Post-campaign notebook
Monday, Nov 14, 2022 - Posted by Rich Miller * All opposed Illinois congressional Democrats appear to have under-performed Biden 2020 results in their newly drawn districts, which is to be expected when the party controls the White House during a midterm. But they didn’t under-perform Biden enough to lose any seats. The Dem maps/candidates/messaging held and the GOP candidates/messaging failed…
* From Tom Kacich’s story on Nikki Budzinski…
Wow. * Speaking of winning Democratic candidates, US Rep.-elect Delia Ramirez sent me a selfie from freshman orientation this morning… * Neil Steinberg…
Whew. * From a Crain’s Chicago Business editorial about what the governor should do now…
In other words, they are demanding that the governor flip on the people who put him and kept him in office. From the same editorial…
So… the Bailey approach of just talking about it? * Daily Herald…
Maybe ask more people? * From last week…
That lead has since narrowed to 178. * Tribune…
Rep. Butler, by the way, will be taking advantage of an ethics loophole that he spoke against after the bill was passed…
As long as he resigns before his current term ends, he can begin lobbying for the railroads on the first day of the 103rd General Assembly. * SJ-R…
Funny how people seem to forget that Black and Latino working class voters are solidly Democratic here. * The Hill…
* Isabel’s roundup… * Crain’s | Illinois elects first Muslim, Indian woman to state legislature: Nabeela Syed, a 23-year-old Palatine native, will be one of the youngest members of the Illinois General Assembly when she assumes office in January. * Tribune | Laura Washington: Democrats’ meddling in primary races notched wins. Was it dirty politics?: This midterm election season ushered in a new form of gamesmanship and potent weapon in campaign arsenals: meddling. The critics are crying foul. It’s dirty politics, they say. It’s undemocratic. It’s just pragmatic politics, its proponents reply. We are in it to win it. * Crain’s | Workers’ Rights Amendment on verge of passage, unions claim: The proposed change to the Illinois Constitution is well ahead with relatively few votes still left to be counted, labor groups point out. * NBC Chicago | With Nearly All Vote Totals Reported, Here’s Where Amendment 1 Stands: As of Monday, 99% of precincts were reporting vote totals for the Workers’ Rights Amendment * Center Square | ALEC weighs in on Illinois’ ‘workers’ rights’ amendment: Conversely, right-to-work laws ensure workers cannot be made to join an association or union or pay dues to it as a requirement for employment. ALEC said states with this policy tend to be more prosperous and have faster wage growth than non-right-to-work states. * Center Square | Illinois’ election the most contested in two decades: With 3.8 million Illinoisans voting in 79 competitive Illinois House elections, the state’s 2022 general election was the most contested in the past two decades. Races included Congressional seats, Illinois House and Senate races, and a constitutional amendment. * Shaw Local | Sauk Valley backed Darren Bailey in ways not seen since Jim Edgar’s 1994 landslide victory: Incumbent Democrat JB Pritzker defeated Bailey in statewide returns. While there has been much analysis about Bailey’s weakness in the Chicago suburbs, there was no question he energized voters in the Lee, Whiteside, Ogle and Carroll counties. In fact, it was the most votes by a Republican gubernatorial candidate in the four-county region since Jim Edgar’s landslide victory in 1994. * Illinois Farmer Today | Farm Bureau policy director gets into weeds of farm bill: “Politics makes strange bedfellows. Nutrition advocates worked closely with the crop insurance industry and farm groups. It’s an all-hands-on-deck effort. We put a lot into it, and they do too. There are going to be many members of Congress that have production agriculture but not a lot of farmers out there who are buying crop insurance. Having the SNAP program (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program) included in the farm bill is a wise move. It keeps all the components together from production to consumption,” Adam Nielsen, Director of National Legislation and Policy at the Illinois Farm Bureau said. * Tribune | How did voters respond to referendums in Chicago’s suburbs?: Voters throughout Chicagoland faced questions about tax increases, support for public services, changes in government structure, and more. Here’s a look at how some of those fared on Election Day. * Crain’s | Health care worker union endorses Brandon Johnson for mayor: SEIU Healthcare, which represents about 36,000 Chicago workers, endorsed the progressive candidate because of a shared vision on working-class issues.
|
- Amalia - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:06 pm:
Matt Podgorski is no Pete Silvestri. terrible result.
- Anyone Remember - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:10 pm:
===In other words, they are demanding that the governor flip on the people who put him and kept him in office.===
That is why I voted for the Constitutional Amendment. The monied interests, across a broad range of issues, will never give up in their crusade against the working / middle classes and unions.
- Demoralized - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:12 pm:
==but I haven’t heard anybody so far say we could have done anything differently==
Maybe you shouldn’t be in charge if you can’t see why you lost. Why would they leave a guy in charge who doesn’t think they did anything wrong when clearly the voters thought otherwise?
- Oswego Willy - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:12 pm:
=== “but I haven’t heard anybody so far say we could have done anything differently.”===
How about not embrace racist thinkers, insurrection apologists and conspiracy theorists… like you’ve been doing since this…
=== So, whatever your political leanings, wherever you live - if you want to fight corruption, restore fiscal sanity, grow our economy, and stand for law and order - you’re on our team. It’s time to suit up, work together, and bring home some wins for the people of Illinois.”===
I’d do that different, but I’m don’t embrace vile in a political party like Tracy does.
- Pundent - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:13 pm:
=“but I haven’t heard anybody so far say we could have done anything differently.”=
Well here’s a top tip for Don Tracy. Illinois has never shown signs that it’s ready to embrace racists, insurrectionists, election deniers and the many others the ILGOP covets these days.. With few exceptions they remain very unpopular in this state. So perhaps you could acknowledge that reality and realize that if this is your base, you’ll largely be on the outside looking in.
- Demoralized - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:21 pm:
==restore fiscal sanity==
I don’t know where this argument is coming from. Illinois hasn’t been as fiscally sound as it is now in years.
- Ron Burgundy - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:30 pm:
Regardless of party, the get re-elected and immediately quit stunt Rep. Butler just pulled disgusts me.
- twowaystreet - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:31 pm:
==As long as he resigns before his current term ends, he can begin lobbying for the railroads on the first day of the 103rd General Assembly.==
Anyone who thinks Republicans bash Dems on ethics for anything other than political points will be proven wrong time and time again.
And underscores how much appreciation I have for Greg Harris for finishing his term and not resigning to appoint a successor and give them the incumbent bump for this last election.
- DuPage Moderate - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:34 pm:
Good, get rid of the whole State Republican party. Get rid of Jim Zay in DuPage. What a bunch of out-of-touch losers.
Time to bring in fresh blood grounded in 2022.
- Ducky LaMoore - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:36 pm:
“Can anyone make an observation about him that isn’t somehow tainted by the third of a billion dollars worth of hype firehosed at us over the past four years?”
Okay… let me try and answer the question…. He is a better governor than the most recent four governors. No amount of money will convince me otherwise. The only thing that could convince me otherwise is JB himself. And he hasn’t done it.
- Annonin' - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:36 pm:
“I’m head of the party, so obviously I can’t deny responsibility,” he said, “but I haven’t heard anybody so far say we could have done anything differently,” President, Tracy Park Improvement Assoc.
We know everyone has seen Don wandering his park waiting for GovJunk to return, but they could have tried to offer some real plans for the future besides union busting, mandated gun carry, jail for certain health care procedures. But they blew it when the Court wrote the Hobbs decision. It zero’d GOPies credibility from coast to coast.
- Blake - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:36 pm:
Between Pritzker’s margin of victory being almost identical to Whitmer’s, the Republican Presidential nominee fairing better in Illinois in 2020 than 2016, Democratic 2022 underperforming Biden 2020, I wonder how well the 2022 map will hold up in 2028 or 2030. I’m not calling for Illinois to be a swing state in 2028 or 2032 Presidential election, but it wouldn’t surprise me if we continue to see Illinois elections look more like Michigan.
- Socially DIstant Watcher - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:37 pm:
==But now that he doesn’t have to talk voters—and organized labor—into supporting him, what other measures is Pritzker willing to take to further bend the pension liability curve downward?==
Like, I dunno, putting surplus funds towards the pension debt? I bet if JB did something like that, Crain’s would really stand up and cheer!
- Big Dipper - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:38 pm:
Maybe legislators who care about ethics should decline to communicate with Butler and his client for a suitable cooling-off period.
- Oswego Willy - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:39 pm:
=== Can anyone make an observation about him that isn’t somehow tainted by the third of a billion dollars worth of hype firehosed at us over the past four years?===
See…
Newspaper endorsements, bond ratings narratives.
Please stop being so lazy.
- Suburban Mom - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:45 pm:
==Funny how people seem to forget that Black and Latino working class voters are solidly Democratic here.==
So often when people in politics say “working class” the “white” is silent. When he said the “working class” is trending GOP, he absolutely did not mean Black or Latino voters, whom he is not mentally including in the working class.
- Benjamin - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 3:56 pm:
I wonder if the underperformance compared to Biden ahs anything to do with the new districts created as part of the remap. Gerrymandering often creates many weak districts for the majority party as a way to maximize their advantage, while packing minority party voters into a few extremely strong districts (i.e., “packing and cracking”).
- Chicagonk - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 4:04 pm:
If the ILGOP doesn’t provide a plan for winning a statewide election, who in their right mind would give them money? Maybe the head of the GOP should be someone from the suburbs instead of central Illinois.
- Lester Holt’s Mustache - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 4:12 pm:
== willing to take to further bend the pension liability curve downward? ==
Isn’t this the same editorial board that originally championed Rauner’s budget antics in an attempt to “bend the pension liability curve downward”, and then flip-flopped when that later became a politically unpalatable fiscal nightmare? Pick a lane, man
- Manchester - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 4:18 pm:
Don Tracy doesn’t know what they could have dome differently. Seriously? Try getting rid of the culture wars. Commit to treating all people equally including people of color, Jews, Muslims, Gays, Trans and women. Stay out of people’s bedrooms and out of their health care decisions. Stop trying to making our country into a Christian Theocracy. This goes for the national GOP and the state GOP.
- Ares - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 4:29 pm:
JB is a philanthropist who has shown an interest in making a difference in government, as Teddy Roosevelt, FDR, and Nelson Rockefeller did, with great success. If only Floridians or Texans were so fortunate.
- Pundent - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 4:34 pm:
=“but I haven’t heard anybody so far say we could have done anything differently,”=
Tracy epitomizes what it means to live in a bubble. His party got thrashed statewide by double digits. In the aftermath of that there should be no shortage of suggestions regarding what it could have been done differently. But Don Tracy sees nothing wrong. The inference is clear - we’re (the voters) the problem not the party.
- Rich Miller - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 4:36 pm:
Benjamin, these numbers aren’t based on the old districts. It’s the precincts in the new districts.
- TJ - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 4:37 pm:
The party that disdains the gen z vote and which is wholly opposed to student loan relief got crushed on a college campus?
Golly gee, what a shock! Talk about a dumb stance for the GOP to take. Coupled with their social issues, they’ve completely written off the under 25 vote.
- Mr K - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 4:55 pm:
Another way of looking at this is that the third-of-a-billion spent by Pritzker over two election cycles is what’s needed to get Illinois out of the hole it’s been in for years. Getting out of the hole is expensive — and it seems Pritzker is the only one (over the past several disastrous governors) who’s actually made a fiscal difference for the positive.
Rauner was supposed to do this — get us “back on track” — but his failure (or — eventually — his complete lack of desire) was spectacular and long lasting (and expensive).
Pritzker is, indeed, fixing it. And clearly it ain’t cheap.
- wizsouth - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 4:56 pm:
How sad for the conservative bulk of Illinois that your state is controlled by voters in Chicago, St. Louis and Springfield and by gerrymandered seats running the length of your good state.
- Oswego Willy - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 4:59 pm:
=== How sad==
“Conservatives” lost all 7 statewide seats.
How does gerrymandering figure into that.
Take your time…
- TJ - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 4:59 pm:
== How sad for the conservative bulk of Illinois that your state is controlled by voters in Chicago, St. Louis and Springfield and by gerrymandered seats running the length of your good state. ==
Oh no, a clear majority of the state’s population voted for the state to be run a way as opposed to what a clear minority of the state’s population wanted. The horror.
And what state are you from, perchance? Because, with the exception of Iowa, all of our neighbors are heavily gerrymandered in the GOP’s favor. No complaints there?
- MisterJayEm - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 5:03 pm:
“Can anyone make an observation about him that isn’t somehow tainted by the third of a billion dollars worth of hype firehosed at us over the past four years?”
Who can say something about his time as governor that isn’t based on something that they learned while he was governor?
How do that make logic?
– MrJM
- Big Dipper - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 5:20 pm:
==But Don Tracy sees nothing wrong==
He’s an out of touch, 70+ white man. He doesn’t want to change with the times, he wants to go back to the 50s.
- JoanP - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 5:45 pm:
= I haven’t heard anybody so far say we could have done anything differently. =
Maybe he should start reading Capitol Fax.
- JS Mill - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 7:11 pm:
Shorter ILGOP and their faithful…
“We have the democrats right where we want them.”
=How sad for the conservative bulk of Illinois that your state is controlled by voters in Chicago, St. Louis and Springfield and by gerrymandered seats running the length of your good state.=
All math to the contrary.
- Pot calling kettle - Monday, Nov 14, 22 @ 10:50 pm:
===Maybe he should start reading Capitol Fax.===
That was the first thought that popped into my mind when I read his comment. (Although, he should probably ignore Lucky P.)