Capitol Fax.com - Your Illinois News Radar

OEIG report smells whiff of patronage hiring

Posted in:

Illinois

By Hannah Meisel

* For a 94-page document, a report from the Office of the Executive Inspector General really didn’t find all that much…just seven jobs within CMS that should not have been classified as ones that could be filled from political consideration. The jobs had been filled with names recommended to CMS by the governor’s office, and the employees were hired in the year or so after Gov. Rauner was sworn into office.

The OEIG did a two-year investigation into seven jobs called “Regional Client Managers” and found that the jobs, originally created in 2004, should no longer be considered “4d(3) exempt,” which is similar to the “Rutan exempt” classification of state employee jobs. Like Rutan exempt jobs, positions classified as 4d(3) exempt can be filled using political consideration.

* When conceived of during the Blagojevich era, the Regional Client Managers were imagined as people who would oversee a bunch of state properties and make sure they were well-functioning. The original job descriptions, and even updated job descriptions years later, envisioned the managers to be fairly independent, create programming, have employees who reported to them, etc. Two examples, which explain why the positions might have been classified as exempt…

“This Client Manager works in concert with the Deputy Director on policy formulating, planning, directing, implementing and administering all property management operations for the client agencies in partnership with the agencies’ Directors.” […]

“This position serves as official agency spokesperson on behalf of the Deputy Director to all internal and external entities such as vendors, contractors, the public, and private and federal officials in the development of initiatives and the resolution of issues associated with client agencies’ property management.”

* Years later, as the OEIG investigated the seven Regional Client Manager positions, it seems most of the jobs turned into kind of glorified custodial managers. One of the people in the jobs said his duties consisted of…

- Setting up tables and chairs for special events
- Reporting the condition of conference rooms to his supervisor; and
- Monitoring inventory inside shared spaces in the Thompson Center.

A far cry from the dozens of bullet points’ worth of responsibilities the jobs were supposed to have. The annual salaries for the seven positions ranged from $51,540 to $75,000.

Does it look flattering for the governor’s office that these employees can be considered “patronage?” No. They were costing the state money, especially as the state went through a two-year budget crisis.

* But I talked to former CMS Director Mike Hoffman this afternoon, who pointed to the 2,500 former patronage jobs he and his team were able to eliminate from the state payroll and the others they reclassified to merit-based hiring. Hoffman was put in charge of efforts to help the Quincy Veterans Home in March.

“It’s frustrating to be called out for mismanagement when you’ve spent the past two years cleaning up,” Hoffman said.

Hoffman said he ultimately accepted responsibility as CMS director, and pointed out that he eliminated the positions on January 1. Also starting in January, CMS has put in place an affidavit process when supervisors do performance reviews — they’ll also have to do more consistent position description reviews so situations like these don’t happen in the future.

posted by Rich Miller
Monday, May 21, 18 @ 3:01 pm

Comments

it’s going to take a while for pritzker, Madigan and the dems to convert all those 2,000-plus positions back into patronage posts. just more proof what a waste of time the rauner administration has caused.

Comment by jim Monday, May 21, 18 @ 3:21 pm
Yep. Some of my coworkeee are counting the days to when jb can help them out

Comment by Anonymous Monday, May 21, 18 @ 3:29 pm
The OEIG doing stellar work, concluding lower level employees engaged in “mismanagement.” What are middle managers supposed to do when guys named “Emil Jones” fall from the sky and land in your agency?

Comment by Anonimity Monday, May 21, 18 @ 3:36 pm
These were created by IPAM during Blago consolidation of facilities management. When that imploded, CMS reassigned them as needed.

Comment by Pieroge tirebiter Monday, May 21, 18 @ 3:39 pm
The admin said Hoffman was resigning over this. So he didn’t resign to take the Quincy job: the Quincy job was a soft landing after this.

Comment by Anonymous Monday, May 21, 18 @ 3:41 pm
How much did this investigation cost the tax payers? Worth it?

Comment by Anonymous Monday, May 21, 18 @ 3:52 pm
===How much did this investigation cost the tax payers?===

Do you even know what the OEIG is and how it works?

Comment by Cubs in '16 Monday, May 21, 18 @ 4:30 pm
==2,500 former patronage jobs he and his team were able to eliminate==

They didn’t eliminate 2,500 positions, did they? Report reads as though they just reclassified a bunch.

Comment by Sugar Corn Monday, May 21, 18 @ 4:53 pm
$25,000,000 here. $25,000,000 there. Pretty soon your talking real money. Me still thinks we can get to slashing a billion if anyone had an ounce of courage.

Comment by BlueDogDem Monday, May 21, 18 @ 6:19 pm
If the OEIG can only find 7 patronage jobs in CMS, they should be transferred en masse to the Mayberry Police Department.

This seemed like a lot of fire and fury over essentially job descriptions. I do have to observe, as an old CMSer, that those lists of duties created to justify the 4(d)3 exemption are absurdly excessive. Yeah, a mid-level bureaucrat is gonna be an “official agency spokesman” or interact directly with agency heads.

Comment by Arthur Andersen Monday, May 21, 18 @ 7:38 pm
Steve Schnorf will always be sorely missed in all levels of government.

Comment by cc Monday, May 21, 18 @ 10:51 pm
Cap Fax has Awards for ‘Best’ in several catagories…..why not for the WORST?

Comment by Anonymous Tuesday, May 22, 18 @ 8:32 am