Place this years revenue into a giant suitcase. The Speaker and the Governor each place a hand on the suitcase. Whoever can keep his hand on the suitcase longer decides what to do with the revenue. No takesies backsies.
Some rank-and-file legislator introduce a bill that does as follows:
Modify the appropriation process so that it ends with a budget no later than, say, March.
Set the tax rate for the second half of the current calendar year and first half of the next calendar year to collect enough to fully fund the appropriated amount (plus for several years some portion of unpaid bills).
Any overcollections or undercollections are added or subtracted from the next year’s budget.
That would give both parties an incentive to find savings, and would also provide better transparency to the public.
You might say this is politically unrealistic, but so is the turnaround agenda and a tax increase alone.
I don’t see how there can be any solution until someone blinks. The Senate is at least trying, but Rauner doesn’t seem to think their attempt is good enough, and I personally doubt Madigan would have gone along with the Grand Bargain either. Both Madigan and Rauner have drawn their lines in the sand and refuse to budge. And no one will bite the bullet and propose cuts (mostly talking about Rauner there, since he is supposed to propose a budget). Somebody has to stick their neck out a little, take some risk and do something they find unpleasant. Not new or insightful I know but it’s what I got, sorry.
- The Real Just Me - Friday, Mar 17, 17 @ 2:33 pm:
Maybe not a new idea, but end the impasse by focusing on the budget, that is revenue and spending. Fashion a New Grand Bargain out of revenue and spending.
One small breakthrough could lead to others. One of Rauner’s few weak points is the K-12 schools. Two of the things he is passionate about is pension reform and local control.
So, yesterday, I tossed out an idea that combined a lot of that. It won’t be all Rauner wants, but it would be something he could point to as an accomplishment.
Agree to give CPS the $215M it needs this year. And agree to start a cost shift from the State to the local school districts for the normal pension costs. For each year going forward, lower the amount CPS gets by the same percentage you shift to all the downstate districts. Do this every year until the State pension contribution is zero.
Things you might include in this:
Adding more oversight to the CPS pension fund, ideally by having either TRS or IMRF be the administrator
A property tax cap the year AFTER normal funding has been completely transferred to the local school districts
Things not to add into this:
Any other school funding reform
No property tax caps for now
No elimination of prevailing wage laws or other union busting items
Keep it clean and both sides can claim they got something out of it.
I think we have to separate our problems (revenue and spending) from why we have an impasse (ideology). If all we had to do was solve our problems this would be easy. I don’t see any solution to solving the impasse short of changing the players with the hope that the ideology changes with them.
@Michelle, actually it is Scott Harry who is in charge of GOMB.
And since he isn’t doing his job, maybe his pay check should be thrown in the same pile as the GA’s. The Executive branch needs to share the pain from the impasse. The Governor’s staff should have their pay delayed as well.
We’ve tried delegating the task to Cullerton and Radogno, and that hasn’t worked. Maybe it’s time to appoint Roland Burris to lead negotiations on a resolution to the impasse which will prove an opportunity for him to fill the blank space remaining on the list of accomplishments at his tomb. /S
We have an impasse because an incoming governor revealed to everyone that he lied throughout his campaign and then spent millions burning every bipartisan bridge in television ads. Rauner was damaged goods by February 2015.
He ranted against any citizen who worked for government, needed assistance from government, or served in office as an elected official. Judges, legislators, party leaders and state workers discovered that the new governor blamed them for the problems he faced.
He never earned the Office. He never regained trust. He only knew how to blame, not lead.
We’re supposed to be at an impasse. We have a governor who has run amok worse than the proceeding felons serving jail time.
Rauner is our state’s Dr. Kevorkian. He wants this impasse. He wants Illinois to collapse.
There’s nothing new here. There’s nothing to do to get around this gubernatorial quack.
Republicans and Job Creators seem to have an aversion to the courts and love for arbitration, so how about submitting all issues not resolved by a set date (3/31/17) to Binding Arbitration with an agreed respected Neutral. (ie., Edgar, Thompson, Obama; not Quinn). Finding the neutral is the hard part, but faced with the ‘trial’ date issues may resolve.
Create a series of “temporary” adjustable personal and corporate income tax rates dedicated to required appropriations for actuarially whole pensions, bill backlog pay down, Medicaid and education at a per student rate. Require all transportation related expenses to be paid from new constitutional amendment funds. Reduce the regular and corporate income tax rates to fund remaining appropriations. COGFA and GOMB would set adjustable rates annually using real math to balance real metrics. Collecting taxes specifically assigned to the big ticket appropriations reduces the temptation to rob Peter to pay Paul. I’ll add one more idea; state legislator and constitutional officer pay should be equal to the lowest paid full-time State employee salary.
Um, “Failure is not an option” - how I dispise that idiotic phrase. It is an ABSOLUTE option, and it has been the operative option for decades.
Illinoised: “…call in sick on the same day.” Yes, and who in hell would be persuaded this action would positively alter the
course of this sickening fiasco. Why not take a page out of the old, tired march chant “What do we want?” “JOBS”. When do we want ‘em?” “NOW!!!” Inane.
- Reformed Public Servant - Friday, Mar 17, 17 @ 3:24 pm:
Turn the IL SEN DEM’s graph into a walk-piece! Gov’s mansion will turn back to the Ds (if they want to own this mess?)
For 1 month let the votes that members in the House and Senate cast be private. No different than the votes cast by private citizens. A bill comes up for a vote, and members vote, but it’s not put on the big board, just the final tally displayed.
take the last grand bargain that was agreed to then cut every budget by 1% and kick the income tax back up to were it was. Lay off everyone that works for the state that used to be in the legislature. Get a democratic high roller to buy all the tv time to rail against everyone in both chambers and Madigan agrees to just pass what the senate sends him(saves a skeleton coming out) then make Rauner own something for a change.
Harley Davidson union workers show up at the Capitol and do a complete tear down of Rauner’s motorcycle. Carhartt starts a twitter revolt #NotOurGuvner and the organic apple orchards from Illinois and Michigan double down on MJM by providing free apples to all statehouse offices.
Or a roofie coloda in a few drinks and let’s start running some substantive bills in both chambers.
RNUG the Civic Federation has recommended a full merger of the CTPF and TRS. It was included in the Federation’s last report on fixing State finances. The City government and CPS retirees are totally opposed to a merger. One big reason has to do with investment decision making for CTPF. Overall with the exception of massive losses in 2008, CTPF as a fund has done well in terms of returns. It did get killed in the 2008 melt down.
As I said, the Executive Branch needs to feel the impasse pain. The GA feels it. The service providers feel it. The colleges and universities feel it. Local government feels the pain. Even regular state employees feel the pain through the backlog of medical bills.
But the people at the top of the Executive Branch feel no pain.
Now my nuclear option: The AFSCME pay ruling should have only applied to bargaining unit employees, not all employees. The Comptroller can easily distinguish who is bargaining unit and who isn’t. Delay or stop the non-bargaining unit employees pay until there is an appropriation. Since that is upper management at most state agencies, that will give the Executive Branch some impasse pain.
Now I hate suggesting this about the hard working SPSA’s that are in some agencies, but you do serve at the Governor’s pleasure and you might have to take one for the team.
== Would you advocate for allowing schools to levy for TRS like they already do for IMRF and SSI? ==
If that is what it takes, I would be OK with that … and it would hit me fairly hard since I currently own 2 and 1/2 homes here (the 1/2 is a jointly inherited house). Anybody want to buy a house or two?
Whatever happened to the idea of extending the pension deadline or lowering the 90% funding mandate? It’s a self-imposed restriction. It has to be tied to something forcing payments to be made, though, or we’ll just kick the can down the road.
Yeah, it’s unpopular because we’ve already vilified the pensioners and voters want blood. So what. Ease the pain and revisit later.