Capitol Fax.com - Your Illinois News Radar » CPS says Rauner can’t legally AV pension provisions of SB1
SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
CPS says Rauner can’t legally AV pension provisions of SB1

Monday, Jul 17, 2017

* From the Chicago Public Schools…

Rich:

Here is some information on why Governor Rauner can’t legally issue an amendatory veto of SB1.

    · Under the Constitution, Governor’s power to issue amendatory veto is limited to making “specific recommendation for change.”

    · The Supreme Court has previously stated that an amendatory veto cannot either change the “fundamental purpose/intent of the legislation” or make “substantial or expansive” changes to it.

    · The purpose and intent of SB1 is to establish a new and more equitable statewide school funding formula – a new formula that holds all school districts harmless.

    · One important and essential element of this new funding formula is to remedy the long-standing unfairness in having the Chicago Public Schools be the only school district in Illinois that is solely responsible for paying all of its required pension contribution from local property taxes—as opposed to all other school districts, whose pension contributions are funded from general state revenues.

    · In the coming year, the State of Illinois is projected to spend an additional $600 million on downstate and suburban teacher pensions, for a total of $4.6 billion.

    · SB1 specifically addresses this inequity by including in the new school funding formula annual state funding to pay for Chicago’s required contribution for its teachers’ pensions. Further to this point, the floor debates on SB1 are clear that a fundamental intent of the legislation is to make teacher pension funding more equitable throughout the State.

    · By using an amendatory veto to remove funding of Chicago teacher pensions from SB1, the Governor is changing a fundamental purpose of the legislation – and he would be making a substantial change to the legislation.

    · As a result, this amendatory veto exceeds the power of the Governor under the State Constitution.

Your own thoughts?

…Adding… I’m not sure if CPS realizes this, but their argument is essentially that an AV would be ruled out of compliance by the Senate or the House. If such a ruling is made, however, the bill would die and the GA would have to start all over again.

- Posted by Rich Miller        

35 Comments
  1. - Phil King - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:21 pm:

    Political and self-interest driven nonsense.

    The Amendatory Veto would not fundamentally alter the purpose of the legislation. The Governor wants evidence based school funding formula reform (IPI does not by the way.)

    If CPS wants the state to pick up their employer pension costs, they should give up their special block grant that no other school district gets.

    They should also consider:

    1) Ending the ridiculous practice of paying the employee share of the pension contribution
    2) Reforming their pensions so that they’re affordable and don’t siphon education dollars away from CPS classrooms and downstate districts.


  2. - winners and losers - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:25 pm:

    I would be amazed if the Illinois Supreme Court agreed with the CPS argument.


  3. - Blue Bayou - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:27 pm:

    RNUG, clean-up on aisle 3.


  4. - Blue Bayou - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:28 pm:

    Hey Phil King, do you, or have you ever worked for IPI?

    The parenthetical is the tell, btw.


  5. - Anonymous - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:29 pm:

    If this is really legally true, it could get ugly fast. We just got over the budget drama. The school funding formula for the state is messed up, he might have points. Is nuking the pension portion and spewing rhetoric really his best move right now? And if it isn’t legally possible would he risk doing a full veto? (Which could be total political suicide)


  6. - Juvenal - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:30 pm:

    The prior court opinion is reflected in House rules, is I wrote here:

    https://capitolfax.com/2017/07/17/rauner-demands-sb-1-be-sent-to-him-so-he-can-av-it/#comment-12779251

    I believe it dates back to 1986.

    This is a good one for Kasper.


  7. - Arsenal - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:30 pm:

    I find it hard to deny that, if the intent of legislation is to bring all school districts under one funding formula, then exempting the biggest school district from that formula is inconsistent with that intent.


  8. - Roman - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:32 pm:

    - Phil King -

    Legislative intent is established by the legislature, not the governor.


  9. - A Jack - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:32 pm:

    The state constitution does read the way that CPS is suggesting. It’s not an appropriation so he can’t lower it. He can make recommendations and send it back. If the recommendations aren’t accepted, the bill is vetoed.

    At least that is the way it reads to me.


  10. - Paul S. - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:32 pm:

    It is my impression that SB1 does remove the block grant special to CPS - however, under the intent of no district losing funds it is included in the base funding amount. The district, in addition to other school districts in the state, negotiated the pension pick-up in exchange for much lower and/or frozen pay. Thus, it was to curb the rising costs of wages.

    Reforming their pensions - talk to the IL Supreme Court about that one.


  11. - Anonymous - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:34 pm:

    You’re absolutely right Arsenal it fully guts the reason for the bill. The question here is if he can legally take essential organs out of the bill and still call it alive.


  12. - RNUG - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:34 pm:

    == RNUG, clean-up on aisle 3. ==

    I don’t do clean-ups.

    No idea which way this one would go.


  13. - cdog - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:35 pm:

    === an amendatory veto cannot either change the “fundamental purpose/intent of the legislation” or make “substantial or expansive” changes to it. ===

    So Chicago teacher pension funding is the fundamental purpose and intent of SB1?

    That’s news to me.


  14. - Blue Bayou - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:37 pm:

    RNUG, I was just appealing to your expertise.

    We need a bat signal for you….


  15. - cdog - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:37 pm:

    === making “specific recommendation for change. ===

    AV SB1 so CPS gets a couple dollars.


  16. - A Jack - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:39 pm:

    So if he changes the bill, and the changes aren’t accepted it’s a veto and schools won’t open in the fall. Of course the GA can override the veto.


  17. - Arsenal - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:40 pm:

    ==That’s news to me.==

    Don’t be daft; the purpose was to bring everyone under one system.


  18. - Anonymous - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:42 pm:

    CPS’s first line is a farce. Of course, the Governor can legally issue an amendatory veto of SB 1.

    The Governor can issue any AV that he wants to do. It doesn’t mean it will get called in the Assembly or be legally upheld if challenged.

    Generally, the Speaker has refused to call any vetoes that seemingly go above and beyond “specific recommendations” for change.


  19. - Anonymous - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:43 pm:

    I thought one main purpose was to bring funding under a unified system instead of modifications district to district… I get the annoyance with the pension system but what’s an actual sane option other than “screw you Chicago / CPS”


  20. - Whatever - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:47 pm:

    I wish them luck with this argument. Back in 1982, the General Assembly passed a bill that said that combined income tax returns (i.e., where a conglomerate includes all of its subsidiaries on a single return) were not allowed - each corporation must file its own return. Gov. Thompson amendatorily vetoed it to not only provide that combined returns were allowed, but to add a few hundred words specifying exactly when they were and were not appropriate. The GA accepted the changes. BP argued the amendatory veto was unconstitutional because it did more than “tweak” the bill, and lost in the appellate court.


  21. - Free Set of Steak Knives - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:48 pm:

    @anonymous 2:42 argues that the governor can legally issue an illegal amendatory veto.

    Try telling that to a police officer the next time you legally make an illegal left-hand turn.


  22. - Norseman - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:59 pm:

    CPS either contacted Madigan’s staff or dipped into past stories about AV’s. In any event, Rich is right in that the bottom line is the bill dies.

    There has been a debate about how broad the gubernatorial AV power goes back at least 38 years of my following IL politics.

    The gov can make his changes and the GA can either accept or reject. The only other possible arbiter is the Supreme Court. I’d be willing to wager BIG money that the courts wouldn’t force Madigan to take a vote or tell Rauner he can’t do the AV.

    Now get back to the scenario whether they come up with a deal (my small wager is on no), or convince enough GOP members to override.


  23. - 47th Ward - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 3:00 pm:

    ===Political and self-interest driven nonsense.===

    Phil, it would save a lot of readers some time and energy if you changed your handle to that phrase above. Because everything you’ve given us so far can be described as “Political and self-interest driven nonsense.”

    Or maybe I’ll just start using “Phil King” as a synonym for it.


  24. - Commonsense in Illinois - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 3:02 pm:

    The tidbit I saw in CTU’s reasoning is: “By using an amendatory veto to remove funding of Chicago teacher pensions from SB1, the Governor is changing a fundamental purpose of the legislation…”

    So, Senator Manar, was the fundamental purpose of the legislation to establish a fairer funding formula or to remove funding of Chicago Teacher pensions?


  25. - Anonymous - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 3:13 pm:

    - Blue Bayou -

    And I was joking on the clean up.


  26. - Arthur Andersen - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 3:27 pm:

    What a bunch of baloney. I agree with Norseman, who joined the party the same time I did (38 years ago.) Also, no one ever wants to talk about the billion dollars CPS/CTPF received under Daley for pensions that was not spent on pensions.


  27. - Blue Bayou - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 3:27 pm:

    No worries, RNUG.

    Many thanks for your insightful comments and helpful explanations.


  28. - Keyser Soze - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 3:34 pm:

    Publicizing the CPS benefit under a magnifying glass now calls into question whether all SB-1 yes votes will return as expected.


  29. - Commonsense in Illinois - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 3:50 pm:

    Both Norseman and Arthur Anderson make good points. In my 40 years, “rulings” by Speaker Madigan on AVs have outnumbered rulings by the courts. Even if the Governor issues the AV, and even if the Speaker decides the AV is within the scope of what the Constitution contemplated, it is still up to the bill sponsors to call the AV for concurrence or override.

    With respect to Arthur’s mention of the dollars wasted by former Mayor Daley and CPT/CTPF, we can talk all about how the money was wasted. But unless an enterprising AUSA or ASA wants to file an information and try to get a conviction, we need to move on. It stinks, but that’s it…game over.


  30. - Anonymous - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 3:53 pm:

    Just as the governor said he “had to” veto those budgets because they were not balanced in accord with his reading of the Comstitution’s budget providions, the legislature can say they “had to” reject an AV because it’s not in compliance with the Constitution’s AV sections.

    The end result is the same: legislature passes, governor vetoes, bill dies, schools don’t open on time and fingers are pointed.

    Who’s the winner when that happens?


  31. - COPN - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 4:07 pm:

    Not a bad argument but seems like a stretch:

    ***Illinois Constitution Art. IV, Section 9(e)
    The Governor may return a bill together with specific recommendations for change to the house in which it originated.

    ***Continental Illinois Nat’l Bank & Trust Co. of Chicago v. Zagel, 78 Ill.2d 387, 398 (Ill. 1979)
    The Illinois Supreme Court held that the Governor’s use of his amendatory veto to reduce the corporate income tax to 2.5% rather than being raised to 2.85% were “specific recommendations” that “contain no change in the fundamental purpose of the legislation, nor are they so substantial or so expansive as to render his use of the veto power violative of section 9(e) of article IV” of the Illinois Constitution. The case involved legislation to replace revenue lost due to the abolition of the personal property tax pursuant to section 5(c) of article IX of the Illinois Constitution.

    ***House Rule 78(c) & Senate Rule 9-2(a)
    The Governor’s specific recommendations for change with respect to a bill returned under subsection (e) of Section 9 of Article IV of the Illinois Constitution shall be limited to addressing the Governor’s objections to portions of a bill the general merit of which the Governor recognizes and shall not alter the fundamental purpose or legislative scheme set forth in the bill as passed.


  32. - COPN - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 4:10 pm:

    ===If such a ruling is made [out of compliance], however, the bill would die===

    I think that may bar only motions to accept, but not motions to override according to Senate Rule 9-2(b) and House Rule 78(d)


  33. - Phil King - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 4:11 pm:

    ==Hey Phil King, do you, or have you ever worked for IPI?==

    Nope.


  34. - Cadillac - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 8:53 pm:

    === - Phil King - Monday, Jul 17, 17 @ 2:21 pm:

    They should also consider:

    1) Ending the ridiculous practice of paying the employee share of the pension contribution ===

    Bingo.


  35. - undiscovered country - Tuesday, Jul 18, 17 @ 8:22 am:

    the problem with the cops point of view which has been touched on here is that it would require the courts (quickly) to say that rauners av is not a veto at all if not constitutionally valid, but rather is a pocket signature. THAT would be a transformational decision that alters the balance of power within state govt. unlikely in the extreme.


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* Reader comments closed for the weekend
* Brady makes some unusual appointments to discrimination and harassment task force
* Pritzker sues endorser, deletes ad she appeared in
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Candidate announcement
* Best tweet of the day
* Question of the day
* Roskam race moved to "Toss Up" by Cook Political Report
* Kennedy lashes out at Emanuel, while Pritzker takes a softer approach
* Rauner refuses to weigh in on federal tax legislation
* Reports: Former Munger firm gets $12.5 million no-bid contract after a $12 million payment was frozen by Mendoza
* "Every time I see a little kid waving I always try to wave back"
* Londrigan, EMILY's List stand by their false statements
* In praise of Mary Ann Ahern
* George Will: Illinois "approaching a death spiral"
* Rauner urged to sign education funding "cleanup" bill
* Republican Party wants Durbin, Duckworth to give away Franken's cash
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
* Open thread
* Yesterday's stories

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............
<


Loading


* McHenry County Board asks Gov. Bruce Rauner to .....
* In Illinois, looming battle over the bankruptin.....
* Will: Illinois Gov out to smash bankrupt 'blue .....
* George Will: Governor tries to save Illinois fr.....
* In Illinois, a Looming Battle Over the Bankrupt.....
* Doubek: For harassment and beyond, Springfield .....
* Bernard Schoenburg: Ives says Rauner joined ‘ru.....
* George Will: In Illinois, a looming battle over.....
* Statehouse Insider: Republican primary for gove.....
* Bernard Schoenburg: Ives says Rauner joined 'ru.....


* Chicago-area school chief who is to resign denies harassment
* Ex-Merrillville councilman admits guilt in bribery case
* Newspaper investigation finds Illinois raffle irregularities
* Newspaper investigation finds Illinois raffle irregularities
* $80M Mississippi River bridge opens from Illinois to Iowa
* $80M Mississippi River bridge opens from Illinois to Iowa
* New temporary US attorney named for central Illinois
* New temporary US attorney named for central Illinois
* EXCHANGE: Ex-general says military is a 'young man's game'
* EXCHANGE: Illinois family's service spans generations

* Electric cars, better fuel efficiency spell doom for Illinois gas tax
* Springfield wants out of legislation limiting payments for 5G antennas
* Fact check: Are Gov. Rauner's grandparents immigrants?
* Londrigan accused of attacking Davis for 'opposite' of remarks
* Gov. Rauner signs sex harassment legislation
* Under the Dome Podcast: Governor's race, sexual harassment, Rodney Davis
* Macoupin Co. highway renamed in honor of soldier who died in Vietnam
* Macoupin Co. highway renamed in honor of solder who died in Vietnam
* Schoenburg: Rep. Davis leads new caucus, pleased with White House access
* Rep. Davis leads new caucus, pleased with White House access

* Here's how Baker McKenzie profits from offshore tax system
* Cards Against Humanity works to maintain its naughtiness
* The either/or world of Cards Against Humanity: Funny or Die
* Why do people give? Not for the tax break.
* Wise up: Government budgets in Illinois are not balanced


* Georgia Nicols horoscopes for Nov. 19, 2017
* Spokeswoman: David Cassidy in hospital with organ failure
* ‘SNL’ host Chance the Rapper creates a new Thanksgiving anthem
* 4 wounded in Chicago weekend shootings
* MAP: Chicago weekend shootings tracker for Nov. 17 – 20
* Man charged with stabbing off-duty CPD officer in ‘domestic incident’
* Prosser Career Academy students win Cooking Up Change chef competition
* Artem Anisimov scores winner as Hawks continue dominance over Pens
* Man found fatally shot in Hainesville driveway
* Acid Redux: The lesson Cubs provide for Astros, other dynasty seekers


* Receptive Ryan: Scianna's TD catch lifts Lincoln-Way East into state finals
* LaToya Cantrell will become first woman mayor in New Orleans' history
* Lena Dunham under fire after defending 'Girls' writer accused of sexual assault
* Kwaku Appiah's return TD sparks Lincoln-Way East past Maine South
* After allowing shorthanded goal, Blackhawks finish power play with winning score
* 'Partridge Family' star David Cassidy in hospital with organ failure: spokeswoman
* Blackhawks and Bruins to play 2019 Winter Classic at Notre Dame Stadium
* U.S. general says order to launch nuclear weapons can be refused if illegal
* Man, 21, charged in stabbing of off-duty Chicago police officer
* Brandon Wimbush turnaround leads Notre Dame over Navy 24-17


» State Week: Are Voters Thinking About 2018?
» Legislative Checklist: Veto Session
» How 3 Women Want To Make Illinois’ Political Future Female
» Illinois Supreme Court Weighing Seizure Of Woman’s Harley
» Illinois Supreme Court Weighing Seizure Of Woman's Harley
» Statehouse Ethical Issues Might Need Outside Oversight, Legislators Say
» Prosecutor: No More Indictments In Laquan McDonald Shooting
» Metra Board OKs Budget With Service Cuts, Fare Hikes In 2018
» For Illinois Sex Offenders, Six Years Can Turn Into Life In Prison
» State Week: Harassment Training, Veto Wins And Losses, Late Payments


* Bernard Schoenburg: Ives says Rauner joined 'ruling class' he was to fight
* Statehouse Insider: Republican primary for governor underway
* Doubek: For harassment and beyond, Springfield needs stronger accountability
* Jim Dixon: It is time for a fair tax for Illinois
* Our View: It’s time for decision on YWCA block
* Electric cars, better fuel efficiency spell doom for Illinois gas tax
* Ed Rogers: A Clinton special counsel won't help Republicans in 2018
* Guest View: Rural health care providers deserve our thanks
* Springfield wants out of legislation limiting payments for 5G antennas
* Fact check: Are Gov. Rauner's grandparents immigrants?


* Decatur police investigating possible late night shooting
* PHOTOS: Decatur Christmas Parade 2017
* SIUC chancellor reveals second draft of academic restructuring plan
* HS 2A Football Semifinal: GCMS vs. Newman Central Catholic
* Gubernatorial candidate McGuire holds education round table in Davenport
* HS Girls State Swim Finals
* HS Football Playoffs: Tuscola vs Athens
* Boy Scouts collect nearly 2 million food items during Scouting for Food drive
* LIVE! Ohio State
* Rajic wins two state titles; Tuscola, GCMS football advance to state


* Mavericks stop 4-game slide with win against Bucks
* Herbert returns, Oregon beats Arizona 48-28
* Boys bowling: Scouting Lake County
* Officials: McHenry County jail inmate's death under investigation
* Harden scores 29 to lead Rockets past Grizzlies 105-83

* Hultgren whishes McHenry County College a ...
* Hultgren and Ruppersberger: Protect infras...
* Shaun Alexander: I'm amazed by the authori...
* US lawmakers urge Trump to prod Rody on dr...
* SULLUM: Trump's 'great relationship' with ...
* This RSS feed URL is deprecated
* Rep. Randy Hultgren congratulates McHenry ...
* 3 suburban GOP reps provide crucial votes ...
* US lawmakers to Duterte: 'Sovereignty does...
* Local Congressmen React to the Passage of ...

* This RSS feed URL is deprecated...

* This RSS feed URL is deprecated...

* Randi Weingarten’s secret meeting with Steve Bannon.
* Believe women.
* SNL Watch Party at SMG-Chatham
* The Weekend Desk Report
* The Weekend In Chicago Rock
* The Week In Chicago Rock
* Sunday week in review.
* Keeping retirement weird. Our Miss Brooks.
* SportsMonday: Peak Bears
* Trump FCC Opens Corporate Media Merger Floodgates


* Illinois Awarded Funds to Offer Advanced Training on Detecting Impaired Driving
* Illinois EPA Announces Upcoming Household Hazardous Waste Collection Events
* IEMA Highlights Emergency Preparedness for People with Access and Functional Needs in May - Ready Illinois website offers preparedness tips for people, caregivers
* First Lady Launches Illinois Family Connects
* Governor and Lt. Governor Unveil 2016 Journal of Local Government Shared Service Best Practices

  
* Google Pixel 2 bootloader issues, iPhone X fixes & more – Pocketnow Daily
* [Sponsored] Take advantage of Tomtop’s electric treadmill flash sale!
* NFL may expand match livestreaming away from Verizon phones
* Razer Hammerhead USB-C earbuds designed to compliment Razer Phone
* Honor V10 specs reportedly include headphone jack, slightly smaller battery
* The Razer Phone is now available at select Microsoft Stores
* HomePod unceremoniously delayed until early 2018

* Sporcle Saturday: Top player performances
* LIVE: MLB Awards unveiled on Network
* White Sox face roster call on Clarkin, 6 more
* Thyago Vieira brings missing heat to White Sox bullpen battle
* MLB Awards grand finale (7 CT, MLB Network)
* White Sox trade for hard-throwing Vieira
* White Sox acquire prospect Vieira from M's


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Blagojevich Trial
Advertising
Updated Posts
Polls

Archives
November 2017
October 2017
September 2017
August 2017
July 2017
June 2017
May 2017
April 2017
March 2017
February 2017
January 2017
December 2016
November 2016
October 2016
September 2016
August 2016
July 2016
June 2016
May 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress




Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller