* Sun-Times…
The abrupt resignation on Friday of Mayor Brandon Johnson’s third chief financial officer in a year could trigger another drop in Chicago’s already shaky bond rating and scare investors away from the city’s bonds.
Ashlee Gabrysch’s departure sent shock waves through City Hall and beyond — her resignation comes in the middle of a budget stalemate, after just three months as CFO. Even more damaging than Gabrysch’s sudden exit is what she said on her way out the door.
A former Wall Street executive, Gabrysch issued a statement saying she was unwilling to compromise her financial integrity. She did not reveal what it was she was asked to do that would have damaged her reputation.
* Gabrysch’s full statement…
“As the City of Chicago’s Chief Financial Officer, there is nothing more important than my fiduciary duty to the City and its taxpayers. The Chief Financial Officer’s statements about city finances are not idle chatter: they are relied upon by investors, ratings agencies, City Council, and taxpayers. The CFO must act scrupulously to ensure they are always accurate and complete.
“Throughout my career, I have remained committed to upholding the highest standards of financial integrity and transparency, and in my short time as Chief Financial Officer, I have faithfully discharged this duty. It has become apparent, however, that to continue in this role would be to compromise my integrity and professional obligations. I therefore have concluded that I must step down from my role, and hereby tender my resignation.”
* The response from Johnson’s office. Crain’s…
“The city of Chicago is facing a serious budget crisis following decades of mismanagement. It is concerning that, during her short tenure, Ashlee was largely absent during critical periods of the City’s budget preparation process. Additionally, her decision to direct the City Treasurer to issue a $75 million payment without proper legal authority or following the required processes raises serious concerns,” the statement said.
It was not immediately clear what the payment is in reference to. But the City Council secured $75 million from the transfer of the city’s parking meter concession and directed it towards a one-time pension payment in 2026.
“Our administration made multiple attempts to meet with her to discuss this action and seek an explanation, including shortly before her public resignation,” the statement said.
“Those attempts went unresolved. Given the seriousness of these concerns, we will refer the matter to the City’s Office of Inspector General for independent review. We welcome a full review of the conduct at issue. Our administration takes its responsibility to protect taxpayer dollars, uphold the law, and ensure the responsible management of City finances seriously. We expect every City official to meet that standard,” the statement said.
* Some background from the Tribune…
Johnson’s budget team pegged next year’s budget gap at $882 million during the forecast deficit rollout in September. When Johnson formally introduced his budget last month, that number shrank to $662 million – a figure that the administration attributed to plans to borrow for the cost of police settlements.
With that number removed from the city’s deficit, Johnson claimed 76% of his gap-filling proposals were structural. Gabrysch disputed that figure during the first day of public budget hearings, saying those settlement costs were part of the deficit and that borrowing to cover it should be counted as a one-time gap-filling measure. With both in mind, she said structural solutions made up 56% of the mayor’s proposal.
“The 76% number comes from removing settlements and judgments from the denominator,” she said at the time. “I stick with the $882 (million) forecasted budget… that is my denominator.” […]
Johnson at the time denied any attempts by his administration to hide the ball. “Look, we were obviously incredibly transparent,” Johnson said when asked about the discrepancy.
* CBS Chicago…
A number of Johnson’s top aides have departed in the past year, including chief legal counsel Mary Richardson-Lowry, budget director Annette Guzman, public health commissioner Olusimbo Ige, police superintendent Larry Snelling and both the city’s preview CFO Jill Jaworski and her interim replacement, acting CFO Steven Mahr.
Alderman Bill Conway, who represents the city’s 34th Ward and serves as Finance Committee Vice Chair in the city council, released a statement calling for an immediate investigation into the resignation.
“In her resignation letter, Ms. Gabrysch wrote that the CFO’s statements must be ‘complete and accurate’ and that she is ‘not able to fulfill those obligations under the conditions in which I have been asked to serve,’” Conway’s statement says in part. “This is an obvious indication that she was asked by the Mayor’s Office to present false information.”
* Gabrysch’s response to the mayor’s statement…
Gabrysch: “This effort by the administration to deflect from the serious issues at stake and attack those who attempt to hold them accountable is disappointing but not surprising. I stand by my statement and will continue to operate in accordance with my values and integrity.”
- Timber Cove Chillin - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 11:36 am:
If he botched the petitions on purpose that would be a solid way to go out tbh
- Moe Berg - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 11:39 am:
Gee, who to believe here? A real head-scratcher.
Several points of commonality between the Johnson Administration and Trump Administration: utter, rank incompetence, constant dissembling, and record-setting abilities to find rakes to step on.
- Levois - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 11:42 am:
I knew someone was going to bring up the Mayor’s petition.
- Three Dimensional Checkers - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 11:50 am:
Mayor Johnson has always lied to the public, the press, investors, everyone. This is nothing new. It is disappointing that they expect some vindication from the Inspector General.
- 44 - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 11:52 am:
“Compromise my integrity”. Let that sink in. Astonishing. Talk about the need for an independent investigation! Perhaps she goes back to a rating agency and writes up a detailed report! We can only hope.
- Candy Dogood - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 12:02 pm:
I don’t think it is much of a surprise to see another CFO leave. Chicago is not exactly flush with cash reserves that would make that job a cake walk, but the resignation itself is a suggestion that the position was taken by someone who perhaps was not adequately committed to the role. Someone who spent years working for a bond rating agency deciding to use their resignation letter as a public statement is an interesting choice, especially since it reflects something that is her opinion and could have dramatic financial impacts on the city and the public without the detail and analysis that would make it easier to defend that statement, but;
=== they are relied upon by investors, ratings agencies, City Council, and taxpayers===
I am not used to public servants listing their duty to investors and rating agencies before the public at large. That’s odd.
Anyhow, I hope that there’s some real beef behind the basis for her statement.
- levivotedforjudy - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 12:06 pm:
This is a quicky and so far nasty divorce. She has stated fairly clearly that she wasn’t going to make false statements or present inaccurate information. My mayor should not poke that bear if he’s smart. Just let her fade away.
- JS Mill - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 12:08 pm:
=It is concerning that, during her short tenure, Ashlee was largely absent during critical periods of the City’s budget preparation process. Additionally, her decision to direct the City Treasurer to issue a $75 million payment without proper legal authority or following the required processes raises serious concerns,” the statement said.=
LOL, so AFTER the CFO departs they share this? Sorry, color me skeptical.
I agree with everything @Moe Berg posted. CTU and the trump admin often employing identical tactics.
- Chris Partliw’s Afro - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 12:18 pm:
I thought the Johnson Administration line was not to discuss personnel matters?
- Candy Dogood - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 12:47 pm:
===LOL, so AFTER the CFO departs they share this? Sorry, color me skeptical.===
This is all pretty odd. But usually one does not publicly feud with an employee in the press. A former employee? Okay, I guess.
I am fully prepared to wait to cast any significant judgement. At the end of the day, I have a hard time trusting Chicago city government officials, especially when they’re at odds with each other, and I am not exactly a fan of how rating agencies treat public finance either due to their tendency to declare imaginary risk so bond markets demand higher interest rates on bonds that are usually over subscribed.
- NIU Grad - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 12:49 pm:
April can’t come soon enough…who will actually manage the finances between now and then is anyone’s guess. The Mayor is probably close to calling in someone from CTU, because they’re the ones calling the shots anyway.
- DS - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 1:37 pm:
The next three plus months before the municipal election are going to be agonizing.
- Six Degrees of Separation - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 1:38 pm:
8-10-26 was only three months ago.
“Ashlee Gabrysch brings an extraordinary depth of knowledge of Chicago’s finances and the fiscal challenges facing cities across Illinois and the country,” said Mayor Brandon Johnson. “Her experience inside government, in public finance research, and analyzing Chicago’s credit gives her a unique perspective on the opportunities and challenges before our city. Ashlee understands that sound financial management requires building the long-term stability necessary to continue making investments in neighborhoods, deliver essential services, and create a safer, more affordable Chicago. I look forward to working with her to strengthen our city’s financial position and build a stronger fiscal future for Chicago.”
- JS Mill - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 1:49 pm:
= I have a hard time trusting Chicago city government officials, =
Agreed. Add in the CTU leadership connection and my skepticism only deepens.
=and I am not exactly a fan of how rating agencies treat public finance either due to their tendency to declare imaginary risk=
A different topic for me, but I cannot agree more. Having been through a number of school bond issuances and ratings calls I have zero trust in bond ratings. We should be AAA everytime. Our bonds are backed by a tax levy. We rarely get better than an A-
- Amalia - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 1:57 pm:
this is a long and continuing train wreck. and yet if he stays on the ballot, the lakefront and NW side DSA types who ignore reality could combine with Black voters and get him in the runoff and maybe a win.
- Big Dipper - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 2:01 pm:
If the administration’s behavior is not surprising why did she accept the job?
- low level - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 2:04 pm:
Ashlee was superb, as was Jill Jaworski and Steve Mehr before her. As for the nonsensical charges, she made the $75M payment after City Council passed the revised meter deal in September. The most recent council action was clarifying in nature after the Mayor’s budget tried to incorporate it into their budget instead of treating it as an additional payment.
They were ready to fire her so she got ahead kf them. Good for her - that was the right move. Then we learn they want to bring in the Inspector General to investigate the timing of the $75M payment? Utter nonsense.
I have never seen a more incompetent group of idiots on the 4th and 5th Floors. Just when I thought it couldn’t get any worse, it did. Unbelievable.
- Woodworth - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 2:15 pm:
Thankfully he is not going to make it on the ballot. The administrative incompetence extended to the campaign side to the benefit of this City’s future.
- Rudy’s teeth - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 2:21 pm:
Shuffling deck chairs on the Titanic…I mean the Fifth floor at City Hall.
- low level - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 3:21 pm:
== Shuffling deck chairs on the Titanic…I mean the Fifth floor at City Hall.==
I don’t agree. With the proper management, things will improve but it will take people with vision and foresight. A competent Mayor and IGA team would help.
- Leslie K - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 3:40 pm:
Between a mayor with a record of petulant behavior who likes to blame others for his own failures and a financial professional with a reputation to protect, I’ll go with the financial professional. Unclear why she took the position in the first place, but glad she seems to be standing up to him.
- Chat_BP3 - Friday, Nov 13, 26 @ 3:43 pm:
What an absolute disaster of an administration. This term can’t end soon enough.