot error stops early voting in Rockford again
        * Ebola causing spike in demand for hospital gear
        * State: Jimmy John's founder owes taxes on planes
        * Former President Clinton stumps for Quinn, Durbin
        * VP Joe Biden to campaign for Schneider in Illinois

        * Rep. Raymond Poe to undergo stem cell transplant
        * Bill Clinton campaigns for Quinn, Durbin
        * Quinn, Rauner spar over jobs, taxes
        * Election 2014: Learn about all the candidates
        * What to watch for in third governor debate tonight
        * U of I sees turning point as election nears
        * Chicago Sun-Times endorses Rauner for governor
        * Sun-Times, Belleville, Champaign, Peoria newspapers endorse Rauner for governor
        * Bill Clinton to address workers at pro-Quinn rally
        * Body camera use concerns Illinois police officers

        * What's next for Tribune, Sun-Times in burb paper deal
        * Chicago heating bills will be significantly lower (if winter cooperates)
        * Chicago heating bills will be far lower (if winter cooperates)
        * Walgreen seeks to seal parts of former CFO's lawsuit
        * O'Hare now a hub for screening travelers from Ebola hot spots


        * Father Bob Botthof, teacher who became priest after losing wife, dies at 85
        * Back to the past with mayor’s move
        * Dr. Lawrence Solomon: Renowned dermatologist, book collector loved a mystery
        * Emanuel’s cable tax hike to cost average consumer $28.80 a year
        * Fix pot law conflicts so industry can grow
        * Chicago Public Schools to sell headquarters for $28 million
        * Cardinal George’s advice to Archbishop Cupich: ‘Spend a lot of time listening’
        * Convicted sex offender in custody after 7 bodies found in NW Indiana
        * Fioretti tries to put heat on Emanuel over short yellow lights
        * Neely’s pre-election resignation deja vu of how she got her start


        * Inquiry broadens into suspect in Indiana serial killings
        * Emanuel set to outline re-election agenda with five speeches
        * Cook County Jail guard, inmates charged in drug smuggling
        * Man admits hate crime in West Side attack on lesbian couple
        * Chicago cops to get 2,500 bulletproof vests
        * 2 men charged with train graffiti had CTA keys, uniforms: Police
        * Historian unearths IDs of thousands buried in Dunning mass grave
        * Oberweis struggles to raise funds, records show
        * DCFS investigates drowning death of infant in Cicero
        * 2 women found dead after Northwest Side fire identified


        * Lincoln Legacy Lecture Series To Focus On "Lincoln's Funeral"
        * Small Campaign Contributions Amount To Chump Change
        * Civic Fed: Lawmakers Once Again Taking Illinois Down Bad Budget Path
        * Cheddar's Leaves Springfield WUIS-SJR Business Report
        * Area Cub Scouts Burned In Explosion
        * Notes On The Final Governor Debate
        * Task Force Hopes To Help Turn Students Into Good Citizens
        * Digging up the history of a Civil War camp on Chicago's South Side
        * Indiana suspect hints at more killings
        * UIS Poverty Series Continues With "American Winter" Screening


        * Rep. Raymond Poe to undergo stem cell transplant
        * Bill Clinton campaigns for Quinn, Durbin
        * Joanna McQuillan Weeks: Cheese balls deserve more respect
        * Our Opinion: White, Madigan for another term
        * Quinn, Rauner spar over jobs, taxes
        * Our Opinion: Say yes to Magro’s project
        * John Schick: Letter confirmed aggression toward bicyclists
        * Election 2014: Learn about all the candidates
        * U of I sees turning point as election nears
        * Our Opinion: Re-elect Durbin for another term in U.S. Senate


        * Area girls' golf rankings: M-S in spotlight
        * Danville mainstay closes doors
        * Fairview Heights City Council votes down clerk pay increase, again
        * Fourth annual Heartland Region Student Summit set for Nov. 7 to 9
        * PHOTOS: Pumpkin Patch Night
        * Local author to hold book signing
        * Regional HS Soccer: Centennial vs. Central
        * Timber Management Field Day set
        * SportsTalk 10-21-14
        * Former Saluki Agnew waived by Browns


        * Police retrace steps of suspected serial killer
        * Indiana man was violent long before 7 killings
        * Former Washington Post editor Ben Bradlee dies
        * Counting down to Saturday's big event
        * Harvest Christian falls in boys soccer sectional

        * Patrick Cannon defense strategy rare but n...
        * Feds fine Jesse Jackson Jr.'s campaign com...
        * Ex-Congressman Jesse Jackson Jr. faces sen...
        * Representative Jan Schakowsky Sends Letter...
        * Rep. candidate pushes to uphold marriage b...
        * Reps. Schakowsky and Waxman Introduce Bill...
        * Statement by Representative Jan Schakowsky...
        * U.S. House Passes Resolution Condemning An...
        * FAA Rejects Call For New O'Hare Noise Stud...
        * Representatives Quigley, Duckworth, Schako...

        * Clinton campaigns for Quinn, Rauner campai......
        * Clinton campaigns for Quinn, Rauner campai......
        * Clinton campaigns for Quinn, Rauner campai......
        * Clinton campaigns for Quinn, Rauner campai......
        * Clinton campaigns for Quinn, Rauner campai......

        * Obama Might Try To Circumvent Congress On ......
        * Senator Mark Kirk: Congress Will Not Suppo......

        * Because it was awesome.
        * Waukegan’s school board president speaks. Crazy talk.
        * New Bost ad hits Illinois 12th Congressional District [video]
        * Batinick says Dunn's desperate campaign charges are "ridiculous"
        * Topinka says reducing income tax would cause a heart attack to the state
        * Early Voting Halted in Winnebago County, Illinois Due to Ballot Mistake
        * Illinois Supreme Court Candidate Exposes Members of Shadowy Political Group
        * Illinois Supreme Court Candidate Under Attack by Shadowy Political Group
        * Bustos and Illinois Dems attempt to paint Schilling as "pro-rape"
        * National College Republicans: CCSI Illinois [video]


        * New TV Ad: Endorsed
        * Governor Quinn Statement on Positive Economic News - Illinois Led the Midwest in Job Creation in September and Had Second Best Growth in Nation; Unemployment Rate Has Dropped More Than Any Other State in the Last Year
        * Rauner Campaign Statement on Final Debate
        * What They’re Saying About Pat Quinn
        * What They’re Saying About Bruce Rauner




            Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller