SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
IML, firefighters unite on “public duty rule”

Thursday, Apr 28, 2016

* First, a bit of background

The [Illinois] Supreme Court’s decision came in a case involving the 2008 death of Coretta Coleman in unincorporated Will County.

Coleman, 58, called 911 because she was having difficulty breathing. There was a series of delays and miscommunication among emergency personnel, and by the time Coleman’s husband arrived home and let paramedics in, more than 40 minutes had passed. She was found unresponsive inside and was pronounced dead at the hospital.

Coleman’s family sued the East Joliet and Orland fire protection districts, Will County, and their employees who were involved in the response.

Citing the public duty rule, lower courts ruled in favor of the defendants. But the high court overruled them in a 4-3 decision, abolishing the rule it had established in previous decisions.

* From the 4-3 majority opinion

We believe that departing from stare decisis and abandoning the public duty rule and its special duty exception is justified for three reasons: (1) the jurisprudence has been muddled and inconsistent in the recognition and application of the public duty rule and its special duty exception; (2) application of the public duty rule is incompatible with the legislature’s grant of limited immunity in cases of willful and wanton misconduct; and (3) determination of public policy is primarily a legislative function and the legislature’s enactment of statutory immunities has rendered the public duty rule obsolete.

* From the spirited dissent

To summarize, then, the compelling new reasons that Justice Kilbride gives for departing from stare decisis and abandoning the long-standing public duty rule are that (1) the rule lends itself to the use of a common analytical tool and (2) the rule is incompatible with statutory provisions that have been on the books for decades and that this court has repeatedly held have nothing to do with the public duty rule. Neither of these reasons is credible, let alone convincing. And this matters, because the importance of stare decisis is that it “permits society to presume that fundamental principles are established in the law rather than in the proclivities of individuals.” Chicago Bar Ass’n, 161 Ill. 2d at 510. That being the case, if the reasons proffered by Justice Kilbride are sufficient to justify a departure from stare decisis in this case, then we may as well abandon the stare decisis doctrine altogether. Because if they are good enough, then anything is good enough, and we need not waste our time going through the motions of what will essentially have become a hollow exercise.

* The Illinois Municipal League and the firefighters are pushing to enshrine the “public duty” concept into law

“This legislation provides a legal umbrella for both our citizens and the first-responders who are sworn to protect them,” said Pat Devaney, president of the Associated Firefighters of Illinois. “Never should a first-responder have to worry about the legal ramifications of an effort to save a life. It’s re-establishing a principle we’ve been operating under for many years.”

Cole said the principle is that police and firefighters have a duty to protect the public at large, but not specific members of the public. […]

“Absent making these changes, we believe we’re going to create an environment where there’s going to be a cottage industry of frivolous lawsuits aiming to capitalize on the suffering of others,” Devaney said. […]

The Illinois Trial Lawyers Association is opposed to the legislation the Municipal League wants approved. ITLA president Perry Browder said the proposed law could extend immunity to situations where there clearly was misconduct by a police officer or firefighters. He also said municipalities are already protected by other immunity laws.

* From the legislation

The public duty rule is an important doctrine that is grounded in the principle that the duty of a local governmental entity to preserve the well-being of the community is owed to the public at large rather than to specific members of the community. […]

A local governmental entity and its employees owe no duty of care to individual members of the general public to provide governmental services.

Your thoughts?

- Posted by Rich Miller        


23 Comments
  1. - Ghost - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 12:42 pm:

    I think there shoild be a willfull and wanton exception, BUT it needs tightened up. the courts have allowed extreme malfeasance to be the same, and i dont agree. I think it requires intentional conduct to jot save somone, not carelessness or ineptness. because hindsight is always 20/20. a goodfaith effort however poorly executed shoild be peotected. intentional conduct not to help someone should not.


  2. - The anti-trib - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 12:55 pm:

    The sky is always falling….looks like the IML sucked the firefighters in. These cases are far and few between. Tort immunity covers municipalities and their employees 99% of the time.


  3. - Ghost - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 1:00 pm:

    i blew an opportunity here for a veiled fahrenheit 451 reference….


  4. - OneMan - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 1:06 pm:

    Guess I am not seeing how you have a duty to we but not a duty to me as it were.


  5. - PublicServant - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 1:13 pm:

    Blanket amnesty from legitimate claims of negligence and/or dereliction of duty is not appropriate. If you’re doing your job, you’ve got nothing to worry about. If you’re not, you deserve to be sued and lose.


  6. - JackD - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 1:15 pm:

    Ghost; the Illinois courts have never defined “willful and wanton” as only intentional.


  7. - Jake From Elwood - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 1:26 pm:

    Love the dissent in this opinion by the old Bears kicker Bob Thomas. It is fiery and minces no words.
    The trend in other states is to weaken governmental immunities. However, this really isn’t a tort immunity issue, but a issue of what duty that first responders owe to specific members of the public.
    I am in favor of codifying the public duty rule.


  8. - Steve Schnorf - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 1:37 pm:

    How would you like to run for reelection with that last paragraph as your platform?


  9. - Rich Miller - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 1:44 pm:

    Schnorf, that could be why he has no co-sponsors.


  10. - wordslinger - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 1:51 pm:

    –A local governmental entity and its employees owe no duty of care to individual members of the general public to provide governmental services.–

    That’s insane. That’s a governmental argument for anarchy.


  11. - Chicagonk - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 1:54 pm:

    In light of how the Illinois courts have expanded the “willful and wanton” carve-out in the statutory tort immunity act, Illinois basically gave yet one more handout to the trial lawyers in this state.


  12. - The anti-trib - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 2:11 pm:

    Chicagonk-

    Proof please?


  13. - L.A. - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 2:13 pm:

    and why the bill is going nowhere fast


  14. - Jake From Elwood - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 2:22 pm:

    This is hardly “Anarchy in the I.L.”

    The public duty rule provides that the governmental unit owes a duty to provide its services to the public at large, but not to individual members of the public. This common law rule only applied in cases where a police officer or firefighter never initiated service because there was an exception known as the “special duty” clause. A police officer or firefighter cannot be expected to have a duty to guarantee the safety and well being of each and every citizen in an emergency, but when that public safety officer does initiate aid, this public duty rule would not apply and the willful and wanton standard of tort immunity would be instead applied as the legal standard of liability.

    Not the simplest concept to understand.


  15. - wordslinger - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 2:50 pm:

    –Not the simplest concept to understand.–

    I guess I’m just thick.

    –The public duty rule provides that the governmental unit owes a duty to provide its services to the public at large, but not to individual members of the public.–

    I weep to think of all the weasels that had to die to provide the words for that sentence.


  16. - Ghost - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 3:19 pm:

    JackD thats why i said if its shored up 😀


  17. - Stu - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 3:29 pm:

    It’s sad that a SWAT team will kick in the door and take-down a teen-aged video gamer, but a senior is left helpless because nobody answered the paramedic’s knock.


  18. - cover - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 3:32 pm:

    = Not the simplest concept to understand. =

    If I interpreted that correctly, there is a legal difference between “we don’t have the resources to respond” vs. “we tried to respond but were incompetent”. I can at least respect the former as a potential defense/immunity, but the latter should not be.


  19. - Anonymous - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 3:46 pm:

    The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled in a similar fashion. Notice you no longer see “to serve and protect” on the side of police cars. They have ruled police have no duty to the individual, only society as a whole. Sorta makes a compelling argument for CCW since your safety is your own responsibility.


  20. - Anonymous - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 3:54 pm:

    One need only google the oathe’s of office police and firefighters take. The police oath has changed to reflect the Supreme Court decision, firefighters has not, they still swear to protect the lives and property of the citizens. Oh how bathrooms and oathe’s are going to change in short order! Who doesn’t love politics!


  21. - Ahoy! - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 4:00 pm:

    –ITLA president Perry Browder said the proposed law could extend immunity to situations where there clearly was misconduct by a police officer or firefighters. –

    Ok, so what does Perry suggest be changed that removes this concern? Or is this just the trial lairs wanting more reasons to sue taxpayers?


  22. - Anon221 - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 4:27 pm:

    A society as a whole cannot be made without individuals.

    I agree with wordslinger on the insanity of the last paragraph, and (hopefully it will remain so) the sanity of no co-sponsors. Let this be a Century Club nomination.


  23. - Payback - Thursday, Apr 28, 16 @ 4:37 pm:

    Some rare insights into how governmental entities think here if you read what’s hidden in plain sight:

    “…the legislature’s enactment of statutory immunities has rendered the public duty rule obsolete.” No one is mentioning that generally you have ONE year to sue an employee of government in Illinois, not TWO as for every other tort. That good old boy bonus alone from the legislature has protected thousands of police criminals from due process.

    “…the proposed law could extend immunity to situations where there clearly was misconduct by a police officer or firefighters.” That’s the purpose. Which is nonsense since local and state govt. pay for the legal defense, civil and criminal, of police employees most of the time anyway. Now firefighters are trying to get in on the act. Where does it end if no one is liable under the law, and everyone is above the law?

    This type of nonsense is why some Chicago Alderman are going to look at removing unlimited legal defense from the C.P.D. union contract in 2017.


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* An image is worth a thousand, um, empty seats
* Then and now
* Budget cuts and some ways forward
* Ryan talks about the impasse
* Question of the day
* How to survive a crazy boss
* Grandstand rollout begins
* Both sides of the governor's involvement
* Cubs trophy coming to Springfield
* Another wave of bomb threats includes Chicago's Jewish Community Center
* It's just a bill
* Mendoza takes heat over used car purchase
* Getting to a "win" is important for some Dems
* Bustos won't run for governor
* Charlie Brown's football
* Yesterday's stories

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............

...............

...............
<


Loading


* Where is Gov. Bruce Rauner? - NBC Chicago..
* Here are some of the acts for the Illinois Stat.....
* High court holds youth transfer law exceeded..
* Kapos: Emanuel says he’d like to improve his pa.....
* Then and now - The Capitol Fax Blog (blog)..
* Ryan talks about the impasse - The Capitol Fax .....
* Conference will explore fair school funding - S.....
* Ex-McPier CEO Ochoa returns to board - Crain's .....


* Drew Peterson transferred out of Illinois prison system
* Former white supremacists help others leave hate groups
* Excerpts from recent editorials in newspapers in Illinois
* Austria approves US extradition for Ukrainian oligarch
* Firefighters work on 1,300-acre southern Illinois wildfire
* GW: Illinois Sen. Tammy Duckworth to speak at graduation
* Leaving hate behind: Ex-extremists quit groups, help others
* Austria approves US extradition for Ukrainian oligarch
* EXCHANGE: Cervical cancer survivor pushing for screening
* Illinois State University seeks public input on its future

* Illinois State University seeks public input on its future
* AFSCME strike authorization vote outcome to be revealed this week
* Cheri Bustos won't run for Illinois governor
* Illinois bill would rein in pro athletes' worker comp claims
* GOP criticizes Illinois comptroller for buying used $32K SUV
* Effort to privatize economic development questioned
* State budget impasse still hurting schools
* DHS moving into former Barney's Furniture store
* Madigan says House will consider sale of Thompson Center
* Bustos, other Dems demand Rauner pay domestic violence money

* Obamacare repeal could cost Cook $300 million a year
* Offices atop Macy's State Street flagship?
* Marcus Lemonis countersues Bow Truss, Phil Tadros in contract dispute
* Illinois execs bullish on 2017, not local economy


* 6 business burglaries in Englewood in two months
* Drew Peterson suddenly in federal custody
* Man gets 34 years in fatal Avondale home invasion
* Opinion: FALN killed my father — don’t name street for its leader
* I can imagine quite a bit: Filming begins on young Han Solo movie
* Spring has sprung a lull in White Sox rebuild
* A former Blagojevich aide’s survival guide for Trump staffers
* Kapos: Emanuel says he’d like to improve his patience
* City worker falsely accused in prostitution sting gets $370,000
* Lincoln museum to showcase Cub-Cardinals rivalry


* CPS tells principals not to allow immigration officials in schools without warrant
* Sheridan couple charged with armed robbery in Aurora parking lot
* 34 years for 2011 home invasion that left teen dead, mom injured
* U.S. extradition OK'd for Ukrainian billionaire indicted in Chicago and linked to Trump
* Trump administration poised to change transgender student bathroom guidelines
* Former Bull Eddie Robinson joins Ice Cube's 3-on-3 basketball league
* All 43 Cubs game-day giveaways in the 2017 season, ranked
* Friends and relatives gather to mourn, remember Arlington Heights family killed in crash
* White Sox catcher Omar Narvaez following veteran Geovany Soto’s lead
* What to Eat. Drink. Do. in February and March


» Former White Supremacists Help Others Leave Hate Groups
» Chicago Cop With Long Complaint History Heads Busy Police District
» Hundreds Protest Trump At Chicago 'Not My President' Rally
» Report: Chicago's African-American Men More Likely To Be Unemployed, Undereducated
» Citizenship Ceremony Held For 25 People At City Hall
» With Eye On Farmers Markets, Lawmakers Target Regulations
» Chicago Aldermen Consider Crackdown On Street Performers
» Gary’s Disappearing Public Schools
» Why Was Rauner Budget Proposal Greeted With Confusion?
» Syrian Family Reunites Three Weeks After Travel Ban


* Their View: Editorial: Remembering Bob Michel
* Illinois State University seeks public input on its future
* Kathleen Parker: Meet Rick. Meet the football. Hike!
* AFSCME strike authorization vote outcome to be revealed this week
* Cheri Bustos won't run for Illinois governor
* Illinois bill would rein in pro athletes' worker comp claims
* Their View: Why aren't Illinoisans blocking traffic in front of their Capitol?
* GOP criticizes Illinois comptroller for buying used $32K SUV
* Bernard Schoenburg: Dems eye Rodney Davis, who expects the challenge
* Effort to privatize economic development questioned


* Prenzler denies security concerns at administration building
* Sheriff’s Office collects 1,362 pounds of meds in Rx 4 Safety program
* School district to consider new principal for Belleville school
* Cigar box hero: Craftsman finds inspiration for guitars in everyday items
* Soup Fest draws crowd, raises money for Jersey County youth programs
* Deadline to leave protest camp won’t be extended
* Student injured in Monticello bus accident
* Armchair Traveler: Alton’s Hayner Library offers opportunity to ‘travel’ world
* Tom Sawyer hits the stage in musical adaptation of classic story
* Alton High School students aim to make a difference with service day


* Wheaton murder suspect barred fromm contacting ex-wife's children
* Saving struggling bee populations focus of Lake County seminar
* KDOT: Lower construction costs could mean cheaper Longmeadow bridge tolls
* Police seize $15,000 in drugs from Fox River Grove brothers
* Panthers cut 3-time Pro Bowler Mike Tolbert and Paul Soliai

* Group upset with Trump wants Town Hall mee...
* Hultgren updates work on heroin, opioid ab...
* US Rep. Randy Hultgren talks veterans' iss...
* US Rep. Randy Hultgren talks veterans' iss...
* GOP congressman appears to distance himsel...
* US Representative Randy Hultgren visits ne...
* Hultgren guides STEM scholars through pres...
* Voters Shame Cowardly Reps with Town Halls...
* Federal hiring freeze puts chill on Yorkvi...
* Hultgren criticizes immigration ban, Roska...

* Towns in Knox, Fulton Counties get federal......
* Durbin broadens factors in considering Tru......

* Towns in Knox, Fulton Counties get federal......
* Duckworth to deliver commencement speech o......

* Rahm reportedly met with Jared Kushner and Jeff Sessions in D.C., and other Chicago news
* Louise Kiernan will head ProPublica in Chicago
* ¡Arriba, Abajo, Al Centro, Pa' Dentro! National Margarita Day Is Just Around The Corner
* This week’s Hitting Left with the Klonsky brothers. Exclusive interview with Yonatan Shipira. The journey of an Israeli helicopter pilot to peace activist and musician. And Chicago education activist and musician Matt Farmer.
* Supporters of birther army doctor Terry Lakin petition Trump for pardon
* Illinois’s only true meadery is riding the current wave of interest in the fermented honey beverage
* Resistance Sunday.
* Betsy and Randi.
* The [Monday] Papers
* The [Tuesday] Papers


* Stars and Legends to Perform at 2017 Illinois State Fair - First Round of Grandstand Headliners Announced for Springfield Fair
* Governor Takes Bill Action
* 2017 Budget Address
* Rauner, Lawmakers Move to Protect Taxpayers from Inmate Legal Bills
* Illinois Department of Veterans’ Affairs Announcednew pilot program titled Tiny Boots

  
* The Average iPhone User in the U.S. Spent $40 on Apps in 2016
* Hanging out at Snap’s unremarkable IPO roadshow
* Users spent more on apps in 2016, with games and entertainment apps leading the way
* News Organizations Refocus FBI Lawsuit to Question Cost of San Bernardino iPhone Hack Tool
* Get a look at the on-screen buttons from the Samsung Galaxy S8
* Samsung could start selling refurbished Galaxy Note 7’s soon
* Travel app Hopper will now break down airlines’ confusing fees

* Giolito feels work from offseason paying off early in camp
* White Sox content with group of catchers entering 2017
* This is not a typo: Soto throws to Soto during BP
* This is not a typo: Soto throws to Soto during BP
* Garcia driven to reclaim outfield spot
* Garcia driven to reclaim outfield spot
* Bourjos enticed to White Sox by weather, opportunity


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Blagojevich Trial
Advertising
Updated Posts
Polls

Archives
February 2017
January 2017
December 2016
November 2016
October 2016
September 2016
August 2016
July 2016
June 2016
May 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress




Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller