* I’ve gone over most of this with you here, but I thought it was important enough to reiterate it in my weekly newspaper column…
The breadth of invited attendees at the event organized last week by Gov. JB Pritzker really stood out for me.
The event along the Chicago River was designed to publicly warn President Donald Trump not to send National Guard or regular military troops into the city. The usual collection of Democratic politicians, union leaders and several anti-violence and progressive activists were on hand and several spoke.
But what made this rally seem different was the presence of people who aren’t usually at these things.
On the list of attendees were six university and college presidents or chancellors, including University of Illinois System President Tim Killeen and Illinois Institute of Technology President Raj Echambadi.
Several business types also showed up.
Derek Douglas, president of the Civic Committee and the Commercial Club of Chicago, called the possible deployment “unprecedented and unwarranted” during his speech.
“Deploying federal troops or federalizing the National Guard without engaging state and local government, business, philanthropic and community leaders — the ones who understand Chicago’s needs and are on the ground working daily to make our city safer — is unprecedented and unwarranted,” Douglas said.
The Commercial Club of Chicago is not a bunch of lefties. It was founded in 1877 by many of the city’s wealthiest people. Fifteen years ago, the Civic Committee was best known for demanding that public employee pensions be reduced.
Billionaire philanthropist James Crown formed a public safety task force in 2022 within the Civic Committee. Crown’s task force set a goal of reducing the number of murders from 805 the year before to below 400 within a half a decade. That looked impossible at the time, and when Crown died the following year, hopes sank.
But Crown’s original goal appears to be within reach this year, two years ahead of schedule. The murder rate has been declining both in the city and around the country for the past couple of years, at least partly because of a big surge in federal funding of the sort of anti-violence programs advocated by Crown. That federal funding has now been cut off.
Douglas admitted during his speech last week that even with the progress, Chicago still “has a ways to go” on violent crime. He also said, “there is a critical role for federal support that could benefit our city,” but that what they need is “aligned action.”
“What we don’t need,” Douglas said, “are disruptions to our economy and our businesses. Active duty military patrolling the streets of our city sends the wrong message and risks slowing our economy and disrupting the progress we’ve made together. It will impact businesses’ bottom lines and ability to operate efficiently. It will impact tourism and employees getting to their jobs. It will impact morale.”
Douglas concluded his speech by saying: “The kind of sweeping, uncoordinated, indiscriminate action being threatened sets a dangerous precedent, and we stand with our city and all Chicagoans to encourage the administration to productively engage with us, to help us continue to make progress on this critical issue.”
Others in the business community attended and contributed written statements.
“We have seen how the sudden deployment of federal troops in other cities can needlessly disrupt communities and businesses, hurt local economies, and deter tourism,” said Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce CEO Jack Lavin. “The best path forward is partnership and collaboration. If the federal government wants to work constructively with local leaders and community partners, we welcome that engagement to keep making progress toward a safer, stronger city.”
Like Douglas, Lavin said he would welcome “constructive engagement” from the federal government.
Civic Federation of Chicago President Joe Ferguson claimed sending in the troops is not “legally justified,” adding, “investment and partnership is what is needed to move this City and State to a better future.”
McPier CEO Larita Clark said none of her convention center’s clients “have expressed the need for federal intervention in Chicago.” She said her team had met recently with nearly two dozen of the convention center’s largest clients. “What we heard from them was that public safety concerns in Chicago had actually lessened in the past year.”
This is not meant in any way to lessen any of the other speakers and attendees, some of whom made strong arguments against a possible federal military deployment. It’s just that I wasn’t all that surprised that they showed up. And, yes, the biz types are all somehow politically connected in various ways.
But they’re not the usual rally folks and, like the other speakers who got most of the news media’s attention, their messages were worth a look. Also, I think Jim Crown might’ve been proud.
- hisgirlfriday - Tuesday, Sep 2, 25 @ 9:06 am:
Good for the business community speaking up.
Spent a little time in the beautiful city this past weekend and it was so packed with people spending money Downtown and I saw they were setting up stuff for Taste of Chicago coming up too.
It would be a shame if that got screwed up by Trump manufacturing unrest.
Here’s hoping that this court ruling that the Trump admin violated the Posse Commitatus Act by using military in California leads to some sort of pause or limitation in their plans for Chicago
https://x.com/kyledcheney/status/1962868487510007874
- Leo from Dolton - Tuesday, Sep 2, 25 @ 10:02 am:
Let’s get real here. This is all about politics. IF Trump called JB and shared the plans, JB would never go along. NEVER. They use each other as foils. Good for them. Bad for us. I do believe Illinoisans think the crime problem can be improved, just not the way Trump is going about it.
- New Day - Tuesday, Sep 2, 25 @ 10:29 am:
The presence of the business community at that press conference was critically important and a masterstroke for the staff and JB. The Federal efforts are bad for Chicago and especially bad for business. Restaurants are dreading the possibility of troops on Michigan Ave, one of the thriving parts of downtown. Troops are unneeded, unwelcome and unhelpful. Good that Derek Douglas, Jack Lavin and others proclaimed that loudly.
- JoanP - Tuesday, Sep 2, 25 @ 10:31 am:
= Spent a little time in the beautiful city this past weekend and it was so packed with people spending money Downtown =
Second that. I spent the weekend, starting Thursday night, at the Chicago Jazz Festival, and Millennium Park was packed, not just with festival-goers, but people just enjoying the gorgeous weather. Parents bringing their kids to play in the Crown Fountain. Crowds around Buckingham Fountain and the Art Institute. Cars backed up trying to get into the Grant Park garages.
Because no one wants to come downtown anymore.
- Norseman - Tuesday, Sep 2, 25 @ 11:05 am:
As a famous IL reporter occasionally likes to say on his post: “MORE LIKE THIS”.
- JS Mill - Tuesday, Sep 2, 25 @ 11:07 am:
=Because no one wants to come downtown anymore=
Yeah, because of the mass exodus to that bustling Indiana. Lol.
- H-W - Tuesday, Sep 2, 25 @ 11:48 am:
Perhaps Trump is trying to cause harm to the economy of states like Illinois that tend to vote democrat. While this may sound odd, I read yesterday that the invasion of California has led to serious concerns regarding the California economy. Removing immigrants from the agricultural sector in particular, as well as the service sector has raised concerns.
In Illinois, an invasion of federal officers in order to remove immigrants from our state will certainly impact our economy. But what some Republicans do not seem to realize or appreciate, when you mess with the economies of the the blue states, you impact the treasury significantly. Illinois and California and New York and Massachusetts and Maryland, etc., pay into the treasury more than they take out.
But I guess republicans are less concerned with the economy these days, and more concerned with “winning” at any cost.
Perhaps
- Bag Tax - Tuesday, Sep 2, 25 @ 11:57 am:
Meh. There were almost as many politicians and civic types at that press conference as there were people shot in Chicago over the long weekend.
- Roadrager - Tuesday, Sep 2, 25 @ 12:20 pm:
==There were almost as many politicians and civic types at that press conference as there were people shot in Chicago over the long weekend.==
You and your fellow trolls are working this into the comment section on every post here today, so good job, good effort. But before you go, two questions:
1) How will armed National Guard members in camo and hi-viz vests picking up Starbucks cups on the Mag Mile bring down the city’s rate of shootings>
2) How do the city’s shooting and homicide rates for 2025 compare to 2021, 2022, 2023, and 2024? If that sounds like too much math for you, there are resources available with user-friendly charts and graphics.
- Rich Miller - Tuesday, Sep 2, 25 @ 12:25 pm:
===How will armed National Guard members in camo and hi-viz vests picking up Starbucks cups on the Mag Mile bring down the city’s rate of shootings===
It could work for now. But what happens when they leave? This whole thing can be seen as an argument for a permanent encampment.
- huckleberry1926 - Tuesday, Sep 2, 25 @ 3:32 pm:
Rich, you took the words out of my mouth at 12:25pm. DC will be the guinea pig.
What I question is the meeting. The Chicago CofC….Personally, Chambers regardless of level, rarely represent the feeling of members or non-members speaking from experience. The Civic Fed and McPier? Out-of-touch with the truly small businesses that generate local retail, services, restaurants, etc. Why won’t the Governor ever meet with the beating hearts that truly make Chicago not just tourism.