SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
Question of the day

Wednesday, Apr 30, 2014

* Greg Hinz writes about yesterday’s widely expected failure of a constitutional amendment for a graduated income tax

Mr. Harmon’s problem wasn’t with his proposal. It was with the timing of his proposal, which comes at the very same time that lawmakers are preparing to vote on making permanent the “temporary” Illinois income tax.

Instead of being revenue-neutral overall, Mr. Harmon’s proposal and companion bill would have set rates at a level designed to pull in as much money overall as the pending permanent income tax hike. Thus, only individual income below $12,000 a year would be subject to a 2.9 percent rate. Anything above that would be hit with 4.9 percent or 6.9 percent, this at a time when rates are set to revert to 3.75 percent on Jan. 1 unless the Legislature extends the “temporary” hike.

Bottom line: While Mr. Harmon was trying to sell what advocates dubbed a “fair tax,” his plan was easily dubbed a “tax increase.”

If the senator really wants to pass a graduated income tax, my suggestion is to let lawmakers do what they’re going to do this year — and that’s probably to make the current 5 percent individual tax rate permanent. Then next year, he can come back with a proposal that’s truly revenue neutral and only shifts the burden around from the bottom toward the top.

* The Question: If you could give any unsolicited advice to proponents and opponents of a graduated tax for Illinois, what would it be?

- Posted by Rich Miller        


38 Comments
  1. - Oneman - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 1:37 pm:

    A) Good Luck

    B) If it was revenue neutral or really close and didn’t have an insane top end vs bottom end rate I would be cool with it even if I end up paying more.


  2. - Jeff Trigg - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 1:44 pm:

    Don’t tax the income of any poor people.


  3. - countyline - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 1:46 pm:

    If its revenue neutral, why do anything ?


  4. - wordslinger - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 1:53 pm:

    Proponents: Let the temporary flat tax increase expire, and let folks live for a while under the budgets it will produce.

    Opponents: Make the temporary flat tax increase permanent.


  5. - Gene Debs - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 1:59 pm:

    If we go back to a 3.75% rate, there will be lots of pain, and I think we can expect further job losses. I’m sure the GA, or at least the super majority Democrats, do not want that. I expect the leadership knows what it wants and has a strategy in mind to make it happen. They have to think about what works politically as well as economically. We can only wait and see confident that they will do the right thing. It may be after they have tried everything else.


  6. - Southsider - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 1:59 pm:

    My advice…keep your word.


  7. - Precinct Captain - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:00 pm:

    For proponents, I’d agree with Wordslinger. The stick (massive, debilitating spending cuts) will work in this instance to get people to see there is a major revenue issue in this state. I’d also say that an alternative is to design a system that collects less revenue than under the current flat 5% system, but more than under the old 3% or the scheduled 3.75% and try to sell that since it would still be a tax cut from the current status quo.

    For opponents, I’d say just keep up their same arguments because people hate taxes until their teachers and cops and hospitals go kaput.


  8. - Just Me - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:07 pm:

    It’s always politically popular to tax someone else.


  9. - PublicServant - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:08 pm:

    Proponents: Keep trying. It’s the fair and right thing to do.

    Opponents: Taxing marginal income at higher rates provides more bang for the buck because those marginal dollars progressively are less likely to be spent and thus help the economy. Those additional dollars left in the pockets of those lower income voters will be spent, thus causing business to sell more widgits, and hire more people to meet the increased demand, and those new employees will, in turn, spend and so on and so on and so on. Ask Scott Walker in Wisconsin, if you don’t believe me, since, if we had their tax structure we’d be more than flush. As a reason for leaving, taxes are quite low on the list of motivators. Thanks gallop!


  10. - Toure's Latte - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:12 pm:

    Raising taxes of full-time minimum wage earners is not a good idea. Maybe couple it with a diminishing income (as it goes up) exemption somehow, to lower their effective rate?


  11. - wordslinger - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:14 pm:

    Notice how the Civvies of the Commercial Club are awfully silent about extending the temporary tax.

    They don’t care about the corporate rate, because most of their companies don’t pay state taxes anyway.

    But those in the $20 million CEO club will gladly take a 5% personal rate over a graduated rate like 8.98% in Iowa or 7.65% in Wisconsin.


  12. - Jimbo - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:16 pm:

    They should just keep the 5% and make the standard deduction 25k. That makes 50k pay 2.5%, 100k pay 3.75% and 200k pay 4.375%. Graduated tax without requiring a CA. And they get to keep the high rate wile claiming it is a tax cut for everyone under 100k, even over the scheduled rate reduction.


  13. - VanillaMan - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:16 pm:

    Everyone knows that the GOP hates taxes, so when you put them into power when the state government is flat out bankrupted like it is in Illinois today - when those Republicans say we need more money to keep government functioning, the public will more easily accept it.

    So if you believe Illinois government has a revenue problem, not a spending problem - show Illinoisans that you are right by putting tax-hating GOPers into office and having them tell Illinoisans instead.

    Blagojevich, Madigan and Quinn have no credibility on this issue among a majority of Illinois voters. Illinoisans don’t trust them. So they won’t give them more money without a fight.

    The whole lame duck Quinncome Tax boondoggle is the result of Illinoisans unwilling to give their corrupted and foolish state leaders more money. It was the only way the Democrats could propose an increase - use the lame duck session, throw in a sunset clause to claim it is temporary, claim that the increase would only go to pay old bills and give away golden parachutes for votes to pass it.

    If we still had the GOP in control - that wouldn’t have happened. Voters trust the GOP with their money more than they do the Democrats.

    It is tiring to read the same complaint repeatedly here. You guys want more money from citizens? Then get people into office the citizens will believe and trust.

    Or haven’t you noticed how we’ve had this problem over the past decade since we’ve had one-party rule?


  14. - Jimbo - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:17 pm:

    *while


  15. - RNUG - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:18 pm:

    Review how Richard Ogilvie sold the original personal property / income tax swap … then find a strong leader to sell this swap.


  16. - VanillaMan - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:18 pm:

    Yup - vote for Rauner if you want a tax increase the public will accept.


  17. - VanillaMan - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:20 pm:

    That is - if you really believe that we have only a revenue problem, and not a spending problem, vote for Rauner. Let him confront the reality you keep claiming it right there, regardless of political party.


  18. - 4 percent - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:32 pm:

    Illinois already has a graduated tax. The EITC provides substantial relief for low income taxpayers, many of whom pay no tax and actually get money back.


  19. - Formerly Known As... - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:35 pm:

    Proponents: Listen to Hinz. He hits the nail right on the head.


  20. - Formerly Known As... - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:37 pm:

    Proponents: Also, make certain the state shows better stewardship of our funds over the next year or two.

    Most people are willing to pay taxes, as long as they feel they are getting their money’s worth.


  21. - Anon - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 2:52 pm:

    == vote for Rauner if you want a tax increase ==

    There’s a catchy slogan. I wonder how many Republicans understand that reality?

    ADVICE TO PROPONENTS
    I second the proposal to jack up the personal exemption for a family of four to $25K while keeping the rate at 5%. No constitional amendment necessary, unless the ISC rules it violates the flat tax requirement.

    OPPONENTS
    Gov. Rauner will raise taxes, but they will be more regressive ones. Stick with that plan.


  22. - RonOglesby - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 3:01 pm:

    ” Taxing marginal income at higher rates provides more bang for the buck because those marginal dollars progressively are less likely to be spent and thus help the economy.”

    This is a great fallacy. Like 100k or 200k a year house holds dont spend that money… cars, homes, new appliances, clothes, etc, etc. And anything they save is either in the bank (which is lent to other people and businesses) or in the market (capitalizing business).


  23. - Adam Smith - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 3:12 pm:

    Also for you economic pinheads who think people with high incomes stuff cash in their mattresses. Where do you think YOUR mortgage came from? Your car loan? Your small biz loan? The capital that starts new companies?

    This is our real problem, so many people, even those as ostensibly politically astute as CapFax commenters, are economic illiterates. They vote based on fear, hatred, revenge and personal gain. That’s both sides of the aisle.


  24. - Upon Further Review - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 3:29 pm:

    Practice austerity and demonstrate good stewardship before daring to ask for a tax increase.


  25. - CapnCrunch - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 3:44 pm:

    “Those additional dollars left in the pockets of those lower income voters will be spent,……”

    Isn’t this a good reason to allow the current tax rate to be reduced to 3.5%?


  26. - CapnCrunch - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 3:45 pm:

    oops 3.75%


  27. - Walker - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 4:04 pm:

    VMan: ===”we’ve had this problem over the past decade since we’ve we had one-party rule.”===

    I followed your whole argument, and you make some good points, but the fiscal problems and structural deficit are thirty-five-year problems in Illinois.

    @Adam Smith”" your “economic illiterates” on one side focus entirely on the supply side, as you described, while those one the other focus on increasing demand. Of course, both dynamics count.

    The balance between the two is what the argument is about, for those of us who operate and study business and economics in the real world.

    Because economic behavior actually changes as income rises, to create an optimal income tax structure, that both supports the market economy and the common infrastructure, security, and services of government, (assuming it isn’t zero by definition) would require different rates by income level.

    No one doubts at the lowest income levels, any additional money gets immediately back into the system creating higher demand. In fact, the higher the income, the greater the leakage of potential productive capital (defined as actually invested in job creation activities) out of the economic system. That’s especially true given worldwide financial markets. That’s usually not a problem at the income levels Ron Oglesby describes, but at significantly higher levels it is.

    To be “economically literate” is not to buy into any simplistic one-sided view.

    As I’m sure you would know, Adam Smith himself would find some modern “Conservative” economics, as touted by politicians and most Randians, as ridiculously simplistic. Smith’s ideal “free market” assumed a good deal of government regulation to keep it working freely for all participants. Keynes would find the economic statements of modern Liberal politicians equally stupid.


  28. - Anon - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 4:18 pm:

    Walker
    Thanks for your consistently constructive contributions. I think there is something to be said for divided government. With a GOP governor calling for some tax hikes, Durkin and Radogno will put some votes on it — something they refuse to do now. It’s remarkable how fast the anti-tax pledges can be deep sixed when it’s convenient to do so.


  29. - Wensicia - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 4:20 pm:

    “Those additional dollars left in the pockets of those lower income voters will be spent,……”

    “Isn’t this a good reason to allow the current tax rate to be reduced to 3.5%?”

    Why? Low-income people receive back most of their state taxes in refunds.


  30. - Anon. - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 4:21 pm:

    == vote for Rauner if you want a tax increase ==

    Reminds me of the old complaint, “They told me that if I voted for Goldwater, within 2 years there would be a half million of our boys in Vietnam. Well, I voted for him, and they were right.”

    To the question –

    To a proponent: Go stand in that corner and leave me alone.

    To an opponent: See that guy in the corner? Go talk to him and leave me alone.


  31. - Empty Suit - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 4:32 pm:

    Stop drop and roll


  32. - john doe - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 5:13 pm:

    @Anon,
    AMEN!


  33. - Jeff Trigg - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 6:52 pm:

    4% & Wensicia, “Substantial, many, most” does not include all poor people, especially responsible, working, young people without kids. There’s no good excuse to tax the income of ANY poor people.


  34. - Excessively Rabid - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 6:56 pm:

    Now that this proposal is off the table, how about trying something that doesn’t require a constitutional amendment? As I keep saying, base the state income tax on federal taxable income. This will bypass all kinds of idiosyncratic (I would say stupid) things about the Illinois tax code. Yes we will all (all of us with significant income)pay a lot more in state income taxes. But it will be much more progressive and will raise the needed level of revenues at a rate of 3.75%. I mean needed as in fully fund the state’s pension contributions after the “reform” abomination is thrown out by the courts. And a lot of the money will still be coming from the pensioners, so that ought to make somebody happy. It leaves unresolved the issue of how much tax revenue in this state is lost to various forms of miscreance, which I think is what upsets many taxpayers every time revenue is discussed. I don’t have a silver bullet for that one.


  35. - Anonymous - Wednesday, Apr 30, 14 @ 8:12 pm:

    man jack it up and leave retired alone.


  36. - lbj - Thursday, May 1, 14 @ 6:57 am:

    Don’t let the amateurs at SEIU Health Care run the campaign.


  37. - amerigom - Friday, May 2, 14 @ 5:17 am:

    We are a consuming nation! As every other Nation.
    ALL; collect taxes! Cities are in the same catagory; they need money to operate, and it’s done by taxing. Why not use consumption, as the means?
    The State of Florida, operates and is funded by a tax on consumption! Very simple!


  38. - amerigom - Friday, May 2, 14 @ 5:21 am:

    P. S,; Have you heard of the Fair Tax?


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* React to Rauner vetoes
* Reader comments closed for the weekend
* Rauner vetoes several union-backed bills
* This just in... Illinois Supreme Court accepts direct appeal of remap case
* Social service providers claim administration has "unchecked discretion" over paying off old contracts
* GOP poll: Kirk and Duckworth essentially tied, Clinton leads by 14
* Today's quotable
* The Roger Ailes connection to Illinois
* Even more editorial support for the Independent Map Amendment
* Question of the day
* Today in Illinois history
* *** LIVE COVERAGE *** Rauner education press conference
* Trump's best point of the night
* Mrs. Rauner appears to support Turnaround Agenda strategy
* Caption contest!
* Adding some context to Rauner's e-mail diatribe
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Supplement to today’s edition
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
* Oh, this ought to be good
* Rauner apologizes for making "unfair, untrue" comments in old e-mail
* Yesterday's blog posts

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............

...............

...............

...............
<


Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

  
* If we had a personal cloud instead of a phone, would we be better off?
* iPhone 7 Pro specs and features, Galaxy Note 7 battery & more – Pocketnow Daily
* Evan Blass leaks Apple iPhone 7 release date
* SurveyMonkey proclaims peak Pokemon GO in US
* Instant hidden rebate for Moto G4 on Amazon
* Dots & Co. tweaks the Dots games by adding a friendly companion
* iPhone 7 Plus? iPhone 7 Pro? Here’s a video showing either or both of them

* Sale scratched after 'clubhouse incident'
* Sale's Sox future may have new wrinkle
* Quintana to start after completion of suspended game
* Is Sale trade more likely after clubhouse incident?
* Sale scratched after 'clubhouse incident'
* White Sox-Tigers suspended after 8 innings
* Rain delaying Tigers-White Sox in Chicago

...............


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Blagojevich Trial
Advertising
Updated Posts
Polls

Archives
July 2016
June 2016
May 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress

Loading


* Illinois governor working with police on mariju.....
* Illinois governor working with police on mariju.....
* Illinois governor working with police on mariju.....
* Illinois governor working with police on mariju.....
* Providers: Stop gap budget won't have 'meaningf.....


* EXCHANGE: Survivors of cancer victims marry, now family of 8
* WNBA withdraws fines for teams that wore black warmup shirts
* WNBA withdraws fines for teams that wore black warmup shirts
* Chicago police say Uber driver a felon with handgun, drugs
* Construction at NIU stalled by state budget ready to resume
* Penguins are returning to Lincoln Park Zoo in new exhibit
* Illinois town hopes its levee can be inspected, deemed safe
* Chicago police say Uber driver a felon with handgun, drugs
* WNBA president lauds activism, wishes it was kept off court
* ACLU praises new Illinois limits on cellphone surveillance

* State costs for amendment notices likely to top $2 million
* Rauner OKs regulating police use of cell-site simulators
* Illinois Supreme Court to consider remap ballot measure
* Rauner vetoes construction-wage, homecare-worker pay increases
* Rauner apologizes, Chicago teachers protest over 2011 email questioning their competency
* Providers: Stop gap budget won't have 'meaningful' impact
* Rauner apologizes for calling Chicago teachers illiterate
* Illinois ordered to rethink medical marijuana for migraines
* Rauner once called Chicago teachers 'virtually illiterate'
* Gov. Rauner signs early childhood law

* Lolla at 25: The math on the tickets, the T-shirts, the grass (not that grass)
* How Clinton can out-convention Trump
* Trump's running mate has a business success story of his own to tell
* Duking it out for dominance at O'Hare
* Why we need to reverse Chicago's tree loss, and other letters from readers


* Man critically wounded in West Elsdon shooting
* Lanes closed on I-57 after rollover crash
* Police: Man injured in Antioch crash ran away without treatment
* Man shot on Near West Side
* Man shot in Austin
* Dear Abby: Heroic workers get kids’ postcards delivered
* Georgia Nicols horoscopes for July 24, 2016
* Ex-Lebanon hostage Thomas Sutherland, 85, dies in Colorado
* Sale’s ‘incident’ might affect his trade value
* Downtown street closures begin ahead of Lollapalooza


* New domestic violence law gives convicted murderer a shot at freedom
* Robin Ventura mum on when Chris Sale will start for White Sox again
* Latest Chris Sale-White Sox controversy has more questions than answers
* 1 dead, 3 wounded in Chicago shootings
* Chris Sale sent home after unexplained, bizarre 'clubhouse incident'
* 1 killed, 1 wounded in Calumet City shootings
* A locked office, getaway car and secret flight: The final steps in Clinton's VP pick
* Latest Chris Sale-White Sox controversy has more questions than answers
* Cubs explore upgrades; await production from Jason Heyward and Ben Zobrist
* Strong thunderstorms roll through Chicago area


* State costs for amendment notices likely to top $2 million
* Statehouse Insider: Rauner, AFSCME conduct PR war while labor talks at standstill
* Bernard Schoenburg: Buscher moves from independent to GOP, Trump
* Connecting people with volunteer opportunities
* Sommer family gives back together
* Joel Erickson: Sen. Kirk must stand up for veterans' rights
* Charles Krauthammer: Notes from Cleveland: The two-part rebellion
* Rauner OKs regulating police use of cell-site simulators
* Illinois Supreme Court to consider remap ballot measure
* Rauner vetoes construction-wage, homecare-worker pay increases


* Defrocked Southern Illinois priest who founded Camp Ondessonk has died
* Big Obstacle 3K course challenges fitness
* Phillip McGrath receives Edward Jones award
* Festival connects cultures
* United Way divvies up funds according to outcomes
* SIU at the crossroads: Leaders weigh future of system's flagship Carbondale campus
* Harrisburg church, Fowler Bonan Foundation teaming up for clothing drive
* Legence Bank welcomes new advisory board member
* Spirit out of season: Christmas in July delivers holiday cheer
* Mildred Osterhage-Kerens


* After Obama's green light, Afghan forces on the offensive
* No ASEAN consensus on South China Sea row _ for now
* Iraq: Suicide attack in Baghdad kills at least 10 people
* Afghanistan marks day of national mourning after huge attack
* Burned body found as wildfire burns near Los Angeles

* House lawmakers overcome hurdle on key tra...
* Rodney Davis talks funding with Bloomingto...
* The agency that fought Illiana gets a new ...
* Rep. Dold takes educational cruise down Ch...
* Lawmakers decry high turnover rate of VA h...
* CBD Oil, and politics
* Simon considering state Senate bid
* Killer Congressman Tom MacArthur trying to...
* Shutdown? State may not notice
* Rep. Bob Dold

* Senators Durbin, Kirk Announce Reopening O......

* Letter: Kirk's integrity - Northwest Herald...

* Laundromat Coming To Wilson & Magnolia Strip Mall
* Trumps returns to old ways: denials and finger-pointing about Cruz
* Trump returns to old ways: denials and finger-pointing about Cruz
* Illinois GOP delegates cast 54 votes for Trump, 9 for Cruz, 6 for Kasich
* IR Readers Favorites for Third Week of July 2016
* Plagiarism.
* KKK Wizard David Duke runs on the Trump Party ticket for Louisiana senator.
* Cartoon Of The Day
* Jonathan Halabi at the AFT. Day 2.
* Saw the new "Purge" movie recently


* Discount Admission Tickets Available For Purchase At Area Retailers - Fair to extend purchasing hours at Emmerson Building
* Governor Announces Appointments
* New Halsted Street Bridge Finished at Byrne Interchange, Multimodal Travel, Neighborhood Connectivity Enhanced - Last of Eisenhower bridges to be completed, project moves into next phase
* No Pokemon Go access on Veteran Home’s grounds
* Governor Takes Bill Action




Hosted by MCS -- CapitolFax.com Privacy Policy -- SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax -- Advertise Here -- Mobile Version -- Contact Rich Miller