SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
A look at what the Supreme Court could do in Harris v. Quinn

Friday, Jun 27, 2014

* Don Moss sent this out to his members. It’s a pretty good wrap-up, so check it out…

SUPREME COURT DECISION ON HARRIS V. QUINN EXPECTED MONDAY - What started as a relatively minor lawsuit by Pam Harris, a home based parent of a child with severe disabilities in McHenry, Illinois who was fighting an Executive Order by Governor Quinn that would allow for the unionization of parents caring for their children, has taken on major proportions that could affect public employee unions nationwide. As we previously indicated, there are three possible outcomes:

A. The Court could rule that family members can be unionized. If this happens, would those parents become state employees, entitled to collective bargaining, insurance and pensions?

B. The Court could block unionization of family members taking care of their children but do nothing else affecting existing state employees..

C. The Court could bar all government workers from involuntarily having to pay union dues if they choose not to do so–in effect a nationwide right-to-work law. This would be a major change that would affect public school teachers, firemen, police and other government workers on the local, county and state levels.

​We received the following message yesterday from Pam Harris:

    Dear Don,

    So you see, we will learn the Harris v Quinn decision on Monday shortly after 9 am. I have no idea why they are holding it to the last day of their term. It never entered my mind that this case would rocket to such importance.

    I am preparing a statement and will be sure to send it to you as soon as the decision is issued.

    People far smarter than I believe that Justice Alito has written the decision for the majority. This makes it slightly more probable that the decision will favor the Plaintiffs. : )

    But ​I​ have learned long ago that reading tea leaves is an exercise in futility.

    Come Monday, we will know. Then we can hopefully find a way to all move forward.

    With kind regards,

    Pam ​


- Posted by Rich Miller        

  1. - George Washington - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 10:45 am:

    I was under the impression that these family members received a sizable raise after unionization. If so, sometimes people need to be careful what they wish for.

  2. - OneMan - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 10:47 am:

    If it is C, watch all hell break lose…

  3. - A guy... - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 10:51 am:

    Wait and see is the best policy here. Thanks Don Moss for the summary. You’re a pro’s pro.

  4. - Chi - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 10:51 am:

    If (C), Illinois could, should and probably will pass a law stating unions don’t have to represent folks that aren’t members. Florida is “right-to-work” but has a similar law. The legislature could go even farther and say non-members can receive a separate wage rate/salary.

    Both of these steps would minimize the still huge impact a ruling like (C) would have.

  5. - walker - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 10:53 am:

    Nice note from Pam. Humble, straightforward, courteous.

    Maybe I’m just jaded by what political types put out.

  6. - A guy... - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:04 am:

    Agreed, Walk.

  7. - Keyser Soze - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:05 am:

    Look for a narrowly focused decision favoring the plaintiff but not applicable to the larger groups, i.e., firemen, police, etc. Can’t see Alito rocking the boat too much.

  8. - Todd - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:19 am:

    The Court is not likely to make a huge change like a watered down right to work (for less) ruling. not what they have been doing. even though they tossed recess appointments, read what the judges said and set the 10 day limit and such. and there was a differance on that.

    My bet here, is that the Court will treat them as independant contractors and not subject to organizing under the Act.

    I don;t think they want to make some wort of Beck type or Moore-Drydock type decision. Look at the gun stuff. They take steps.

    Even if you look to the cell phone case, they made a simple and logical decision. want to look at it, get a warrant.

    Here they looking at a statute and the notion if the Union and the application of the statute. Under the streaming of ntwork news it was an interpretation of copyright and how far that goes.

    I thnk this will be more akin to that one.

    And i think the Unions overeached in this case. They have set up a possible new definition, or clarification on when individuals can fall under a collective bargaining unit and what it the appropriate “bargaining” unit. And I think this overreach is goign to cost them and others.

  9. - Todd - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:22 am:

    And Chi — Floridia’s law can’t apply to private sector workers and collective bargaining agreements as it is preempted by federal law. if they write in no dies fees or assesments, the union STILL has to represent them under FEDERAL law.

    That is what the Indiana suit is all about using the state constitution ona theft of services without compensation. Pending before the state supreme court.

  10. - Jimbo - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:22 am:

    The current SCOTUS is an activist court. I can’t see the four conservatives and Kennedy passing up a chance to legislate from the bench. I hope I’m wrong, but I think they’ll go with C.

  11. - Chi - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:37 am:


    I was speaking specifically re: public employees, as that is what Harris v. Quinn entails. I should have been clearer. The union rights for public employees come purely from state law, and so can be tailored without regard to the NLRA.

  12. - ILPundit - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:40 am:

    If Alito is writing the majority opinion, and the fact that they’ve held it until the final day of the court session, I’m inclined to predict we will be seeing some form of option C.

  13. - Chi - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:44 am:

    I have no doubt Alito wants to write some version of C, but I do have doubts he could find a majority willing to go that far with him.

  14. - Jimbo - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:48 am:

    ILPundit, wait, do we know that Alito is writing for the majority, or is that conjecture?

  15. - Jimbo - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:49 am:

    Nevermind, I should read better. It is just a rumor though.

  16. - Chi - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:50 am:

    The conventional wisdom says Alito will write it, because he is the only Justice who hasn’t yet issued an opinion from a case heard in January (Harris was heard in January, and the only January case yet to be decided).

  17. - Chi - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 11:50 am:

    Scotusblog says it is “almost certain” that Alito will write Harris because of this distribution of the workload.

  18. - bigdaddygeo - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 12:01 pm:

    I think Keyser is right. Kennedy won’t go along with anything that changes the status quo. I don’t think there is a big risk to employee unions. The growth and income for union members are in positions that have state licensing and bachelors or higher education requirements - public school teachers, urban planners, etc. Even if the ruling doesn’t require dues paying, the impact would be small. There isn’t a law that requires CPAs to pay dues to the Illinois Society of CPAs or an architect to pay dues to the Illinois Chapter of AIA. They do it because it is professionally in their interest.

    I think the bigger risk to organized labor is allowing non-traditional “workers” be represented. If a union can represent workers who don’t have regular hours, supervise their own work, provide their own tools and place of work, without a pension plan, or even a steward (how can a union give grievance counsel to a worker who is their own supervisor) then a union can represent what ordinary people call independent contractors. Those home health care workers can vote to decertify and form their own union. WashTech or Programmers Guild would be able to compete with CWA or SEIU for technology members and organize all of the 1099 computer guys CMS has been using for 20 years. And all the while, PQ and MM would be able to smile and say - look these are hard working union members.
    I think that change is the real risk to organized labor.

  19. - Pam Harris - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 3:46 pm:

    For the record, the case was filed to achieve B. and it remains my desired outcome. It is also, I think, the most likely.

    George - there are two of IL’s 9 Medicaid waivers involved in Harris v Quinn: Home Services and Home Based. Our son Josh participates in the Home Based waiver and it is not unionized. There was an election shortly after Governor Quinn signed the Executive Order and by 2:1, the unions lost the election. The Home Services program was unionized in 2003 by simple card-check. And although there has a wage increase, the participant criteria was subsequently changed to eliminate many participants and those who remained saw a decrease in their hours of support.

  20. - Grandson of Man - Friday, Jun 27, 14 @ 4:10 pm:

    “For the record, the case was filed to achieve B. and it remains my desired outcome. It is also, I think, the most likely.”

    I wish you success in that outcome. I agree that if a group of people voted to not join a union, as they did in Tennessee with the VW plant, then they should not be forced into a union. It is my understanding that it’s what happened with home healthcare folks.

    As a unionized public employee, I believe that for the rest of us who are already established in unions for which people vote in the majority, the status quo should stand. I hope fervently that this will be the outcome. I believe that because federal law mandates that all people in a unionized jobs must reap the benefits of union contacts, regardless of their opinions about unions, they should pay a fair share dues amount.

    I’m okay with the decision being a “win-win,” so to speak.

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.

* Question of the day
* So long, Kurt!
* Will "right to work" pop up again?
* A little bit of what's at stake this week
* More poison pills
* Time heals most wounds
* NYT looks at Griffin, Rauner
* LaQuan McDonald case: Three suggestions for state action
* Yesterday's blog posts

Visit our advertisers...







Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

* ES File Explorer Pro removes bloat, unnecessary features
* Samsung patents several new foldable smartphone designs
* ZTE Nubia Z11 to get simultaneous U.S. and China release
* OLED panels for smartphones could be about to get much more affordable
* [Deal] Buy an extended service plan through Straight Talk today to save up to $55
* [Deal] Cricket Wireless Cyber Monday Samsung Galaxy sale
* [Deal] Get the HTC One M9 for 40% off and the Re Camera for 60% off

* Non-tender deadline looks familiar for White Sox
* Detroit Tigers make AL Central's first big splash with Jordan Zimme...
* South Side Sox' SB Nation MLB Awards voting results
* Starting Pitcher Rankings: Chris Sale and Jose Quintana maintain st...
* Scouting profile: Adam Engel
* Alex Avila will try to shed limitations with White Sox
* White Sox program provides kids real chance


Main Menu
Pundit rankings
Subscriber Content
Blagojevich Trial
Updated Posts

November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005


RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0


* Business Groups Plea for Budget Solution in Let.....
* Will “right to work” pop up again? - The Capito.....
* A little bit of what's at stake this week - The.....
* The loophole that unleashed an unprecedented fl.....
* Closer Look: Task force looks to shrink Illinoi.....

* Cities, counties struggle during Illinois budget mess
* 1st weekend of Illinois firearm deer hunt beats last year
* Police investigate break-ins at 4 Champaign-Urbana hotspots
* Urbana chef taps family members for his kitchen staff
* Chicago police: Man steals van with 2-year-old girl inside
* Man in custody after bodies found in Lake County home
* Report: SAFB considered for new spy agency office since 2005
* Chicago announces expansion of police body-camera program
* No notable delays for holiday travelers at Chicago airports
* Closer Look: Task force looks to shrink Illinois government

* Cities, counties struggle during Illinois budget mess
* 'Pot doctors' pushing boundaries in Illinois, other states
* Burger King manager: Police erased video of Chicago shooting
* Local free community college plans may be template for U.S.
* Rauner faces challenges in move to block refugees
* Vendor Payment Program suspended due to budget impasse
* Rauner pardons man found innocent of 1999 attack
* Springfield jobless rate falls again, to 5.1 percent
* Springfield police chief sees problems with body cam law
* Lawsuit challenges Illinois ban on marijuana campaign money

* IMF adds China's yuan to basket of top currencies
* Obama's Chicago fundraisers slower to step up for Clinton
* Deere cutting 220 workers in Moline
* I like my old phone just fine, thanks
* Tribune Publishing refutes Murdoch tweet, says not in sale talks

* Cop who shot Laquan McDonald due back in court
* Is Anita Alvarez losing her Hispanic political base?
* Sports Illustrated: Blackhawks whiff on Stadium Series jerseys
* THE WATCHDOGS: How Midway clout king got out of property taxes
* Trump scraps endorsement event after black pastors object
* Chicago Teachers Union plans strike vote on Dec. 9: report
* Obama visits Bataclan, site of French terror attack
* Niklas Hjalmarsson skates swiftly and carries a big stick
* Bears may offer suite life at ground level
* Officials see uptick in historic renovations in Springfield

* Student with gun arrested at Barrington High School
* South Side shooting wounds man
* Tribune Publishing statement: Not in discussions to sell company
* Teen charged with shooting at Fuller Park that killed 3, wounded 2
* Winter overnight parking ban starts Tuesday
* Holiday toll: 8 killed, 20 wounded over Thanksgiving weekend
* Squad car crashes during chase of stolen van with girl, 2, inside
* No injuries when part of building collapses in Back of the Yards
* Skilling: This November one of wettest on record
* U. of C. cancels Monday classes after threat to Hyde Park campus

* James Durkin: Compromise needed to restore Illinois' standing
* Bernard Schoenburg: Book on Blagojevich impeachment lets reader 'be right there'
* Andy Shaw: It's time to crack down on no-bid contracts
* 'Pot doctors' pushing boundaries in Illinois, other states
* Burger King manager: Police erased video of Chicago shooting
* Kristina Rasmussen: Relying on one another, not the government
* Charles Krauthammer: The Syrian immigration cul-de-sac
* Rob Elliott: EPA ethanol ruling affects more than energy policy
* Local free community college plans may be template for U.S.
* Rauner faces challenges in move to block refugees

* Police seeking Champaign bank robber
* 11-30-15 Monday Morning Quarterbacks
* Thorne tears meniscus
* Illinois assistant leaving
* Chicago police officer who fatally shot teen due in court
* The Latest: Student leader says few details given on threat
* Ford to book $600 million 4th quarter expense for new labor contract
* Kevorkian archive opens as physician-assisted deaths rise
* Calendars show Clinton made time at State for supporters
* Suspect in Colorado clinic shooting to appear in court

* Student in custody after bringing gun to Barrington High School
* Meet the Maine West football player who moonlights as fire dancer
* Dolphins fire offensive coordinator Lazor after loss at Jets
* Thomas Bach: Hamburg bid rejection is 'missed opportunity'
* 'Suspicious activity' puts Barrington High School on hard lockdown

* House lawmakers overcome hurdle on key tra...
* Rodney Davis talks funding with Bloomingto...
* The agency that fought Illiana gets a new ...
* Rep. Dold takes educational cruise down Ch...
* Lawmakers decry high turnover rate of VA h...
* CBD Oil, and politics
* Simon considering state Senate bid
* Killer Congressman Tom MacArthur trying to...
* Shutdown? State may not notice
* Rep. Bob Dold

* Durbin Pushing for Spending Bill - Alton D......

* Manchin, Kirk introduce bill targeting gov......

* Morning Minute: Pending home sales headed slightly higher in October
* Chicago To Expand Police Body Camera Program
* Advocates Meet With Rauner's Office, Call For Acceptance Of Syrian Refugees
* Report: CTU To Hold December 9 Strike Authorization Vote
* Teen Viral Sensation Says McDonald Shooting Proves Cops, Conservatives Are Racists
* Harris runs to split black vote, defeat Zopp, and position Duckworth against Kirk
* GOP Hindu-American Political Arm Emerges for 2016 Elections
* Lack of Illinois Lottery payouts sending gamblers out of state
* OBrien: Laquan McDonald -- Victim of Liberalism
* Sixteen shots. The story that broke the silence.

* Emergency Management Officials, National Weather Service Encourage Winter Preparedness - November is Winter Weather Preparedness Month in Illinois
* Keep Your Family Safe This Winter - November through February are leading months for carbon monoxide related incidents
* Governor Takes Bill Action
* Illinois Department of Labor Director Hugo Chaviano Awards Governor’s Award for Contributions in Health and Safety to the Illinois Refining Division of Marathon Petroleum Company LP
* State Regulator Elected Treasurer of Interstate Medical Licensure Compact

Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller