LIVE session coverage...
SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
Text of Rod Blagojevich’s appeal

Thursday, Jul 17, 2014

* Emphasis added

In McCutcheon v. Federal Election Com’n, 134 S. Ct. 1434 (2014), the Court struck down a law restricting aggregate limits on political (campaign) contributions. First, the Court noted that political contributions are protected speech under the First Amendment. McCutcheon, 134 S. Ct. at 1444, 1448. To restrict protected speech, the government must have a compelling interest. Id., at 1444. The government does have a compelling interest in “preventing quid pro quo corruption or its appearance …..” Id., at 1445.

The McCutcheon Court further explained that the government’s interest “in preventing the appearance of corruption is equally confined to the appearance of quid pro quo corruption, the Government may not seek to limit the appearance of mere influence or access.” Id., at 1451 (citation omitted). “The line between quid pro quo corruption and general influence may seem vague at times, but the distinction must be respected in order to safeguard basic First Amendment rights. In addition, [i]n drawing that line, the First Amendment requires us to err on the side of protecting political speech rather than suppressing it.” Id., 1451 (citations and internal quotation marks omitted).

Blagojevich’s conviction is based in large part on his attempts to solicit campaign contributions. In this appeal, he argues that the lower court’s instructions to the jury on this issue “omitted the quid pro quo requirement that the government prove that Blagojevich’s requests for campaign contributions were made in return for an ‘explicit promise or undertaking’ to perform or not perform an official act.” Def. Brief, p.50. Instead, Blagojevich’s jury was told to convict on the lower standard that he attempted to obtain a campaign contribution “knowing or believing that it would be given to him in return for the taking, withholding, or other influencing of specific official action.” Def. Brief, at p. 51.

The McCutcheon decision thus supports Blagojevich’s position that, where a criminal prosecution is based upon attempts to solicit campaign contributions, the government must prove a quid pro quo or explicit promise.

* Let’s go to the AP for some context

Blagojevich’s attorneys filed their appeal one year ago, and the sides held oral arguments before a three-judge panel in Chicago in December. Going more than six months without a decision on an appeal is unusual, though it is impossible to say if the lengthy consideration bodes well for Blagojevich or for prosecutors.

Prosecutors are likely to file a response to Wednesday’s defense filing, though they aren’t required to. A spokesman for the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Chicago, Randall Samborn, declined any comment.

The panel’s hard-hitting questions for a Blagojevich prosecutor during oral arguments raised defense hopes that some convictions could be thrown out. The questions’ focus: Exactly where is the line between legal and illegal political wheeling and dealing? And did Blagojevich cross it?

At one point, Judge Frank Easterbrook noted how exceptional the prosecution of Blagojevich was. He even compared Blagojevich’s bid to land a Cabinet seat to how President Dwight Eisenhower named Earl Warren to the U.S. Supreme Court after Warren offered Eisenhower key political support during the 1952 campaign.

* From that earlier hearing

With some passion behind his remarks, [former chief judge of the U.S. 7th Circuit Court of Appeals, the conservative Frank Easterbrook] asked if there was “any criminal conviction in U.S. history” other than Blagojevich’s in which a politician was convicted for trying to trade one job for another.

“I’m aware of none,” responded the government’s Debra Bonamici.

Her answer seemed to hang in the air for a bit as courtroom observers took that in.

Easterbrook described how in the run-up to the 1952 presidential election, then-California Gov. Earl Warren offered to use his post to “deliver California” for Eisenhower in return for a seat on the Supreme Court. It was a deal that Eisenhower eventually honored.

“If I understand your position, Earl Warren should have gone to prison, Dwight Eisenhower should have gone to prison,” Easterbrook implored. “Can that possibly be right?”

Her eventual answer was nuanced, including explaining the allegations included Blagojevich’s attempt to have a 501c (4) set up for him to head if he appointed Valerie Jarrett to the U.S. Senate.

