LIVE session coverage...
SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year.
We’ve seen this problem before

Monday, Nov 28, 2011

* My Sun-Times column last Friday was about the gaming bill’s prospects. I’ve essentially written this same column a few times in the past, whenever a gaming bill appeared to be floundering due to a lack of support by all the leaders. Still, it’s worth the reminder

The last two decades give us a pretty simple Illinois history lesson: Unless all four state legislative leaders and the governor are pulling hard in the same direction, no gambling expansion bill can become law.

The last significant bill passed a few months after Gov. Pat Quinn was sworn into office. That proposal got rid of the illegal and unregulated video poker machines in taverns, truck stops and fraternal organizations such as Veterans of Foreign Wars posts and replaced them with a new system controlled by the state.

The unprecedented expansion was designed to help fund Illinois’ massive infrastructure program and was backed by all the biggest players, including the governor, the House speaker, the Senate president and both Republican minority leaders.

Prior to that, former Gov. George Ryan was able to pass a gaming bill that moved a long-dormant casino from near Galena to Rosemont. The move looked simple on paper, but the intricacies of all the deals that had to be cut with existing casino owners, Chicago’s mayor and racetrack owners were mind-boggling.

The other casino owners did everything they could to protect their monopolies, and the track owners, after years of decline, wanted a piece of the pie. But even Ryan, a master of the legislative process, couldn’t pass the big plan he really wanted, which would’ve allowed riverboat casinos in Cook County.

Three gambling expansion plans died under Gov. Rod Blagojevich, and the same fate befell a huge expansion proposal under Gov. Jim Edgar. The common denominator was the lack of unanimous support by the five biggies.

So, it’s really no surprise that the current gaming proposal is stuck in the mud. That bill would give Chicago a casino, plus one each in the Southland, Lake County, Rockford and Danville, along with allowing the racetracks to offer slot machines.

Back in early 2010, Quinn seemed to be leaning in favor of slots at the tracks, or “racinos,” or at least that’s what he is reported to have indicated in a couple of private meetings. But now, Quinn is totally against the idea.

Some say it’s because he received hundreds of thousands of dollars for his campaign last year from two prominent Illinois gaming families — the Pritzkers (who own a big chunk of the Elgin casino) and the Bluhms (whose patriarch, Neil Bluhm, owns the new Des Plaines casino).

Frankly, it doesn’t matter why Quinn opposes racinos or the rest of the proposed legislation. Take him at his word that he believes the expansion plan is just too top-heavy. The only thing that matters is that Quinn opposes it.

The General Assembly tried to go around the governor during the fall veto session, but the revised bill got fewer votes in the House than it did during the spring session.

Some members were absent, another had resigned and a couple of Republicans flipped their votes because they were angry about another bill to give Chicago authority to install speed-enforcement cameras.

But, again, it doesn’t matter why the bill fell so far short. What matters is that Quinn isn’t on board. It can’t become law without him.

The governor took himself out of the legislative game this year with more stupid moves than I have space to recount. His job approval rating among Illinois voters is somewhere around 30 percent. His approval rating in the General Assembly is far lower than that.

But while Quinn has shown all year that he can’t pass a bill to save his life, he still has that veto pen. As long as he does, there’s just no getting around him on a gambling bill.

* Meanwhile, I looked through a new gaming expansion report that the governor’s office is touting. Read the full report by clicking here. The study claims that Illinois would collect only about $160 million in new gaming taxes from the proposed casino expansion.

Most of the media coverage appears based on the study’s summary, but the study itself has some flaws. For instance, the Chicago casino’s “draw” is projected to be limited to almost only the city, and conventioneers and tourists are not fully incorporated into the projections.

The summary also underplays the $500 million in license fees Illinois would receive from the expansion, and an estimated $1.2 billion via a special “reconciliation fee” four years from enactment. And, according to the study, admissions at casinos and racinos would increase 137 percent and gaming revenues would rise by 110 percent.

* Related…

* Sneed: A racetrack deal?

* New gambling plan pushed before last one in effect

* Editorial: Put video gaming into place before more expansion

* Quinn’s office: Gambling bill not as lucrative as promised

* IL gov report doubts hefty gambling revenues

* Quinn report says ‘racinos’ would cut state’s gambling income

* Pulse: Gaming back in Springfield again

* Warren: The Casino Roadblock

- Posted by Rich Miller        


2 Comments
  1. - Ahoy - Monday, Nov 28, 11 @ 9:49 am:

    Anybody else think it’s odd that the study has come out with matching results of the Governor’s position on gaming? I guess you get the answers you pay for.


  2. - PQ's Primary Opponent - Monday, Nov 28, 11 @ 10:32 am:

    Same road =’s same result/no bill…. has the Gov actually talked to the Mayor and the casinos about an impact fee? I doubt it, not sure the Mayor will be in favor of giving away 1 penny of his money to the tracks..Can’t wait to have this same discussion in 2012, 2013, and 2014>>>


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* Reader comments closed for the weekend
* Chicago Tribune: Coal plant closures could send electricity costs soaring
* *** UPDATED x5 *** SUBSCRIBERS ONLY: This just in...
* Question of the day
* OK, so where's your plan?
* Caption contest!
* Topinka: Cigarette tax hike a "common sense solution"
* Slots at tracks a possibility? Maybe
* AFSCME loses appeal over canceled raises
* *** UPDATED x2 - Ricketts gave preliminary approval, lauded TV ad *** Cubs owners try damage control
* Morning Shorts
* *** LIVE SESSION UPDATES ***
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Supplement to today’s edition and a Statehouse roundup
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
* Yesterday's blog posts

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............

...............

...............


Search This Blog...

Search the 97th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 97th General Assembly By Keyword


Categories
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Blagojevich Trial
Advertising
Updated Posts
Polls

* ‘Hack weekends treat coders like monkeys in a cage’
* Microsoft Launches So.cl Social Network
* Apple And Samsung CEOs In Talks Over Patent Disputes This Week
* Embarakiya Floor Lamp is An Arab Sheikh in Disguise
* Future Asus notebooks might get integrated projectors
* Focal Locus Workstation Looks Silly, Promises Better Posture
* Shelly Palmer Radio Report – May 21, 2012

  
* China Says OK For Google To Buy Motorola As Long As Android Stays Free And Open For 5 Years
* Android Community Weekly: May 20th, 2012
* Frustrations of a Windows Phone User
* Samsung Mobile Chief Open To Cross-Licensing Deal With Apple
* How Android Developers Can Thrive With Google Play
* Some HTC ‘products’ are allowed to enter the U.S. Market after passing U.S. Customs review
* Dozens of games to go on sale May 24th through June 1st in the Google Play Store ‘Because We May’

* BR_WhiteSox: http://t.co/pBtg4FTi - Flowers jumps at his chance for So..
* BR_WhiteSox: http://t.co/AMGBSC8D - Flowers jumps at his chance for So..
* BR_WhiteSox: http://t.co/pBtg4FTi - Haugh: Peavy helping Sox make wave..
* BR_WhiteSox: http://t.co/pBtg4FTi - Sweep at Wrigley encourages Sox: ..
* BR_WhiteSox: http://t.co/pBtg4FTi - Tests ahead before Cubs, Sox meet ..
* BR_WhiteSox: http://t.co/pBtg4FTi - Old clips help Beckham heat up: h..
* Floyd looks for different result against Twins


May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog-Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

   
Loading


* What saved states: reform or punting? - The Boston....
* Polish president honors Gov. Quinn, Illinois Natio....
* Illinois child care aid saved; leaders prep for ne....
* Polish President, Gov. Quinn tour Marseilles base ....
* Joint chiefs chairman honors Illinois soldiers - R....
* Our View: Today's stew includes boats, belts, plan....
* Ill. governor pushes pension, Medicaid reforms - Y....
* U of I profs have own pension ideas - Northwest He....


* APNewsBreak: 22 states join campaign finance fight
* Spontaneous NATO protest flares up in Chicago
* Police: 45 arrested, 4 officers hurt in protests
* APClips: Live updates from NATO summit protests
* Some NATO protesters injured after police clashes
* Google gets China OK for Motorola deal
* Kraft gets IRS OK for tax-free grocery split

* House budget would have 'drastic' effects on school districts
* Gambling expansion expected to get another look in legislature
* Our Opinion: More gambling a bad bet
* Bernard Schoenburg: Story jogs fond ‘West Wing’ memories
* Statehouse Insider: Problems need a fix -- right now
* U of I professors offer alternative for university retirement plan
* Prosecutor recommends no charges for state prison warden
* 6 seek to oppose indicted state representative
* Child care funding approved, sent to Quinn
* State Senate Dems set budget goal higher than House's

* IL Senate Dems come out with budget of their own
* Video: ISBE Chairman
* Week in Review: Betting on iGaming, controversy over Nation of Islam
* Appeals court sides with Quinn on denying pay raises
* IL school chief warns of possible cuts to general state aid for schools
* Senate rejects Nation of Islam follower for human rights commission
* Study says cuts to home care lead to rising costs elsewhere

* Britain's Cameron detours from NATO to City Hall green roof, Mart's 1871
* 'Good to be home,' Michelle Obama tells first wives, youth center children
* Google gets China OK for Motorola deal
* Ricketts siblings host top Obama advisers at Cubs-Sox game
* Greek, Italian dignitaries celebrate with Chicagoans


* Daley appointee: Working for the taxpayers while suing them
* Chicago NATO Summit focuses on Afghanistan
* Crowd cheers as protesters freed after arrests
* Supt. McCarthy on the front line: ‘You lead from the front.’
* Feds going after investors in firm tied to Daley son
* NU study: 2,000 U.S. inmates exonerated
* Hundreds of protesters rally outside Art Institute
* Obama on NATO Summit: It’s no Taste of Chicago
* Officer suffered concussion in van incident in Loop Saturday, top cop says
* NATO chief calls Chicago ‘perfect place for this NATO summit’


* 1 killed, 4 wounded in separate South Side shootings
* Pit bull foe: 'I feel like a dog racist'
* Neighbors mourn South Side boy
* Illinois among 22 states joining campaign finance fight
* Rainstorms pelt the region, with more due overnight
* Injuries, arrests in clashes between protesters and police
* 2 wounded in separate South Side shootings
* Rainstorms pelt portions of the region, with more due overnight
* Service resumes on CTA Brown Line
* Neighbors vow to rebuild fire-damaged Indian Boundary Park fieldhouse


* 50 Wards in 50 Weekdays: 30th Ward’s William Olascoaga works for the city he loves
* Demonstrators rolls on
* NATO protester numbers dwindle
* Video: Tom Morello: Rehearsal at NATO summit rally
* Video: Tom Murello: Sound check at NATO summit rally
* Police probe possible cyberattack on city of Chicago website by Anonymous
* Steep bond for NATO protesters held on bomb charges
* Protester numbers dwindle as police gain ground amid standoff at Cermak, Michigan
* Party leaders refuse to budge on debt positions
* Chinese activist renews call to fight injustice

* Using untested law poses risks for prosecutors - Chicago Tribune
* 2 more charged with felonies related to NATO - Chicago Tribune
* Veterans Chuck Medals Towards NATO Conference
* NATO protesters march on warmest weekend of year - News-Democrat
* Chicago providing water for NATO protesters - Pantagraph


* Police, protesters clash outside NATO summit in Chicago
* Springfield man dies after losing control of ATV
* Our Opinion: More gambling a bad bet
* Lawn mower stolen
* Robbery suspects arrested
* Three allegedly attack doorman
* Prosecutor recommends no charges for state prison warden
* 3 charged with terror conspiracy ahead of NATO in Chicago
* Facebook page lets Lincoln lovers interact
* Peoria-area high school prank fills hall with fish bait, toilet paper


* Poll: Consumers in northern Illinois going mobile
* Young illegal immigrants coming out of the shadows
* GOP chooses Davis for US Rep. Tim Johnson's seat
* Tollway council opens door to Route 53 extension
* U of I plans to close police institute


* More potholes in Illinois’ future?
* Carbondale reopens spray park, kicks off aquatic center capital campaign
* TO DONATE
* ALL INVITED
* Protesters march through Chicago to NATO summit
* Pulliam to house new schools, lose pool
* Johnston City Boy Scouts helping observe Memorial Day
* BPD records show history of incomplete documentation of racial profiling forms
* BPD turning focus back to traffic
* Chicago Navy veteran to be honored for service

* House Passes Violence Against Women Act Witho..
* GOP picks ballot candidate for US Rep Tim Joh..
* Word on the Street: 17th District candidates ..
* Protesters March Outside McCormick Place - NB..
* Republicans Give Nod to Shimkus Aide in Congr..
* Davis "Honored" to Be GOP Candidate for Congr..
* GOP picks ballot candidate for US Rep Tim Joh..
* Tim Johnson Retirement: Rodney Davis Chosen B..
* FIO Must Have Strong Role Abroad to Ensure Co..
* Pentagon restricts F-22 flights, safety a con..

* Sen. Durbin defends NATO - Crain's Chicago Bu.....
* Peavy, Dunn lead White Sox past Cubs 6-0 - My.....
* House Speaker John Boehner stands by hard lin.....
* Proposal would require ESL businesses to clos.....
* NBC's Gregory Covers for Durbin on Dem Failur.....

* Clemens trial resonantes here - St. Louis Pos.....
* Senate Iran sanctions bill stalls as GOP call.....
* Washington Digest: Five budget votes show pol.....
* The Food Allergy & Anaphylaxis Network Celebr.....
* Iowa river searched for 4 missing after boat .....

* Low-key, almost mellow, were NATO Summit protesters, despite the end
* Sunday NATO rally
* Health care rally at Emanuel's house
* NATO Protesters Rally In Support Of Education, Labor & Living Wages (VIDEO)
* Protesters, Police Brawl Near McCormick Place
* Hundreds Descend On Mayor’s Home Decrying Mental Health Clinic Closures (VIDEO)
* Nellcôte (Chicago): Wine
* Nellcôte (Chicago): Dine
* Nellcôte (Chicago): A decadently designed West Loop eatery channels the Rolling Stones’ days on the French Riviera
* The Dutch (New York City): Beverage director Josh Nadel comes up with some bloody good brunch cocktails


* Radogno talks Medicaid, pensions and more with Illinois Channel
* Sullivan Extracts $9.2 Million in Savings from Entitlement Program (AUDIO)
* Child care program to receive additional funding
* Progress on Medicaid reform becomes the focus of a busy session week
* Dem lawmakers pass minimum wage hike over Republican objections

Header Photo...
Wayne Bretl


Hosted by MCS    SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version    Contact Rich Miller