SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year.
Durbin goes to ground during SOPA/PIPA protest

Thursday, Jan 19, 2012

* Yesterday saw an outpouring of opposition to the vile SOPA/PIPA legislation. Several members of the Illinois congressional delegation contacted me to say that they were withdrawing their support or announcing that they were opposed. Others announced opposition to local media. And this movement wasn’t just confined to Illinois

It appeared by Wednesday evening that Congress would follow Bank of America, Netflix and Verizon as the latest institution to change course in the face of a netizen revolt.

Legislation that just weeks ago had overwhelming bipartisan support and had provoked little scrutiny generated a grass-roots coalition on the left and the right. Wikipedia made its English-language content unavailable, replaced with a warning: “Right now, the U.S. Congress is considering legislation that could fatally damage the free and open Internet.” Visitors to Reddit found the site offline in protest. Google’s home page was scarred by a black swatch that covered the search engine’s label.

* The online protest was so intense that it knocked several Senate websites offline

Around 11 a.m. PT [yesterday], the rush of visitors looking for ways to contact their members of Congress overwhelmed several Web pages of individual senators. […]

The amount of traffic “temporarily shut down our Web site,” Sen. Ron Wyden, the leading opponent of the Protect IP Act, wrote on Twitter.

By noon PT, the Senate’s Web sites were loading again, but slowly or with difficulty. The Web site of Sen. Dianne Feinstein, a California Democrat who’s a sponsor of Protect IP, was generating a 500 server error.

Other Senate Web pages displayed this message: “Sorry, the web page you have requested is experiencing technical difficulties. The Webmaster has been alerted. You will be automatically redirected to the www.senate.gov home page after 10 seconds.”

* But not everybody was happy with yesterday’s actions

In one early sign that the blackouts and protests would have an effect, the MPAA yesterday characterized them as “stunts.” The group’s chairman, Chris Dodd, took a thinly veiled swipe at Wikipedia by denouncing the protests as “an irresponsible response and a disservice to people who rely on [the sites] for information and [who] use their services.”

* Chris Dodd is a former Democratic US Senator and is a longtime friend of US Sen. Dick Durbin. Sen. Durbin is still listed as a co-sponsor of this legislation. And despite a promise by his press person yesterday, Durbin’s office never did get back to me about why he is still supporting this goofy bill. He did, however, send a form letter to an Illinois blogger

Effective enforcement of intellectual property laws is critical to the encouragement of innovation and the creation of jobs. In recent years, we have seen a proliferation of Internet websites that are devoted to the unauthorized distribution and sale of pirated and counterfeit goods. These websites deprive innovators and businesses of revenue and result in the loss of American jobs. In addition, these websites present a public health concern when they sell counterfeit, adulterated, or misbranded pharmaceutical products.

I will keep your views in mind as the Senate considers this issue in the coming months.

* Let me make something very clear here. I hate pirates. I publish a copyrighted newsletter, and I have had to take action against people who posted material from that newsletter online.

But pirates, by very definition, operate outside the law. They’re gonna be with us pretty much no matter what. Stomping on the 1st Amendment and breaking the Internet in order to stop some pirates who will find another way to evade the law anyway seems pretty stupid to me. In other words, Congress shouldn’t mess with people like me in order to get at the pirates. It’s insane.

* Here is a good summary of some of this bill’s harmful impact

1. Guilty until proven innocent. One huge issue with the ways these bills are written is that you don’t necessarily have to be a proven violator of copyright infringement, all you have to do is be accused. An accusation alone is enough to cause detrimental harm to your business. You could lose your domain, have your website shut down and even be sued. All with no warning.

2. You’re held responsible for your user content. If you have any part of a website, blog or social networking page that allows for users to submit content, you will be responsible for what they submit. For example, if you have a blog and allow comments, you’ll be responsible for monitoring them to make sure you don’t have any pirated content submitted or links provided to sites that contain pirated content. Or, if you are on Facebook or Twitter, you’ll be responsible for monitoring your followers’ posts on your page to make sure they don’t have forbidden content. Can you imagine how difficult this will be?

3. Social networking as we know it will change. We all use social networking to build our businesses, but if these bills are passed, social networking sites will be forced to drastically censor their sites, limiting the content that can be shared and changing the way we use them for our businesses.

4. Where to sell your items? If you rely on sites like Etsy, Ebay or even Facebook to sell your items, you’ll be up a creek as they’ll be forced to shut down to avoid prosecution. Each of these sites contain photos submitted by users, the problem is, there would be no way for them to inspect every single photo uploaded to their sites to make sure it has the appropriate copyrights.

* And I couldn’t agree more with this

The world has changed. The way that people discover and purchase new content has changed. It’s a new world. They should try living in it — and continuing to prosper in it — instead of trying to shove it back the way it was when Groucho Marx still had a hit TV show.

Exactly.

Get a clue, Senator Durbin. Man up and tell your old buddy Dodd that legacy media shouldn’t be allowed to write legislation that regulates new media. And, trust me, I will never forget this vote. Ever.

- Posted by Rich Miller   20 Comments      


PREVIOUS POSTS »
* Reader comments closed for the holiday weekend
* US Sen. Kirk moved from Northwestern to Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago
* *** UPDATED x1 *** Lisa Madigan: Settlement money will be used to help homeowners, not state budget
* Question of the day
* *** UPDATED x3 *** SUBSCRIBERS ONLY: Campaign updates and a Statehouse roundup
* And here comes the blowback
* Poll: Half of Illinoisans want public employees to pay more for pensions - Half approve of gaming expansion
* Governor Flatline
* Hit them where it really hurts
* Yesterday's blog posts

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............


Search This Blog...

Search the 97th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 97th General Assembly By Keyword


Categories
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Blagojevich Trial
Advertising
Updated Posts
Polls

* Make a Cup of Ginger Tea to Help with Nausea, Sore Throat, and Motion Sickness [Team]
* 42 New Digital Media Resources You May Have Missed
* Top 10 Twitter Pics of the Week [PICS]
* Freeze Raw Bacon to Avoid Spoilage [Food Hacks]
* Flapcast Organizes and Streams Podcasts in Your Browser [Webapps]
* New this week on the Inside Network Job Board: Atari, GREE, Lolgames, more
* What to make of AT&T’s vanishing spectrum crisis

  
* Big Cuts at Airy Labs, Ex-Employees Blame Management
* Four Mistakes Publishers Make When Bringing Content to Tablets
* Series 3 of collectible Android figures leaked
* How I use my BlackBerry to eat healthier
* Big Valentine’s Day Sales on iPad Games from EA and Others
* Root the Droid 4 Thanks to This Exploit by Dan Rosenberg
* Contest: 50 copies of Slide Show Maker up for grabs

* BR_WhiteSox: http://t.co/pBtg4FTi - Is there method to Marlins' spendi..
* KenWo Diaries- White Sox Encounters
* BR_WhiteSox: http://t.co/AMGBSC8D - Manny Ramirez wasn't in Orioles' p..
* Dunn problem was known issue for Guillen before season
* BR_WhiteSox: http://t.co/AMGBSC8D - Cardinals sign ex-Sox reliever Lin..
* BR_WhiteSox: http://t.co/yNvrT72i - Ozzie knew about Dunn in spring tr..
* BR_WhiteSox: http://t.co/7fdpjiJf - Dunn's swing bad in February? Of c..


February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog-Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

   
Loading


* Returning veterans find job search a challenge, th....
* Pols pull bait-and-switch on teacher pensions, tax....
* Quinn adds LGBT-friendly section to tourism site -....
* Employment, education programs for veterans - Post....
* AG: Illinois to get $1B in mortgage settlement - Y....


* Chicago police union sues Burge's attorneys
* Ill. nursing home cited after resident's death
* Ill. Catholics worry over Obama birth control plan
* Returning veterans find job search a challenge
* Ill. man killed, trooper injured in crash
* 2 toddlers dropped off on Chicago street
* Illinois mom gets probation in daughter's death
* Ill. mom gets probation in daughter's death
* Ill. offices closed for Lincoln's Birthday
* Judge orders taping of suspect's mental exam

* Quinn: Gun registry would be 'uphill climb' in Illinois
* State Senate panel takes up 'Caylee's Law'
* Two Springfield residents among those receiving The Order of Lincoln
* Illinois to start Medicaid fraud checks without federal government's OK
* Creating jobs: What can a governor do?
* 'No damned way:' Metro-east lawmakers plan to fight proposed gun registration
* Luechtefeld to lead Clean Coal Review Board
* Downstate lawmakers: No gun registry
* Poll: 54 percent disapprove of Quinn's performance
* Quinn to Obama: Illinois moving ahead on Medicaid fraud crackdown

* Video. Gov. Quinn Q&A
* Video: Pat Quinn on Cat
* Unseasonably warm winter heats up tourism in IL
* Video: ISU's Bowman on MAP expansion
* Video: Lawmakers mull police recording law
* Bill would make it legal to record IL cops in public
* IL college chiefs back Quinn call for more MAP money

* Foodies prepare: Seating for Achatz's Next go on sale Saturday
* Former Sun-Times columnist, Jeffrey Zaslow, killed in car crash
* Kirk transferred to rehab institute
* Insurers will pick up birth control tab if religious groups refuse to cover it
* Charter National Bank is first Chicago-area failure of the year


* City sticker runner-up doesn’t want design used amid controversy
* Boy discovered dead, woman injured in Roseland fire
* Police: ‘Abandoned’ toddlers dropped off wrong street
* BRAIN TEASERS
* City employee reimbursement data now online
* Cook County Circuit Court Clerk regrouping after fire
* North Side jewelry heist like something out of ‘Mission: Impossible’
* Jeffrey Zaslow, The Last Lecture author, killed in car crash at age 53
* Medical marijuana grower busted on Northwest Side gets six years in prison
* Koschman family, Alvarez spar over transcripts in Daley nephew case


* City won't use any contest art for city sticker
* Man killed, trooper injured when Illinois State Police squad car rear-ended
* Boy found dead after firefighters rescue woman from Far South Side fire
* Two dead, another injured in overnight violence
* South Side bus crash results in 10 injuries
* Indiana State Police warn motorists of bogus troopers on I-80
* Bail set at $400,000 for man charged with DUI in deaths of 2
* Cops: Officer fatally shoots man who hit him after ramming garage door with van
* Police: Relative ID's 2 toddlers left at wrong Englewood home
* Blaze strikes Clerk Dorothy Brown's home


* Emanuel stays out of city sticker controversy
* Stakeholders talk crime prevention strategies
* Mark Kirk transferred out of Northwestern
* Santorum rides the anti-contraceptive conservative wave
* Chicago Police Department Pull the Plug on City Sticker
* Police see crime drop after crackdown
* CPS head wants Illinois to end No Child Left Behind
* Illinois company fined for improper fetus disposal
* U.S. Government seals $25 billion mortgage settlement
* Illinois to get about $1 billion in national mortgage settlement

* Find Chicago's new ward map confusing? Try getting a garbage can - Crain's Chicago Business
* Emanuel off target on gun plan, but wider approach makes sense - Crain's Chicago Business
* Chicago residents urged to 'adopt' sidewalks - News-Democrat
* Emanuel withholds most records detailing push for speed cameras - Chicago Tribune
* Quinn thinks gun registry would be ‘uphill climb’ - Arlington Heights Daily Herald


* Man arrested in alleged battery of girlfriend
* Free 'Lincoln Tomato' seeds to Old State Capitol visitors
* Frontier adding Denver flights from Bloomington
* Vampires invade the Abraham Lincoln Presidential Museum
* Best image from the "Vampire Hunter" preview
* 'Vampire Hunter' at Lincoln's Tomb
* Illinois extends volleyball coach Hambly’s deal
* U.S. Sen. Mark Kirk moved to stroke rehab center
* Montgomery County crash injures two
* Police investigating possible abduction attempt


* Illinois to start Medicaid fraud checks without federal approval
* Former Polish president tours Lincoln Museum
* Quinn thinks gun registry would be 'uphill climb'
* Chicago-St Louis high-speed rail plans speeding up
* Illinois walnut trees threatened by fungus


* Auditor, treasurer need to move on
* Measure would make it legal to record Illinois cops in public
* Building should start coming down this week
* Returning veterans find job search a challenge
* Chicago police union sues Burge's attorneys
* Street closures planned in Champaign, Urbana
* Event tries to help vets transition into civilian life
* Photo of the week: Melissa Cox
* Photos of the week 2/12/2012
* SIU softball drops season opener

* Kinzinger stops in Genoa to talk taxes, spend..
* Editorial: Mass transit is for all, not just ..
* Moderate Republicans Spotted in the House? - ..
* Former congressman gives backing to Bustos - ..
* McConnaughay wins backing from Roskam - North..
* Homeless Advocates Divided Over Bill Aimed At..
* The people know Illinois is in deep trouble -..
* Lipinski takes on liberal newcomer, again - C..
* Cunningham fighting to get back on ballot - K..
* Sixth Congressional District Candidates Debat..

* Dick Durbin Aide's Spouse Lobbied For Illinoi.....
* Durbin backs Goetten over Gill - News-Gazette...
* Ill. offices closed for Lincoln's Birthday - .....
* Durbin: Transportation bill disastrous for Il.....
* Black History Month program scheduled Feb. 19.....

* Author shares how to rally back after being d.....
* Fire crews battle trucking business blaze - K.....
* In Maine, Paul vies to extend Romney losing s.....
* Kirk transferred to rehab institute - Crain's.....
* Sen. Kirk transfers to
 rehab center - Daily .....

* Runner Up in City Sticker Contest Pulls Out
* Romney wins CPAC straw poll, Santorum close
* Illinois Taxpayers now fund official LGBT tourism site
* Your donation would be greatly appreciated
* Tribune reports on Antheus in Hyde Park
* Clarke's Opening on Monday!
* Pierce: When will Catholics get the message? Never.
* Maine Republican Caucus Vote, CPAC straw poll results out Saturday night
* Rahm Emanuel puts city worker expense account payments on-line
* Catholics, Obama, contraception coverage: DNC video has Obama's back


* Sandoval fights to make public universities more accessible and affordable
* Governor Quinn Breaks Ground on $37.8 Million State Police Forensic Laboratory in Belleville - New Building Will Create 260 Jobs and Provide State-of-the-Art Forensic Capability for Area Law Enforcement
* Illinois Department of Veterans’ Affairs to honor Aurora resident as its ‘Veteran of the Month’
* Emanuel pushes statewide handgun registry
* Figures show enforcing Medicaid residency requirement could save millions

Header Photo...
Wayne Bretl


Hosted by MCS    SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version    Contact Rich Miller