* At the time, Wordslinger was befuddled by this turn of events

“If I understand your position, Earl Warren should have gone to prison, Dwight Eisenhower should have gone to prison,” Easterbrook implored. “Can that possibly be right?”–

That’s nonsense. Show me, in any written history, that Warren made such an “offer” and that Eisenhower agreed to “honor” it.

As it was, 77 of the 90-member California delegation voted for Warren at the convention, so Warren hardly “delivered” the state to Ike.

How the U.S. attorney could let that fiction slide just shows how unprepared the office was.

The facts:

In 1952, Gov. Warren ran as a favorite son, and thought he had the 90-vote California delegation sewn up. In truth, Sen. Nixon spent the train ride from Sacramento to Chicago picking off a handful of Warren delegates for Ike.

Because of this, in part, Ike’s biggest backers, Gov. Dewey and Gen. Clay, recommended him for VP. Nixon was also considered an attractive VP candidate for his youth, war service and for being from the booming West. In addition, he served as a bridge between the right-wing isolationists (for the Hiss case) and the moderate East Coast internationalists (for his support of NATO).

After Ike was elected president, he nominated Warren for solicitor general, with the idea of appointing him to the next open Supreme Court seat, which he did.

But that was to keep Warren from being a primary rival in 1956 and to placate the liberal wing of the GOP, just as Lincoln did with Salmon Chase and the Radical Republicans in 1864.

- Posted by Rich Miller        


25 Comments
  1. - Formerly Known As... - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 9:46 am:

    Much as I dislike Blago, his lawyers make an interesting argument in the appeal based upon the McCutcheon ruling. Can’t fault a desperate man for trying everything possible.

    Good memory on the wordslinger post, some very salient points in there. He always brings a lot to the table.


  2. - Interested Observer - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 9:54 am:

    The McCutcheon decision was decided by the Supreme Court on April 2, 2014. I wonder who prompted Blago’s attorneys to file their amended appeal asking the panel to take judicial notice of the decision more than three months later.


  3. - funny guy - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 9:56 am:

    Still–has any other politician been charged, let alone convicted, for trading one job for another? President Washington spent most of his first term handing out Post Master jobs to his supporters.


  4. - hanging chad - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 10:01 am:

    Blago was convicted of much more than just selling a US Senate seat.

    Let’s talk about him shaking down a children’s hospital for campaign cash……


  5. - The Captain - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 10:08 am:

    Hammers in an all nail world.


  6. - wordslinger - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 10:11 am:

    Judge Easterbrook’s history lesson is whack and doesn’t belong in a federal courtroom.

    For the record, the initial roll call of the states at the 1952 convention at the International Amphitheater ended like this:

    Ike: 595
    Taft: 500
    Warren: 81
    Stassen: 20
    MacArthur: 10

    Before the ballot was recorded, shifts were allowed and another 250 votes went to Eisenhower for the win. But only four of those were from California.

    Out of Ike’s final 845 vote total, 13 were from California.

    So I don’t think Ike or Warren should have gone to prison.

    Interesting sidenote, Taft had pledged if he won to recommend the recently fired MaCarthur as his running mate. Taft died suddenly and unexpectedly in July 1953. If he’d been president, MacArthur would have succeeded him.


  7. - Richard - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 10:12 am:

    God stuff from Wordslinger, as usual. Looks like Judge Easterbrook’s history is a little off. But the judge’s point is on target, despite his choosing of a poor example to illustrate it. Political horse trading has gone on forever…it’s only recently become criminal.


  8. - ZC - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 10:12 am:

    Also, this is about money. Blago didn’t just want to trade a job - he wanted cash, in return for appointing Jackson Jr. to the Senate. I’m not aware of Eisenhower or Warren negotiating about fundraisers.

    I think it’s a point that politicians exchange “favors” all the time, in return for implicit or explicit appointments - “I’ll endorse you,” or even a non-action, i.e. “I WON’T run or do anything, if you appoint me.” And I think it’s pretty clear you have to screw up in a major way to get indicted over that kind of trading.

