SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
Time for a law change

Tuesday, Jul 8, 2014

* From Section 5-227 of the state’s Pension Code

None of the benefits provided for in this Article shall be paid to any person who is convicted of any felony relating to or arising out of or in connection with his service as a policeman.

That’s pretty darned broad, if you ask me. It’s pretty clear that triggering this provision doesn’t have to directly involve a felony during service, but the felony has to somehow be connected to the service, however loosely.

* This bring us to the disgusting case of former Chicago police Commander Jon Burge

For decades, police and prosecutors had discounted complaints that suspects were being coerced into making false confessions — at gunpoint, with shocks to the genitals or with plastic bags over their heads — at the Area Two headquarters, where Burge supervised the violent crimes unit.

Later, those same authorities wrung their hands and claimed the case against Burge wasn’t strong enough to win a conviction. The evidence was old, they said; the witnesses were uncooperative or unreliable.

After the statute of limitations expired, it fell to U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald to get a measure of justice: In 2010, Burge was convicted of perjury for lying during a 2003 civil trial brought by one of his many victims.

* That felony conviction most certainly “arose” from his service as a police officer. The four members of the police pension board appointed by the mayor voted to yank Burge’s pension. The four police officers on the pension board sided with Burge. Attorney General Lisa Madigan quickly stepped in

A week later, the Attorney General filed suit in the Circuit Court, naming the retiree, the Board and all its individual Trustees as defendants, seeking an injunction to prohibit further pension payments to the retiree and requiring that all payments made since his conviction be refunded. The defendants filed motions to dismiss, alleging that the Circuit Court lacked subject matter jurisdiction over what amounted to a collateral attack on a routine benefits decision of the Board. The Circuit Court agreed and dismissed. The Appellate Court reversed, holding that the Circuit Court had concurrent jurisdiction over the Attorney General’s claims pursuant to Section 1-115 of the Pension Code, which authorizes the Attorney General to sue to “enjoin any act or practice which violates any provision of this Code.” 40 ILCS 5/1-115.

That appellate ruling certainly seemed reasonable since Burge’s conviction was obviously related to his service time. But

The Supreme Court reversed the Appellate Court. The majority notes that Section 5-189 of the Pension Code expressly confers “exclusive original jurisdiction” on the Retirement Board “in all matters relating to of affecting the fund, including . . . all claims for annuities, pensions, benefits or refunds.” That grant of authority includes deciding proposals to “increase, reduce, or suspend” any pension.

The Attorney General argued that Section 1-115 was a sweeping grant of concurrent jurisdiction over any decision to award benefits, so long as the award violated some clause of the Pension Code. The majority disagreed, finding that the Attorney General’s construction would potentially create two tracks of Circuit Court proceedings, one via administrative review, with the Circuit Court required to give deference to the Board’s findings, and one an independent suit under Section 1-115. Such a system would inject “tremendous instability . . . into the Fund.” The majority acknowledged that “[p]reventing significant violations of the Pension Code” were “important goals,” but found that authorizing collateral attacks against any Board decision wasn’t necessary to achieve that goal, since acts in excess of jurisdiction and breaches of the Trustees’ fidicuciary duties could be challenged in separate suits. In addition, the Department of Insurance has general responsibility for examining and investigating pension funds created under the Code. But no such issue was involved in the case, the majority found. The Attorney General’s challenge to the Board’s action was merely an allegation that the Board had erred in failing to terminate benefits on the particular facts involved here – an “individualized error.”

* The dissent was stinging and made a lot of sense

Chief Justice Garman dissented at length, joined by Justice Thomas Kilbride. There were several problems with the majority analysis, the Chief Justice argued. First of all, read literally, Section 5-189 would give the Board exclusive original jurisdiction over its own breaches of fiduciary duty. Second, the majority ignored the breadth of the Trustees’ fiduciary duties. In addition to loyalty, the Trustees have duties to diversify (with limited exceptions), to exercise “care, skill, prudence and diligence,” and to administer in accordance with the Code. So if the retiree’s felony conviction related to, arose out of, or was in connection with his service as a policeman, continuing to pay him benefits was a breach of the Trustees’ fiduciary duty to administer the Fund pursuant to the Code.

