SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
Here we go again

Thursday, Mar 27, 2014

* Tribune

Quinn sought to portray his fiscal blueprint as part of an effort to end a cycle of budget game-playing by his predecessors that left state finances in shambles. He said part of his strategy was the controversial pension overhaul law last year that he argued would dramatically cut retirement costs and let more tax revenue flow to schools, health care and other services.

Rauner contends that Quinn’s pension alterations are too timid and will save the state far less than the governor contends. That argument may have gotten a boost Wednesday when the state’s bipartisan fiscal forecasting agency revised downward by several billion dollars its long-term savings projection for the pension overhaul.

* That snippet may have been based on this Bruce Rauner campaign press release…

On the same day of Pat Quinn’s budget address in which he broke his promise to keep the 67% personal income tax temporary, the Commission on Government Forecasting and Accountability released an analysis of the so-called pension reform law that shows it will save $22.6 billion less than was promised when the legislation was passed.

* This isn’t much different than the same stupid canard I dealt with in the subscriber section back in January. Here’s what I wrote back then. Substitute $15 billion with $22.7 billion and adjust everything else and you’ll get the same sort of results…

ONE OF THE DUMBEST ARGUMENTS EVER There’s been much screaming and hollering about how new calculations show that the pension reform law is projected to save $15 billion less than originally advertised last fall when the bill passed.

The complaints are based mainly on a recent Chicago Tribune article entitled “Illinois pension law saves $15 billion less than first thought.” The ultra-conservative Illinois Policy Institute, Bruce Rauner and other pension bill opponents have used the story as ammunition to claim that the law is based on a tissue of lies.

But the premise of that article was completely off base because it looked at the wrong number. The only truly valuable number is what taxpayers will end up shoveling into the pension system. Like everything else, it’s all about the final bottom line.

OK, we’re gonna get into a little math here, but it’s really easy so stay with me a minute.

The basic thing to remember here is that calculations originally showed last fall that pension reforms meant taxpayers would owe the pension systems $220 billion over 30 years. A recalculation with updated numbers, however, showed the total taxpayer obligation is now at $205 billion. That’s really good news, but it’s being irresponsibly spun as bad news.

The original estimates were based on Fiscal Year 2012 data. Without the new pension law, the data showed that taxpayers were on the hook for $380 billion in pension payments over 30 years. The reform law reduced that obligation estimate to $220 billion, which was a 42.1 percent reduction in what the government would have to give the pension funds.

When the numbers were updated to include Fiscal Year 2013 data (which included some pretty high investment returns), the new research found that taxpayers were now on the hook for $350 billion over the next 30 years without the reforms. The reform law would result in a 41.4 percent reduction to just $205 billion.

So, what about that $15 billion difference touted by the opponents? Where does it come from?

It’s not that hard to figure out and here’s an easy little example if you’re still scratching your head.

Let’s say you’re looking for a new watch. You find one at Macy’s that’s originally priced at $109 and is on sale at 40 percent off. You’d save $43.60 for a final price of $65.40. That’s still more expensive than Rauner’s watch, but not a bad deal at all.

But then you go next door to Bergner’s and you see the exact same watch listed at $100 and it’s also on sale for 40 percent off. You’d save $40 with the 40 percent sale, but your final bottom line price would be $60, compared to $65.40 at Macy’s,

It doesn’t take Einstein to figure out the better bottom line deal here. Yeah, your 40 percent “savings” are higher with the more expensive Macy’s watch, but the bottom line price you pay is significantly lower at Bergner’s.

The Policy Institute and Rauner would have you believe that Bergner’s is somehow ripping you off because the sale’s 40 percent reduction amount is lower than Macy’s. But that’s just plainly ridiculous. Who thinks like that?

Discuss.

- Posted by Rich Miller        


24 Comments
  1. - PublicServant - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 9:16 am:

    ===67% personal income tax===

    LOL. What’s a word here, or a word there in the grand scheme of things?…


  2. - I B Strapped - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 9:22 am:

    It’s all Mox Nix anyway when the ISC Jams Madigans scheme and Rauner goes to Plan B next year.


  3. - wordslinger - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 9:28 am:

    The Tribbies should stay away from “numbers” stories. Like Barbie said, “math is hard.”


  4. - Bill White - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 9:32 am:

    === The Policy Institute and Rauner would have you believe that Bergner’s is somehow ripping you off because the sale’s 40 percent reduction amount is lower than Macy’s. But that’s just plainly ridiculous. ===

    In terms of intellectual honesty, this belongs in the same category as counting people who move out of state (and therefore do not receive IL funded Medicaid) as example of Medicaid fraud because the old names and addresses were never purged from the database.


  5. - Grandson of Man - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 9:35 am:

    The key is the strong investment returns in 2013 that lowered the overall taxpayer liability. The entire pension debt model shifted downward in cost, which is good.

    What the IPI and their allies are doing is using reverse psychology. A 67% income tax increase sounds horrible, even though the tax was raised from 3-5%, which still makes us competitive with most tax states. It seems to be the same thing with the $22.6 billion.


  6. - langhorne - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 9:36 am:

    once a campaign gets a headline and/or story they like, it lives on forever. no matter how discredited. even if it is from the bone gap gazette.


  7. - Political Neophyte - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 9:57 am:

    Who thinks like that? The Policy Institute thinks like that.


  8. - train111 - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 10:10 am:

    Who thinks this way? Campaign consultants writing 30 second adds for TV.

    Which is easier to sell a campaign on–Anti-tax, anti-spend, anti-everything hysteria or cold boring facts?
    Most overpaid consultants are going to run away with the first rather than trying to explain the second.


  9. - dupage dan - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 10:13 am:

    Nice explanation - helps those of us (me) who don’t have the inclination to work that out.

    However, why does it matter? Does anyone really think the state gov’t is gonna keep to that schedule? We were all ramped up with Edgars program, how long did that last? The gov’t is gonna wait till this settles down a bit - hopefully, in a few years, folks memories will be a little fuzzy, and the politicians can go back to their previous behavior.


  10. - Palm Tree - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 10:21 am:

    Who thinks this way?
    People who are trying to craft an argument to justify their No vote on the most comprehensive pension reform package in Illinois history. A package that credit rating agencies have praised. A package that if found constitutional reduces total taxpayer costs on pensions by almost half.

    People who initially supported the bill but were told by their financial benefactor to vote No.

    Now they are looking for cover for that No vote. People like Representative McSweeney.


  11. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 10:54 am:

    More embarrassing reporting from the Tribune…Abdon has a lot of work to do.


  12. - Timmeh - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 10:58 am:

    For someone whose company ran the pension funds, it seems like Rauner doesn’t understand the numbers. Or is willingly distorting them. Either way, that’s not what you want from an “outsider businessman” running for governor.


  13. - MrJM - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 11:09 am:

    Who thinks like that?

    Oh, this has nothing to do with “thinking”…

    – MrJM


  14. - 47th Ward - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 12:55 pm:

    Overheard in the Tribune Tower:

    The numbers all go to eleven. Look, right across the board, eleven, eleven, eleven and…

    Oh, I see. And most amps go up to ten?

    Exactly.

    Does that mean it’s louder? Is it any louder?

    Well, it’s one louder, isn’t it? It’s not ten. You see, most blokes, you know, will be playing at ten. You’re on ten here, all the way up, all the way up, all the way up, you’re on ten on your guitar. Where can you go from there? Where?

    I don’t know.

    Nowhere. Exactly. What we do is, if we need that extra push over the cliff, you know what we do?

    Put it up to eleven?

    Eleven. Exactly. One louder.

    Why don’t you just make ten louder and make ten be the top number and make that a little louder?

    These go to eleven.


  15. - sue - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 1:02 pm:

    Many(including myself) would have no problem leaving the personal tax rate at 5 percent if it had solved the State’s fiscal issues-BUT IT DOESN’T seem to have worked-employment remains stagnant, credit ratings have been slashed; bills remain unpaid and pensions are still grossly underfunded- The problem doesn’t seem to be revenues but spending- Quinn had the benefit of increased tax revenues for 4 years and rather then reduce the State’s deficit- he found a number of programs to expand- Assuming the rate remains at 5- it would be nice to see the legislature bring the spending down to the level where revenues equal outlays


  16. - Rich Miller - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 1:03 pm:

    ===Quinn had the benefit of increased tax revenues for 4 years and rather then reduce the State’s deficit- he found a number of programs to expand===

    Which were?


