Mendoza on Illinois: "This is the greatest state. We get to live here. Don’t even think of moving anywhere else. This is where you want to be. This is it. The weather only weeds out the people who don’t deserve to live here."
I was going along with it until “deserve”. Saying “Yay, our home is great and I love it” is good. Admonishing people, saying “If you don’t like it here you don’t deserve to live here” is judgmental and harsh, at the least.
She is just trying to punch through. It’s hard to get people to focus on the Comptroller’s speech anyway. If she wasn’t running for Mayor, this wouldn’t have registered one blip.
- Jose Abreu's next homer - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 3:37 pm:
As my sister accepted a job in other state this weekend (very sad).
Thank you for the link, @wordslinger, very helpful.
This is a topic that doesn’t get the attention it deserves imho - IL outmigration being fueled in part by outmigration from Chicago’s S/SW sides.
I’ve read a couple long-form pieces on this subject in the past year, will try to provide links next time outmigration comes up.
Re: Mendoza’s view of IL, I sort of agree with her. Illinois is a wonderful state despite its serious financial problems - which can, given political will, be overcome.
However, the weather is pretty bad, and those who decide to emigrate to FL or AZ should, I think, be forgiven.
Come on people. Can anyone crack a smile anymore? The “weather weeds out the people who don’t deserve to live here” is funny. By the way, IL is a great State. You’re still here!
This is a non-issue for me. This was a single line in the middle of speeches full of both serious policy proposals and jokes at the expense of Illinois. Heck, Jesse White preceded Mendoza by making jokes about revoking drivers licenses and needing sensitivity training, and no one said “Hey, maybe we shouldn’t joke about those things since corruption and workplace harassment are real issues.”
Point is, maybe this isn’t the most inspiring line of not the most inspiring speech, but it got some laughter, and I think Mendoza’s record should speak louder than a mediocre joke.
Democrats are so tone deaf. They can keep raising taxes and run everyone else out. A few Chicago powerbrokers will be left looking around asking “where’d everybody go?”
But just as much as saying “if X happens / doesnt happen” is dumb - (go ahead and leave for all I care), so is saying “you dont deserve to live here”.
Often, she doesnt know when to stop. Not a good thing for a Mayoral candidate either Male or Female (Vallas has this same tendency, especially when he ran CPS)
“However, the weather is pretty bad, and those who decide to emigrate to FL or AZ should, I think, be forgiven.” Climate change will make both southern Florida and Arizona uninhabitable in 40 to 50 years.
I’m with @Northsider. It was meant as a funny line on a day marked by optimism. It’s also in keeping with her branding as a spunky fighter. Maybe a little silly, but nothing to get upset about.
The speeches were real nice. I did not hear JB speak on Mental Health and the strong leadership roles that is needed as well as implementing more programs within the mental Health Division.
- Oswego Willy - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 3:25 pm:
A lazy tone deaf line to what challenges face Illinois.
As a throwaway line, it’s not unlike someone you’d meet in a tavern bragging about their “home”.
That crew is better than this.
- Not again - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 3:26 pm:
Not in touch with the reality of why people are leaving. Just look at Minnesota right?
- BraidwoodBilly - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 3:28 pm:
Yikes. So much for empathizing with those struggling here. She’ll need better messaging if she wants to be Mayor of Chicago.
- Steve - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 3:30 pm:
She probably got that line from Rahm Emanuel or Alderman Ed Burke.
- Perrid - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 3:31 pm:
I was going along with it until “deserve”. Saying “Yay, our home is great and I love it” is good. Admonishing people, saying “If you don’t like it here you don’t deserve to live here” is judgmental and harsh, at the least.
- OneMan - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 3:34 pm:
So I am guessing she makes the same argument about Chicago being the greatest city. as well? Let me guess, she does that tomorrow.
It was nice for her to come down to Springfield today.
- Colin O'Scopy - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 3:35 pm:
She is just trying to punch through. It’s hard to get people to focus on the Comptroller’s speech anyway. If she wasn’t running for Mayor, this wouldn’t have registered one blip.
- Jose Abreu's next homer - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 3:37 pm:
As my sister accepted a job in other state this weekend (very sad).
- Duopoly - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 3:52 pm:
==She probably got that line from Rahm Emanuel or Alderman Ed Burke.==
Nah I think it was her pal Aaron Schock.
- City Zen - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 4:09 pm:
“Don’t even think of moving anywhere else. This is where you want to be. This is it.”
Inspired by Boiler Room?
“I want you to go out and buy yourselves a new car, go buy yourselves a house, go into debt…”
That movie didn’t end well either.
- wordslinger - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 4:15 pm:
Anyone who wishes to go deeper than Katrina tantrums on demographic changes, the below link is a good start.
It’s actually a complex, nuanced issue, something that those who communicate in print should be able to handle.
http://robparal.blogspot.com/
- dbk - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 4:36 pm:
Thank you for the link, @wordslinger, very helpful.
This is a topic that doesn’t get the attention it deserves imho - IL outmigration being fueled in part by outmigration from Chicago’s S/SW sides.
I’ve read a couple long-form pieces on this subject in the past year, will try to provide links next time outmigration comes up.
Re: Mendoza’s view of IL, I sort of agree with her. Illinois is a wonderful state despite its serious financial problems - which can, given political will, be overcome.
However, the weather is pretty bad, and those who decide to emigrate to FL or AZ should, I think, be forgiven.
- Wensicia - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 4:40 pm:
“This is the greatest state. This is where you want to be. This is it.”
This is all that was needed.
- Northsider - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 5:00 pm:
Come on people. Can anyone crack a smile anymore? The “weather weeds out the people who don’t deserve to live here” is funny. By the way, IL is a great State. You’re still here!
- OutOfState - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 5:02 pm:
This is a non-issue for me. This was a single line in the middle of speeches full of both serious policy proposals and jokes at the expense of Illinois. Heck, Jesse White preceded Mendoza by making jokes about revoking drivers licenses and needing sensitivity training, and no one said “Hey, maybe we shouldn’t joke about those things since corruption and workplace harassment are real issues.”
Point is, maybe this isn’t the most inspiring line of not the most inspiring speech, but it got some laughter, and I think Mendoza’s record should speak louder than a mediocre joke.
- Truth Squad - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 5:10 pm:
Democrats are so tone deaf. They can keep raising taxes and run everyone else out. A few Chicago powerbrokers will be left looking around asking “where’d everybody go?”
- low level - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 5:48 pm:
But just as much as saying “if X happens / doesnt happen” is dumb - (go ahead and leave for all I care), so is saying “you dont deserve to live here”.
Often, she doesnt know when to stop. Not a good thing for a Mayoral candidate either Male or Female (Vallas has this same tendency, especially when he ran CPS)
- striketoo - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 5:53 pm:
“However, the weather is pretty bad, and those who decide to emigrate to FL or AZ should, I think, be forgiven.” Climate change will make both southern Florida and Arizona uninhabitable in 40 to 50 years.
- Roman - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 7:39 pm:
I’m with @Northsider. It was meant as a funny line on a day marked by optimism. It’s also in keeping with her branding as a spunky fighter. Maybe a little silly, but nothing to get upset about.
- DuPage - Monday, Jan 14, 19 @ 8:11 pm:
I won’t think of moving out of state, unless they put a new tax on retirement income. Then, I would have to weigh all factors.
- Anonymous - Tuesday, Jan 15, 19 @ 6:08 am:
Illinois: love it or leave it.
- Mywellbeing - Tuesday, Jan 15, 19 @ 8:34 am:
The speeches were real nice. I did not hear JB speak on Mental Health and the strong leadership roles that is needed as well as implementing more programs within the mental Health Division.