Capitol Fax.com - Your Illinois News Radar


Latest Post | Last 10 Posts | Archives


Previous Post: Live Ed Burke Trial Coverage
Next Post: Open thread

Isabel’s morning briefing

Posted in:

* ICYMI: US retail lobbyists retract key claim on ‘organized’ retail crime. Reuters

* Related stories…

* Isabel’s top picks…

* Here’s the rest of your morning roundup…

posted by Isabel Miller
Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 7:44 am

Comments

  1. “The NRF’s claim of inventory losses was repeated in multiple media reports on the issue. The NRF has cited growing rates of crime in calls for Congress to pass new laws.”

    Yeah but it’s not fair to expect journalists to have caught that this was all nonsense. It was a really well sourced story, they had the unsupported Congressional testimony of one guy from a law enforcement trade group and literally nothing else. Good enough for 2 years of hysteria.

    Comment by Larry Bowa Jr. Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 8:47 am

  2. “Yeah but it’s not fair to expect journalists to have caught that this was all nonsense. It was a really well sourced story, they had the unsupported Congressional testimony of one guy from a law enforcement trade group and literally nothing else.”

    Oh how it irritates me knowing that this redaction will not be covered. I’m sure I’ll be hearing about this over the holidays, and I am also sure that those espousing the lies will not take any other answer than total acceptance.

    I wish these companies would just say “they want infinite money, for no additional ingenuity,” and use that to cut costs. At least it would be honest.

    Comment by That Guy Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 9:18 am

  3. RE: Isabel’s story on Retail Crime

    It seems that too many people today are simply waiting for soundbites that help them continue their anger and judgement. In this case, fear of crime has been growing through incomplete stories that misrepresent actual reality. Lay Illinoisans then feast on these stories.

    I have a friend who wrote a book. In it, he discussed the word, “representation.” Schwartz suggests we need to put a hypen in that word. When people “re-present” ideas, their “re-presentations” need to be seriously critiqued and analyzed, rather than accepted carte-blanche.

    The role of the media is so much more important in times like these, especially in places like Illinois that have divided into two hostile camps. The re-presentation of news must be managed carefully, and fully. Unfortunately, local media is being bought up and carved out by national interests (e.g., Sinclair, Gannett, etc.). Well intended or not, these purveyors of “news” have no connection to the communities of Illinois, and in their haste to carve out profit models, re-present news events in ways that are less newsworthy, and more about cheap profiteering.

    I miss local news in small town Illinois. It is as if communities no longer exist - only the nation-state.

    Comment by H-W Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 9:21 am

  4. Oh gee, another narrative that was pushed solely by a motivated party and never actually verified with any sort of statistics or independent reporting? Quelle suprise.

    Comment by Homebody Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 9:24 am

  5. “While the city might be comfortable placing asylum seekers on a site where toxins are present without a full understanding of whether it is safe, the state is not”

    I can’t think of an instance where Pritzker’s office was this cutting with Lightfoot.

    Comment by Nick Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 9:41 am

  6. Burke ; Sorry Charlie, only the best tuna gets permits

    Comment by Rabid Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 9:47 am

  7. The same people who gleefully repeated the lies re shoplifting also did so re population loss. Then when they are disproved it’s either can’t trust the corrected “fake news” (the earlier “fake news” was fine) or crickets.

    Comment by Big Dipper Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 9:50 am

  8. ==Burke ; Sorry Charlie, only the best tuna gets permits ==

    Love this since Charlie the Tuna was in fact born in Chicago

    It’s very good that people are seeing through the industry spin on “organized retail theft” but it’s much, much more important that we all learn the lesson about crime scare coverage and legislative “responses” before the next time on the next issue (which is now).

    Comment by Stephanie Kollmann Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 10:17 am

  9. I have ridden motorcycles for over 50 years and was fortunate that neither me nor my bike touched the street. But two things are certain to me. 1) wearing a helmet was never a problem and always a good idea (plus I always thought it added to the cool factor) 2) there are more distracted drivers and people less tolerant of people on two wheels

    ABATE has always fought helmet laws and I always thought they were doing a disservice to riders. Isn’t there any legislature that thinks this law needs to be changed?

    Comment by Lurker Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 10:22 am

  10. I think Cap Fax should have a regular Stephanie Kollmann advice column based on some of her comments here and on Twitter. She could be #twill’s own Dear Abby!

    Comment by Change Agent Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 10:38 am

  11. Apologies for the banned punctuation. But if anyone deserves a complimentary exclamation mark, it’s Stephanie.

    Comment by Change Agent Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 10:43 am

  12. =much more important that we all learn the lesson about crime scare coverage and legislative “responses” before the next time on the next issue (which is now).=

    Amen. Just go back to the battle to legalize marijuana.

    Comment by JS Mill Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 10:47 am

  13. @ Lurker

    Do insurance companies doing business in Illinois have provisions regarding injuries while not wearing helmets? Just curious. I am sure some bikers would not hesitate to lie if they were told the cost of insurance were higher for people not routinely wearing helmets. But with modern technology (think: satellite technologies currently used to monitor drivers), it might be possible to give discounts to those wearing helmets with sensors.

    Comment by H-W Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 10:49 am

  14. ==Yeah but it’s not fair to expect journalists to have caught that this was all nonsense.==

    That’s what journalists do when their employers allow them the time to dig.

    NPR was reporting on this back in September, including this bit in a planet Money report: “External theft is the biggest cause of shrink - 37%. But it’s not the only cause. If you add in the other causes of shrink, which is theft of inventory by employees and loss of inventory by corporate mismanagement, those two internal problems actually add up to a lot more than external theft - 54%.”
    (https://www.npr.org/2023/09/11/1197953024/is-retail-theft-getting-worse)

    There were multiple stories and most (if not all) called into question the retailer’s framing.

    Comment by Pot calling kettle Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 11:43 am

  15. EV sales are reportedly up dramatically this year and surpassed one million sold for the year. Global EV demand/sales is also expected to continue growing. That is very good news for Illinois, who is trying to be at the forefront of clean energy.

    Comment by Grandson of Man Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 12:28 pm

  16. @H-W: that is interesting thought. I do know motorcycle insurance for bodily injury is much more expensive in Illinois compared to helmet states, and many will not offer it above the minimum. But, collision insurance for motorcycles is relatively cheap otherwise. I have never heard of a device to prove you are a helmet wearer but I like your thinking.

    Of course, I still prefer my thinking of make it a requirement.

    Comment by Lurker Wednesday, Dec 6, 23 @ 4:03 pm

Add a comment

Sorry, comments are closed at this time.

Previous Post: Live Ed Burke Trial Coverage
Next Post: Open thread


Last 10 posts:

more Posts (Archives)

WordPress Mobile Edition available at alexking.org.

powered by WordPress.