    But money’s different, in the eyes of the law.


  9. - walker - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 10:13 am:

    So if we just talked generally about an available job opening, and I say something like: “I value your continued support, and expect that good things will happen for your career,” it’s free speech.

    If I say “Give me [this], and you will get [that],” check for wires or taps.

    OK got it. That’s easy.

    That is too fine a distinction to do much about preventing corruption.

    We all should be as “befuddled” as Word.


  10. - Motambe - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 10:18 am:

    Thanks, Rich, for the correct summary on the Eisenhower/Warren saga. We had that lesson in David Kenney’s class at SIUC in 1973. Too bad Easterbrook and Bonamici are so misinformed or uninformed.


  11. - wordslinger - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 10:37 am:

    The Ike/Warren tale has a life of its own, just like Richard I, the presidential kingmaker.

    Daley held Illinois for Kennedy when Stevenson made a half-hearted third attempt at the 1960 Dem convention in LA, but that’s it as far as kingmaking. Despite the legend, Kennedy would have won the electoral college without Illinois.

    Daley’s role in presidential elections after 1960:

    ‘64: LBJ was unopposed at convention, crushed Goldwater nationwide.

    ‘68: Moving right along….

    ‘72: Got kicked out of the Dem convention.

    ‘76: Nil.

    In the general elections, Illinois went GOP in ‘68, ‘72 and ‘76. So much for the kingmaker.

    When the legend becomes fact, print the legend.


  12. - funny guy - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 10:41 am:

    A job produces money–I don’t see the distinction. Moreover, the right job means more money in the future. Look at the criminal counts that Blago was convicted of—90% related to the Senate seat. If he wins this issue, you can see a drastic reduction in time.


  13. - ZC - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 11:22 am:

    funny guy,

    It’s true, your point is very valid. But, in terms of legal precedent and how courts function, regardless of the arbitrariness of the distinction, I think it’s pretty clear if you look at corruption investigations that “money is different.” There are favors, and then there are favors.

    Philosophically I’m on board that it’s all kind of fuzzy. But it’s important to draw at least semi-transparent lines for public officials to know where they practically can and cannot step. If all implicit quid pro quos of any kind constitute illegal behavior, because in -some- conceivable way they benefit the politician … well, that’s a new world. And personally I don’t think I’d be in favor of it, for some of the reasons Rich has been alluding to recently given this teacher qualification “scandal.” I’m not aware of any prosecutions based on horse-trading between two pols over an endorsement or an implicit promise for one to run (or not run) for an office. But Blagojevich had to know when he was asking for cash, that -is- “something of value” that federal courts will interpret as part of a bribe for “an official act” on the part of a public official.


  14. - dupage dan - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 12:05 pm:

    === When the legend becomes fact, print the legend ===

    “The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance” great movie.

    It helps much to have the historical background, doesn’t it? Thanks.


  15. - Formerly Known As... - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 12:08 pm:

    ZC raises some great questions.

    If cash is the dividing line in a quid pro quo, is there a moral difference between cash paid to a candidate’s campaign fund and cash paid to a candidate?


  16. - Anyone Remember - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 12:10 pm:

    Wordslinger -

    Thank you. Two things keep me here. One is the lack of tolerance for sock puppetry. The other is the knowledge of the commenters.


  17. - Plutocrat03 - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 12:35 pm:

    Political horse trading has gone on forever…it’s only recently become criminal.

    Perhaps it was always criminal and only recently has anyone bothered to enforce the law.


  18. - wordslinger - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 12:53 pm:

    In the presidential election of 1824, Andrew Jackson won pluralities in both the popular and electoral college votes in a four-way race.

    Without a majority winner in the electoral college, the election was decided by a vote of the House of Representatives.

    The second-place finisher, JQ Adams, made a deal with Speaker of the House Henry Clay (who had finished fourth): Throw his support to Adams, and Adams would make him secretary of state.

    At that time, secretary of state put you on the short list to be the next president. Adams had been secretary of state, as had Jefferson, Madison and Monroe.

    Now that’s some horse-trading.

    Didn’t work out for Clay. Jackson screamed bloody murder about the deal until the next election and beat Adams handily.


  19. - ZC - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 1:07 pm:

    Exactly Wordslinger!

    We have to distinguish between what’s illegal and what’s merely sleazy or unethical. Sometimes the right response is not to head to court but just show these guys the door at the next ballot opportunity.


  20. - ZC - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 1:11 pm:

    Formerly Known As,

    Or I’ll raise you one; what if the candidate says, “Don’t give the money to me; give it to my district, ie spend a lot on my voters, which will help get me reelected, and then I’ll do you a favor”? That’s still money and it’s still a quid pro quo favor. There’s a lot of grey here no question.


  21. - Streator Curmudgeon - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 1:49 pm:

    Maybe Earl Warren et al should have gone to prison for the Warren Commission, undoubtedly the biggest cover up in U.S. history. It manipulated evidence, ignored crucial witnesses, and parroted LBJ and J. Edgar Hoover’s “lone nutter” theory. Its findings were refuted by the House Select Committee on Assassinations and today only the naive believe the Warren Commission was honest.


  22. - What's in a name? - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 1:53 pm:

    I think Wordslinger is jet showing off now.

    (Just kidding, great stuff.)


  23. - What's in a name? - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 1:54 pm:

    just not jet


  24. - Formerly Known As... - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 1:59 pm:

    ZC - you just had to go and take things up a notch, didn’t you? lol It’s a great question, and one there are clearly no simple answers to.

    I suppose it ultimately comes down to a matter of human judgment. Judgment by the politician about where those boundaries are, and judgment by authorities about whether the politician is flouting those boundaries. It seems unlikely the Feds would have pursued Blago if it were only one minor “mistake” in a grey area, but the brazen accumulation of so many transgressions proved too much to ignore. Blago was despicable.

    Your posts here just made my day, ZC. Thank you.


  25. - Anyone Remember - Thursday, Jul 17, 14 @ 3:43 pm:

    Plutocrat03
    =Perhaps it was always criminal and only recently has anyone bothered to enforce the law.=

    My observation is campaign contributions are starting to be treated like record industry payola in the 1950s.


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* That's probably the ballgame
* Chris Crane: New Plan Will Help Ensure Reliable Power
* Question of the day
* *** UPDATED x1 *** Heroin bill to survive political bickering
* Durkin threatens caucus with "consequences"
* 7 dead, 45 diagnosed with Legionnaires’ disease at Quincy veterans' home
* Emanuel demands Rauner "re-evaluate" child care slashes
* Today's number: $1.18 billion
* The most romantic thing I've ever seen
* Protecting Wall Street, while exposing local employees
* Illinois Credit Unions – Actively engaged in the communities they serve
* *** LIVE *** Overtime session coverage
* AFSCME bill override roundup
* Caption contest!
* Dave McKinney lands at Thomson Reuters
* Governing ain't easy
* Good morning!
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
* Yesterday's blog posts

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............

...............

...............

...............


Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

          
        * Motorola “Bounce” may launch as Moto X Force, with new render incoming
        * How to Move Your Data From Android to iOS
        * Narrative Clip 2 wearable camera gains video and audio support
        * Clips Offers Easy Video Editing On Your iPhone
        * Edjing 5 DJ app made more efficient, intuitive, faster, and easier to share
        * iPad Pro might be announced along with the new iPhones next week
        * Lenovo gives its Vibe S1 dual front-facing cameras

        * White Sox paying David Robertson a lot, but getting a lot
        * Sale fans 10, Avi homers in loss at Target Field
        * Sale equals Unit with 13th 10-K start of '15
        * Rodon takes aim at slowing Twins' playoff pursuit
        * Twins 8, White Sox 6: Bullpen collapse wastes resiliency
        * Sale fans 10, Avi homers in loss at Target Field
        * Robertson undeterred by waiver claim reports

        ...............


        Main Menu
        Home
        Illinois
        YouTube
        Pundit rankings
        Obama
        Subscriber Content
        Durbin
        Burris
        Blagojevich Trial
        Advertising
        Updated Posts
        Polls

        Archives
        September 2015
        August 2015
        July 2015
        June 2015
        May 2015
        April 2015
        March 2015
        February 2015
        January 2015
        December 2014
        November 2014
        October 2014
        September 2014
        August 2014
        July 2014
        June 2014
        May 2014
        April 2014
        March 2014
        February 2014
        January 2014
        December 2013
        November 2013
        October 2013
        September 2013
        August 2013
        July 2013
        June 2013
        May 2013
        April 2013
        March 2013
        February 2013
        January 2013
        December 2012
        November 2012
        October 2012
        September 2012
        August 2012
        July 2012
        June 2012
        May 2012
        April 2012
        March 2012
        February 2012
        January 2012
        December 2011
        November 2011
        October 2011
        September 2011
        August 2011
        July 2011
        June 2011
        May 2011
        April 2011
        March 2011
        February 2011
        January 2011
        December 2010
        November 2010
        October 2010
        September 2010
        August 2010
        July 2010
        June 2010
        May 2010
        April 2010
        March 2010
        February 2010
        January 2010
        December 2009
        November 2009
        October 2009
        September 2009
        August 2009
        July 2009
        June 2009
        May 2009
        April 2009
        March 2009
        February 2009
        January 2009
        December 2008
        November 2008
        October 2008
        September 2008
        August 2008
        July 2008
        June 2008
        May 2008
        April 2008
        March 2008
        February 2008
        January 2008
        December 2007
        November 2007
        October 2007
        September 2007
        August 2007
        July 2007
        June 2007
        May 2007
        April 2007
        March 2007
        February 2007
        January 2007
        December 2006
        November 2006
        October 2006
        September 2006
        August 2006
        July 2006
        June 2006
        May 2006
        April 2006
        March 2006
        February 2006
        January 2006
        December 2005
        April 2005
        March 2005
        February 2005
        January 2005
        December 2004
        November 2004
        October 2004

        Blog*Spot Archives
        November 2005
        October 2005
        September 2005
        August 2005
        July 2005
        June 2005
        May 2005

        Syndication

        RSS Feed 2.0
        Comments RSS 2.0
        WordPress

        Loading


        * The Latest: Child care restoration fails in Illinois House
        * City of Peoria, creator of Twitter parody settle lawsuit
        * Officials begin process of dissolving Belleville Township
        * Group promotes Lincoln family gravesites in Hancock County
        * House Democrats seek to override Rauner on union arbitration
        * Bond set for Indiana man accused in suburban Chicago assault
        * ISP investigate baby's bathtub drowning in eastern Illinois
        * Will County officials say rabid wildlife count on the rise
        * Chicago police: 1 dead, 2 injured in morning shooting
        * Judge closes start of Drew Peterson pretrial hearing

        * Illinois House Democrats seek to override Gov. Rauner on union arbitration
        * Veto override vote looms in Illinois House
        * Legionnaires' disease cases rise at Quincy veterans home
        * All Democrats present as veto override vote looms in Illinois House
        * Bill to stop Illinois State Museum closure advances in House
        * Illinois House faces crucial vote on union arbitration bill
        * United Way advance keeps Helping Hands shelter open as state budget impasse continues
        * House faces crucial vote on union arbitration bill
        * LIHEAP program delayed by state budget impasse
        * United Way advance keeps Helping Hands shelter open as budget impasse continues

        * Small-biz owners diss Emanuel record
        * Obama, Durbin hit the magic number on Iran nuke deal
        * Navistar posts another loss, sending stock down again
        * Stocks rebound after 2-day selloff
        * Meet Chicago's first couple of indy filmmaking


          * Deputies shot on duty last year anxious for news on cop's killer
          * Illinois planning for 'yesterday's transportation system,' IDOT chief warns
          * Sirott and Murciano leaving WGN Radio
          * 5 people shot dead, including 16-year-old boy, over 10 hours in Chicago
          * Video reviewed, manhunt continues in killing of Fox Lake police officer
          * East Aurora paying for School Board member's home Internet
          * Festival hosted by Chicago rappers taking a break in 2015 because of 'demanding year'
          * Illinois House overrides Rauner changes to heroin bill
          * Gunfire strikes West Side school, no injuries reported
          * Reality series to follow Chicago Bliss lingerie football team


          * Illinois House Democrats seek to override Gov. Rauner on union arbitration
          * Legionnaires' disease cases rise at Quincy veterans home
          * Bill to stop Illinois State Museum closure advances in House
          * James Skibo: Museums are treasures worth saving, not destroying
          * The Rev. Alexander Sharp: Gov. Rauner's desire for criminal justice reform in question
          * Michael Gerson: Donald Trump declares war on demography
          * E.J. Dionne: Iran and the case for realism
          * Illinois House faces crucial vote on union arbitration bill
          * United Way advance keeps Helping Hands shelter open as state budget impasse continues
          * LIHEAP program delayed by state budget impasse


          * PODCAST: Regina Lee, Humanitarian Award winner and educator
          * Savoy population up nearly 1,000 in five years, officials estimate
          * Updated: Arthur zoo developer targets Rockome Gardens
          * Peoria and the ACLU settle 'Twittergate' lawsuit
          * Urbana man faces class X burglary charges
          * Arrests take two guns from streets
          * Teen charged in juvenile court in mugging
          * Teens charged with stealing purse during 'candy sale'
          * Guilty plea in weapon case brings 18 months' probation
          * Showdown near on arbitration bill


          * New details emerge in Fox Lake police officer murder investigation
          * Farmer Kip Tom joins crowded 3rd District congressional race
          * SEC's title hopes may rest on an influx of new starting QBs
          * Police officer killed in Illinois was on brink of retirement
          * New NASA soil moisture satellite loses 1 science instrument

          * House lawmakers overcome hurdle on key tra...
          * Rodney Davis talks funding with Bloomingto...
          * The agency that fought Illiana gets a new ...
          * Rep. Dold takes educational cruise down Ch...
          * Lawmakers decry high turnover rate of VA h...
          * CBD Oil, and politics
          * Simon considering state Senate bid
          * Killer Congressman Tom MacArthur trying to...
          * Shutdown? State may not notice
          * Rep. Bob Dold

          * 'Pressure Durbin on Iran treaty' - Beloit ......
          * Steve Cochran Full Show 9/2/15: Dick Chene......

          * Sen. Kirk calls attention to International......

          * Buyer’s remorse. NEA and edTPA.
          * Madigan fails? Whose Speaker is he?
          * Morning Minute: U.S. Pending Home Sales Move Higher in July
          * Chicago Youth To Protest At City Hall Over Dyett High School
          * Lawmakers Thwart Rauner's Proposed Changes To Home Services Eligibility
          * REALTORS® keep line of communication open with Markham mayor
          * Get all the information you need for upcoming license renewals
          * Inman service officially kicks off Thursday
          * Get four hour-long safety webinars for free on Sept. 9
          * Buy your IAR Inaugural Gala tickets now


          * Legionnaires’ Disease Outbreak at Illinois Veterans’ Home-Quincy Update
          * Veteran Spouse Ada Ruth Cripps Honored As The IDVA Volunteer of the Year
          * State-Teamsters One Step Closer to Finalizing Agreement
          * GOMB Director Issues Statement
          * Governor Announces Appointments




              Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller