Latest Post | Last 10 Posts | Archives
Previous Post: A look ahead
Next Post: That toddlin’ town roundup
Posted in:
* We’ve talked about this before. From Capitol News Illinois…
Religious and environmental ideals are at odds for some in the ongoing debate around what to do with human remains.
A proposal at the Illinois Statehouse would legalize and regulate “natural organic reduction,” a process in which human remains are rapidly decomposed into compost. The process is also known as human composting or terramation. […]
Notable among the bill’s opponents is the Catholic Church. Daniel Welter, the recently retired chancellor of the Archdiocese of Chicago, spoke to lawmakers at the request of the Catholic Conference of Illinois on Tuesday.
“Turning the mortal remains of a human person into compost for the purpose of fertilization, as one would with vegetable trimmings or eggshells, degrades the human person and dishonors the life that was lived by that person,” he said during the committee hearing.
Welter added that he and the church “oppose any tendency to minimize the dignity of a human being, even after death.”
“Even after death.”
* There’s a man trying to get Decatur’s Calvary Catholic Cemetery cleaned up. He and one other person took these pics within the past few days. Maybe this post will help the cause, considering the current debate…
Not great.
posted by Rich Miller
Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 10:48 am
Sorry, comments are closed at this time.
Previous Post: A look ahead
Next Post: That toddlin’ town roundup
WordPress Mobile Edition available at alexking.org.
powered by WordPress.
A honest reading would certainly make a distinction between the remains and the grave markers…but whatever.
Comment by James Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 10:51 am
James, you’re playing semantics, when the spirit of the statement applies.
The annoying thing is, pulling weeds or filling potholes is cheap, just some time and labor. Fixing broken headstones would take more time, money, coordination, etc., but come on.
Comment by Perrid Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 10:56 am
The Comptroller is responsible for cemeteries. What does her office say?
Comment by New Day Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 10:58 am
According to a Google search I did (grain of salt), burial plots range from $1,375 to $5,600. Milano Monuments estimates those knocked over upright headstones in Decatur cost $1,900+. That’s a lot of revenue to risk. Why hope that the word of the church will convince people to pay a premium to not be a tree when you can use the State’s monopoly on the legitimate use of force to stifle the competition before it even begins?
Comment by Nuke The Whales Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 10:58 am
– degrades the human person –
Yes, that’s the entire point of composting. Great choice of words, guy from the church.
“Dust you are and to dust you will return.”
I guess his bible degrades the human person too.
The bill does not *force* anyone to compost themselves. If they wish to have a catholic burial, then they can still have that.
Yet here we have yet another example of how the church is attempting to dictate that *nobody* can do this, because of the beliefs of a religion that person doesn’t belong to.
The church continues to insist on expanding its control onto people who do not share their beliefs.
Never forget, the Catholic Church is officially a theocracy in its chosen form of government. This is not hyperbole, is factual.
Comment by TheInvisibleMan Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:01 am
“Thou art dust, and to dust you shall return”. The thing that upsets me about the funeral industry is how they insist on expensive sarcophagi, expensive concrete liners, etc. In what seems like trying to stave off natural decay. It’s a scam. People should have the option to go in a more natural way if they wish. The tombstone issue is solved with a memorial wall and name plates. The Catholic guy is off base here and more likely just lobbying for keeping the cemetery business lucrative.
Comment by Give Us Barabbas Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:01 am
===The Comptroller is responsible for cemeteries===
Try using the Google…
“Other cemeteries and funeral homes, including family burial grounds, those with religious affiliations, and those owned and operated by municipalities, along with those businesses that do not sell on a pre-need basis, are outside the jurisdiction of the Comptroller’s Office.”
https://illinoiscomptroller.gov/about/place/licensee-info/faq
Comment by Rich Miller Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:02 am
I like the idea of natural degrading of the body or composting. I would much prefer that or cremation to rotting inside an expensive casket inside a concrete vault and gradually becoming wormfood. As far as I’m concerned the Catholic Church or any other church can keep their opinions to themselves.
Comment by Manchester Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:12 am
==The tombstone issue is solved with a memorial wall and name plates.==
You just said that people should have an option and then said that they shouldn’t do tombstones. Either they have freedom to do what they want or they don’t. Pick a lane.
Comment by Demoralized Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:15 am
I’m not sure how I feel about allowing composting. I suppose an individual should get to choose (within reason) what happens to their body after they die. But I can guarantee you that this option will not be free. It’s not like you can just throw the person in the back yard and turn them into compost. It will be regulated and it will cost money.
Comment by Demoralized Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:16 am
Given the proximity of Calvary to Millikin University, it should be easy to reach out to student organizations to get volunteers to help with the cleanup.
Re: dignity of the human being, I’ll just point to the shell games regarding abusive priests.
Comment by The Dude Abides Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:17 am
“I tell ya, golf courses and cemeteries are the biggest wastes of prime real estate.”
Al Czervik
Comment by 47th Ward Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:19 am
We’re thinking of doing a road trip out there one day next week to help with the cleanup. Will share details when we know specifics.
And yes, Natural Organic Reduction is regulated, nobody is tossing anyone in the back yard. It’s conducted by a licensed funeral director just like cremation or alkaline hydrolysis. Cost is comparable to both of these methods. The compost resulting from the process is required to be tested, shows zero trace of human DNA, is prohibited for use in food production or commercial sale. And obviously, no funeral director is required to offer this option nor is anyone forced to use the process.
Comment by Kelly Cassidy Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:29 am
“It will be regulated and it will cost money.”
Same is true of burying yourself in a sealed box in the ground beneath an expensive stone. That’s not an argument against allowing me to embrace what nature is going to do to my vessel anyway.
Maybe all the God botherers out there can find it within themselves to leave us alone after we die. Can I be left alone by all the fake pious, finally, at least in death? It’s not a big ask, it only requires you have the basic humility to realize you don’t have every answer in this life.
Comment by Larry Bowa Jr. Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:31 am
== I would much prefer that or cremation to rotting inside an expensive casket inside a concrete vault and gradually becoming wormfood. ==
Certainly freedom of choice is at work here. But there are also environmental considerations. The act of cremating a body represents significant CO2 emissions equal to the exhaust of many automobiles. If someone truly wants to make every effort to limit their carbon footprint, composting is the best alternative when considering your afterlife choices.
== It will be regulated and it will cost money. ==
Yes, duh. it’s a different aspect of the burial industry. But it’s been shown to be much cheaper as you do not require the purchase of a burial plot or coffin and other accessories. And you get the added benefit of enriched mulch! (If you want).
Comment by Boomerang Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:35 am
I wish more cemeteries would follow the lead of Congressional Cemetery in DC, and become dog friendly. Also, they’re green burial friendly as well.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/dc-politics/congressional-cemetery-the-citys-most-exclusive-dog-park/2017/02/24/1508d56a-f470-11e6-b9c9-e83fce42fb61_story.html
Comment by GV Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:36 am
The Invisible Man’s post is so spot on for this topic and for the topic of reproductive choices. “The church continues to insist on expanding its control onto people who do not share their beliefs.” yep, we are not a theocracy but they are trying to force us to be one under their control. I’m not crazy about human composting for myself but choice is choice. If the RC church is so key on cemeteries, I assume Daniel Welter will now lead the charge to fix the one pictured, in disarray.
Comment by Amalia Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:39 am
Catholic Church is definitely struggling with cash at the moment too much to maintain their cemeteries. /s
If their only objection to the bill is that it doesn’t align with their own personal burial practices, it should not be a factor for a public body.
Comment by NIU Grad Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:42 am
Still can’t figure out why the Church would get involved legislatively, unless the law requires them to provide a burial alternative that’s contrary to their beliefs. This just legalizes natural reduction, it doesn’t require the Church to do it.
Comment by vern Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 11:46 am
So the catholic church is ok with cremation but not with human composting. Got it.
I’ll stop before I get banned for life.
Comment by Huh? Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 12:08 pm
It is my understanding, as a former catholic cemeteries laborer, that the cemetery doesn’t “own” the headstone and that the sale agreement specifies that the decedent’s family is responsible for the repair and maintenance of the monument. The Cemetary cleans up garbage and debris, cuts the grass, trims the trees, maintains the roadways and fences, but that monuments aren’t touched or maintained by cemetery staff.
I have worked with some local community groups to clean and preserve headstones in some local abandoned cemeteries (removing moss, weed wacking, etc). Maybe a similar group in Decatur can help?
Comment by Just Another Anon Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 12:27 pm
As a Boy Scout my troop did two visits to a local cemetery. Our scoutmaster contacted the cemetery and received permission along with rules as to what we could or could not do.
We performed grounds and vegetation clean up and were allowed to prop up smaller tombstones that were knocked down from their bases or fell due to drainage issues. We filled bags of garbage with trash, bottles and cans alone. We trimmed pathways from vegetation that covered them up over the years.
We were instructed to leave the tombstones alone if it wasn’t an obvious match to the base.
That’s when I first learned of the mass deaths of baby children from pre-WWI pandemics. A few of them spent less than a year on this earth. Many of those markers are close to where my family plot is. Most were buried together in one entire section at the time.
Get some volunteers together and get started.
Comment by Louis G Atsaves Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 12:33 pm
The Catholic Church seems to really love telling non-Catholics what to do. Maybe if you don’t want to compost bodies, you shouldn’t do it. Stop telling me what I can and can’t do.
Comment by Homebody Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 12:36 pm
As InvisibleMan, the Dude and Amalia note, it’s pretty rich of the Catholic Church to be against this claiming an interest in “dignity of a human being”.
Comment by Chris Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 12:41 pm
“The Cemetery cleans up garbage and debris, cuts the grass, trims the trees, maintains the roadways and fences, but that monuments aren’t touched or maintained by cemetery staff.”
Depending on who the trustees hire to do the maintenance, especially mowing, the headstones and markers can be damaged. It’s happened at the Catholic cemetery where some of my family are buried. No apologies or offers to fix what is damaged. Not saying that is the case for the Decatur location, just an observation from another location.
Comment by Anon221 Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 12:48 pm
On the other hand, what’s with HB1367? The state is going to tell me that my ashes have to be placed in a cemetery, except for 8 ounces. I have other plans.
Comment by PAM Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 12:49 pm
Since we don’t have any choice about how we arrive in this world, at least we should have some about how we go out. I don’t need or want the catholic or any other church interfering with that.
Comment by Flapdoodle Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 12:50 pm
Personally, I’m a fan of the Hunter S. Thompson burial method.
Comment by TheInvisibleMan Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 12:54 pm
Didn’t various dioceses move money into their cemetery funds to shield it from abuse lawsuits?
Bang up job guys.
Comment by Anonish Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 1:03 pm
As I mentioned on Twitter the other day, I’m fine with the Catholic Church saying it is against their beliefs and adherents should not do it, but I’m not Catholic and don’t see the relevance of their opinion on how I’m buried.
Comment by ArchPundit Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 1:03 pm
I’m saying, at the composting cemetery, you wouldn’t need headstones, but there could be a communal memorial wall by the entrance to the place, where one can put up a little optional name tag, if they wanted to, and that should be more than enough to satisfy the complainers who insist there be some kind of headstone. If the Catholic Church wants to be a stickler, they don’t need legislation for that, they can just tell their parishioners what the Church wants done, that’s it, and they should not try to impose their will on everyone else. My Catholic teaching says at the Resurrection, you are reconstituted whole, no matter if you were lots at sea, atomized by an explosion, or eaten by wolverines. Where your atoms are, doesn’t matter.
In terms of cremation and cremains, I’m for fewer regulations, not more. As long as it’s not littering, folks should have the option.
Comment by Give Us Barabbas Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 1:13 pm
==As a Boy Scout my troop did two visits to a local cemetery.==
I thought the same thing. Seems to me like it might be a good Eagle Scout project for someone going through the Eagle Scout process.
Comment by Demoralized Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 1:36 pm
==That’s not an argument against allowing me==
I wasn’t making that argument. Try to not get the vapors. Sheesh.
Comment by Demoralized Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 1:41 pm
Another excuse for to pile on and attack Catholics, as always. Seems to be liberals’ favorite pastime. Disappointed in this reporting. Some broken headstones in one cemetery does not negate the entire argument against turning people into compost.
Comment by Dem Observer Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 1:45 pm
“argument against turning people into compost.”
People will turn into compost no matter what your argument is. The only variable is the amount of time it will take.
Oh, and according to the church, I *am* a Catholic. You see, they inducted me into their ranks as a member when I was a minor and couldn’t make legal decisions for myself. I also was an altar boy and performed Catholic Mass for years. Their rules specifically say I can not remove myself from their membership now as an adult. A rule they changed within the past 10 years or so to paper over the number of people fleeing their organization.
But thank you for trying to use the victimhood shield to deflect from responsibility. It reminds me of my 7th grade catholic school teacher.
Comment by TheInvisibleMan Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 1:57 pm
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tH2w6Oxx0kQ
Comment by Dotnonymous Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 2:12 pm
“Lord, my body has been a good friend…but I won’t need it in the end” - Cat Stevens
Comment by Dotnonymous Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 2:19 pm
@DemObserver, I’m not a Roman Catholic but that religion does not get to govern my life. that’s the point.
Comment by Amalia Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 2:21 pm
===Another excuse for to pile on and attack Catholics, as always.
Again, do what you want for your faith, but how should that control me who is not Catholic? Do you have some interest in how my body is handled I’m unfamiliar with?
Comment by ArchPundit Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 2:41 pm
“Some broken headstones in one cemetery does not negate the entire argument against turning people into compost”
When an organization that has systematically protected and condoned serial child molesters, when that organization bases its argument on the “dignity of life” and avoiding “degrading the human person” - That is what negates their argument.
For crying out loud, 6 of the 9 Supreme Court Justices are Catholic. Poor Catholics just don’t have a voice in this country.
Comment by Henry Francis Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 3:26 pm
== Welter added that he and the church “oppose any tendency to minimize the dignity of a human being, even after death.” ==
It would seem the greater “dignity minimization” would be what I asked for what happens to me after my death not be followed. Cremation, if I said I didn’t want it to happen, would be a greater minimization than following my request, no matter what it might be.
I am genuinely curious about where that line is from their perspective. Is burial in the ground in a pine box, without a vault, ok? Is it any action that hastens decomposition? Is the Capuchin Crypt a problem?
Comment by OneMan Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 3:34 pm
. . .burial plots range from $1,375 to $5,600–
Our single township cemetary plot was $450.00. Two “cremains” can be placed. No opening charge if you dig your own hole.
Just sayin’
Comment by Stix Hix Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 4:54 pm
The Catholic cemetery where my mom is headed to her pre-paid plot wants $1500 to open the grave, a fee for a concrete vault, over three hundred for the double cremains container, another couple of hundred for the stone platform on which the headstone will be placed. I get the headstone for free from DVA, since dad was a vet. But sheesh, you can’t even afford to die anymore… I mean, we’re not Pharaohs…
Comment by Give Us Barabbas Monday, Mar 20, 23 @ 4:59 pm
Seems to me it’s a great option. If my body can be used to grow plants or whatever. Life would spring from my remains and life would continue. I’d still be productive for eternity.
Comment by Flexible One Tuesday, Mar 21, 23 @ 12:13 am