SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
Is Quinn’s AV constitutional?

Wednesday, Aug 1, 2012

* Gov. Pat Quinn was asked by reporters at least twice during a press conference yesterday about whether he actually has the power to use an amendatory veto to drastically change a piece of legislation, as Quinn did yesterday with his assault weapons ban AV. Here’s the first reporter question…

Do you concede there are any limits on your AV power?

He didn’t.

* Second question…

Where is there in the Constitution that says the governor can add such substantive language on a different topic to a bill?

Quinn pointed to unnamed Illinois Supreme Court opinions and voter action.

Press conference raw audio…

* OK, let’s go to the Illinois Constitution

The Governor may return a bill together with specific recommendations for change to the house in which it originated.

And that’s it.

* The Illinois Supreme Court has ruled that the governor’s AV powers go beyond just correcting errors or making minor changes. From People ex rel Klingert v. Howlett

Our examination of the records of the [Illinois Constitutional] Convention shows that the following terms were used to describe the kinds of “specific recommendations for change” that were contemplated: “corrections;” “precise corrections;” “technical flaws;” “simple deletions;” “to clean up the language.” In response to the following question put by Delegate Netsch, however, “Then was it the Committee’s thought that the conditional veto would be available only to correct technical errors?” a committee member answered, “No, Ma’am.”

* However, in the same case the Supremes also ruled on another matter...

The Illinois Supreme Court was confronted with Gov. Richard B. Ogilvie’s amendatory veto which amended the title of the bill and substituted a reworded proposal for all of the text after the enacting clause, although reiterating verbatum much of the language of the bill as originally passed. The court was obviously troubled that the scope of the governor’s authority in the new Constitution was not clearly stated nor could it be found in the committee reports or debates.

The justices did not attempt to delineate the exact kinds of changes that would fall within the power of the governor, but merely stated that “[It can be said with certainty, however, that the] substitution of complete new bills, as attempted in the present case, is not authorized [by the Constitution].” [Emphasis added, and added text from the original opinion can be found here]

* Gov. Quinn’s amendatory veto language begins with this

* So, Gov. Quinn’s amendatory veto appears to go way beyond even what Gov. Ogilvie tried. The Court has been clear that while governors are part of the legislative process, they cannot erase an entire bill and substitute their own language. Ogilvie used much of the same text from the original bill in his new proposal and the Court still shot it down. Quinn didn’t even bother with that nicety. He just wiped out the underlying bill entirely and wrote his own, new bill.

It’s a moot point, of course. As I told you yesterday, there’s no way this AV is going anywhere. But this sure looks like a major constitutional overreach by Gov. Quinn.

* Related…

* Illinois governor wants ban on assault-style weapons, high-capacity magazines: Illinois Governor Pat Quinn Tuesday ventured into territory where most elected officials and politicians fear to tread: An outright ban on assault style weapons and high capacity magazines for all guns.

* Illinois governor wants ban on assault weapons

* Quinn faces uphill fight for assault weapons ban - Colorado theater massacre demands action, governor says

* Assault weapons idea a publicity stunt, area lawmakers say

* Topinka: Assault weapons ban would be ‘hard to enforce’

* Local lawmakers oppose gun ban

* Gun owners balk at assault weapons ban proposal

* Illinois gov. proposes state assault weapons ban

- Posted by Rich Miller        

  1. - western illinois - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 9:42 am:

    Why doesnt he just AV pension reform?It would be just as Constituational.

  2. - Michelle Flaherty - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 9:45 am:

    But I thought the governor had swore his devotion to the constitution. Didn’t he just say that in his special session orders?

  3. - Sunshine - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 9:48 am:

    Perhaps the longer he is in this position of power, the larger his head becomes, and the smaller his brain?

  4. - Esteban - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 9:51 am:

    How does one determine what is-or isn’t- an “assault weapon” and who will make that determination?

  5. - Kerfuffle - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 9:54 am:

    It is all about appearances. You can’t let a good crisis go to waste even if PQ’s solution to that crisis doesn’t pass constitutional muster.

  6. - Shore - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 9:54 am:

    If you’re aiming at suburban independents who aren’t pro gun with a stunt like this, you need to be able to convert because otherwise you come off looking like an incompetent goof and it backfires because one of the things suburban independents really value is competence and leaders who can get stuff done in a serious way that delivers solid results.

  7. - Anonymous - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 9:57 am:

    I refuse to believe that Gov. Quinn would do something with no chance of success because he wanted to have a one-shot publicity stunt.

  8. - Cincinnatus - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 10:02 am:

    Quinn is doing nothing more than following the recent trend of executive branch folks doing pretty much anything they want to, whether authorized by legislative initiative or not, and relying on the courts (or the people) to force these bureaucrats to follow the law. We are not only seeing our freedoms reduced by executive fiat, but costing countless dollars in litigation costs.

  9. - lake county democrat - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 10:03 am:

    I’m not endorsing this behavior and admit it’s a dicey area - if the Illinois Supreme Court reaffirmed it’s previous interpretation of the clause and Quinn kept doing it I’d definitely condemn it.

  10. - East Sider - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 10:03 am:

    This is a stunt to allow downstate democrat incumbents a chance to “lash out at liberal Chicago politicians.” I’m sure Dan Beiser and Bill Haine are already crafting so-called “legislative updates” (aka: political mailers by for at taxpayers’ expense) supporting 2nd Amendment rights and pandering to gun owners.

  11. - Small Town Liberal - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 10:10 am:

    Cinci - If you think executive action is a recent trend, you really need to brush up on your history.

    Also, the legislature never defined exactly what an AV could be used for, and I don’t agree that this goes way beyond Ogilvie’s AV. Both added language, both retained language.

    If you think it’s unconstitutional, take it to court. Otherwise, vote on it as is or override it. Is it really different than if it was simply vetoed?

  12. - OneMan - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 10:11 am:

    I refuse to believe that Gov. Quinn would do something with no chance of success because he wanted to have a one-shot publicity stunt.

    And I refuse to believe that NIU isn’t going to win a national football championship within the next 10 years. Doesn’t mean my thoughts are based in reality.

  13. - Kerfuffle - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 10:28 am:

    Small Town Liberal - “Also, the legislature never defined exactly what an AV could be used for”……The legislature didn’t define it because they couldn’t. It came out of the Constitutional Convention (and is now part of the IL Constitution).

  14. - Small Town Liberal - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 10:35 am:

    Kerfuffle - I’m no expert on such things, but I read the article Rich linked, and that was one of the two solutions recommended by the writer (an attorney who worked for Ogilvie apparently)

  15. - Dirty Red - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 10:38 am:

    OneMan ftw.

    This reminds me of Rod’s Rewrite to do Right campaign.

  16. - Rich Miller - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 10:39 am:

    ===The legislature didn’t define it because they couldn’t.===

    Actually, both chambers have defined what the governor’s AV powers are by rule. And this AV is a clear violation of those rules.

  17. - AC - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 10:41 am:

    If only he had such power over the state budget, he could have paid employees the raises he agreed to…

  18. - Anonymous - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 11:17 am:

    But didn’t those House and Senate “rules” get get ignored, or suspended, when the free rides for seniors was part of an AV penned by Blagojevich?

  19. - Been There - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 11:25 am:

    ===If you think it’s unconstitutional, take it to court.====
    There isn’t anything to take to court and there never will be anything to take to court. That’s Rich’s whole point. Unless this becomes law, which it won’t because the sponsor won’t move it or it won’t get out of the rules committee, there is nothing to take legal action on. All media hype.

  20. - Cincinnatus - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 11:28 am:

    One wonders if Dave Luechtefeld plans to let the underlying bill fail or if he is going to drive an override…

  21. - Todd - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 11:36 am:

    Been there– yes there is. And it is being looked at.

    Quinn issued the AV. In a couple days, the bill will have hit the 60 day mark defined by the constitution to act, I believe he has fulfilled that obligation by the AV to act and so if the AV goes beyond what is constitutionally acceptable, then the underlying bill becomes law. At least that is the theory that the lawyers are looking at right now. . .

  22. - Javorica - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 12:07 pm:

    Quinn at least has enough smarts to know that while this bill will never get through, it’s great publicity for him and Rahm with the democrats in the urban communities. On the contrary people who understand a bit more about the process know that he is still inept and the bill he gutted was drafted by pro gun legislators who won’t be happy Quinn used his questionable AV power to gut their bill. They likely just won’t let it out of committee or won’t call it for a vote. Very Franks-esk in PR.

  23. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 12:10 pm:

    Oy. Its been a long time since I looked at the rules.

    I don’t believe the AV can be ignored, although it can be dismissed by a ruling of the chair which is subject to roll call.

    Unlike Rich, I’m not completely ruling out an override.

    There are lots of downstate Democrats who are happy to vote against an assault weapons ban and distance themselves from the governor, and lots of suburban Republicans that Democrats would be only too happy to see on the record as opposing an assault weapons ban.

  24. - Rich Miller - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 12:12 pm:

    ===Unlike Rich, I’m not completely ruling out an override.===

    I’m not, either. All I’m saying is that no matter what happens this AV is deader than a rock on a stump.

  25. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 12:16 pm:

    My bad, Rich. Unlike the bill’s sponsor, I’m not completely ruling out an override.

    From CBS News:

    Luechtefeld’s measure would have allowed Illinois residents to have ammunition purchased from in-state companies shipped to them. Currently, Illinois residents can only have ammunition shipped if it’s bought out of state.

    He added that he doesn’t think his bill is controversial, and that Quinn’s move kills it.

  26. - Rich Miller - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 12:19 pm:

    ===and that Quinn’s move kills it.===

    A failed override attempt would kill it as well, however.

  27. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 12:23 pm:

    In response to all the debate over whether the AV is Constitutional, let me just add one point.

    As Rich may recall and I’m sure Todd remembers, Gov. Ryan used his amendatory veto to add language banning discrimination against gay Americans to a bill which amended the Human Rights Act to prohibit discrimination against motorcyclists in public accommodations.

    Many of us who don’t have a vote in the General Assembly would probably assume that AV clearly changed the intent of the underlying bill and should have been rejected by the House.

    As I recall - and Todd remembers this one better than I do - it was upheld by the House with a razor-thin margin.

    My caveat is this: the House doesn’t rule on whether an AV is “Constitutional,” that is for the courts to decide.

  28. - wordslinger - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 12:34 pm:

    –Actually, both chambers have defined what the governor’s AV powers are by rule.–

    The GA can’t trump or interpret the Constitution. It may be unconstitutional, but that’s for the Supremes to say.

  29. - Agricola - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 12:41 pm:

    ===I don’t believe the AV can be ignored, although it can be dismissed by a ruling of the chair which is subject to roll call.===

    Not to be rude, but an AV most certainly can be ignored. Here are two of the ways in which it can be ignored: (1) if no legislator files a motion to accept the AV (and there is no mechanism to compel the filing of such a motion); or (2) if a motion is filed but not called for a vote.

    Also, even if the Senate were to accept the AV’s changes, that action does not change the ability of the House to ignore the AV.

  30. - Todd - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 12:56 pm:

    the bill was HB-1039:

    The bill died as it was not called.

    the question could now become, as i eluded to earlier, what if the court finds the governor acted outside his authority and did not properly return the bill, so it should be law since he did not follow the proscribed procedure?

  31. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 12:57 pm:

    True, Rich. Luechtefeld seems to be assuming that an override attempt would fail though. I give Todd more credit.

    @Agricola -

    Not rude at all. Both the “exceptions” you point out have the affect of accepting the Governor’s actions as a total veto. That’s an admission of defeat for the underlying bill, not what I would call “ignoring” the governor’s action. But I think we’re splitting hairs at this point.

  32. - Cincinnatus - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 1:25 pm:


    Splitting hairs is what keeps most of the legislators occupied, and most of the lawyers in this state busy billing hours!

  33. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 2:06 pm:

    Todd -

    Seems like an unlikely scenerio, if the article Rich links to is correct. Although it is from 1977.

  34. - Kerfuffle - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 4:36 pm:

    Rich - Appreciate your comments regarding what the legislatre has done in regard to implementing rules for AVs but I don’t think legislative branch rules on how the executive branch can use (or in this case misuse) its constitutional authority holds much weight. I could be wrong - and often am according to my wife.

  35. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 7:26 pm:

    To Rich’s earlier point, here is the applicable Senate Rule (emphasis added):

    9-2. Amendatory Vetoes.
    (a) The Governor’s specific recommendations for change with respect to a bill returned under subsection (e) of Section 9 of Article IV of the Illinois Constitution shall be limited to addressing the Governor’s objections to portions of a bill, the general merit of which the Governor recognizes, and shall not alter the fundamental purpose or legislative scheme set forth in the bill as passed.

  36. - unclesam - Wednesday, Aug 1, 12 @ 9:11 pm:

    If I recall correctly, Speaker Madigan over the last few years (especially during the final years of Blago) has instituted a process to have every AV thoroughly reviewed to ensure the Gov did not exceed his constitutional authority, and if the review process finds that the AV issued did exceed the constitutional restrictions then the Speaker simply did not allow any motion on that AV to advance and die in House Rules.

  37. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Thursday, Aug 2, 12 @ 7:27 am:

    @Uncle Sam -

    I think you are mostly right. I believe they are reviewed to determine whether they comport with House Rules, which are substantially similar to the Senate Rule posted above.

    Part of the reason I doubt the courts will intervene is that the legislature has, by rule, put a system in place for dealing with Amendatory Vetoes it feels are not germane. Its nonsensical for the General Assembly to run to the courts to seek relief.

    If, however, the bill were enacted with the AV, the Illinois State Rifle Association would probably have a strong case for striking it down. That’s where the constitutional question becomes legally relevant.

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.

* Happy Thanksgiving!
* *** UPDATED x1 *** Five unanswered questions
* *** UPDATED x1 *** Question of the day
* Caption contest!
* Crossing the line
* Moody's warns Illinois
* The Credit Union Difference
* *** UPDATED x1 - Franks responds *** Uh-oh
* Then and now
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
* Yesterday's blog posts

Visit our advertisers...







Search This Blog...

Search the 98th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 98th General Assembly By Keyword

* LG V10 not going to Canada
* Heed these warnings if you get a VR headset this holiday season
* Google sheds some light on EU’s requirement to keep some info out of the light
* OnePlus Type-C USB cables not compatible with some 3rd party chargers
* Google and Samsung to fix TouchWiz, OnePlus X updates & more – Pocketnow Daily
* CyanogenMod 13 support for Nexus 6P, Nexus 5X now available
* The Accessibility Of The iPhone 6s

* Scouting profile: Adam Engel
* Alex Avila will try to shed limitations with White Sox
* White Sox program provides kids real chance
* Johnson solid candidate for White Sox rotation
* White Sox sign catcher Avila to one-year deal
* White Sox sign catcher Avila to one-year deal
* White Sox sign catcher Avila to one-year deal


Main Menu
Pundit rankings
Subscriber Content
Blagojevich Trial
Updated Posts

November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005


RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0


* Rauner faces challenges in move to block Syrian.....
* Rauner faces challenges in move to block refuge.....
* Rauner faces challenges in move to block Syrian.....
* Rauner faces challenges in move to block Syrian.....

* Hunters find body of missing southern Illinois woman
* EXCHANGE: Augustana digitizing Hauberg glass plate images
* Rauner faces challenges in move to block Syrian refugees
* Illinois high court takes Moline company's tax break appeal
* Boone County jail inmate charged with attacking guard
* Chicago schools prepare lesson plan on teen's shooting
* Chicago Public Schools reverses special education cuts
* Former Chicago Transit workers sentenced in fraud scheme
* Rauner pardons man found innocent of 1999 attack
* Springfield police chief bemoans body-cam 'burden'

* Rauner pardons man found innocent of 1999 attack
* Springfield jobless rate falls again, to 5.1 percent
* Springfield police chief sees problems with body cam law
* Lawsuit challenges Illinois ban on marijuana campaign money
* Number of Illinois inmates released on parole climbing
* Bryce Benton circulating petitions to challenge Sen. Sam McCann in GOP primary
* Executive Mansion roof repairs nearing completion
* Candidates begin filing petitions for March primary election
* Benton circulating petitions to challenge McCann in GOP primary
* Rauner administration says House Democrats holding local aid hostage

* Review: Sociale in the South Loop
* Her Barbie was a lawyer. Now she defends victims' rights
* Meet the guy making money off your food scraps
* Anger, pain and calls for change in response to police video
* United, Delta bet on long oil slump

* In wake of dashcam video, Emanuel must navigate political minefield
* White House under holiday lockdown after man jumps fence
* Trevor Daley turning the corner at both ends of the ice
* Rauner faces challenges in move to block Syrian refugees
* Brown: Simeon basketball players bring their A-game to court
* 16 reasons every Blackhawks fan should be thankful on Thanksgiving
* Blackhawks cool off Sharks; Kane extends point streak to 17
* Four more Laquan McDonald police dashcam videos released
* President Obama: ‘Disturbed’ by Laquan video, grateful for ‘peaceful’ protests
* Black leaders call for Supt. McCarthy to resign

* 1 dead, 2 wounded in North, South Side shootings
* 4 arrested in 2nd night of Laquan McDonald shooting protests
* University of Illinois marching band performs in Macy's parade
* Laquan McDonald shooting protest groups plan Friday march
* Cops: Man tried to lure, kidnap 9-year-old girl in South Chicago
* Teen dead, 4 others wounded in city shootings
* Woman dies in Chesterton fire
* Naval recruits get taste of home at Chicago Ridge Thanksgiving dinner
* Cops: Will County explosions just legal shooting practice
* Charges: Former Illinois man abducted, assaulted teen; kept him shackled

* Eugene Robinson: The GOP's political correctness dodge
* Douglas Holt: Woman's protest of Trump was misguided, inappropriate
* George Will: Muzzling pet advice another case of free speech erosion
* Bernard Schoenburg: Josh Langfelder took father's advice on election petition signatures
* Rauner pardons man found innocent of 1999 attack
* Springfield jobless rate falls again, to 5.1 percent
* Michael Gerson: The Trump effect, still 'understated'
* Catherine Rampell: For millennials, first comes love — then what?
* Springfield police chief sees problems with body cam law
* Lawsuit challenges Illinois ban on marijuana campaign money

* 48th Annual Turkey Trot
* Podcast: Champaign County States Attorney Julia Rietz 11-26-15
* Wednesday's highlights: Nottingham, Chargers get first win
* Clubs listings, Nov. 26-Dec. 3, 2015
* Area update: Soup kitchen needs help with backpack giveaway
* Frank's Faves: Giving thanks
* Golf links swap hits roadblock
* Chuck Koplinski: Beautiful 'Brooklyn' a love story for the ages
* Update on candidate filings in Vermilion County for 2016
* 80th N-G All-State Football: POY Josh King

* Informal hat and scarf giveaway makes Batavia warmer
* Arlington Heights hosts homestyle Thanksgiving for Navy recruits
* Lake Zurich Culver's feeds hundreds for Thanksgiving
* Old and new friends break bread at annual Lazarus House dinner
* 2,820 run through Batavia

* House lawmakers overcome hurdle on key tra...
* Rodney Davis talks funding with Bloomingto...
* The agency that fought Illiana gets a new ...
* Rep. Dold takes educational cruise down Ch...
* Lawmakers decry high turnover rate of VA h...
* CBD Oil, and politics
* Simon considering state Senate bid
* Killer Congressman Tom MacArthur trying to...
* Shutdown? State may not notice
* Rep. Bob Dold

* Nebraska ethanol producers name former Dur......

* Opinion: Sen. Kirk must stand with crimina......

* Chicago Teachers Union. “If we strike, we do so to protect our children,” says Karen Jennings Lewis.
* Resign.
* Don't Let The Turkeys Get You Down
* “The Driver’s Side” – News From The Motorist’s Perspective
* IDOT Debuts Winter Weather Driving Tips Video
* Pot Dangerous? Mother's Testimony Says Yes [video]
* Happy Thanksgiving
* It seems like it’s everywhere, that video of the final moments of Laquan’s life
* Laquan McDonald.
* Sixteen shots. The story that broke the silence.

* Emergency Management Officials, National Weather Service Encourage Winter Preparedness - November is Winter Weather Preparedness Month in Illinois
* Keep Your Family Safe This Winter - November through February are leading months for carbon monoxide related incidents
* Governor Takes Bill Action
* Illinois Department of Labor Director Hugo Chaviano Awards Governor’s Award for Contributions in Health and Safety to the Illinois Refining Division of Marathon Petroleum Company LP
* State Regulator Elected Treasurer of Interstate Medical Licensure Compact

    Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller