Wonkish - Countdown to May 31: Tax plans emerge
Monday, Apr 20, 2009 - Posted by Wonkish.com POSTED BY WONKISH.COM For a month, legislative leaders have allowed Governor Pat Quinn’s income tax plan to languish in full public view, stirring up public discord for being both too big (see: politicians), and not quite big enough (see: interest groups). Now, some competing proposals are beginning to emerge, claiming to deliver a softer blow, and/or offered in exchange for tax relief in other areas. 1) Senate President John Cullerton mused: “We could accomplish the same amount of money the governor acquires with his income tax increase by making it a one percent increase instead of a one-and-a-half percent increase, but without having an increase in the personal exemption.” 2) Cook County Assessor James Houlihan offered his own tinkering, that would accompany some other changes in the sales tax and Property Tax Credit. The income tax plan stands alone, however: “Illinois’ tax structure must be made more progressive. To that end, relief should be targeted to those most in need. By enlarging the Earned Income Credit to 30 percent of the federal credit, raising the personal exemption to $4,000, and increasing the income tax rate to 4.25 percent, tax relief would be targeted to lower-income families. The changes would bring an additional $2.73 billion to state coffers, even with municipalities getting their 10 percent.” Roughly, all three of these income tax plans claim to generate the same amount of revenue ($2.7 - $2.8 billion). Senator Cullerton is looking for the simpler route - one point and be done with it. Assessor Houlihan is aiming for the same end as Governor Quinn - if you have to raise taxes, make the tax code more progressive while you do it. But which one really would be an easier sell? Which plan would be more progressive? Take a look at the chart below that shows the tax cut or tax increase by income for a family of 4 for each of the plans. Click the pic for a much larger image… Which plan would work better for you? If the State needs to raise $2.7-$2.8 billion in new revenue, what plan do you think would be the best? (For those of you who can’t play hypotheticals and object to the assumption that more revenue is needed, please make sure to visit the Wonkish.com Budget Tool and share your link here which shows all your cuts).
|
Protected: SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - EJackson; Biss; SEIU; Bradley; Syverson (Use all caps in password)
Monday, Apr 20, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller
Enter your password to view comments |
Don’t let them cut to the bone
Monday, Apr 20, 2009 - Posted by Capitol Fax Blog Advertising Department [The following is a paid advertisement] In Springfield, they’ve had the same answer to budget deficits year after year: cut the fat. But today Illinois faces its biggest budget crisis ever. And the fat? It’s all but gone. Without new revenue, there’s only one option left: deep, devastating cuts to the kind of vital services we all depend on—like home care for seniors and child care for our kids. Drastic cuts that will hurt Illinois families and make a bad economy worse. In tough times, the right answer isn’t slashing home care and leaving vulnerable seniors on their own. Or taking child care away from working parents who’re struggling just to get by. Tell Springfield the right answer is a plan for new revenue—a real plan that’s fair to all of us and that puts Illinois on solid fiscal footing for the years ahead. Join the fight. Go to illinoisfuture.org. Tell Springfield we need a fair plan for new revenue now. TELL SPRINGFIELD: DON’T CUT HOME CARE and CHILD CARE!
|
Question of the day
Monday, Apr 20, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller * The setup comes from Massachusetts…
* The Question: Should Internet sales be taxed? Explain. I think we’ve done this one before, but with the budget and economic situation the way it is, I figured it was worth another debate.
|
Bean counters
Monday, Apr 20, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller * This is the sort of thing that happens when you let the Blagojevich bean counters - who never really appreciated the actual impact of their cuts - continue to run the show….
Great. Anything else going out in the agencies that we should know about? Please, try to keep personalities out of this. I’m interested in the proposed budget or current budget cuts, not your boss. * Related…
|
Burris in a bubble and Cobb spins out
Monday, Apr 20, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller * US Sen. Roland Burris apparently resides in a bubble…
What’s next? Will he follow every political loser in the last 60 years and invoke Harry Truman’s grand comeback? With less than ten months before the primary, a mere four months before petitions hit the streets, $850 in the bank and only 50 people showing up for his first major fundraiser, Burris’ media adviser thinks she still has enough time to rehabilitate his image? Please…
She’s “comfortable” with where Burris is now? Let’s jog her memory…
* And this is a super-brilliant strategy in Obama’s home state…
Yeah. OK. Obama had a 67 percent job approval rating in that Rasmussen poll of likely Illinois voters. 90 percent of Illinois African-Americans “strongly approved” of Obama’s job performance. Democrats gave him an overall 89 percent approval rating. Keep taking swings at Obama in Illinois. I’m so sure that’ll work for a Democrat. * We’ll close with this…
Except, in his case, he should run “from,” not “for.” [*The Rasmussen poll tested Burris’ favorable rating, not his job approval rating.] * Related…
|
Stopping a criminal
Monday, Apr 20, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller * As usual, Kurt Erickson gets it…
Should some laws be changed? Yes, of course. But, the only way to stop a real criminal is by arresting or indicting him/her. Passing new laws just means more charges can be filed, which is helpful in its own right, to be sure. But new laws wouldn’t have stopped Rod Blagojevich. What we may need is more prosecutors. * And speaking of not preventing anybody from behaving a certain way, this is from the governor’s Illinois Reform Commission Terms of Use page…
That language seems to be boilerplate crud used by people who have no concept of how the Intertubes work. Is that derogatory enough to make the commission stop me from linking to them? * And speaking of criminals, Gary Goehl, who once worked for Cook County Treasurer Ed Rosewell, did 18 months in federal prison and was, according to some, ” the recipient of more illegal loans than any civic official in Chicago history,” has an op-ed in the New York Times…
* Anyway, there was, apparently, one upside to Rod Blagojevich’s total ineptness as a leader…
So far, more federal transportation stimulus money has been approved for Illinois than for any other state, and we have Rod Blagojevich to “thank.” * But there were many downsides, including the deteriorated mass transit system…
* Related…
|
Suffredin to Stroger: Resign
Monday, Apr 20, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller [Bumped up from Saturday for visibility and commenting purposes.] * And so it begins. From a press release…
The Chicago Defender has some background on the controversy…
More at the Tribune. Stroger has said he is running for reelection but CBS2 reports…
* Related…
|
Morning Shorts
Monday, Apr 20, 2009 - Posted by Mike Murray Quinn * New leadership for a board with history of corruption
* ‘An Opportunity for Total Corruption’
* SJ-R Opinion: Reopening a welcome sign of change
* Gov. Quinn’s pick to head Illinois DNR had early start on love of outdoors * Get specific at energy summit
IL Budget & Taxes * Tribune Editorial: It’s the jobs
* Groups Want More Money State Money For Tax Relief
* Supervised visitation centers: A safe haven for children and mothers amid threats of violence
* Early Childhood Advocacy Day
* This is the worst time to cut services * More taxes would be optional under bill
* Illinois allows counties to use property tax caps to slow the rate of growth * Up in smoke?
* Illinois Protests Taxes Statewide * SJ-R Opinion: Protest … but don’t ignore facts GA and Ethics Reform * More taxes would be optional under bill * Police crosswalk stings will target drivers who don’t yield to pedestrians * Transit agencies push for capital bucks
* It’s time the Legislature allows civil unions * Legislators’ tuition waivers costly to other students
* Pantagraph Op-ED: Approve bill to reform ‘member initiative’ rules
* Rank projects before spending our tax money
* Tribune Editorial: If not for those wiretaps …
* Let’s make Alabama as ethical as Illinois * Bowden is one public servant doing it right
IL Congressional Delegation * Once high-flying Triple J is losing altitude
* Quigley Prepares for Congress
* Son of Hastert exploring run in 14th District
* Is Hastert’s son eyeing dad’s old seat? * Manzullo voices displeasure with big government
* An Illinois Congressman Says Economy Not Improving
* Bernard Schoenburg: Colbert puts Schock on the spot * Rep. Gutierrez visits Salinas
* Labor agreement could backfire on immigration reform
* Brown becoming the new green at local UPS
Economic Stories * Exxon Mobil overtakes Wal-Mart to top Fortune 500
* Bank of America posts 1Q profit, surpasses view * GM exec says 1,600 will lose jobs in next few days * State takes conservation police applications * Hobby Lobby increases pay
* Havana plant takes aim at carp * Illinois’ struggles: Economic woes take their toll across the state
* Krug: Debts and debtors, take heed
* Woman tries to build a future in tough times
* Jobless resume seekers take emotional toll on printer
* Making a little go a long way
* How skinny people could save the world
* Global Economic Leaders Gather in Chicago to Advance Financial Literacy Chicago City Hall * Durbin, Daley to announce economic stimulus money for Chicago’s Blue Line
* City, unions seek to avoid layoffs: Daley
* Mayor Richard Daley set to announce “Talk Like Shakespeare Day”
* Da Bard: ‘Talk Like Shakespeare Day’ coming to Chicago * No conflict, John Daley says
* Committee helping pick CSU president resigns
* City’s plan to swing wrecking ball at Reese Hospital for 2016 Olympics under national spotlight Other Interesting and News Worthy Items * Area’s only black-owned radio station celebrates 2 decades
* Chicagoans help StreetWise keep doing what it’s doing
* Newspapers try to maintain civil, intelligent conversations with readers * Chicago-area Holocaust museum opens * Illinois Holocaust Museum: Bill Clinton featured at opening event
* Photo gallery: Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center opens * Holocaust teaches lessons for today * Museum brings some Hogwarts to Hyde Park
* Message from pulpits: Stop sexual violence
* Police crosswalk stings will target drivers who don’t yield to pedestrians
* Police crosswalk stings will target drivers who don’t yield to pedestrians * Chicago Police Go Undercover as Pedestrians
* Pothole breeding ground
* Ill. fire department uses oxygen masks for pets
* Patrick Fitzgerald to Take the Witness Stand
* Ambrose trial brings secret fed witness program into spotlight * Illinois meth arrests decline
* 271 million pounds of drugs taint U.S. water
* Report: Chicago suburb supplied contaminated water
* Poison in the well
* Lincoln stamps collection sold for nearly $2 mil * White Sox to visit White House * Sox getting White House tour * Blackhawks Win Game 2 * The Hawks’ playoff payoff
* Derrick Rose Dazzles in Playoff Debut
|
Protected: SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today’s edition of Capitol Fax
Monday, Apr 20, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller
|
Reader comments closed for the weekend
Friday, Apr 17, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller * I’m actually glad to get back to session next week. A little action is what I need right now. * Speaking of action, what better way to end a week than with the Bottle Rockets, featuring Springfield’s very own Keith Voegele on bass… With a fuel pump that’s deceased
|
Another son rising?
Friday, Apr 17, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller * John Laesch blogs about someone who was recently polled in Democratic Congressman Bill Foster’s district…
Ethan Hastert is Denny’s son. A GOP friend tells me that Ethan is calling around to the district’s county chairmen. The younger Hastert is a onetime aide to former VP Dick Cheney. He also had one bit of trouble in his past, but that was quite a while ago. Anyway, this looks like a possibility. [H/T: Progress Illinois]
|
Afternoon stuff
Friday, Apr 17, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller * Some were wondering why Jimmy Breslin showed up at Rod Blagojevich’s arraignment this week. Now we know. From a press release…
* I have no idea who these people are, but they’ll be with Rod Blagojevich in the jungle on some goofy reality TV show if his judge is silly enough to give him back his passport and allow him to travel. More likely, the Blagojevich invite is just a clever PR ploy by NBC to keep this show in the headlines. It’s certainly working…
* Possible shenanigans in Lyons?
* Smoking ban blamed again for falling casino attendance…
* New York’s Lincoln Memorial. * A follow-up from earlier this week. The Obamalac is now “just” a Cadillac… You can click on the pic for a larger image.
|
Protected: SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Urban League; Pals; Birkett; Health insurance; Burns; Hendon; Brady; Ameren; Schmitz; Sandoval/Hamos; Taxes; Garrett; Froehlich; Roundup (use all caps in password)
Friday, Apr 17, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller
Enter your password to view comments |
Question of the day
Friday, Apr 17, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller * As I’ve already told you, Rasmussen Reports has this new poll result…
* The Question: How would you rate the job Pat Quinn has been doing as Governor… do you strongly approve, somewhat approve, somewhat disapprove, or strongly disapprove of the job he’s been doing? Please, explain your answer as fully as possible. Thanks.
|
The white hats and the black hats?
Friday, Apr 17, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller * This white hat/black hat stuff might sound good to lapdog editorial boards, but it’s dangerous and oft abused rhetoric in politics…
Actually, the real bad guys probably figure they’ll just get around whatever reforms are passed. Check out the post immediately below about how Bill Cellini withdrew his lobbyist registration so his wife could stay on as chair of the Illinois Historic Preservation Agency board of trustees. Coincidentally, one of the reform commission’s proposals is to bar registered lobbyists from contributing to campaigns. * Speaking of editorial boards, I’m wondering whether the economic downturn and resulting newspaper budget cuts have left the boards without much talent. The other day, the Bloomington Pantagraph made this claim…
I’ll say it again: No challenger has won in decades against a sitting congresscritter unless said critter has been involved in a big scandal. Caps haven’t helped challengers here. And today, the Daily Herald makes this crazy claim…
Let’s see, Alexi Giannoulias just finished raising over a million dollars in a month in capped federal contributions, and didn’t even take money from lobbyists or PACs. Congressman Mark Kirk raised almost $700K in a quarter. Here’s more…
It’s so because they say it’s so, and nothing more. And, just to be clear, I’ve agreed with the Tribune on more than one occasion here and elsewhere that a higher individual cap would be acceptable. My reasoning is based on helping challengers who don’t often have the same extensive financial networks as incumbents and my desire to keep those fishy big contributions out of the process. Then again, those big contributors could still do uncapped independent expenditures. * Reform and congressional roundup…
|
Harris to testify against Blagojevich as Cellini stays in the game
Friday, Apr 17, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller * More trouble for Blagojevich…
Harris was only charged with one count of wire fraud, so the feds haven’t dropped anything - although some details might possibly have been handled before the indictment. The wire fraud count carries a prison sentence of up to 20 years , so he could still be looking at some time. Here’s the count…
* As you already know, Bill Cellini is trying hard to separate himself from the Blagojevich trial…
But CBS2 reported yesterday that the trial would, indeed last six months. Not sure if that’s a mistake or what. * The SJ-R reports that Cellini is still active…
The story also detailed Cellini’s former lobbying client list, which included Chicago HMO - Stu Levine’s outfit. Cellini withdrew his name from the lobbyist list in late 2003…
But was he still lobbying?
Cellini wasn’t the only one who decided to simply stop being a “registered” lobbyist after that “reform” law passed. There should’ve been an investigation of this mass exodus, but nobody ever did it. Paging Attorney General Lisa Madigan: Where were you on this? * Related…
|
Stroger fires cousin ahead of “media circus”
Friday, Apr 17, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller * So, what was this about?
* Stronger kinda sorta answered the question this morning…
More…
* Related…
|
Morning Shorts
Friday, Apr 17, 2009 - Posted by Mike Murray * Peoria gays react to unwelcome sign
* Illinois Ranks 5th in Foreclosure Filings * Kane, Kendall foreclosures up from 2008 * Extra Unemployment Benefits Begin in Illinois
* 1 in 11 Illinoisans are jobless * State unemployment hits 9.1% * Quinn appoints Young to health planning board * Quinn appoints friend to head health board * Autism now insured, but parents say loopholes still exist
* Madigan lawsuits target Frankfort, New Lenox contractors
* Plan would dramatically shorten trips from Chicago to other Midwest cities
* Envisioning the future: Rapid bus shoulders RTA goals * Pace buses to use shoulder of I-55 * Airport Project in Peoria to Create Jobs * U.S. Olympic Committe head admits IOC team grilled organizers about funding * Arrests could generate big bucks for Peoria
* Holy Cow! Cheap beef costs more than the good stuff
* Chicago crime: City panel renews push to realign police districts * Southeast Side wards need more police, aldermen say * Prostitution: Cook County sheriff’s office lends hand to women to stop prostitution
|
Protected: SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today’s edition of Capitol Fax
Friday, Apr 17, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller
|
Burris raises $845; 62 percent want him to resign
Friday, Apr 17, 2009 - Posted by Rich Miller [Bumped up for visibility.] * Yeah, you read that headline right…
And check this out…
Burris has been saying he had $400,000 or $500,000 in legal bills, depending on whom he talked to. So what’s up with that? * Meanwhile, Rasmussen has a new poll…
And…
That approval rating is five points higher than Dick Durbin and six points lower than Barack Obama.
And…
And…
Interesting. One more…
|
« NEWER POSTS | PREVIOUS POSTS » |