Capitol Fax.com - Your Illinois News Radar

Get the lead out

Posted in:

Illinois
Updated Posts

* Michael Hawthorne at the Tribune…

More than 8 of every 10 Illinoisans live in a community where brain-damaging lead was found in the tap water of at least one home during the past six years, a new Chicago Tribune analysis found.

The alarming results are from a limited number of samples collected under federal regulations by the state’s 1,768 water utilities. Depending on the number of people served by each utility, only a handful or a few dozen homes are occasionally monitored, but when combined the tests provide snapshots of a widespread threat to public health that for decades has been largely ignored. […]

The U.S. EPA and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention stress that lead is unsafe to consume at any level. More than 400,000 deaths a year in the U.S. are linked to the toxic metal. Even tiny concentrations can permanently damage the developing brains of children and contribute to heart disease, high blood pressure, kidney failure and other health problems later in life.

Yet federal regulations allow the vast majority of water utilities to hide the hazards from customers. Once a year, water bills include a brochure that almost always declares tap water is safe to drink. […]

Earlier this month the Biden EPA suspended regulations adopted during the last days of the Trump administration that effectively delayed lead service line replacements for up to three decades and, in some cases, allowed cities to keep toxic pipes in the ground indefinitely.

Not to mention the apparent connection between lead poisoning and increased violence. This needs to be fixed. Pronto.

Go read the whole thing.

…Adding… Press release from last month…

Illinois Rep. Lamont J. Robinson (D-Chicago) has introduced the Lead Service Line Replacement and Notification Act (HB 3739), a bill creating a feasible and equitable plan, funding, and timeline for Illinois water utilities to identify and replace all lead service lines—the most effective way to eliminate toxic lead in drinking water. Illinois Sen. Melinda Bush (D-Grayslake) will file a Senate companion version.

No amount of lead is safe to consume, yet for decades lead was used for water service lines, the pipes that bring drinking water into our homes. Congress banned the installation of lead service lines in 1986, but most lines installed before then were never removed. At least 686,000—and potentially many more—remain in Illinois, the state with the most lead service lines in the nation. In addition, Black and Latinx Illinois residents are disproportionately affected by exposure to lead.

“Lead service lines are as common in Illinois as they are dangerous, but that danger isn’t borne equally across our state,” said Rep. Robinson, chief House sponsor. “A disproportionate number of these lead service lines are found in predominantly Black and Brown communities, displaying yet again the legacy of environmental racism at work in our most vulnerable communities.”

Even low levels of lead exposure can lead to learning disabilities, stunted growth, lower IQ, impaired hearing, and behavioral issues in children. Adults who have been exposed have higher risks of cardiovascular disease, high blood pressure, and kidney and reproductive problems. These serious health problems come with staggering costs that accrue to all of us. For example, in 2017, 1,470 Illinoisans died prematurely from heart disease that was attributed to lead exposure, costing nearly $28 million in hospitalization costs alone.

“Illinois children live in a state with the largest number of lead service lines, increasing their risk of neurological and behavioral abnormalities due to lead exposure. That is unacceptable,” said Sen. Bush, chief Senate sponsor. “Given all we know about the severity of lead exposure, particularly among children and expecting parents, it should go without saying that the state of Illinois has a clear mandate to responsibly plan for the replacement of toxic lead service lines.”

The Lead Service Line Replacement and Notification Act would require all water utilities to find and replace their lead service lines while setting forth a feasible timeline based on national best practices. The bill would also establish a funding source to aid utilities in creating an inventory and replacing lead lines for all affected communities.
“The reality is that Illinois is out of time. A decade ago the United Nations declared safe, affordable, accessible, clean drinking water and sanitation a human right—essential to the full enjoyment of life. Illinois must step up and take action to replace the thousands of contaminated pipes throughout the state, particularly in Black and Brown communities that are struggling with countless other crises like health and a lack of community-oriented economic development. Babies, pregnant mothers, seniors—all residents have a right to clean water,” said Naomi Davis, founder and CEO, Blacks in Green.

Replacing all of Illinois’ lead service lines could also help put Illinoisans back to work by generating thousands of good jobs in the skilled trades. Over 20 years, lead service line replacement could create some 11,225 jobs per year and over $1 billion in related economic activity, according to an analysis by the Metropolitan Planning Council (MPC).

“On behalf of the union plumbers and pipefitters of the Illinois Pipe Trades Association, we pledge our support in addressing the growing public health crisis of lead in our drinking water. We urge the Illinois General Assembly to take immediate action to resolve the issues of our state’s aging water infrastructure. Millions of Illinois citizens are impacted by unsafe levels of lead in drinking water, disproportionately affecting our poorest communities and our most vulnerable citizens. Without action this year, the human and financial toll will only continue to grow,” said Rick Terven, Jr., legislative and political director, Illinois Pipe Trades Association.

The bill includes numerous provisions to ensure equity. Establishing a funding source is one important component to leveling the playing field.

“In communities within close proximity to industrial facilities, it is imperative to mitigate cumulative exposures to toxins such as lead. Mandating lead service line replacement would reduce exposure to the risk of lead in the water, bringing some sense of security to the Black and Brown communities disproportionately impacted by environmental harms. Equitably funding lead service line replacement is critical to ensuring that those most vulnerable to exposure can access any resulting program and attain clean and safe drinking water in their homes,” said Brenda Santoyo, policy associate at the Little Village Environmental Justice Organization.

In addition, utilities would be required to prioritize replacement at facilities used by high-risk populations, such as preschools and daycares. Also, a portion of the fund would provide water rate assistance for low-income families.

“This bill gives every community in Illinois the resources they need to replace the legacy infrastructure in their communities,” said Josh Ellis, vice president, MPC, which recently did an analysis showing that Black and Latinx residents in Illinois are twice as likely as whites to live in communities with the most lead service lines. “This is especially important for Black and Latinx Illinoisans, who are not only the most likely of Illinois residents to live with lead service lines, but who also are disproportionately exposed to other sources of lead, such as paint and soil.”

“Lead service lines demonstrate the direct connection between environmental policy and public health,” said Colleen Smith, deputy director of the Illinois Environmental Council. “Now, the COVID-19 pandemic has elevated the already urgent need for action. All Illinoisans must have access to safe, clean water.”

The bill would prevent a practice known as partial replacement, in which only the utility’s side of the lead line is replaced, while the portion of the line that runs under a private property remains. This practice can disturb the lead material in the remaining pipe, actually increasing the risk of lead leaching into drinking water.

“The federal government has yet to take meaningful steps to address lead in our drinking water, and it’s more critical than ever for Illinois’ legislature to step up and take bold action,” said Jeremy Orr, senior attorney, Safe Water Initiative, NRDC (Natural Resources Defense Council). “Illinois must mandate full lead service line replacement, ban the dangerous practice of partial replacement, and establish an equitable revenue source that ensures individual homeowners and ratepayers won’t have to shoulder the burden of paying to replace these lead pipes.”

posted by Rich Miller
Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 2:21 pm

Comments

I’d recommend everyone getting a comprehensive water testing kit online and checking the sink you get the most drinking water from (even if you use a filter).

If you’re looking for a new home, you can also sneak some water into a bottle for testing later.

Comment by NIU Grad Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 2:34 pm
I still have a lovely letter from the IL Attorney General sent to my local school district after a request for review on a FOIA, when the school district knowingly and willfully tried hiding the fact that they knew they were failing water testing for over a year in dozens of schools, without any notification being given to the parents.

Eventually the ILEPA and ILDPH had to get involved when it was discovered that none of this data had been submitted to the state either, in violation of state laws.

It took months and months of pressure to get a school district with tens of thousands of children to take action. They were clearly hoping nobody would notice and the problem would just go away, just like cancer goes away when you ignore it.

It’s not just the utilities and service lines, many public buildings, especially schools were built with the lowest bidder. Those builders used cheap interior fixtures and piping with lead solder in the brass connections. The practice has mostly been stopped, but any school older than 10 years is almost certainly dealing with a lead problem.

Comment by TheInvisibleMan Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 2:37 pm
Not to mention the connection between lead poisoning, learning disabilities and special education costs.

There are schools in Chicago with 25 percent of the student population that have learning disabilities.

Comment by Thomas Paine Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 2:37 pm
The American Rescue Plan includes about $7.5 billion for the State of Illinois and $5.5 billion for local governments. These funds must be used to directly respond to the COVID-19 pandemic, provide premium pay to essential employees, provide government services affected by a revenue reduction resulting from COVID-19, and make investments in water, sewer, and broadband infrastructure. As we know, it cannot be used towards pensions.

Much of this money from the State’s perspective is accounted for. But the State should consider using some of what is left over after upping vaccinations and testing for those investments in water and sewer infrastructure (and broadband too, as more work occurs remotely).

Comment by Frank Manzo IV Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 2:45 pm
If you live in an old home, and you have lead pipes, replace them with schedule 40 or PEX. Lead service lines are an issue. Most people don’t know what their service line is made of and they don’t know that the service line is their responsibility, not the utility’s responsibility. To avoid leaching from lead, flush your line thoroughly before drinking the water. pH of the water is also important. A low pH will be more corrosive. If the pH of your water is below 8.3, it is most likely corrosive.

Comment by Ducky LaMoore Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 2:57 pm
While I agree with fixing as soon as possible this is no chump change project. Whatever cost People’s Gas is up to for replacing the gas pipes you can probably triple that. The water pipes are buried deeper and can’t be put in like the gas pipes.

Comment by Been There Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 2:59 pm
== Not to mention the apparent connection between lead poisoning and increased violence. ==

Lots of compelling arguments that this is a thing. Would love to see an academic deep dive to examine if it explains Chicago’s disproportionally high violence rates compared to city like LA and New York.

Comment by TNR Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 3:01 pm
I’m worried that since science is used as proof of the danger of lead in our drinking water that the GOP will deny it and tell us that it’s an infringement on our freedom to drink any kind of water we want.

Comment by don the legend Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 3:04 pm
Rockford is getting rid of its lead pipes. So is Madison Wisconsin.

Comment by Da Big Bad Wolf Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 3:27 pm
Rockford has 14,000 lead service lines, Elgin has about 12,000 and Aurora has 22,000. They will need some infrastructure dollars to help. Revolving loans will not be enough.

Comment by Proud Sucker Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 3:49 pm
This is a disgrace. Every town in this country should be checked and repaired at Federal Government expense or at minimum zero interest loan. If they actually do do an infrastructure bill this should be number one not some high speed rail to nowhere. This ties into story from yesterday about raw sewage in central Illinois. Fix it. If only we had a high power senior senator to bring back stuff to his own state. I bet Harry Reid and Harry Byrd would get it done

Comment by DuPage Saint Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 4:01 pm
====The bill would prevent a practice known as partial replacement, in which only the utility’s side of the lead line is replaced, while the portion of the line that runs under a private property remains. This practice can disturb the lead material in the remaining pipe, actually increasing the risk of lead leaching into drinking water.====

This is a really important part of the bill. When Chicago put meters in a bunch of houses they found out later that lead levels increased in almost all that still had the old pipes in the houses.

Comment by Been There Friday, Mar 19, 21 @ 4:08 pm