  17. - titan - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 1:22 pm:

    Who thinks like that?

    A very large portion of the general population are functionally innumerate. They can be made to think like that.


  18. - Demoralized - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 1:44 pm:

    @sue:

    Look forward to your list of cuts that would need to happen if the tax increase expired. The revenue didn’t go to a bunch of new spending. It went to basically maintain and hopefully help keep the ship from completely sinking. Discretionary spending has been cut and cut and cut. They’ve passed legislation to deal with the pension (whether it’s constitutional or not is another question), which is a huge cost driver. I’d be interested to see what additional brilliant ideas you would have to make up for the shortfall if the tax is allowed to expire.


  19. - DuPage - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 1:45 pm:

    If it saves so little then it won’t be missed when the ILSC throws it out!


  20. - jerry 101 - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 1:56 pm:

    Holy stinkbombs Batman! I’m paying a 67% income tax rate in Illinois?!?! Dad gum it!!

    Bruce Rauner. Businessman. Bad at math.


  21. - wordslinger - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 2:19 pm:

    –Bruce Rauner. Businessman. Bad at math–

    Give him a break. He’s just conflicted.

    “…and, frankly, sometimes I disagree with myself.”

    Best. Quote. Ever.

    http://chicago.cbslocal.com/2014/03/21/rauner-enlists-bipartisan-support-in-seeking-new-solutions-for-illinois/


  22. - Driveby - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 3:39 pm:

    I always though that the unfunded liability was the thing to look at. I’ll have to read here more often for a more enlightened viewpoint like this.


  23. - Donkey Dem - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 3:54 pm:

    Cut the Nursing Home’s Mental Health, and the Poor. That’s the why to balance the budget. And Oh, give the unions whatever they want.


  24. - RNUG - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 6:27 pm:

    - wordslinger - Thursday, Mar 27, 14 @ 2:19 pm:

    I pointed that quote out to my wife when I read it in the paper the other day. Probably the most honest thing the man has said …


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* GOP leaders respond to special election push
* This just in... Special session called for January 8
* *** UPDATED x1 - GOMB disputes numbers *** Today's number: 3,000
* Shake this up, please
* On "war zones" and "foreign invasion"
* Topinka memorial roundup
* Question of the day - Golden Horseshoe Awards
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
* Yesterday's blog posts

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............

...............

...............


Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

          
        * Send last-minute holiday photo cards right from your iPhone or iPad
        * Apple's 10 biggest hits, misses, and head-scratchers of 2014
        * Lumia 930 Captures the Icy Underworld
        * Hyundai hands car dash to Android, Apple for device-based interface
        * Chef Vikas Khanna and his Lumia love
        * Android 5.1 dates, Galaxy S6 Edge, Apple Touch ID Changes & more – Pocketnow Daily
        * Gameloft outs Brothers in Arms 3, now with more actions and bigger weapons

        * iGO Electric FatBike Launches On Kickstarter (video)
        * Steve Jobs Deposition Video Will Not Be Released
        * LG G3 Gets Android 5.0 Lollipop in India
        * Comedy as activism: Why laughing together beats mourning alone
        * Giada F110D Bay Trail Powered Fanless Mini PC
        * Android TV Launcher Gets Bug Fix Update
        * SolarHug Bracelet Solar Powered External Backup Battery (video)

        * White Sox sign George Kottaras to a minor league deal
        * Kottaras to join White Sox with Minor League deal
        * Loss of Draft picks viewed as good trade for White Sox
        * Windy City revival: Cubs, White Sox revamped for '15
        * ZiPS projections underscore White Sox's riskiest bets
        * AL Central looking like one powerhouse division
        * Samardzija, Lester are right fits in Windy City

        ...............


        Main Menu
        Home
        Illinois
        YouTube
        Pundit rankings
        Obama
        Subscriber Content
        Durbin
        Burris
        Blagojevich Trial
        Advertising
        Updated Posts
        Polls

        Archives
        December 2014
        November 2014
        October 2014
        September 2014
        August 2014
        July 2014
        June 2014
        May 2014
        April 2014
        March 2014
        February 2014
        January 2014
        December 2013
        November 2013
        October 2013
        September 2013
        August 2013
        July 2013
        June 2013
        May 2013
        April 2013
        March 2013
        February 2013
        January 2013
        December 2012
        November 2012
        October 2012
        September 2012
        August 2012
        July 2012
        June 2012
        May 2012
        April 2012
        March 2012
        February 2012
        January 2012
        December 2011
        November 2011
        October 2011
        September 2011
        August 2011
        July 2011
        June 2011
        May 2011
        April 2011
        March 2011
        February 2011
        January 2011
        December 2010
        November 2010
        October 2010
        September 2010
        August 2010
        July 2010
        June 2010
        May 2010
        April 2010
        March 2010
        February 2010
        January 2010
        December 2009
        November 2009
        October 2009
        September 2009
        August 2009
        July 2009
        June 2009
        May 2009
        April 2009
        March 2009
        February 2009
        January 2009
        December 2008
        November 2008
        October 2008
        September 2008
        August 2008
        July 2008
        June 2008
        May 2008
        April 2008
        March 2008
        February 2008
        January 2008
        December 2007
        November 2007
        October 2007
        September 2007
        August 2007
        July 2007
        June 2007
        May 2007
        April 2007
        March 2007
        February 2007
        January 2007
        December 2006
        November 2006
        October 2006
        September 2006
        August 2006
        July 2006
        June 2006
        May 2006
        April 2006
        March 2006
        February 2006
        January 2006
        December 2005
        April 2005
        March 2005
        February 2005
        January 2005
        December 2004
        November 2004
        October 2004

        Blog*Spot Archives
        November 2005
        October 2005
        September 2005
        August 2005
        July 2005
        June 2005
        May 2005

        Syndication

        RSS Feed 2.0
        Comments RSS 2.0
        WordPress

        Loading


        * Quinn To Call Special Session..
        * Quinn Wants Special Election To Replace Topinka..
        * Quinn Sets Special Session..


        * China pledges to speed entry of US pharmaceuticals
        * Report: Illinois fails to monitor runaway kids
        * Gov. Quinn calls session for comptroller election
        * Chickenpox forces southern Illinois prison lockdown
        * Instructor at Illinois school for visually impaired arrested
        * Chicago announces plans to build 88-story skyscraper
        * GOP says Rauner should appoint next comptroller
        * Quincy mother gets 2 years for unlawful restraint
        * Contract to bring 75 jobs to Scott Air Force Base
        * Illinois jobless rate falls to 6.4 percent

        * Quinn calls legislature back to Springfield to approve special election to replace Topinka
        * Audit: DCFS loses track of runaways
        * Audit: Illinois fails to monitor runaway kids
        * Chicago couple convicted of stealing state grants
        * Topinka remembered as tough, honest leader at memorial service
        * Illinois employers reminded of income-tax rollback
        * Memorial service for Topinka begins in suburban Chicago
        * Police use vacant Jacksonville site to train for worst-case scenarios
        * State-grant fraud case in hands of federal jury
        * Gov.-elect Rauner says some agency directors may stay

        * Great moments in Chicago architecture 2014
        * Restaurant menus shed some weight
        * McDonald's to sponsor 2015 SXSW festival
        * Chicago tourism arm opens fourth bureau in China
        * Dow soars more than 400 points


        * A whole lot of nothing from the City Council
        * Dozens gather at Logan Square eatery for ‘Serial’ podcast finale
        * Sony’s choice on ‘The Interview’ is one lost battle in a long war
        * Playing for dollars, smiles at O’Hare
        * Rewriting the Sony cyberattack script
        * Sony’s choice on ‘The Interview’ is one lost battle in a long war
        * Emanuel denies Willie Wilson petition challenge is racist ploy
        * Ex-FBI agent’s book tells mob tales in ‘A Gun in My Gucci'
        * Off Message: The Year in Review
        * Dem Rep. Bill Foster talking to big donors about U.S. Senate race


        * Metra train fatally hits pedestrian in Oak Forest
        * Chicago man shot to death in Montgomery
        * 3 people injured in separate shootings
        * Santa helps Catholic school complete fundraising mission
        * Rahm Emanuel defends record on ethics in first term
        * Restaurants that repeatedly failed health inspections in 2014: analysis
        * Second bottlenose dolphin born at Brookfield Zoo
        * 2 found dead in South Side home died in murder-suicide
        * Wisconsin girls in Slenderman case ruled competent to stand trial
        * North Chicago 21-year-old dies after hit and run in Waukegan


        * Parties' Power Grabs In Battle For Comptroller; Quinn Calls Legislators Into Special Session
        * Let's Talk Kids - "Your Phone-a-Friend List"
        * Vatican signals new tone on US nuns
        * StoryCorps: Bilingual pre-school teacher describes the state of education in Chicago
        * Chicago mayor's commission unveils plan for a safer Chicago
        * US announces protections for transgender workers
        * Cook County to join cameras-in-court program
        * IIAA Teaches Life Skills Through Sports
        * Illinois Republican: Cuba Agreement "Good First Step"
        * Unions sue to stop Chicago pension overhaul


        * E.J. Dionne: Chuck Schumer: Take two
        * Esther Cepeda: The rainbow that isn’t
        * Raoul, Righter, Nekritz, Sandack: Clarifying privacy, eavesdropping bill
        * Quote of the day: Friday, Dec. 19, 2014
        * Quinn calls legislature back to Springfield to approve special election to replace Topinka
        * Audit: DCFS loses track of runaways
        * Audit: Illinois fails to monitor runaway kids
        * Bernard Schoenburg: Schmidt considers challenging Sgro for park board president
        * Brian Sauder: Faithful decisions for the holidays
        * Eugene Robinson: The price of being hacked


        * Next steps on Cuba: Normalizing could take awhile
        * Clouds will be regular guest in Q-C through the weekend
        * Clouds will be regular guest in Q-C at least through the weekend
        * Upcoming Services (Dec. 19)
        * Man feels shortchanged over postal regs
        * Police Beat
        * Clinton pastor happy for new approach to Cuba
        * ‘Todos somos Americanos’
        * ISVI instructor facing sex abuse charge
        * Cuba relations seen as opening doors


        * Key Profumo scandal figure Mandy Rice-Davies dies
        * Italy's anti-corruption czar to join Rome bid team
        * Funeral service set for former Decatur mayor
        * American Hockey League
        * Jags' Marks caps 21-13 win over Titans with sack

        * Controversy and change mark 2014 in Highla...
        * Bost Readies to Join Congress
        * Republican David Brat Wins Virginia’s 7th ...
        * Rep. Bob Dold
        * Illinois District 10 Race
        * 8 things new members of Congress definitel...
        * Bost to resign early from state house, hea...
        * Mike Bloomberg takes his money local
        * Illinois Rep. Mike Bost flips his lid over...
        * Midterm elections see Big Red wins in Ill....

        * Durbin on Cuba Relations...

        * GOP senator wants 'The Interview' shown at......

        * City Clerk Debuts Online Residential Permit Parking Map
        * Expert Writing Service for Students’ Deductive Writing
        * Will Jan. 8 mean anything?
        * Remember "Night After Night"
        * Santa's Taking The L Through Uptown
        * Party With The Pups At Driftwood
        * Santa's Taking The L Through Uptown (Updated)
        * Kinzinger bullish on America and Illinois
        * Illinois U.S. Sen. Mark Kirk Promises to Screen 'The Interview' at Fundraisers
        * Quinn calls for special session to push special 2016 comptroller election


        * Governor Quinn Calls Legislative Special Session - Governor Urges Legislature to Set Up 2016 Special Election for Comptroller
        * Governor Quinn Announces Illinois’ Unemployment Rate Hits New Low - Illinois’ Economic Comeback Continues; Unemployment Rate Falls to Lowest Level in More than Six Years
        * Illinois Ranks #1 in Volunteer Rate Among the Country’s 8 Largest States - 2.57 Million Illinoisans Give $7.2 Billion in Service
        * Law Enforcement, IDOT Make Final Push to Save Lives in 2014, Roadside Safety Checks Planned Over Holidays - New Episode of “The Driving Dead” Premieres Friday as Holiday Travelers are Reminded to Drive Sober and Buckle Up
        * Department of Insurance Announces Two Convictions Resulting from its Workers’ Compensation Fraud Investigations - Former Crystal Lake Police Officer and Former Business Owner Convicted




            Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller