SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
When a “fact check” is no such thing

Tuesday, Sep 7, 2010

* Ever since the Daily Herald lost its political reporter (Eric Krol and then Joe Ryan) and its Statehouse bureau chief (John Patterson), its campaign stories have really gone downhill.

A great case in point is the paper’s latest piece on Republican 10th Congressional District candidate Bob Dold and Social Security reform.

The issue first heated up when Dold posted this on his Facebook page and then deleted it

Congressman Paul Ryan has taken a lot of heat for his Social Security plan, which would allow people under the age of 55 to invest a portion of their FICA tax

Offers workers under 55 the option of investing over one third of their current Social Security taxes into personal retirement accounts, similar to the Thrift Savings Plan available to Federal employees.

That’s pretty much the same idea that got President George W. Bush is such hot water after the 2006 campaign. And it’s very much like Dold’s own plan which he wrote about before the GOP primary in his Tribune questionnaire

Additionally, I would propose allowing a portion of Social security payments (not more that 25%) to be put into Government authorized individual retirement accounts that would be able to be passed to heirs if not used

Dold now says on his website only that he would allow people under 55 to invest a “small portion” of their FICA taxes.

Ryan says his plan isn’t privatization, and that’s the only source the Daily Herald used in its alleged fact check…

THE FACTS: The official website for Ryan’s proposal, roadmap.republicans.budget.house.gov, details its concepts for Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and other programs. It also includes a section called “Setting the Record Straight” that seeks to debunk accusations about the plan, as well as another section with answers to frequently asked questions.

According to the website, the Roadmap would not privatize Social Security. The personal accounts it proposes would be managed by a public board.

It’s not difficult to find other sources which claim that Ryan wants to privatize Social Security. But Ryan’s statement is presented as the one and only “fact.”

And instead of quoting Dold’s very own Chicago Tribune questionnaire which cited the 25 percent figure, the Daily Herald instead delved into the semantics of Dold’s original Facebook post and the he said/she said which followed.

I know I’m repeating myself this morning, but this is yet another reason why blogs can often be far better vehicles for reading about politics (or anything else) because they are much more willing to use material from different sources than newspapers are. It’s just stupid that the DH didn’t quote Dold’s Tribune response. It makes zero sense. Their fact check is rendered completely meaningless. I’m not sure why they even bothered.

* To make matters worse, the DH completely botched the admittedly stale deleted Facebook post controversy. This is the explanation the Dold campaign gave me for removing that Paul Ryan post

It’s Facebook. We put things up and take things down all the time. We’re not announcing policy on Facebook.

And this is what the Dold campaign just told the Daily Herald…

As for the disappearing Facebook post, a Dold spokeswoman said the comment simply was replaced by one about a different issue, the proposed Metra STAR line. Dold stands by the original posting’s message, she said.

Democrat Dan Seals’ campaign watches that Dold Facebook page pretty closely and they say they’ve never seen the Republican delete a post except for that Ryan post. And you don’t “replace” Facebook posts. You can delete them and add a new post, but there’s no such thing as replacing them. It’s a goofy explanation and the Daily Herald “fact check” completely let them skip away clean. Also, if they don’t post about policy on Facebook, why did they post about Metra?

* Meanwhile, the Dan Seals campaign claims its latest poll has the Democrat with a large lead. From a press release…

– DOUBLE-DIGIT LEAD: Seals holds a 13-point lead over Republican Bob Dold, 49% to 36%. This margin is slightly larger than Seals’ 8-point lead in May (46% to 38%). [http://www.swamppolitics.com/news/politics/blog/2010/07/poll_watch_dems_find_glimmers.html]

– WINNING INDEPENDENTS: Seals leads by 5 points among self-identified independent voters, 39% to 34%.

– STRONGER NAME ID: Seals’ name identification remains strong at 74% compared to his opponent, who was recognized by just 47% of respondents. Seals leads in both Cook and Lake Counties and leads with almost every demographic subgroup.

– LARGE CROSSOVER VOTE: In addition to his strong base of Democratic and independent support, Seals is also winning 16% of voters who say they plan to support Mark Kirk in the 2010 U.S. Senate race, pointing to a diverse coalition of bi-partisan support.

The campaign’s polling memo is here. A We Ask America poll taken in early August had this race much closer, with Seals leading Dold by just 3 points. But there have been some problems with that poll’s accuracy.

* Down-ballot campaign roundup…

* Hare, Schilling agree to 2 debates, but where?

* Cullerton says Democrats will retain state Senate

* Lots of Lawmakers on the Ballot, Few Races Close

* A look at some of the hottest state legislative races in the suburbs

* Legislative debates slated at Decatur Tech Academy

* Washington: Forrest gains, but can he topple Dem?

* Segvich supporters back Daley challenger

* Cook County Board Candidate Admits Conviction

* Felicia Page finds niche in Macon County State’s Attorney’s office

* Maurice Davis begins run in Macon County State’s Attorney’s office

* GOP to open Vermilion County HQ on Tuesday

- Posted by Rich Miller        


6 Comments
  1. - John Bambenek - Tuesday, Sep 7, 10 @ 11:46 am:

    Remind me again why letting younger workers invest a portion of what would be contributed to Social Security would be so catastrophic (assuming we keep the promises made to current and soon-to-be retirees)?

    Take into account that private (or semi-private) investment accounts wouldn’t be able to be “tapped” (in theory at least) for current government spending as opposed to the pile of IOUs that make up the Social Security Distrust Fund.


  2. - John Galt - Tuesday, Sep 7, 10 @ 12:06 pm:

    After following a few DuPage County races pretty closely, it’s my opinion that the Daily Herald is pretty crummy at reporting political stories. They either end up being blatantly biased and/or only reporting half of the story. Not a fan of Jake Griffin….


  3. - Fan of the Game - Tuesday, Sep 7, 10 @ 12:16 pm:

    Journalism as it has been marketed to us over the past half century is just about dead. Those objective reporters delivering facts are gone. They have been replaced by the wire story and the rehashed press release because they are cheaper and fill space just as well.

    Fact checking is irrelevant. If the story is written correctly, everything in it can be true without being true. For example, let’s say a story reads, “The Joe Blow campaign says it released all of the candidate’s tax records.” No fact checking is needed. It is factually true that the campaign made that statement. Whether the candidate actually released the tax records might be open to debate.

    The void will be filled. Capitol Fax is one of the media that will fill it because discerning people want to see the whole picture…the real picture.


  4. - Xgman - Tuesday, Sep 7, 10 @ 12:41 pm:

    So now Dold supports the Star line!?! In the primary he had two or three mailers criticizing the RTA reform bill that made the Star line a possibility. So he was anti-transit then; and now pro-transit? Does he believe in anything?


  5. - KeepSmiling - Tuesday, Sep 7, 10 @ 2:00 pm:

    Yes and our non-fact-checking non-reporters aren’t even looking into the results of Metra’s New Starts analysis to illuminate whether the STAR Line is a good idea. The media doesn’t seem to care that the ridership projections and the cost effectiveness of the STAR Line have been determined, but Metra will not share the info with the public. (thanks, taxpayers, for footing the bill for the $1 million plus study that you don’t get to see.) I hear the results are not such great news for the STAR Line. But while the findings sit under-wraps in an office, Metra will once again let politicians use the STAR Line to try to get support from the mayors and communities along it.


  6. - G. Willickers - Tuesday, Sep 7, 10 @ 10:34 pm:

    Hey Bambenek — there ain’t nothing stopping you from investing whatever you want right now. 401(k)s, IRAs and Roth IRAs are all protected forms of investing for retirement and, if you can afford it, you can pour all the money you want into your own private investments outside of those vehicles too.

    But to claim you want to invest a portion of Social Security in some way that still “keeps the promise” to seniors is beyond obtuse. Magic is pretend and magic is the only that gets done.

    Well, magic or a drastic benefits cut or a massive FICA tax increase, either of which would be necessary to fund the enormous amount of Wall Street fees necessary to run such a pipedream scheme.

    Here’s the thing you and your fellow conservatives just don’t get. Social Security ain’t an investment. It’s insurance. It’s insurance against living in a cardboard box tucked away in an alley off Green Street in Champaign. It’s insurance against choosing between a scoop of dry cat food or half a can of dog food as your only meal for the day.

    And when you siphon off 25% (or whatever percent you think you can get away with) in order to create another 401(k) or IRA by a different name such an action would either raises taxes or cuts “the promise” of which you speak so highly by default.

    Ain’t no such thing as a free lunch, not even in conservative-lala-land.


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* Reader comments closed for the holiday weekend
* Fracking rules finally unveiled
* Question of the day
* A big IDOT roundup
* Even Steven, for now
* *** UPDATED x1 - Confirmed *** Report: Libertarians file charges
* Big guys dinged a bit, but little guys helped a lot
* Today's photo
* Yesterday's blog posts

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............


Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

          
        * Moto X+1 gets detailed in in-depth video leak
        * IFA 2014 expectation roundup: smartwatches galore
        * The Moto X successor gets a new possible name as Moto Maker info leaks
        * Sony to launch two new wearable devices at IFA 2014
        * Sony’s Xperia plans for IFA 2014 get detailed, see what the OEM is planning to announce
        * Typing Writer Turns Your iPad Into A Typewriter (And No, It Wasn’t Created By Tom Hanks)
        * Best Buy slashes G Watch pricing to just $179 ahead of IFA

        * Shelly Palmer Radio Report – September 1, 2014
        * Netflix says that Comcast is costing it customers
        * Possible Moto X+1 Prototype With Leather Backplate Spotted
        * Lenovo’s Vibe X2 Invite Takes A Slight Poke At Apple
        * Icewind Dale: Enhanced Edition Announced, Available For Pre-Order
        * Emojli Messaging App Launched, Lets You Chat Only Using Emojis
        * The New Moto X Will Be Headed For Verizon

        * Breaks turn in Quintana's favor against Tigers
        * Molina outrighted; roster spot opens up for Rodon
        * Wilkins, Snodgress part of White Sox shuffle
        * Noesi looks to continue push toward season's end
        * Breaks turn in Quintana's favor against Tigers
        * Dunn to retire following season
        * White Sox deal Dunn to A's for pitching prospect


        Main Menu
        Home
        Illinois
        YouTube
        Pundit rankings
        Obama
        Subscriber Content
        Durbin
        Burris
        Blagojevich Trial
        Advertising
        Updated Posts
        Polls

        Archives
        August 2014
        July 2014
        June 2014
        May 2014
        April 2014
        March 2014
        February 2014
        January 2014
        December 2013
        November 2013
        October 2013
        September 2013
        August 2013
        July 2013
        June 2013
        May 2013
        April 2013
        March 2013
        February 2013
        January 2013
        December 2012
        November 2012
        October 2012
        September 2012
        August 2012
        July 2012
        June 2012
        May 2012
        April 2012
        March 2012
        February 2012
        January 2012
        December 2011
        November 2011
        October 2011
        September 2011
        August 2011
        July 2011
        June 2011
        May 2011
        April 2011
        March 2011
        February 2011
        January 2011
        December 2010
        November 2010
        October 2010
        September 2010
        August 2010
        July 2010
        June 2010
        May 2010
        April 2010
        March 2010
        February 2010
        January 2010
        December 2009
        November 2009
        October 2009
        September 2009
        August 2009
        July 2009
        June 2009
        May 2009
        April 2009
        March 2009
        February 2009
        January 2009
        December 2008
        November 2008
        October 2008
        September 2008
        August 2008
        July 2008
        June 2008
        May 2008
        April 2008
        March 2008
        February 2008
        January 2008
        December 2007
        November 2007
        October 2007
        September 2007
        August 2007
        July 2007
        June 2007
        May 2007
        April 2007
        March 2007
        February 2007
        January 2007
        December 2006
        November 2006
        October 2006
        September 2006
        August 2006
        July 2006
        June 2006
        May 2006
        April 2006
        March 2006
        February 2006
        January 2006
        December 2005
        April 2005
        March 2005
        February 2005
        January 2005
        December 2004
        November 2004
        October 2004

        Blog*Spot Archives
        November 2005
        October 2005
        September 2005
        August 2005
        July 2005
        June 2005
        May 2005

        Syndication

        RSS Feed 2.0
        Comments RSS 2.0
        WordPress

        Loading


        * Tougher rules ahead on domestic abuse..
        * It’s ‘Labor’ Day, Not ‘Union’ Day..
        * Gov. Quinn to live for a week on minimum wage -.....
        * Rauner, Quinn Lay Out Plans At Forums..
        * Local party leaders ‘confident’ about November .....
        * Gov. Quinn announces $14.4 million in park gran.....


        * Little League team honored with parade in Vegas
        * Rauner vow revives governor's mansion question
        * Quinn to live on minimum wage for a week
        * Infection affecting west-central Illinois soybeans
        * Newborn baby found alive inside Illinois trash bin
        * Bank loans used to collect unpaid medical bills
        * Man brings 2 military flares to Illinois sheriff
        * 4 shot to death in Chicago suburb of Elmhurst
        * Springfield drug suspect had reinforced door
        * Beyond governor race, big stakes in Illinois vote

        * Does the governor need to live in the Executive Mansion?
        * Statehouse Insider: Hands off investments
        * State of unions: AFSCME wins some, loses some on outsourcing
        * State of unions: Domination of Illinois' workforce becomes campaign issue
        * State of unions: Lawmakers approved keeping some workers out of unions
        * State of Illinois posts applications for medical marijuana businesses
        * DNR issues long-awaited ‘fracking’ rules
        * Quinn grants 38 clemency requests
        * IDNR issues long-awaited ‘fracking’ rules
        * Court rules state retirees can stop paying health insurance premiums

        * If only it were this easy to lift share prices
        * 'Chicagoland' star returns to school
        * Amid re-election fight, Quinn pushes through a tax on business
        * Chicago's worst IPO in 2014: Ryerson
        * Why ComEd is worried about your smartphone


        * Firefighters extinguish blaze at Evanston towing company
        * Off-duty paramedic delivers own baby on Edens Expressway
        * Firefighter among two injured in South Chicago fire
        * Joliet woman guilty in double-murder; two more to stand trial
        * Aurora couple on O’Hare shuttle bus ‘landed in a pile of humans’ after crash
        * Durbin’s race against Oberweis no runaway
        * Quinn announces $102 million investment for high-speed rail
        * Quinn to live on minimum wage for a week
        * Ex-cop convicted of protecting crooks is back on public payroll
        * Person shot at forest preserve in Oak Forest


        * Tougher rules ahead on domestic abuse
        * Shootings on North, South sides wound at least 5
        * 'As horrible as it sounds, it came out of love': family of 4 dead in murder-suicide
        * No bail for 2nd man charged in killing of woman days before Mother's Day
        * Quinn takes on minimum wage challenge
        * Man, 49, dies after being pulled from water near Montrose Beach
        * Cops: Man dies following Tri-State crash


        * Donated Breast Milk Helps Sick Infants
        * DNR Releases Fracking Rules
        * Update From Ferguson Via KWMU's Rachel Lippmann
        * Listen to State Week - August 29, 2014
        * Inspector's Report Reveals Clout Hiring At IDOT
        * 'Belleville' The Movie Is NOT A Documentary
        * Journalist and doctor encourage honest conversations about death
        * Undocumented Immigrants Call For Presidential Orders
        * State Retirees To Stop Paying Health Premiums
        * How America's most plentiful bird disappeared


        * Does the governor need to live in the Executive Mansion?
        * Our Opinion: Driving into floodwater a deadly practice
        * Angie Muhs: A debate in Springfield would send the right message from candidates
        * Charles Krauthammer: Lower corporate tax rates. Now.
        * Bernard Schoenburg: Dillman, Watson looking at possible runs for alderman
        * Statehouse Insider: Hands off investments
        * Statehouse Insider: Hands off investments
        * State of unions: AFSCME wins some, loses some on outsourcing
        * State of unions: Domination of Illinois' workforce becomes campaign issue
        * State of unions: Lawmakers approved keeping some workers out of unions


        * Marion Lester Lawrence
        * Betty Mik
        * Brad Hinchcliff
        * Joseph Young
        * Naomi Goddard
        * Jaxson Keeling
        * Marjorie Pirtle
        * Julia Finn
        * Alexander Johnson
        * Charles Lasley


        * Donnie Wahlberg and Jenny McCarthy wed in St. Charles
        * Rolling Meadows driver charged in crash near Daily Herald building
        * Cougars will face Wisconsin to open playoffs
        * Disabled children killed in Elmhurst murder-suicide
        * Addison Trail puts it all together

        * Roskam: Making college more affordable for...
        * Army Veteran Shane Scherer Joins Roskam's ...
        * Roskam speaks on issues to chamber lunch c...
        * Roskam talks tax reform, health care, immi...
        * Roskam hires wounded veteran in West Chica...
        * Inactive Congress Discussed - Alton Daily ...
        * Roskam, Kirk speak to local business owner...
        * Roskam Talks Taxes - Alton Daily News
        * Nadler introduces resolution condemning an...
        * Roskam gives business leaders vision for f...

        * Durbin On Social Security Shortfall...
        * Bishop Larry Trotter Endorses Jim Oberweis......
        * Bishop Larry Trotter Endorses Jim Oberweis......
        * Bishop Larry Trotter Endorses Jim Oberweis......
        * Bishop Larry Trotter Endorses Jim Oberweis......

        * Putin Hopeful Russia Won’t Lose Right to H......
        * Susquenita enters Tri-Valley League under ......
        * Putin hopeful Russia won't lose right to h......
        * Soccer-Putin hopeful Russia won't lose rig......

        * Hidden in Plain Sight: The Architecture of Chicago's Labor Movement
        * Contemplating on Labor Day whether “labor” will influence this election
        * Durbin - Oberweis race tightening; Oberweis endorsed by Bishop Trotter
        * "The Tarot Show" Coming To Uptown Arts Center
        * ... Or Are You Just Happy To See Me?
        * Oberweis will attempt to bypass Quinn with veto override
        * Where's Weyermuller? Having it his way at Burger King
        * O'Brien: Yes We Tan. Obama Concedes to ISIS in "Taupe and Change" suit
        * Foster: Oberweis' flip-flop on immigration cost him my vote
        * Chris Christie comes to Chicago to campaign for Bruce Rauner. Although Rauner needs no lessons from Christie on how to reward political pals with pension funds.


        * Governor Quinn Invests $102 Million in High-Speed Rail Upgrades on Chicago-St. Louis Line - Funding Will Improve Capacity, Safety on Joliet-Dwight Segment
        * Quinn Refuses to Answer New IDOT Questions
        * IDNR Delivers Revised Rules to Implement Hydraulic Fracturing Regulatory Act - Rules strengthened to ensure public participation, improve transparency, toughen penalties and protect the environment
        * Governor Quinn Proclaims September as “Recovery Month” in Illinois - Encourages people to speak up about mental illness and substance abuse
        * Governor Quinn Dedicates Jane Byrne Interchange - Governor Renames Circle Interchange in Honor of Chicago’s First and Only Female Mayor to Date




            Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller