Capitol Fax.com - Your Illinois News Radar » “Anti-consumer, but pro-politician”
SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
“Anti-consumer, but pro-politician”

Monday, Apr 25, 2016

* From a reader…

Rich,

Thought you might be interested in this opinion from the Third District Appellate Court, Mercy Crystal Lake Hospital and Medical Center v. Illinois Health Facilities and Service Review Board, 2016 IL App (3d) 130847. http://www.illinoiscourts.gov/Opinions/AppellateCourt/2016/3rdDistrict/3130947.pdf

I have no involvement in the case, but found it interesting while reviewing cases because two of the justices, Holdridge and Schmidt, offer insight into what Holdridge calls the “sausage factory in Springfield.” (see paragraph 34.) Schmidt’s special concurrence gives some historical context behind the Certificate of Need for hospitals and basically rips the whole process. Schmidt says, “This legislation assures that money keeps pouring in to Illinois politicians not only from those wishing to build new hospitals, but also from incumbent hospitals wishing to avoid any competition. Each side wants their friends on the Board. This, of course, leads each side to “donate” to Illinois governors and senators. This in addition to the history of bribes to Board members.” (see paragraph 48)

I realize it pales in comparison to other things going on in Springfield (not the least being the lack of budget), but thought you might be interested.

Thanks for doing such an amazing job with the blog. It is must-read for anyone who cares about Illinois.

Regards,

[Redacted]

* The opinion’s setup

In closing, we offer a few words on the special concurrence. Justice Schmidt’s offering brings to mind a timeless observation made in 1869 by American lawyer and poet John Godfrey Sax, to wit: “Laws, like sausages, cease to inspire respect in proportion as we know how they are made.” (Internal quotation marks omitted.) An Impeachment Trial, The Chronicle, Mar. 27, 1869, at 4. By taking the public on a tour of the sausage factory in Springfield, Justice Schmidt risks triggering a collective case of indigestion. On the other hand, Justice Schmidt may be this generation’s Upton Sinclair. A little dyspepsia might be a small price to pay for some much needed (and long overdue) transparancy. After all, as Justice Brandeis so aptly put it, “[p]ublicity is justly commended as a remedy for social and industrial diseases. Sunlight is said to be the best of disinfectants; electric light the most efficient policeman.” Louis D. Brandeis, Other People’s Money and How the Bankers Use It (1914). We can only hope that the light that Justice Schmidt shines on the factory floor in Springfield leads to the production of more sanitary and wholesome sausages in the future. For now, to paraphrase Captain Renault from Casablanca, we will merely note that we are shocked, shocked to find that political considerations are influencing the legislative process in Illinois.

Heh.

* The hardball concurrence

In essence and in fact, this legislation is nothing more than an additional corruption tax added to the cost of healthcare in Illinois. This legislation is clearly anticonsumer, but propolitician. Ironically, eradicating the Planning Act would fulfill the stated goal of the Planning Act. Yet, as the cost of healthcare continues to rise and Illinois remains the poster-child for political corruption, the General Assembly repeatedly refuses to do so. This legislation assures that money keeps pouring in to Illinois politicians not only from those wishing to build new hospitals, but also from incumbent hospitals wishing to avoid any competition. Each side wants their friends on the Board. This, of course, leads each side to “donate” to Illinois governors and senators. This is in addition to the history of bribes to Board members.

By restricting the output of healthcare services and diminishing incentives to pursue innovation, the Planning Act imposes significant and unnecessary costs on healthcare consumers, i.e., the people of Illinois. As a result of this legislation, Centegra has been forced to jump through years of pointless hoops and incur untold unnecessary costs in order to build its hospital. Guess who ultimately incurs those costs. This is unacceptable. For these reasons, I specially concur in the judgment.

- Posted by Rich Miller        

20 Comments
  1. - Clem - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 11:29 am:

    I don’t disagree with anything the justices wrote about the sausage making, and I don’t pretend to know much about the delivery of health care. But it seems something like the health facilities board needs to be in place or no hospitals will remain in poor urban and downstate communities.


  2. - Concerned - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 11:32 am:

    Justice Schmidt drops mic, walks off-stage.


  3. - Qui Tam - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 11:45 am:

    ==eradicating the Planning Act would fulfill the stated goal of the Planning Act. ==

    Awesome!

    What a difference a district makes. If it were the along to get along 4th District, they’d heaping praise on their political patrons instead of bashing.


  4. - Freezeup - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 11:53 am:

    I read many opinions out of the 3d

    When it comes to search and seizure cases, Schmidt is a rockstar.

    He is a bright spot in an oft reversed appellate court district.


  5. - Norseman - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 12:01 pm:

    === But it seems something like the health facilities board needs to be in place or no hospitals will remain in poor urban and downstate communities. ===

    The purpose of CON is to prevent duplication of services, not assurance of services.

    CON is one of the many continuing attempts to curtail the rising cost of healthcare. I understand the theory behind CON, the problem with the theory is that it runs up against the problem of implementation by humans intent on usurping the process for personal or political gains.


  6. - Keyser Soze - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 12:04 pm:

    Adding to the souffle, consider:

    “…For undemocratic reasons and for motives not of State,

    they arrive at their conclusions - largely
    inarticulate.

    Being void of self-expression they confide their
    views to none,

    but sometimes in a smoking room, one learns
    why things were done….”

    - Rudyard Kipling


  7. - Micki - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 12:11 pm:

    Clem - The legislature voted last year to take away the authority for the Board to prevent closures so, there is nothing that they do that would keep hospitals in poor areas.


  8. - walker - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 12:34 pm:

    Standard practice for industry lobbyists to encourage legislators to vote for unfair advantages for the biggest players in a marketplace — while all the time spouting “conservative” free-market lingo.


  9. - Anonymous - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 12:35 pm:

    The Health Facilities Board is a joke. They voted to keep Murray Center and JAcksonville Center open and of course Quinn still said he was closing them……it is a waste of tax dollars.


  10. - Clem - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 12:42 pm:

    @Micki

    Yes, there is nothing to stop them from closing facilities in poor areas, but they do need approval to open new facilities in affluent areas. This has the effect (or at least it should — it’s too early to tell,) of keeping hospitals in underserved locations. You can’t close shop on the South Side and move operations to Orland Park without the Facilities Board giving the okay.

    I think Norseman is correct about how politics perverts the intent of the policy.


  11. - steve schnorf - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 12:43 pm:

    sure, the unfettered marketplace will take care of any problem /snark


  12. - Any Mouse - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 12:45 pm:

    Clem- note that the board is being used to reduce the supply of hospitals.

    This is a great example of why we have the worlds highest costs for healthcare.

    See also restrictions on opening a new medical school or using Nurse Practitioners and other mid-level practitioners.


  13. - wordslinger - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 1:03 pm:

    Somebody’s going to get dyspepsia from swallowing their Bartlett’s Familiar Quotations.

    Seriously, Sax, Brandeis and Capt. Renault, all in the same paragraph?

    It appears the judges were looking for a reason to tee off on the law, bringing it all back to Levine and Rezko.

    The actual allegations of “corruption tax” and “anticonsumer, propolitician” (try hyphens; those aren’t words) aren’t supported by any facts referenced in regards to this specific case.


  14. - Cheswick - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 1:14 pm:

    - Keyser Soze - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 12:04 pm:

    == Adding to the souffle, consider:

    - Rudyard Kipling ==

    So, they let Rod have a computer in prison, now?


  15. - jim - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 3:17 pm:

    judging from these comments, it seems people have a hard time accepting the obvious.


  16. - Steve - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 3:46 pm:

    Should we have an Illinois board to determine how many coffee houses should exist or should we let consumers decide?


  17. - Arthur Andersen - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 4:25 pm:

    word +1

    Another great post-Blago “reform” law that didn’t work.


  18. - MyTwoCents - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 5:40 pm:

    Merits of debating the law aside I fail to see what that part of the opinion has to do with the case that was before them. Maybe they should stick with the legal matters at issue and let the General Assembly debate policy.


  19. - Anonymous - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 6:24 pm:

    Schmidt should be good on the search and seizure cases - he was a police officer after all. Holdridge is the real scholar in the third.


  20. - Rasselas - Monday, Apr 25, 16 @ 7:36 pm:

    Steve, people (most people) don’t die when they don’t have access to coffee houses. Hospitals are in a different category.


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* Reader comments closed for the weekend
* Illinois rated second most likely governor's office to flip parties
* It's just a bill
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - A couple of new mailers and a fundraising list
* Question of the day
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - ICPR responds again
* Rauner says "left-leaning" Chicago press is "plenty biased"
* Keep your trackers out of taverns
* "If any region should feel alienated from state government, it's the suburbanites"
* Democratic legislator files resolution condemning "scofflaw counties"
* Rauner ad gets it wrong, but Pritzker needs to end his silence
* Just a small critique
* Are the Democrats unified?
* Buttigieg delivered the best zinger of the day
* White vows to finish out sixth term
* Rauner to return to Quincy Veterans Home this weekend
* *** LIVE COVERAGE ***
* Yesterday's stories

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............

...............
<


Loading


* Democrat JB Pritzker adds $20M more to his camp.....
* HS FOOTBALL: North Schuylkill brings size, new .....
* History close to home..
* Helene Miller Walsh, wife of former US Rep. Joe.....
* Thumbs Up: To remembering the past, even the pa.....
* Politics, American Style: Big GOP Donor Loses, .....
* Penalty for first-time distracted-driving ticke.....
* Current mess started long before Rauner..
* With 80 days until the election, Davis and Lond.....
* Angie Muhs: SJ-R to host candidate debates in c.....


* 2 Chicago boys die after being pulled from Lake Michigan
* Senate intern shot after returning home from Washington DC
* Festivals, parades to mark Illinois’ 200th Constitution Day
* River advocates: Canoeing, kayaking encourage stewardship
* EXCHANGE: Peoria police officer hands out stuffed animals
* EXCHANGE: Valmeyer rises from the depths years after flood
* NFL Hall of Famer Brian Urlacher to speak at Carlsbad summit
* Rediscovered bulldog mascot gets artist-custodian’s touch
* NW Indiana boy, 8, saves his brother, 2, from dog attack
* Carbondale considers biodegradable ‘natural’ burials

* Penalty for first-time distracted-driving ticket to increase
* Judge in Aaron Schock case removed from all cases involving federal government
* Rauner signs bill to educate students about loans
* Doris Kearns Goodwin coming to Springfield for fundraiser
* Davis staffer arrested after altercation at Londrigan fundraiser
* Illinois Democrats say downstate counties can go their way
* Rauner appoints GOP official Shaw to retirement board
* Illinois Democrats talk of importance of fall elections
* AP fact check: No Pritzker plan to increase taxes 26 percent
* Rauner: 2018 election is 'one of most important' in Illinois history

* DuPage pushes fight for O'Hare western terminal
* United sheds punching-bag status with biggest U.S. airline rally
* Northern Trust looks to get into crypto custody
* Redbox gears up for its first major ad campaign
* Whither the Kraft Heinz ketchup packet?


* 2 hurt in fire at Cicero apartment complex
* WH lawyer McGahn not ‘a John Dean type ‘RAT,” Trump says
* Man shot in northwest Indiana
* Nun shows off skills, throws curveball for first pitch before White Sox-Royals
* In Aretha Franklin’s anthems, women heard an empowering message
* Fans injured in storm at Backstreet Boys Oklahoma concert
* Plenty of danger for Dems if they win House and impeach Trump
* Chopping down trees in Jackson Park shouldn’t be taken lightly
* Pearl Jam as eclectic as always in triumphant, emotional Wrigley Field return
* Boy dies after being pulled from Lake Michigan at Indiana Dunes


* Trump: White House lawyer McGahn isn't 'a John Dean type 'RAT"
* Toddler's family grows closer after his parents die in eerily similar rollover accidents 2 years apart
* Pearl Jam at Wrigley Field review: A rousing setlist full of classics, deep cuts
* Tommy La Stella leads off as Cubs try to win series vs. Pirates
* Georgia high school football team walks out of practice to protest rough conditions
* Pearl Jam performs at Wrigley Field
* Brad Biggs' 10 thoughts on the Bears' 24-23 win over the Broncos
* Democrat J.B. Pritzker adds $20M more to his campaign; now up to $126.5M total
* 23 people shot, 1 fatally: 'Welcome to Chicago, I guess'
* Cubs treading water despite offensive struggles: 'We've got to get it together'


» New Law To Address Police Officers' Mental Health
» Chicago Musicians Remember Queen Of Soul Aretha Franklin
» Deep Fried Politics
» State Week: Both Democrats and Republicans Assert Party Unity At State Fair
» Web Extra, The Week in Review: Editorial Boards Push Back
» The Week in Review: Campaign Season ‘Officially’ Kicks Off at State Fair
» #664 Remembering Aretha Franklin
» Dems Vow Down-Ballot Effort, Red-State Reach
» Aug. 16, 2018 - Full Show
» Live From The State Fair: Ag, Food, Entertainment, And President Lincoln


* Penalty for first-time distracted-driving ticket to increase
* Thumbs Up: To remembering the past, even the painful parts
* UIS Perspectives: A beautiful, functional and improving campus
* Statehouse Insider: It's time for the campaign season to begin. Again.
* Our View: Kindergarten study a good starting point
* BGA: How an ordinary homeowner forced reform upon an Illinois township government
* Angie Muhs: SJ-R to host candidate debates in congressional races
* Bernard Schoenburg: Ag policy forum featured only Republicans
* Judge in Aaron Schock case removed from all cases involving federal government
* Rauner signs bill to educate students about loans


* Female cheetahs detect suitable mates from males’ urine, study by SIU researcher shows
* Decatur mom organizes resource fair for special needs
* Scibird brothers early Bloomington photographers
* Where road projects are planned this week in the Decatur region
* $3.6 million later, Nelson Park sewer project set to finish this fall
* Column | Ladies in the Lede: IDNR program is a crash course in 'Becoming an Outdoors Woman'
* New set of works unveiled at Scovill Sculpture Park
* With 80 days until the election, Davis and Londrigan both confident in 13th District support
* 5 Questions with ... Melverta Wilkins, Caterpillar product change engineer and founder of Sista Girls and Friends
* Building opportunity: Leaders, youth meet to discuss local issues


* Kawasaki Frontale close gap to leaders Sanfrecce Hiroshima
* Over 2 million Muslims begin annual hajj pilgrimage
* South Elgin asking residents to speak up if they have complaints about MetroNet
* DFB chief regrets leaving Mesut Ozil to face racist attacks
* Were Colorado girls strangled? Father's lawyers requested DNA swabs from children's necks.

* The Daily 202: Bernie and Hillary who? Dem...
* MADIGAN on RAUNER's leadership — how A...
* Our View: An unfortunate political encounter
* Illinois congressman apologizes after camp...
* Illinois congressman's staffer arreste...
* Davis Staffer Fired After Altercation
* I-TEAM nominated for regional Emmy award
* Davis: Ex-staffer made 'tragic mistake...
* Illinois congressman's staffer arreste...
* Alton political consultant: Springfield or...

* Trump tabs Springfield-based prosecutor fo......
* Ami Investment Management Boosted Graham H......
* Rlj Lodging Tr (RLJ) Holder Land & Bui......
* Koch Industries Increased Its United Techn......
* Zacks Investment Management Has Upped Stak......

* Of the 4 female veterans in Congress, 2 ar......
* Can Tahirah Amatul-Wadud Become the Next P......
* Senate passes resolution defending press a......
* Just a small critique...
* Millhiser gets nod from Trump to be next U......

* A Conservative's Conservative Before He Was Nominated And An Open-Minded Jurist After
* The Rahm Emanuel TIF Game: Slush Funds And Shovelfuls Of Cash
* Defining ‘Regular and Substantive’ Interaction in the Online Era
* Career-ready diploma seals show students are ‘ready for life’
* What will AI and robotics mean for higher education?
* Blockchain Gains Currency in Higher Ed
* AI can now tell your boss what skills you lack—and how you can get them
* Keep 'Em Down On The Farm
* The Week In Chicago Rock
* Kusanya clean-up day August 19, 2018


* Bicentennial announces plans for Aug. 26th Constitution Day
* Gov. Rauner proclaims Traffic Fatality Awareness Day, urges public's help in making Illinois roads safer
* Illinois Department of Human Rights Honors "Dream Builders"
* Gov. Rauner signs public safety legislation
* Illinois Payrolls Up for Sixth Straight Month

  
* Camp W is a great game for the end of summer
* New Snapchat update for Android teases better performance and new features
* You can now download tickets to visit museums for free on Sept. 22nd
* Weekly poll: Are in-display fingerprint readers the future?
* Unity isn’t just for video games anymore — it can also help you build a career
* Rollout begins of dark mode and Material Design within Android Messages (Update: Not anymore)
* Arm TechCon All-Access Pass and Huawei P20 Pro giveaway!

* White Sox Minor League update: August 18, 2018
* Six Pack of Stats: Royals 3, White Sox 1
* Lopez takes hill in rubber game vs. Royals
* Royals, White Sox look to claim series
* Royals out score White Sox 3-1
* Covey runs out of gas in big rebound start
* Gordon homers, Royals rally past White Sox


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Blagojevich Trial
Advertising
Updated Posts
Polls

Archives
August 2018
July 2018
June 2018
May 2018
April 2018
March 2018
February 2018
January 2018
December 2017
November 2017
October 2017
September 2017
August 2017
July 2017
June 2017
May 2017
April 2017
March 2017
February 2017
January 2017
December 2016
November 2016
October 2016
September 2016
August 2016
July 2016
June 2016
May 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress




Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller