|
Enter your password to view comments
|
Question of the day
Friday, Sep 7, 2007 - Posted by Rich Miller
You may have been following the controversy over whether SIU President Glenn Poshard’s 1984 doctoral thesis was plagiarized. Here’s a brief summation…
Portions of Poshard’s thesis may have been lifted from as many as 19 other works by 22 authors, the [Daily Egyptian newspaper] said. In some instances, Poshard borrowed heavily from another text but changed a few words here and there, the newspaper said. Some of the copying appeared verbatim, the newspaper said.
Gross said almost all of the copied sections were found in a portion of the dissertation titled “review of the literature,” suggesting Poshard meant to illustrate that he was synthesizing the works of others and not expressing original thoughts.
A group of SIU faculty and students formed to defend the honor of former SIU Edwardsville campus professor Chris Dussold who’s suing the university over being fired for allegedly plagiarizing his teaching statement. That group apparently did the analysis and leaked the results to the DE. The timing was curious…
Gross also questioned the timing of the revelations, which came one week after the university and Dussold broke off negotiations over a settlement of his lawsuit.
Today, the Tribune editorial board weighed in…
Poshard acknowledges that he neglected to put quotation marks around some material (16 times, according to the Daily Egyptian), but says he believed that was OK as long as he cited the sources in footnotes, which he might have forgotten to do a few times (14, the newspaper says). But that’s not plagiarism, Poshard says.
Yes, it is. And it’s an egregious and unforgivable offense for a university president, of all people. Poshard should step down. […]
He allowed in at least one interview that he wouldn’t have been named university president without that doctorate. He’s right, and now that degree has been exposed as a fraud.
The DE’s original story is here.
Question: Should Glenn Poshard resign? Explain.
93 Comments
|
Uh-oh…
A high-ranking official in Gov. Blagojevich’s office spent nearly two years in a federal prison for refusing to aid a government terrorism probe into a series of bombings in Chicago and New York City.
Steven Guerra, Blagojevich’s $120,000-a-year deputy chief of staff for community services, was identified by federal prosecutors as a member of the Puerto Rican separatist group, FALN, which was behind a wave of violence and killings in the 1970s and early 1980s.
In 1983, Guerra, now 53, was among five people convicted in New York of contempt of court for refusing to testify before a federal grand jury investigating the group. The felony conviction resulted in a three-year prison sentence for Guerra, who was released in 1986 after serving 23 months.
Federal prosecutors labeled Guerra and his four co-defendants “a danger to the community,” and said they advocated armed violence, kidnappings, hijackings and prison breaks in the name of a “free” Puerto Rico.
But, he did do his time behind bars, and as the governor’s spokesperson told the Sun-Times…
“If there was really evidence that he had been involved in criminal activity, undoubtedly the federal government would have aggressively pursued charges. Instead, he was charged with refusing to testify before a grand jury. He served his sentence,” she said. “And he’s had an excellent record in the social services community for nearly 20 years since then.”
There were a lot of very ugly allegations made against him by an informer that he wasn’t given an opportunity to rebut. Maybe they’re true, maybe not.
He claimed he had no info about the FALN before he was whistled in to testify. The government believed otherwise and had him sent to prison. His refusal to talk essentially made him the equivalant of a terrorist enabler in the government’s eyes.
We need some questions answered.
Has Guerra solemnly renounced all violence and taken a vow to oppose any and all FALN-related activities? How does he respond to the allegations made by the government’s informer, who is now in the witness protection program? Does he believe now that he should have testified back then, or would he do the same thing over again?
I also wonder if Gov. Blagojevich has ever asked this guy if he’s renounced his past. If Guerra has not completely broken with his former beliefs and Blagojevich hasn’t even bothered to ask him about it, then we have a very serious problem here indeed. Frankly, having somebody like this working in the governor’s office doesn’t sit well with me even if he has broken all ties to terrorists. But we need more answers first.
If the governor and Guerra stay mum, I believe we need a full legislative investigation of this matter. And not a sideshow hearing, either. What’s required here is a sober, fact-finding investigation, with full subpoena power, to get to the bottom of this troubling issue.
Both Guerra and Blagojevich have some explaining to do. Now.
*** UPDATE *** You can find the appellate decision that upheld Guerra’s conviction here.
*** UPDATE 2 *** The Sun-Times has Guerra’s sentencing memorandum posted online. Download it here.
It’s a big file, so I’ve broken it down into a few smaller items…
* In this part, the FBI claims it has “received information from a person who was spoken to by a person actually present” (kind of a stretch) that Guerra said at a meeting, “The right of our country to its independence, was not to be discussed with words, but with bullets. For believing this, we came to be branded as terrorists.”
* Here’s most of the dirt the feds claimed it had on Guerra, provided by a single informer who is now in the witness protection program.
* The government claims in this section that Geurra and his cohorts’ silence has “given the FALN a free hand to engage in terrorist bombings with no questions asked and with impunity — which is exactly what they intended.”
*** UPDATE 3 *** From Abby Ottenhoff…
I talked to Steven about the questions you posed. Below is my response based on his answers…
Not only does he renounce violence and criminal activities by FALN, but he has never been involved with the organization. The only suggestion that he was involved or had knowledge of the group came from hearsay statements made by a convicted felon. If there was any factual basis to those claims, the federal government would certainly have pressed charges. There were no facts and there were no charges.
He served his sentence for not cooperating, and he doesn’t regret his decision to follow his conscience.
*** UPDATE 4 *** From U.S. Rep. Luis V. Gutierrez…
“For more than twenty years, Steven has worked hard to ensure that our community has access to quality healthcare and good schools. He has done excellent work at numerous community based organizations in Chicago, and has been an effective and exemplary employee of the State of Illinois. I know that Steven will continue to build on his strong track record of public service.
“Nearly a quarter-of-a-century ago, Steven made what he considered a principled decision, and he paid a heavy price for that decision. He was never charged with involvement in any criminal activity, and, in the subsequent years, he has worked tirelessly and selflessly to build and better our community. I have known Steven for a long time. He is a good man who cares about making our state a better place to live.”
*** UPDATE 5 *** From CBS2…
State Rep. Greg Harris, vice-chair of the Homeland Security House Committee, is calling for an investigation.
“I’m not an attorney,” Harris said. ”I want to be very sure of the legal grounds upon which we stand, but there’s clearly enough here for cause for concern and for us to pursue it in some depth.”
And click on this photo for the Sun-Times’ Saturday follow-up…
113 Comments
|
Rigid dogma and testosterone
Friday, Sep 7, 2007 - Posted by Rich Miller
* Add yet another item to the very long list of things that bother me about Gov. Blagojevich. He is so dogmatic and doctrinaire about his aversion to any tax hikes on “people” that he would even veto a bill like this…
Gov. Rod Blagojevich vetoed Senate Bill 831, legislation that would have allowed Will County to hold a referendum on a proposed countywide tax on gasoline.
If the bill had been approved, the county board then would have voted on the idea of staging a referendum. If the board members approved it, the issue would have been placed on a ballot. And if voters backed the proposal, a tax of no more than 4 cents per gallon would be levied on gas sold in Will County. […]
Will County Executive Larry Walsh was disappointed by the veto. “It is grass-roots government at its best — you bring an issue before the voters and let them tell you if they want it or not,” he said.
Look, maybe you disagree with raising taxes. I might even agree with you. But why veto a bill that puts county board members on record and then let’s voters themselves have the final say?
For years, this has been a state that prided itself on (usually) putting partisanship and rigid ideology aside and getting things done. Ideology just wasn’t our thing.
But now we are saddled with a governor who worships at the altar of “no tax hikes on people” to the extreme point where he doesn’t want to even allow those very same “people” to impose the taxes on themselves via a direct, front-door referendum.
* Meanwhile, Senate Majority Leader Debbie Halvorson had this insight…
Senate Majority Leader Debbie Halvorson, D-Crete, said the stalemate that has kept lawmakers in town for a record-setting overtime session this year could be broken with a woman’s touch.