Even more disturbing, the Chief Justice argues, the majority’s sweeping construction of the Board’s original and exclusive jurisdiction would seem to place decisions awarding retirement benefits beyond any court review. There was no basis for believing that another system participant could intervene in a retiree’s benefit proceeding. Appeal under the Administrative Review Act was limited to parties of record aggrieved by the decision. Therefore, “[n]o party would have both incentive and ability to challenge the Board’ s error. So long as the Board awards benefits, its errors will now go unchallenged” – even if the Board chose to openly defy a decision of the Supreme Court itself.

Obviously, the statute now needs to be changed.

- Posted by Rich Miller        


25 Comments
  1. - LincolnLounger - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 10:17 am:

    Rita Garman is an Illinois treasure.


  2. - Gift Giver - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 10:23 am:

    This plays right into Rauner’s message about public sector unions. Protecting their own at the expense of the public.

    If he wasn’t so over the top, his message would really be resonating.


  3. - forwhatitsworth - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 10:28 am:

    This comment is a little off the topic of pension reform language, but it is very much connected to yesterday’s hot topic of “What Next.” Many people propose the idea of taxing retirement income/pensions to generate more revenue, yet fixing our outdated taxing structure gets very little mention. Carmello Anthony is in the spotlight as a free agent in the NBA and a possible Chicago Bull. Since 2011 as a New York Knick, Carmello’s New York tax liability has been almost $10 million dollars - $7 million to the state (8.82%) and almost $3 million (3.876%) to New York City. If Carmello had played for the Bulls his tax liability would have been $3.8 million. Why can’t Illinois collect its fair share of revenue from the people who can afford to pay it, instead of creating new taxes on people with limited income to solve Illinois’ economic woes?


  4. - PublicServant - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 10:36 am:

    ===This comment is a little off the topic of pension reform language, but it is very much connected to yesterday’s hot topic of “What Next.” Many people propose the idea of taxing retirement income/pensions to generate more revenue, yet fixing our outdated taxing structure gets very little mention. Carmello Anthony is in the spotlight as a free agent in the NBA and a possible Chicago Bull. Since 2011 as a New York Knick, Carmello’s New York tax liability has been almost $10 million dollars - $7 million to the state (8.82%) and almost $3 million (3.876%) to New York City. If Carmello had played for the Bulls his tax liability would have been $3.8 million. Why can’t Illinois collect its fair share of revenue from the people who can afford to pay it, instead of creating new taxes on people with limited income to solve Illinois’ economic woes?===

    Spot on forwhatitsworth. Carmello is staying in New York by the way. This goes to show that the rich live where they live regardless of the tax burden.

    As for Illinois, our poor economic recovery is based in no small part on our regressive tax system, which collapsed when the great recession hit, and the middle class and poor took it on the chin. If we had had a progressive tax in place, we’d be much better of than we are now by a long shot.


  5. - A guy... - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 10:45 am:

    Not to dispute the fellow above, but Carmelo Anthony was required to file taxes in Illinois, prorated for the number of days he played here. Pro Athletes must file taxes in every state (or province in Canada) and city (where applicable, like NYC) on a pro rata basis. So, his actual NY filing would include home game dates (1/2) + any games in Brooklyn. Your point is still well taken, but the premise is slightly flawed.


  6. - Lil Squeezy - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 10:47 am:

    A member should file suit for breach of fiduciary liability.


  7. - A guy... - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 10:49 am:

    To the post: It’s disgusting that Burge isn’t in jail. More disgusting that he’s receiving a public paid pension, one that even pales in comparison to what “the people” have had to pay out to his victims. This creep is just the gift that keeps on giving. I’m surprised, really surprised, none of those brutally attacked victims never paid him a visit. The pension system has a severe flaw for this creep to get a penny. That blue wall remains solid generation after generation. Ugh.


  8. - PublicServant - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 10:55 am:

    Agreed A Guy. Burge and other pension abusers are what give the pensions a bad name. And I agree with Lil Squeezy too. Those “thin blue line” cops on the board ought to be sued for breach of fiduciary duty.

    And…Rich is right too. We need a pension code change to correct this garbage.


  9. - DuPage - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 11:00 am:

    I thought the pension systems had to follow the law. I guess not.


  10. - Lycurgus - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 11:01 am:

    but wouldn’t a pension code change at this time impair or diminish Burge’s pension rights? Wouldn’t that be unconstitutional? What a world.


  11. - Geronimo - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 11:09 am:

    According to the logic of people and businesses fleeing Illinois should they be required to pay higher taxes, why isn’t New York a ghost town?


  12. - Nonplussed - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 11:12 am:

    A guy: I think Burge is in prison.


  13. - Jake From Elwood - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 11:17 am:

    The four police officers who refused to revoke the pension are to blame here, not the legislature. They are the four who failed to adhere to fiduciary duties in making such a nonsensical finding. Of course the felony is tied to the policework. Shame on these four failed fiduciaries.


  14. - Jake From Elwood - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 11:21 am:

    Also not sure whether the City of Chicago intervened in the case. If not, why not? If they had intervened, they would have likely had standing to fight this issue on appeal, where the AG did not.


  15. - Old and In The Way - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 11:22 am:

    A Guy
    Can’t speak for Carmelo but none of the pro athletes (8) we represent file as you describe. Not sure where you got this.


  16. - A guy... - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 11:44 am:

    ===Old and In The Way - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 11:22 am:

    A Guy
    Can’t speak for Carmelo but none of the pro athletes (8) we represent file as you describe. Not sure where you got this.====

    Check again. My Tax Atty. has several Blackhawks, White Sox, a couple Bulls, and one Cub on his roster. They all file multiple state and province returns.


  17. - A guy... - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 11:46 am:

    ===Nonplussed - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 11:12 am:

    A guy: I think Burge is in prison.====

    Not to quibble with you, but I believe he was in prison awaiting trial and I believe I’ve subsequently read that he moved back to Florida.


  18. - Precinct Captain - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 12:29 pm:

    Jake, I’m not surprised the cops on the pension board voted for Burge. They probably don’t think he did anything wrong and that he’s not a racist too. Could they even be part of the cabal that marched him at the South Side Irish Parade years ago? Wouldn’t surprise me. Denial, obfuscation, and cover up are the name of the game at CPD & FOP. The SA’s office too. The irony of the whole Burge saga is that it was a dead to rights cop killer, Andrew Wilson, who blew the whole thing open.

    A guy, Burge is in prison, #50504-018, in North Carolina. http://www.bop.gov/inmateloc/


  19. - Obamas Puppy - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 1:21 pm:

    ===This plays right into Rauner’s message about public sector unions. Protecting their own at the expense of the public.===
    The law is made by the General Assembly and interpreted by the courts what this has to do with unions is beyond me.


  20. - A guy... - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 1:25 pm:

    === Precinct Captain - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 12:29 pm:

    A guy, Burge is in prison, #50504-018, in North Carolina. http://www.bop.gov/inmateloc/====

    Thanks for the update. Hope it’s not a pleasant stay.


  21. - Tom Joad - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 2:29 pm:

    A Guy
    Can’t speak for Carmelo but none of the pro athletes (8) we represent file as you describe. Not sure where you got this.” Maybe you should call the Illinois Department of Revenue. This has been the law for over 10 years.


  22. - A guy... - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 2:49 pm:

    Here you go:
    www.bostonglobe.com/business/2013/03/21/tax-season-crunch-time-for-accountants-serving-pro-athletes/rA1UqaYIA1AOOE59kHR5uI/story.html


  23. - Former Pension Trustee & Retired - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 4:06 pm:

    The pension trustees did follow the law. Once retired from police service the pensioners actions do not apply. He is no longer a police officer. Commander Burge was not convicted of a crime that occurred while he was a police officer. His conviction is a separate offense that occurred after his police service. You may not agree with that but it is proper.

    There are many other public pensions that have a similar provision. The pensioner must be charged and convicted of a felony that occurred while in office.

    Many politicians skate on this because they were not charged or convicted while in office.

    It appears that Burge was involved in illegal activity. He has not been convicted of any such offense. What about his superiors, the politicians and prosecutors that allowed this to occur?


  24. - Amalia - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 5:22 pm:

    @PrecinctCaptain, who was in the Mayor’s chair 1983-1987? why was nothing done about Burge then?


  25. - Rollo Tomasi - Tuesday, Jul 8, 14 @ 10:28 pm:

    If Burge lost his pension then the same should hold true for Beavers. Funny the four appointed city people all voted to let Beavers keep his pension. Why? Maybe because he’s one of them and refused to wear a wire and get near John Daley. Even convicted felons get treated differently if they hold elected office.


TrackBack URI

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* Question of the day
* Another Bost rant ad released
* Uh-oh
* Today's quotable
* AFSCME goes with Quinn
* *** UPDATED x1 *** Paranoia will destroy 'ya
* *** UPDATED x2 - Sanguinetti responds - NORML blasts Rauner *** Rauner blasts medical marijuana law
* Bost responds to "rant" ad
* Another day, another Rauner deal under the microscope
* Rauner lashes out at Quinn over IDOT scandal
* Dueling ads are no contest
* Paying the price for making bad hires
* Entrenched party portrays itself as the "reform" party
* Starting to gear up a bit
* Yesterday's blog posts

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............


Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

          
        * Moto 360 vs Pebble Steel (Video)
        * This is Tim: Cook talks to Charlie Rose about Apple Watch, Samsung, and the future
        * Shazam update makes it easier to purchase music on Google Play
        * Bose unveils ‘colorful’ Bluetooth speakers, on-ear headset
        * AutoData app turns off data connection to save power
        * Satya Nadella doesn’t define success in mobile by its market share
        * Heli Hell game lets you blow stuff up

        * New Keyboards Bring Faster, Easier Typing to the iPhone 6
        * iOS 8 Review: The Problem Solver
        * iPhone 6 Plus Review: How Big Is Too Big?
        * iPhone 6 Review: It’s a Winner
        * Xbox One Controller For Windows Announced
        * Toshiba Unveils Thinner 20MP CMOS Sensor For Smartphones
        * AirVR Headset Lets You Strap An iPad Mini To Your Face

        * MLB announces Clemente Award nominees
        * White Sox starters lead the way in cutting home run rate
        * White Sox get another look at Bassitt against KC
        * White Sox 'pen burned by KC's speed in ninth
        * South Side Sox Podcast: AL Central Showdown
        * Bullpen can't preserve Danks' fine start in KC
        * Royals 4, White Sox 3: Defense, bullpen astound again


        Main Menu
        Home
        Illinois
        YouTube
        Pundit rankings
        Obama
        Subscriber Content
        Durbin
        Burris
        Blagojevich Trial
        Advertising
        Updated Posts
        Polls

        Archives
        September 2014
        August 2014
        July 2014
        June 2014
        May 2014
        April 2014
        March 2014
        February 2014
        January 2014
        December 2013
        November 2013
        October 2013
        September 2013
        August 2013
        July 2013
        June 2013
        May 2013
        April 2013
        March 2013
        February 2013
        January 2013
        December 2012
        November 2012
        October 2012
        September 2012
        August 2012
        July 2012
        June 2012
        May 2012
        April 2012
        March 2012
        February 2012
        January 2012
        December 2011
        November 2011
        October 2011
        September 2011
        August 2011
        July 2011
        June 2011
        May 2011
        April 2011
        March 2011
        February 2011
        January 2011
        December 2010
        November 2010
        October 2010
        September 2010
        August 2010
        July 2010
        June 2010
        May 2010
        April 2010
        March 2010
        February 2010
        January 2010
        December 2009
        November 2009
        October 2009
        September 2009
        August 2009
        July 2009
        June 2009
        May 2009
        April 2009
        March 2009
        February 2009
        January 2009
        December 2008
        November 2008
        October 2008
        September 2008
        August 2008
        July 2008
        June 2008
        May 2008
        April 2008
        March 2008
        February 2008
        January 2008
        December 2007
        November 2007
        October 2007
        September 2007
        August 2007
        July 2007
        June 2007
        May 2007
        April 2007
        March 2007
        February 2007
        January 2007
        December 2006
        November 2006
        October 2006
        September 2006
        August 2006
        July 2006
        June 2006
        May 2006
        April 2006
        March 2006
        February 2006
        January 2006
        December 2005
        April 2005
        March 2005
        February 2005
        January 2005
        December 2004
        November 2004
        October 2004

        Blog*Spot Archives
        November 2005
        October 2005
        September 2005
        August 2005
        July 2005
        June 2005
        May 2005

        Syndication

        RSS Feed 2.0
        Comments RSS 2.0
        WordPress

        Loading


        * Candidates need reality check on pensions - Chi.....
        * Rauner Fulfills $1M Pledge..
        * Peoria woman highlighted in latest IDOT scandal..
        * Rauner applys pressure to layoff improperly hir.....
        * New subpoena in federal probe of Quinn anti-vio.....
        * The Country’s Opinion Of Congress Has NEVER Bee.....
        * New subpoena issued for Ill. anti-violence program..
        * Student journalists not part of ‘working press’.....


        * Teen eludes electronic monitoring, attacks student
        * APNewsBreak: Chicago DEA chief heading to DC
        * Southwest flight makes emergency landing at Midway
        * McLean County nixes marijuana cultivation center
        * CDC study: Americans' bellies are expanding fast
        * School bus driver killed during safety drill
        * APNewsBreak: Chicago DEA chief heading to DC
        * New subpoena issued for Ill. anti-violence program
        * Nik Wallenda to tightrope walk over Chicago River
        * Columbia murder victims' family seeking damages

        * Evans: Eliminate conflicts of interest in legislature
        * New subpoena issued for Quinn’s anti-violence program
        * Rauner questions medical marijuana program secrecy
        * State legislative panel delays decision on fracking rules
        * Quinn: Monitor not needed to oversee state hiring
        * Video of state lawmaker's tirade resurfaces in U.S. House race
        * Rauner’s call for firings of ‘illegal patronage hires’ would affect many in Springfield
        * Quinn, Rauner clash on business, hiring
        * Coaltion forms to push school funding reform
        * Rauner’s education plan raises eyebrows

        * American Airlines agents approve union
        * Southwest flight makes emergency landing at Midway
        * CME, floor traders settle lawsuit
        * Floor traders cave, settle suit against CME
        * Boeing, SpaceX to share big NASA contract


        * Wallenda will walk tightrope across Chicago River in November
        * Probation officer suspended after teen’s assault on CSU student
        * No bail for teen accused of sexually assaulting CSU student
        * Flawed reform is better than none
        * Mexican Independence Day parade attracts plenty of pols
        * Southwest Airlines flight makes emergency landing at Midway
        * Wallenda’s walk — watch it or not?
        * Gov’t should  renegotiate  FBI building lease


        * Ex-banker gets prison for raiding garages of Lincoln Park neighbors
        * Hinsdale high school district stops investigating teachers who 'liked' Facebook post
        * Barefoot man flees traffic stop, eludes police for hours
        * White supremacist Matthew Hale wants to play violin in solitary
        * Well water testing urged for some McHenry Co. residents
        * Emanuel sidesteps his campaign's criticism of Fioretti
        * Convicted killer of Indian Head Park teen due back in court next month
        * Wallenda to walk the wire between Chicago skyscrapers
        * Convicted ex-aide to former Mayor Washington dies
        * Emanuel calls on Chicagoans to push Fallon on 'Tonight Show' visit


        * Springfield Mayor Houston Points Out Sewer Improvements
        * Fracking Rules Action Delayed; Could Be A Sign Of Revision
        * Attacks Get Personal Between Quinn, Rauner
        * Who Owns The Rights To Vivian Maier's Photos?
        * Legislature Approved A $100 Million Tax On Business & Didn't Know It
        * Schools CEO: privatizing janitorial services not 'as smooth as we would like'
        * What's The Best Way To Help Kids In Struggling Schools?
        * Quinn Defends Public Education, Though He's A Product of Private Schools
        * AFSCME Puts Aside Differences, Endorses Quinn
        * The Future Of Downtown Springfield Inc. In Jeopardy


        * Evans: Eliminate conflicts of interest in legislature
        * Michael Gerson: Leading from behind the curve
        * New subpoena issued for Quinn’s anti-violence program
        * Rauner questions medical marijuana program secrecy
        * State legislative panel delays decision on fracking rules
        * Quinn: Monitor not needed to oversee state hiring
        * Video of state lawmaker's tirade resurfaces in U.S. House race
        * Rauner’s call for firings of ‘illegal patronage hires’ would affect many in Springfield
        * Another view: New law might boost clothing recycling
        * John Freml: Bishop Paprocki does not speak for all Catholics


        * Relay For Life to hold meeting
        * A late night for the Illini
        * SportsTalk 9-16-14
        * What's being done to fix Illinois 15?
        * One-mile walk to benefit Alzheimer's Association
        * Marion man sentenced on weapon charges
        * Belleville Chamber opposes St. E's plan for O'Fallon hospital
        * Waterloo's Paul Schimpf: Politics not rocket science
        * Champaign County harvest report 9-16-14
        * AP STATE FOOTBALL RANKINGS


        * Suburban Scots divided on Scotland's independence
        * Hinsdale district asks teachers union to drop strike threat
        * Chicago Bar Association releases judge recommendations
        * S. Elgin to offer downtown business beautification programs
        * District 86 nixes Facebook post probe

        * Patrick Cannon defense strategy rare but n...
        * Feds fine Jesse Jackson Jr.'s campaign com...
        * Jesse Jackson Jr. political fund fined nea...
        * Jackson Jr.'s political fund fined nearly ...
        * 'Celebrity Crime Files' Season Three, With...
        * Gutierrez says he will co-chair Emanuel's ...
        * Luis Gutierrez Demands Executive Amnesty B...
        * Congressmen Send Letter To Goodell, Other ...
        * Gutierrez: I Will Mobilize Millions Of Imm...
        * Gutierrez: Delayed immigration executive a...

        * Durbin, Enyart Announce $3.2 MIllion in Fe......
        * Senators Durbin, Risch Announce Senate Nat......
        * Senator Durbin: CFPB Lawsuit Should Be The......
        * Senator Durbin: CFPB Lawsuit Should Be The......
        * Senators Durbin, Risch Announce Senate Nat......

        * Shangri La's Barr al Jissah ResortSpa to o......
        * ISIS fight: Congress to vote on arming Syr......

        * U of C, UIC Among Four Obama Library Finalists
        * New Poll Shows Quinn With 11-Point Lead Over Rauner
        * Illinois Education Association Endorses Schneider
        * Report: Wage Theft Costs U.S. Workers Billions Of Dollars Annually (UPDATED)
        * Activists Protest Near West Side Shooting Involving Chicago Police
        * Denzel Ford police shooting 3
        * Denzel Ford police shooting 2
        * Denzel Ford police shooting 1
        * Poll: Durbin Leading Oberweis By 23 Points
        * Town Hall Meeting Illuminates TIF Use In Chicago's 2nd Ward


        * New subpoena in federal probe of Quinn anti-violence grant program
        * Rauner calls on Quinn to halt secret medical marijuana licensing
        * BREAKING: Quinn in court filing says no to hiring monitor, stands by cronies
        * Governor Quinn, clean house
        * IDOT, Secretary of State and AAA Launch National Child Passenger Safety Week in Illinois - Statewide Effort to Ensure Proper Restraints and Save Lives of Illinois Children




            Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller