Latest Post | Last 10 Posts | Archives
Previous Post: Today’s must-read
Next Post: ‘Preliminary data’ released on Pretrial Fairness Act
Posted in:
* E&E News…
EPA has issued a violation notice to the operator of the country’s first carbon dioxide injection wells for permanent storage, alleging that the company hasn’t complied with its federal permit.
Agribusiness company Archer-Daniels-Midland — also known as ADM — operates a facility in Decatur, Illinois, that injects CO2 into deep rock formations for geologic storage. In a three-page notice, EPA said the company conducted activity that allowed injection and formation fluids into “unauthorized zones,” failed to follow an emergency response and remediation plan and did not “monitor the well in accordance with the Permit.”
EPA declined to go into detail about the violation notice, citing it as an “active enforcement matter.” But ADM said it relates to the corrosion of a monitoring well and not its CO2 injection well, which is still operating.
In March, “we detected some corrosion in a section of one of two deep monitoring wells at approximately 5,000 feet and below,” ADM spokesperson Jackie Anderson told POLITICO’s E&E News in a statement. That corrosion allowed CO2 and formation fluid to migrate into a formation where those liquids weren’t permitted to go, she said.
* From the violation notice…
Based on EPA’s inspection, review of the wells and the Permit, and review of monitoring reports submitted by you for monitoring periods from January 1, 2022, to July 1, 2024, you failed to meet the requirements of the Permit and the UIC regulations in the following ways:
• Construction, operation, maintenance, plugging, or conducting any other injection activity in a manner that allows the movement of injection and formation fluids into any unauthorized zones.
• Failure to follow the Emergency Response and Remediation Plan in accordance with the Permit;
• Failure to monitor the well in accordance with the Permit;
* Illinois Clean Jobs Coalition…
On Friday, September 13, E&E News reported that corrosion in one of Archer-Daniels-Midland Co.’s (ADM) carbon sequestration wells in Decatur, Illinois, allowed carbon dioxide (CO2) to leak. One month prior on August 14, the US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) filed a Notice of Violation to ADM related to the company’s Class VI underground injection well facility, alleging that ADM failed to comply with federal regulations and the terms and conditions of its permit.
The Illinois Clean Jobs Coalition worked closely with Governor Pritzker and his administration, Senator Laura Fine, Representative Ann Williams, and industry stakeholders in the spring legislative session to pass a Carbon Capture and Sequestration (CCS) protections law that ensures Illinois communities and our land and water are protected from the risks associated with new CCS projects. Bolstered by new federal taxpayer incentives, there are 22 pending applications for new CO2 injection wells in Illinois.
In response, the Illinois Clean Jobs Coalition released the following statement:
“This incident demonstrates how important strict CCS regulations are to protect our communities and environment, and is exactly why we passed the CCS protections act in Illinois this year. There are significant risks at every step of the CCS process, and it’s not a matter of if carbon sequestration facilities leak, but rather when.
“Neither ADM nor the USEPA have released any details about the nature of the leak or its impacts on the local community, groundwater, or the environment, and we are anxious to learn more. This is why we fought for more rigorous public notification requirements, emergency response planning, site monitoring, and to require that sequestration site operators are legally and financially responsible for sequestration sites in the CCS Protections Act. The total lack of public notification of the leak in the month following the agency’s alleged notice of violation to ADM is unacceptable and dangerous.
“When CCS protections passed this spring, we made clear that the fight to protect our communities, land, water, and climate, from the risks associated with every step of the CCS process was not over, and that these protections would likely need to be updated and strengthened as we learned more about these projects. There are real concerns from many legislators, community partners, and Illinoisans who rely on public drinking water about the need for even stronger protections, and this incident shows that these concerns need to be taken seriously to ensure Illinoisians are protected to the fullest extent possible.”
* Protect The Mahomet Aquifer campaign…
A recent leak at Archer Daniels Midland’s carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) facility underscores concerns for the safety of the Mahomet Aquifer, a critical drinking water source for nearly one million people across 14 counties in Central Illinois.
The leak, reported by E&E News to have occurred at ADM’s ethanol plant near Decatur, has raised fears about the long-term safety and viability of carbon storage in the region. ADM began sequestering CO2 on its site in 2011, and has injected and stored about 4.5 MMT CO2 over the past 13 years. The leak occurred about five miles outside of the Mahomet Aquifer.
This leak spotlights the risk to the Mahomet Aquifer if carbon sequestration is not banned through or under the aquifer.
This week, Sen. Paul Faraci (D-Champaign) and Rep. Carol Ammons (D-Urbana) introduced legislation that “would prohibit carbon sequestration activity over, under or through a sole-source aquifer.” The bills will be considered during the November veto session and HB5874 is already available on ilga.gov.
“This leak is a wake-up call. It’s a stark reminder that carbon capture is not the climate solution it’s sold as, but a dangerous gamble with our drinking water,” said Pam Richart, co-director of Eco-Justice Collaborative.
The Mahomet Aquifer was designated a sole source aquifer by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency in 2015, meaning that contamination would create a significant public health hazard with no feasible alternative drinking water source available to the region.
“The proposals for storing CO2 under the Mahomet Aquifer and its recharge areas now under review by the U.S. EPA are over 50 times that already sequestered by ADM, and this could be just the beginning,” Richart said. “The Mahomet Aquifer, which sustains nearly a million people in Central Illinois, cannot afford to be put at risk by experimental technologies like carbon capture and storage. ”
“We applaud Senator Faraci, Representative Ammons, Senator Rose and Representative Schweizer for taking action to protect the Mahomet Aquifer. This incident demonstrates why a ban is the only way we can be certain that the Mahomet Aquifer will be protected,” said Andrew Rehn, Director of Climate Policy at Prairie Rivers Network. “We need clean water forever, and to do that, we must take action now to protect the Mahomet Aquifer before it’s too late.”
The U.S. EPA is reviewing several carbon sequestration projects across Central Illinois. Three of the projects aim to inject carbon through the Mahomet Aquifer and store it underground, potentially exposing the water supply to contamination from carbonic acid and harmful heavy metals.
The push for a legislative ban aligns with growing public sentiment against CCS projects. A recent poll conducted by Embold Research found that 71% of Illinois registered voters oppose carbon sequestration under the Mahomet Aquifer, citing fears of water contamination and the unproven safety of the technology.
ADM has received more than $281 million in federal funding for carbon capture and storage projects since 2009, in addition to tens of millions of dollars in tax credits.
Earlier this year, Governor JB Pritzker signed Senate Bill 1289 to regulate carbon capture and storage in Illinois. The law requires corporations to provide an alternative drinking source if it becomes contaminated by a leak. But there is one critical gap that wasn’t addressed in the legislation — sole source aquifers like the Mahomet. The sole source designation means that there is no reasonably available alternative drinking water source for users of the Mahomet Aquifer. Therefore, no company would be able to provide an alternate source.
The Protect The Mahomet Aquifer campaign is urging citizens to contact their local legislators and demand that the proposed legislation to ban CCS projects under the aquifer be passed without delay.
…Adding… Sen. Chapin Rose…
State Senator Chapin Rose released the following statement regarding the reported leak of a carbon sequestration well operated by ADM in Decatur:
“This is exactly what I was sounding the alarm about back in May when Democrats were ramming through their supposedly ‘green’ Carbon Sequestration bill. This is exactly why that bill should not have passed, why Governor Pritzker should never have signed that bill. Because it leaves the Mahomet Aquifer exposed to this exact danger. And this is why my legislation, Senate Bill 3963, which would protect the aquifer from CO2 injection, needs to be passed immediately.”
posted by Rich Miller
Friday, Sep 13, 24 @ 1:03 pm
Previous Post: Today’s must-read
Next Post: ‘Preliminary data’ released on Pretrial Fairness Act
WordPress Mobile Edition available at alexking.org.
powered by WordPress.
While the impact of CO2 leaks into aquifers is a concern, I am much more concerned about other threats that are already impacting or likely to impact the Mahomet and other near-surface aquifers: 1) agrichemicals, 2) leaking CAFO waste pits, 3) aging pipelines, 4) documented hazardous waste sites and 5) active industrial facilities, landfills, and other handlers of chemicals that are know to be threats to human health.
The likelihood that CO2 leaking from deep injection will impact these aquifers is low (it has a long way to travel to get to shallow aquifers like the Mahomet) and the CO2 itself would not impact human health (we buy and consume lots of liquids with dissolved CO2). The chemical interactions on the way up are unknown and could produce negative impacts.
All that said, the threats I listed are real, immediate, and fairly well understood. And yet, the concern and regulation of agricultural chemicals and CAFOs (1 & 2) is incredibly poor; as is the decommissioning of aging pipelines. I would much prefer to see a focus on addressing those threats as a priority. Just because its “agriculture” does not mean it should be given a pass; likewise, for ignoring those aging pipelines.
Comment by Pot calling kettle Friday, Sep 13, 24 @ 2:16 pm
I hate to say I told you so…but I told you so.
Comment by Dotnonymous x Friday, Sep 13, 24 @ 2:32 pm
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Nyos_disaster
Comment by Dotnonymous x Friday, Sep 13, 24 @ 2:35 pm
Yeah…it’s just Decatur…nothing to see here.
Breathe deep while you still can?
Comment by Dotnonymous x Friday, Sep 13, 24 @ 2:39 pm
PCK, The Illinois Department of Agriculture regulates outdoor uses of pesticides (farm, right-of-way, etc.) It has been monitoring shallow aquifers since the early 90s and has a management plan for groundwater.
https://agr.illinois.gov/environment/groundwater.html
Comment by very old soil Friday, Sep 13, 24 @ 2:41 pm
@Pot calling kettle…you gonna need a bigger mop to clean up this mess….nice try…no cigar.
Comment by Dotnonymous x Friday, Sep 13, 24 @ 2:42 pm
Carbon sequestration is junk technology, simple as that. Also save the mahomet aquifer.
Comment by Save the Mahomet Aquifer Friday, Sep 13, 24 @ 3:07 pm
==you gonna need a bigger mop to clean up this mess==
That is my point. With respect to the Dept of Ag, the regulations and monitoring are out-of-date and inadequate, especially with respect to the ever-growing presence of CAFO’s. The design standards and monitoring protocols are not appropriate for the volume and concentration of the waste. The last update of the act regulating CAFOs was over 25 years ago, and having the DOAg in charge instead of the PCB or IEPA is like having the fox in charge of the hen house.
While I agree with regulating the CO2 industry now, rather than later, ignoring the present threats is dangerous and irresponsible. And giving Ag a pass because it’s “Ag” has allowed this problem to become worse over the past decades.
Comment by Pot calling kettle Friday, Sep 13, 24 @ 3:29 pm
The idoa regulates the siting of cafos. The iepa regulates their operations. Also don’t blame the agencies for things you don’t like. Blame the legislature..they write the land approve the rules
Comment by Very old soil Friday, Sep 13, 24 @ 3:47 pm
I’m with PCK on this. Who could possibly have imagined CO2 in water turns into carbonic acid. Who knew it could dissolve pipes? How could we know a gigantic company that can move the actions of governments internationally, might forget to check their plumbing and decide it’s cheaper to just keep paying fines?
Comment by Give Us Barabbas Friday, Sep 13, 24 @ 4:07 pm