Capitol Fax.com - Your Illinois News Radar

IEA puts pressure on IDPH

Posted in:

Illinois

* IEA…

The Illinois Education Association (IEA) called for the Illinois Department of Public Health (IDPH) to identify verified COVID-19 outbreaks in schools. The announcement comes after ProPublica Illinois revealed in a story published today that while Illinois public health officials have identified COVID-19 outbreaks in at least 44 school buildings, they won’t disclose where those buildings are and that they may not know the full picture of how the virus has spread.

At least 105 students and 73 staff have been affected, according IDPH. However, state numbers show that between Aug. 15, when schools started to reopen around the state, and Oct. 2, when ProPublica ended its inquiry, nearly 8,700 children in Illinois between the ages of 5 and 17 tested positive – about 180 kids per day – more than double the amount being infected prior to schools reopening, which averaged 72.

“From the start, we have said schools should only open if they can do so safely – with all the appropriate safety precautions in place – and knowledge of an outbreak in a school building absolutely meets that criteria,” said Kathi Griffin, president of the Illinois Education Association. “The number one goal of everyone should be the health and safety of students and those who educate and care for them.”

IDPH defines an outbreak as two or more confirmed cases within 14 days of the start of symptoms in people who do not share a household and did not have close contact in another setting.

“We know there are districts in our state that are being very good about notifying public health officials, staff and families when there are cases and that keeps communities safe,” Griffin said. “But we also know there are districts that aren’t. And, when those cases are kept in the dark, the appropriate people can’t quarantine. The infection spreads. Students, staff and communities are put in harm’s way. Everyone is struggling on how to handle this, but transparency is key.”

According to the Illinois State Board of Education’s map, which was last updated on Sept. 21, 685,000 Illinois students are attending school in person, at least part time, in 69 percent of the state’s school districts. The other 31 percent of districts account for 1.2 million students who continue to learn remotely. Though, many districts are contemplating returning to the classroom in the coming weeks.

“How is a community supposed to decide whether to return to the classroom if they don’t know the true impact this is having across the state? Health officials inform communities when nursing homes or jails have outbreaks because it impacts those who live and work there. Certainly, communities are entitled to know about outbreaks at schools. It shouldn’t even be a question,” Griffin said.

* From that article…

In all, 8,668 Illinois children ages 5 to 17 have tested positive for the virus from Aug. 15, when schools started to reopen, to Oct. 2, state health officials said. That amounts to about 180 new infections among children each day, on average, since school returned. Between March and early August, there were 11,953 confirmed COVID-19 cases among children, an average of about 72 a day. Fewer than five school-aged children have died of the disease, according to the Illinois Department of Public Health.

Even as parents, school leaders and others in the state have pushed for more transparency about cases related to schools, the state health department said this week that it continues to weigh whether to publish data on school-driven outbreaks and has no timeline to decide whether to do so.

IDPH spokeswoman Melaney Arnold said health officials are concerned that publishing COVID-19 data tied to schools could identify students and staff and violate their privacy. The department publishes case counts for other facilities, including nursing homes and psychiatric hospitals. It also specifies the number of cases in people younger than 20 in each county.

posted by Rich Miller
Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 3:38 pm

Comments

Most nursing homes are smaller than schools, so their claim to preserve privacy doesn’t hold up. We don’t know long term affects on children and we do know they can spread the virus to adults. Communities need to know this information.
Private schools are hiding this information too.

Comment by kidz Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 4:09 pm
If I lost my child because some local school official wanted to suppress information about a deadly pandemic I am not sure what I would do and don’t like to imagine it because I don’t think that I would ever have enough capacity to forgive that person for the decision they took away from me regardless of their motives.

Comment by Candy Dogood Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 4:32 pm
You can’t claim that it’s “safe” for kids to return to school and then withhold information on outbreaks.

Comment by Pundent Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 4:36 pm
This is a mistake. In a smaller school, revealing there’s a COVID-19 case will identify who is afflicted. How many students are gone for 14 days on a routine basis? If there is only one, that person has been outed.

Comment by Anyone Remember Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 4:47 pm
Start bugging Local Health Departments for the information. All COVID cases are reported to the local health departments and the local health departments are doing the contact tracing, so they should know what schools.

Christian County had no issues with publicly announcing the chili dude with COVID, so is public announcement of outbreaks a punishment now for those public health officials don’t like?

Comment by JSS Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 4:49 pm
The right to privacy is enshrined in the constitution, I think IDPH is doing the right thing here.

Comment by Davis Junction Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 4:56 pm
For once I agree with the IEA. If it’s a public health crisis stop keeping the information private. On the other hand an “outbreak” of two cases isn’t a cause for concern. More Illinois students will commit suicide this year than will get seriously sick from this coronavirus.

Comment by Downstate Illinois Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 5:01 pm
LOL, our districts union president just wrote me an email demanding that we bring all kids back and she knows we can do it.

Comment by JS Mill Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 6:05 pm
‘More Illinois students will commit suicide this year than will get seriously sick from this coronavirus.’

Not the only people effected

Comment by Morty Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 7:06 pm
‘ You can’t claim that it’s “safe” for kids to return to school and then withhold information on outbreaks.’

This

Comment by Morty Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 7:07 pm
Focus on helping kids. Stop recruiting members

Comment by View from the Cheap Seats Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 8:23 pm
As I mentioned in the open thread, I wonder if the likes of HIPAA, Educational Privacy Act, or even claims of Attorney-Client Privilege or Attorney Work Product are factoring into IDPH’s decisions not to release info on school outbreaks. I especially wonder about ACP or the work product claim possibly being used to deny this info, with the rationale of “just in case we eventually get sued.”

Comment by Chatham Resident Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 9:26 pm
Other states are reporting out COVID cases by school so there must be a way to do it legally.

Comment by ugh Thursday, Oct 8, 20 @ 10:06 pm
=== More Illinois students will commit suicide this year than will get seriously sick from this coronavirus. ===

So now you’re an epidemiologist? Wow.

Comment by Anonymous Friday, Oct 9, 20 @ 9:51 am
Above was me.

Comment by PublicServant Friday, Oct 9, 20 @ 9:52 am