Governors own, they always do, and owning successes and investing in infrastructure, and anything you can *point* to as an accomplishment, it’s a good ad.
It’s tacking and blocking, a 4-yard running play, and you stack enough of those running plays you score touchdowns.
Kinda weak sauce. A slight pass to run in Rockford area. A fail beyond there. People in Chicago would likely be more interested in jobs there than 80 miles away.
C-.
I guess it legitimately doesn’t matter what he spends his money since he has an infinite amount, but I think this trying to paint JB as a competent manager of state government on things that no one has heard of is curious. I think it’ll have the opposite effect.
That being said, if you’re the family/close friend of someone in the commercial, A-. Your friend is on TV, so that’s cool.
I dunno if in one breath one might say Pritzker only cares about Chicago then not be impressed when Pritzker shows things outside of Chicago, like investing, and dismiss it.
It seems that there’s a purposeful strategy that shows Pritzker cares about Illinois, not a pandering to Chicago needs.
B a very solid professional add that sticks with the theme that he is governor for the whole state and has worked to improve all corners. Very much on message and positive. Unlike the ridiculous armageddon ads from Sully and Irvin.
= 80 miles away.=
That is actually the point. Pritzker isn’t just about Chicago.
- Colin O'Scopy - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:31 am:
I give it an A-. Take a victory lap when there is one to be had as it’s a good story to tell.
JB’s wardrobe does confound me. The “working man” look on billionaires just seems off, and that included Rauner’s faux-regular guy schtick.
I suppose he just doesn’t feel comfortable with the way he looks. He has a difficult frame to clothe.
A solid B. Pritzker can continue to roll out a steady stream of messages targeted at accomplishments throughout the state while his opponents shift from outrage to outrage. Whether it’s in Rockford, Chicago, or Carbondale, this is what good governing looks like.
=What’s not said is most of the expansion/improvements were started (planned and programmed) under Quinn and Rauner.=
Kind of shows the consequences of Rauner’s messaging. Rivian is now on track to produce 200 cars a week in the plant that we couldn’t give away. Nice to have a governor that sees the benefit in touting business growth in this state.
“People in Chicago would likely be more interested”
Damned if you do….
- Back to the Future - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:02 am:
B grade for the Ad.
F for the timing of the Ad.
Just yesterday DCFS was rated the worst it has been in 30 years after almost 4 years of Pritzker poor management. While the Director of this tragedy continues to be held in contempt for what he is doing to children, Mr. Pritzker runs a “look at me” Ad.
How about helping those children?
Maybe I am just stuck on that news report, but to me this just highlights Team Pritzker’s “politics over people” philosophy.
=Just yesterday DCFS was rated the worst it has been in 30 years after almost 4 years of Pritzker poor management.=
And that will be part of the record that Pritzker will have to run on as well. But are you suggesting that he should avoid running any positive ads as some sort of penance? I’m guessing that you aren’t the audience he’s aiming this message at.
Grade: B. Ad shows the Governor acting like an adult doing his job and not over promising/bragging. A low bar, I know, but one so few politicians manage to clear these days.
Good ad. Easy B. Keep getting positive messages across. Glad to see Rockford get some serious attention. Just got to wonder what would happen if Coles County International Airport had a similar development. The Eastern Bloc would have a split brain seizure then find something else to complain about.
C-, JB have you heard of Bell Bowl Prairie at this airport? You care about Illinois? How about protecting one of the last remnants of an orginal unplowed prairie. Economic progress over the environment, smh. BTW you can build the cargo area and save the prairie, just takws some creative solutions to stormwateer
=== I would advise anyone running to use her as much as possible===
Agreed. She makes that ad.
- here we go again - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:38 am:
Solid A-. Amplifying regional economic success is a smart re-election strategy. If he “owns” DCFS, well, he owns regional economic successes as well. The path for the general election is to stay competitive downstate as a Democrat and this type of ad keeps him in the hunt.
Rate it a C- - JB sending a mixed message. Jobs yes but what about environment ?
With all that cargo growth what about the prairie destruction. And the Cargo jets that are being attracted are 747’s old jets that are some of the worst in terms of Co2 pollution…
“Within three years, Dunn said the airport expects “to be running from 120 to 140 747s per month.”
C for Carhartt but I’m not completely sure that’s a Carhartt jacket so I am withholding that grade. Governor Pritzker is a man who loves to layer.
I don’t want to be harsh about the kind of video the Governor has to be making as an incumbent demonstrating things that he’s done that have gone well. This is an A- ad for Northern Illinois and a B- ad for Southern Illinois. I think it’s effectiveness is based entirely on where the ad buy is.
= runs completely counter to JB’s so-called green creds.=
The governor is supporting the funding of projects, not hunting down endangered owls.
Are your standards so rigid that one must be all or none? If so there are many on the blog with long memories that will hold you to those strict standards. Just saying.
The RKFD airport growth is very good for an area that has long felt left out of the states plans. The airport has been a catalyst for economic growth in an are that needed it desperately. This is a very good thing. Prairie ground notwithstanding.
== But are you suggesting that he should avoid running any positive ads as some sort of penance?==
I mentioned this when we looked at one of Irvin’s ads, too- a candidate’s ads just aren’t going to mention any bad news about the candidate, and it’s silly to expect them to do so.
==in a green environment we need to be limiting airfreight the best we can==
Yup, I’m just absolutely sure that you of all people think we should be prioritizing environmental regulations over jobs.
Grading criteria are always relevant, right? I would give this a C in that it is just normal, average, what I would expect. I would give it a B because it is upbeat and optimistic. I would give it a B because it does not appear to make any mistakes.
I would give it an A for not being mean, angry, attacking (see my comment on Open Threat, where I express frustration with other campaign ads - Matthew Rauschert)
I like it. Tell them what you’re doing and take credit for it it. Keep stacking up accomplishments. Carharts work here. Carharts spells working people and jobs. It’s a solid B.
==Carharts work here. Carharts spells working people and jobs.==
I dunno if they “work” or not- I suspect most voters don’t actually care. As much as we made fun of Rauner’s wardrobe (and then, oddly, also criticized Pritzker’s ad that made fun of it, too), I would be surprised if that wasn’t the least of the average voter’s concerns.
- Torco Sign - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:14 am:
C. It seems like a commercial for Southwest or something. Not bad but not compelling at all.
- May Soon Be Required - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:15 am:
He didn’t learn from Rauner about carharts?
- Live Wire - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:18 am:
Carharts are ok, leather vest with a Governor patch is a step too far
- Oswego Willy - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:18 am:
It’s a solid B, it’s what incumbents do.
Governors own, they always do, and owning successes and investing in infrastructure, and anything you can *point* to as an accomplishment, it’s a good ad.
It’s tacking and blocking, a 4-yard running play, and you stack enough of those running plays you score touchdowns.
It’s a B.
A reminder. Governors own.
- A Guy - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:19 am:
Kinda weak sauce. A slight pass to run in Rockford area. A fail beyond there. People in Chicago would likely be more interested in jobs there than 80 miles away.
- SWSider - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:22 am:
C-.
I guess it legitimately doesn’t matter what he spends his money since he has an infinite amount, but I think this trying to paint JB as a competent manager of state government on things that no one has heard of is curious. I think it’ll have the opposite effect.
That being said, if you’re the family/close friend of someone in the commercial, A-. Your friend is on TV, so that’s cool.
- Oswego Willy - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:24 am:
I dunno if in one breath one might say Pritzker only cares about Chicago then not be impressed when Pritzker shows things outside of Chicago, like investing, and dismiss it.
It seems that there’s a purposeful strategy that shows Pritzker cares about Illinois, not a pandering to Chicago needs.
Blocking and tacking.
- JS Mill - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:28 am:
B a very solid professional add that sticks with the theme that he is governor for the whole state and has worked to improve all corners. Very much on message and positive. Unlike the ridiculous armageddon ads from Sully and Irvin.
= 80 miles away.=
That is actually the point. Pritzker isn’t just about Chicago.
- Colin O'Scopy - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:31 am:
I give it an A-. Take a victory lap when there is one to be had as it’s a good story to tell.
JB’s wardrobe does confound me. The “working man” look on billionaires just seems off, and that included Rauner’s faux-regular guy schtick.
I suppose he just doesn’t feel comfortable with the way he looks. He has a difficult frame to clothe.
- Pundent - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:31 am:
A solid B. Pritzker can continue to roll out a steady stream of messages targeted at accomplishments throughout the state while his opponents shift from outrage to outrage. Whether it’s in Rockford, Chicago, or Carbondale, this is what good governing looks like.
- Amalia - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:33 am:
B. shows real progress for an area outside of Chicago on money from airports. also makes Chicago people happy that cargo may be diverted.
- Cheryl44 - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:36 am:
Solid B. It’s a reminder JB is governor of the entire state.
- Gordon Willis - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:38 am:
Nice ad, speaks to the center. What’s not said is most of the expansion/improvements were started (planned and programmed) under Quinn and Rauner.
- Franklin - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:41 am:
Nice of the Governor to spend some of his trust fund on an ad for the Rockford airport.
- Al - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:45 am:
Confused. We are closing coal power plants due to global warming. Not sure air cargo is part of a sustainable carbon neutral path forward.
- Colin O'Scopy - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:46 am:
=Nice of the Governor to spend some of his trust fund on an ad for the Rockford airport.-
Would you prefer he be the beneficiary of other peoples’ “trust funds”, like Ken Griffin or Dick Uhlein? How about the Koch family?
- Oswego Willy - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:46 am:
===… spend some of his trust fund…===
… and yet, only as governor, could Pritzker do what this ad presents.
You didn’t rate the ad, why?
- Grandson of Man - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:51 am:
Pretty solid, an A. Pritzker has a direct hand in economic growth, and shows it through the people he’s helped.
- Pundent - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 8:53 am:
=What’s not said is most of the expansion/improvements were started (planned and programmed) under Quinn and Rauner.=
Kind of shows the consequences of Rauner’s messaging. Rivian is now on track to produce 200 cars a week in the plant that we couldn’t give away. Nice to have a governor that sees the benefit in touting business growth in this state.
- JS Mill - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:00 am:
=Not sure air cargo is part of a sustainable carbon neutral path forward.=
So you want us to go all electric?
And the GOP wonders why all it can do is yell at the clouds.
- Flyin' Elvis'-Utah Chapter - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:01 am:
B+-Incumbent gets things done.
“People in Chicago would likely be more interested”
Damned if you do….
- Back to the Future - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:02 am:
B grade for the Ad.
F for the timing of the Ad.
Just yesterday DCFS was rated the worst it has been in 30 years after almost 4 years of Pritzker poor management. While the Director of this tragedy continues to be held in contempt for what he is doing to children, Mr. Pritzker runs a “look at me” Ad.
How about helping those children?
Maybe I am just stuck on that news report, but to me this just highlights Team Pritzker’s “politics over people” philosophy.
- Pundent - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:05 am:
=Just yesterday DCFS was rated the worst it has been in 30 years after almost 4 years of Pritzker poor management.=
And that will be part of the record that Pritzker will have to run on as well. But are you suggesting that he should avoid running any positive ads as some sort of penance? I’m guessing that you aren’t the audience he’s aiming this message at.
- Arsenal - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:06 am:
Another solid B. Nothing revolutionary, but targeting Rockford is smart. Dems have room to grow there.
- Rachel - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:11 am:
Grade: B. Ad shows the Governor acting like an adult doing his job and not over promising/bragging. A low bar, I know, but one so few politicians manage to clear these days.
- Rudy’s teeth - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:12 am:
Rate B
Generally positive message. Minimal to no doom and gloom. A plus for zero “you know.”
- zatoichi - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:19 am:
Good ad. Easy B. Keep getting positive messages across. Glad to see Rockford get some serious attention. Just got to wonder what would happen if Coles County International Airport had a similar development. The Eastern Bloc would have a split brain seizure then find something else to complain about.
- BluegrassBoy - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:20 am:
C-, JB have you heard of Bell Bowl Prairie at this airport? You care about Illinois? How about protecting one of the last remnants of an orginal unplowed prairie. Economic progress over the environment, smh. BTW you can build the cargo area and save the prairie, just takws some creative solutions to stormwateer
- City Zen - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:30 am:
D because the Bell Bowl Prairie controversy has yet to be resolved and paying over it runs completely counter to JB’s so-called green creds.
The woman at the 6 second mark that exclaims “Rockford” saves it from a failing grade. I would advise anyone running to use her as much as possible.
- Rich Miller - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:35 am:
=== I would advise anyone running to use her as much as possible===
Agreed. She makes that ad.
- here we go again - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:38 am:
Solid A-. Amplifying regional economic success is a smart re-election strategy. If he “owns” DCFS, well, he owns regional economic successes as well. The path for the general election is to stay competitive downstate as a Democrat and this type of ad keeps him in the hunt.
- Donnie Elgin - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:39 am:
Rate it a C- - JB sending a mixed message. Jobs yes but what about environment ?
With all that cargo growth what about the prairie destruction. And the Cargo jets that are being attracted are 747’s old jets that are some of the worst in terms of Co2 pollution…
“Within three years, Dunn said the airport expects “to be running from 120 to 140 747s per month.”
https://www.rrstar.com/story/news/2021/06/01/rockford-airport-expansion-bring-hundreds-new-jobs/7494094002/
- Bruce( no not him) - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:45 am:
Downstate thinks Rockford is Chicago.
If you want to get downstate to notice, come farther south.
- Blue Dog - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 9:54 am:
C-. in a green environment we need to be limiting airfreight the best we can.
- Candy Dogood - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 10:00 am:
C for Carhartt but I’m not completely sure that’s a Carhartt jacket so I am withholding that grade. Governor Pritzker is a man who loves to layer.
I don’t want to be harsh about the kind of video the Governor has to be making as an incumbent demonstrating things that he’s done that have gone well. This is an A- ad for Northern Illinois and a B- ad for Southern Illinois. I think it’s effectiveness is based entirely on where the ad buy is.
- JS Mill - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 10:04 am:
= runs completely counter to JB’s so-called green creds.=
The governor is supporting the funding of projects, not hunting down endangered owls.
Are your standards so rigid that one must be all or none? If so there are many on the blog with long memories that will hold you to those strict standards. Just saying.
The RKFD airport growth is very good for an area that has long felt left out of the states plans. The airport has been a catalyst for economic growth in an are that needed it desperately. This is a very good thing. Prairie ground notwithstanding.
- Henry - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 10:17 am:
I agree it is a solid ad. I believe Rockford was fastest growing cargo airport before JB was elected?
- Pundent - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 10:30 am:
=in a green environment we need to be limiting airfreight the best we can=
How exactly? And where’s the candidate willing to run on this premise with a viable alternative plan?
- Arsenal - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 11:39 am:
== But are you suggesting that he should avoid running any positive ads as some sort of penance?==
I mentioned this when we looked at one of Irvin’s ads, too- a candidate’s ads just aren’t going to mention any bad news about the candidate, and it’s silly to expect them to do so.
==in a green environment we need to be limiting airfreight the best we can==
Yup, I’m just absolutely sure that you of all people think we should be prioritizing environmental regulations over jobs.
- H-W - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 11:59 am:
Grading criteria are always relevant, right? I would give this a C in that it is just normal, average, what I would expect. I would give it a B because it is upbeat and optimistic. I would give it a B because it does not appear to make any mistakes.
I would give it an A for not being mean, angry, attacking (see my comment on Open Threat, where I express frustration with other campaign ads - Matthew Rauschert)
- The Dude - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 3:37 pm:
C at best.
Very forgettable.
- Chris Waller - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 4:37 pm:
I like it. Tell them what you’re doing and take credit for it it. Keep stacking up accomplishments. Carharts work here. Carharts spells working people and jobs. It’s a solid B.
- Anonymous - Wednesday, Mar 23, 22 @ 4:55 pm:
==Carharts work here. Carharts spells working people and jobs.==
I dunno if they “work” or not- I suspect most voters don’t actually care. As much as we made fun of Rauner’s wardrobe (and then, oddly, also criticized Pritzker’s ad that made fun of it, too), I would be surprised if that wasn’t the least of the average voter’s concerns.