“If I was in on those meetings, things would not be going that way. Too much testosterone in there, if you know what I mean,” said Halvorson. “Men don’t want to compromise because they feel then that they lose something, where women want to compromise because that’s a win-win for everybody.”
Um, hmmm. How do I put this as delicately as possible? I’ve, uh, had occasion to argue with women who absolutely didn’t want to compromise, so I’m not so sure of the Leader’s blanket statement.
It’s not a gender thing, necessarily. But I do think that Halvorson, for one, would be a much different governor than Rod Blagojevich… in a good way.
* By the way, Attorney General Lisa Madigan was at Knox College yesterday and held a press conference after delivering the convocation address…
Given the disputes in Springfield, we asked Madigan her opinion on the bill that would give Illinois voters the power to recall statewide elected officials. She says, “I think it’s a fine idea.”
* More testosterone-related (or not) stories, compiled by Paul…
* Speaker Madigan takes his case against the governor’s veto on the road
* Madigan calls for hearings on budget cuts
* Madigan sets budget roadshow
* Hearings set on “savage cuts” in the state budget
* Editorial: Casinos a last resort for capital plan
* Blago to School District: ‘Drop Dead’
* CTA to commuters: Misery is coming
31 Comments
|
Morning shorts
Friday, Sep 7, 2007 - Posted by Paul Richardson
* Inside Rep. Weller’s Nicaragua land deal - Illinois lawmaker benefits from trade accord, fails to report extent of his ocean-view holdings…
Besides not mentioning his Nicaraguan investments during the CAFTA debate on the House floor, Weller did not give anywhere close to a complete accounting of them in his required 2005 financial disclosure statement. House ethics rules require representatives to disclose all property they own except for their personal residences.
The congressman listed only one Nicaraguan property purchase on his 2005 disclosure form, but property records in Nicaragua show that he bought or sold at least eight pieces of land.
That’s not the only discrepancy. On at least two occasions, Weller has reported a land sale on his House ethics form and reported a much lower price for the same sale on Nicaraguan property records. […]
Since his wedding, Weller has omitted his wife’s finances from his annual personal financial disclosure form, which calls for the inclusion of spousal assets.
* Dems at odds for pick on State’s Attorney
* State’s attorney hopefuls studied
* Obama’s family tree gets even more interesting
One of Obama’s ancestors once accused a fellow New England colonist of witchcraft and later stole from the governor’s house. Another had two brothers killed by American Indians, who scalped one brother and kidnapped the other’s daughter. Still another ancestor was said to have been slain by pirates. And yet another lost a son in the Civil War to pro-slavery bushwackers who torched the man’s home and threw burning coals on his infant daughter.
Obama has ancestors who were born in Kenya, England, Scotland, Ireland, France, Germany and the Netherlands. And today, he has seven half brothers and half sisters living across the world.
* Father of fallen Marine to run for Congress in 8th district
* Archpundit: Time for Dan Lipinski to go back to academia
* Geneva mayor vying to succeed Rep. Hastert
* Former Gov. Thompson backs Giuliani
* Thompson’s for Giuliani, Hastert’s for Romney
* Haas: Green Party prepares for 2008 run
* Dick Simpson: How to fix county government
The next three steps to be implemented by the Stroger administration recommended by the transition team will be: 1) implementing performance measures for county government services, 2) greening (or pro-environment) efforts throughout the county, including new rubberized asphalt paving projects in the suburbs, and 3) releasing the proposed county budget on time for the first time in many years.
In a democracy there should be discussion, debate and leadership. No one expects all of the transition team proposals to be enacted. Team members are as fallible as anyone else. But in the current meltdown, the administration is beginning to reinvent county government. After November, the entire transition team report will become public and we will all be able to evaluate the Stroger administration’s performance. Bringing the county into the 21st century is important for all its citizens.
* Stroger open to hiking taxes on utility bills, cigarettes
* Stroger ally proposes three types of tax hikes
* Chicago Public Radio: Property tax relief for Cook Co?
* Possible Union influence in elections rile commissioners
* Tribune Editorial: The Chicago city sheep
* City’s public school may try to franchise success stories
* Kane county still tops charts of collar county poor
* Illinois sees more interest in mortgage program
* New law aims to keep guns from mentally ill
* Editorial: Thumbs up to the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency
* Friday Beer Blogging: Beer snob edition
6 Comments
|
|
Comments Off
|
|
Enter your password to view comments
|
A bit slow around here today
Thursday, Sep 6, 2007 - Posted by Rich Miller
Hmmm…
How do we get things going a bit?
Maybe…
I must be desperate…
Can the Cubs really hold onto first place?
[gag]
49 Comments
|
|
Enter your password to view comments
|
|
Comments Off
|
Question of the day
Thursday, Sep 6, 2007 - Posted by Rich Miller
First, the setup…
In an effort to be “creative and innovative,” a Cook County commissioner Wednesday proposed a county tax swap: Eliminating the county’s share of homeowner property taxes while boosting the county share of sales tax by 2.25 percentage points.
Such an increase would boost overall sales taxes in Chicago to 11.25 percent. […]
Moreno also hopes the plan will bring in up to $60 million a year in new revenue for the cash-strapped county, which again is facing a budget deficit.
Moreno… wants property owners to continue paying their taxes, with the county issuing rebate checks to residential homeowners.
What do you think of this idea?
36 Comments
|
Senate to return, but future is uncertain
Thursday, Sep 6, 2007 - Posted by Rich Miller
* As I told you yesterday, the Senate is coming back to town next week to take up a transit bill and a capital projects proposal. The Pantagraph starts out our coverage…
The General Assembly’s record-breaking overtime session will carry into another week when members of the Illinois Senate convene Monday.
Just a day after the Illinois House rejected a plan to pump millions of dollars into mass transit programs serving commuters in the Chicago region, Senate leaders announced they would descend on the Capitol to try their hand at a solution that also could include a multi-billion dollar statewide road and school construction program.
* The capital plan would be funded with three new casinos. Despite what a few reported, the mass transit bailout would still be funded the same way as the House proposed…
The Senate plan would call for a quarter-cent sales-tax increase in Cook County, a half-cent increase in the collar counties to support transportation and transit, and a provision that would let Chicago increase its real estate transfer tax, said Senate Majority Leader Debbie Halvorson (D-Crete).
* And…
In addition, existing casinos like the Grand Victoria in Elgin would be given the chance to expand by buying the rights to more slot machines and table games.
* But both proposals face uncertain futures…
Although the ruling Senate Democrats say they expect Senate Republicans to support the latest deal, GOP sources said Wednesday they were unaware of details and there’d been no further conversations on the issue since Senate President Emil Jones Jr., a Chicago Democrat, declared the construction deal “dead” and blamed it all on Senate Republican leader Frank Watson of downstate Greenville.
Even if such a deal were to pass the Senate, it faces a dubious future in the Illinois House where both Republicans and Democrats alike have said there’s not enough votes to approve such a massive gambling expansion.
“I think three casinos would be very difficult,” said David Dring, spokesman for House Republican leader Tom Cross of Oswego.
* And…
House Speaker Michael Madigan has said he supports the concept of a capital bill, but has objected to expanding gambling, saying there is no support for such a step in his chamber.
* But Mayor Daley is starting to get antsy…
Blagojevich is against the [transit] funding plan because of the tax increases.
Daley insisted he is not frustrated with the governor, but “you have to make a decision,” he said.
“If he doesn’t like this, then come up with a plan. I just want to see a plan.”
* Meanwhile, the Tribune’s editorial board is blaming Tom Cross for the bill’s defeat in the House…
In blocking a transit deal for Northeast Illinois, House Republican leader Tom Cross is following a tradition, though not necessarily an honored one. He’s logrolling.
You want more money for mass transit, he was saying, you have to give me more money for roads.
Result: A bill to reform and fund the transit system — the first real overhaul in 25 years — fell 10 votes short of the 71 needed. Only five Republicans voted for it. […]
So don’t blame Blagojevich if your bus isn’t running Sept. 17. Right now Tom Cross is in the driver’s seat on this one.
* The Daily Herald’s editorial board begs to differ…
Republican lawmakers in the House who voted against the mass transit bill have different ideas on how to approach transportation funding. They agree mass transit needs a boost. But they want money for bus and rail folded into an overall transportation program that also includes funding for road improvements.
This argument is more reasonable than obstructionist. It has been a long time since the state has approved a comprehensive transportation program that addresses both transit and road improvements. Meanwhile, roads are congested and bridges are crumbling.
* And the Sun-Times edit board wants politicians to take public transit for a week…
That means you, Gov. Blagojevich. And you, House Speaker Michael Madigan and Senate President Emil Jones, the Chicago Democrats in charge of the Legislature. And you, Rep. Tom Cross and Sen. Frank Watson, the Republican leaders.
See what it’s like for your constituents who maybe can’t afford a car payment, insurance, a $78 state sticker, a $75 city sticker and $9 to $28 a day to park. Oh, and $3-a-gallon, taxed-to-the-hilt gasoline (the answer to so many of the state’s financial shortfalls).
Climb down out of your minivan and climb up 50 stairs to the CTA platform. Join the working people as they walk from train station to bus stop or workplace. If there’s any justice in the world, one day of your week will be windy and raining. You can practice hanging on to your briefcase and your umbrella — while the wind flips it inside-out, of course.
Huddle under a bus shelter. Look for a place to sit while you wait. Run for the bus like your life depends on it. Try arranging your life — just for one week — around a train schedule.
* More session-related stuff, compiled by Paul…
* Ginger Ostro: Inaccurate claims about governor’s budget
* Editorial: Governor’s bridge fails to cross real health care issues
* Editorial: Don’t rock the boat
* Tribune Editorial: CeaseFire’s success
23 Comments
|
The Sun-Times had this brief bit in today’s edition…
After raising nearly $30 million during his first term, Gov. Blagojevich’s campaign cupboard is relatively bare.
He had $283,782 in his campaign chest as of the latest reporting date, June 30. That sum has prompted speculation that Blagojevich wants to keep the fund low because his administration is under federal scrutiny, and the last governor, George Ryan, had his campaign fund seized.
Doug Scofield, Blagojevich’s campaign spokesman, scoffed at the idea that the governor has halted his fund-raising.
“I think the second half of the year — now that the budget is completed — we’re going to turn to fund-raising with a major event sometime this fall,” Scofield said.
Scofield told me the same thing when I called him about this over a month ago. He also claimed that Blagojevich had put off his annual funder because of the overtime session fights. So far, though, I haven’t heard of any major fundraising activity yet.
The governor has shown time and time again that he can raise lots of cash at the drop of a hat, so I’m not sure this means too much. Then again, the longer he waits to raise money, the more speculation will abound that he may not be running for a third term, which will make him a lame duck in some minds.
Thoughts?
28 Comments
|
|
Comments Off
|
Morning shorts
Thursday, Sep 6, 2007 - Posted by Paul Richardson
* Were voters steered to absentee ballots?
The Cook County state’s attorney’s office is investigating whether Ald. Bernie Stone’s (50th) political organization improperly steered Indian and Pakistani voters toward absentee ballots, according to sources.
Those under investigation include city employees. For now, the probe is limited to Stone’s North Side ward, the sources said. Subpoenas have been issued for witnesses and documents.
* State trying to stop medical waste incineration
* Clean air advocates urge tougher smog standards; more here
* State expands loan program for first time homebuyers
* Free legal help will be available to Illinois veterans
* City leaders greenlight Daley’s compliance office
* Federal judge to decide who will police city hiring
* Department declines to review Poshard thesis; more here
* Gun control laws stems from VT tragedy
* Worker’s lawsuit claims race bias at Casino Queen
* Grawley puts family before politics
* Daley wants to raise cost of O’Hare, Midway parking; more here and here
* Tribune Editorial: CeaseFire’s success
23 Comments
|
|
Support CapitolFax.com Visit our advertisers...
...............
...............
...............
...............
|
|
Hosted by MCS |
SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax |
Advertise Here |
Mobile Version |
Contact Rich Miller
|