Capitol Fax.com - Your Illinois News Radar » Bed-and-breakfast owner defiant in face of gay discrimination ruling
SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
Bed-and-breakfast owner defiant in face of gay discrimination ruling

Wednesday, Nov 30, 2016

* Illinois ACLU

The Illinois Human Rights Commission has declined review and adopted the report and recommendation of an administrative law judge, ruling against a Paxton Bed & Breakfast after its owners denied a downstate couple – Mark and Todd Wathen – access to the facility to celebrate their civil union in 2011. Today’s action comes after an administrative law judge found that the denial of the use of the facility was because the Wathens are gay – a violation of Illinois law. The judge also previously ordered the Bed & Breakfast to pay $30,000 to the Wathens for their emotional distress, as well as attorneys’ fees and costs. Most importantly, the owners of the Bed & Breakfast were ordered to cease discriminating against same-sex couples by denying them use of the facilities for marriage and civil union ceremonies.

The Illinois Human Rights Commission refused the Bed & Breakfast’s request to review the administrative law judge’s recommended orders, which makes them the final orders of the Commission.

The following can be attributed to John Knight of the ACLU of Illinois, who along with Betty Tsamis of the Tsamis Law Office and Clay Tillack and Robert A. H. Middleton of Schiff Hardin served as counsel to the Wathens:

The Commission’s decision once again sends a clear message that denying couples the use of a public wedding venue in Illinois because they are gay or lesbian is simply not permitted. Business owners cannot pick-and-choose to follow laws simply because they personally disagree with same-sex couples’ decision to marry.

Fortunately, we have not seen many examples of this type of blatant discrimination since the same-sex couples have had the freedom to marry in Illinois.

The judge’s ruling is here. More background is here.

* Law Bulletin

Section 5-102(A) of the Human Rights Act states that it is a civil rights violation to deny “the full and equal enjoyment of the facilities, goods, and services” on the basis of race, color, religion, sexual orientation and other categories at a “public place of accommodation” — defined as restaurants, theaters, parks and a broad collection of other types of businesses aimed at convenience and enjoyment.

Robinson found that, because the inn really only declined services to others if, for instance, they couldn’t afford them, that the inn qualified as a public place of accommodation under the law.

He also said the inn owners did not factually back up their defense under the Illinois Religious Freedom Restoration Act — which says that “the government may not substantially burden a person’s exercise of religion” unless it proves a narrowly tailored, compelling interest for doing so.

That defense should be resolved by an appellate court, Robinson wrote. But he added that Timber Creek did not explain how allowing a same-sex ceremony on its premises, especially when its employees were not required to be present at such an event, was “somehow a sub silencio endorsement of anything goes on during that event.”

That logic was spelled out in Robinson’s initial decision in the case on Sept. 15, 2015. His rationale on damages was spelled out in his March order, in which he also briefly contemplated the notion that the Wathens might be “testers” — activists less interested in justice for themselves than in creating legal precedents.

* Associated Press

Jason Craddock, an attorney for the bed and breakfast owners, said he plans to fight the decision. The owners have been ordered to pay about $80,000 in damages and legal fees and allow same-sex couples access to their facilities. Timber Creek’s website still notes that they do “not host civil union or gay marriage ceremonies and/or receptions.”

Craddock said he wasn’t surprised by the panel’s move and was prepared to ask the whole commission to consider the case and, if necessary, take it beyond the agency to an Illinois appellate court.

* News-Gazette

[The B&B’s co-owner, Jim Walder] called the panel’s decision “disappointing,” but he added that “it will not change our policy.” Walder was referring to a policy that remains explicitly stated on the TimberCreek B&B’s website, saying the business “cannot host civil unions or gay marriages” because “we cannot be part of what God condemns.”

“For thousands of years homosexuality has been considered sodomy and gay marriage an abomination — civilly and Biblically,” Walder said Tuesday. “We choose to remain consistent in obeying long-held civil understanding and biblical teaching on both.”

Discuss.

- Posted by Rich Miller        

30 Comments
  1. - siriusly - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:03 am:

    For thousands of years human slavery was also normalized, commercialized and accepted.

    As a society and as a country we have always - from day one - built into our governance structure the mechanisms to adapt and change.

    The argument that a law can be ignored because it establishes a “new normal” is not really consistent with our nation’s history. It’s not a valid legal argument in this country.

    We have changed norms for the better constantly since the Revolution.


  2. - How Ironic - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:17 am:

    Hopefully they go bankrupt, and lose the business. We don’t need that type of bigotry in the state. Religious freedom, doesn’t mean ‘discrimination enabled zone’.


  3. - thunderspirit - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:19 am:

    The Supreme Court has interpreted the free exercise clause of the First Amendment so that the freedom to believe is absolute, but the ability to act on those beliefs is not.

    If, in the name of religious freedom, the freedom of others are infringed upon, that’s a violation.


  4. - Ron Burgundy - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:19 am:

    Sorry, law is the law folks. I suggest you find a different line of business.


  5. - Chicago_Downstater - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:25 am:

    Unfortunately, I can see this being overturned based on the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) in a higher court. And the Hobby Lobby ruling probably won’t help either.

    Sad state of affairs when our government let’s folks use religion as an excuse to discriminate. Can’t wait until divorcees start being denied services. *last sentence = much snark*


  6. - HangingOn - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:25 am:

    So I’m guessing they refuse to provide services for people who are divorced too. Also people who aren’t married but want to share a bed. I mean, doesn’t the bible say those things are against God?

    If these people who claim they refuse because God says it’s bad, there are a *lot* of people that have to be excluded. There would be very few people left to pay him to stay in his B&B.


  7. - Skeptic - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:31 am:

    To borrow a line from Trump supporters, “You lost, get over it.”


  8. - Nothsider - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:35 am:

    Skeptic, you forgot the most important word: “Buttercup.”

    As for these delicate flowers and their B&B, if I ever have cause to be in Paxton, I’ll definitely spend my lodging money elsewhere.


  9. - illini97 - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:40 am:

    They’re out $80,000 and still going? Just how profitable is a B&B in East Central Illinois?


  10. - Last Bull Moose - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:41 am:

    Under the current law, they should simply not host any weddings or receptions. It would be cheaper than paying the cost of court fees and judgments.

    It used to be that businesses classified as common carriers, usually in transportation, had to accept all customers. That was a condition of using the public highways. Other businesses could accept or refuse customers for any reason or no reason.

    Now it seems that all businesses are considered common carriers. You can only refuse business if you think the customer won’t pay.


  11. - Demoralized - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:52 am:

    We don’t get to pick and choose the laws we follow. If they can’t operate their business in accordance with the law then perhaps they should find another line of work. Or, as LBM has suggested, simply don’t do receptions for anyone anymore.


  12. - SKI - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 9:55 am:

    Glad they got it handed to them in court. How is this any different than refusing service to someone due to the color of their skin? I believe back in day the south hide behind religion to justify segregation too.


  13. - Archiesmom - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:01 am:

    I haven’t looked through all of the links, and I only skimmed the website, but it appears that they would let this couple stay there and commit acts that are against their religious belief, but just refuse to allow their facilities to be used for a gay marriage. I find that interesting. I suppose the fact that the facility is advertised in multiple places as being Christian is supposed to be a big hint that perhaps those with different lifestyles or viewpoints wouldn’t exactly be comfortable there.


  14. - fed up - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:02 am:

    So if my religion requires me to oppose bigotry at every turn, my business could choose to NOT serve discriminatory B&B owners, AND it would be legal, according to them? Hmm


  15. - 47th Ward - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:05 am:

    Can’t the owners simply stop being a public accommodation and instead become a club? Then they could exclude any non-members they choose, or admit new members as they see fit.

    Club Leviticus has a nice ring to it.


  16. - Bothanspied - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:11 am:

    47th - No, even with a private club, you cannot discriminate membership based on race, creed, religion


  17. - SKI - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:13 am:

    - Bothanspied - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:11 am:

    “47th - No, even with a private club, you cannot discriminate membership based on race, creed, religion”

    Tell that to some private golf courses in the south….


  18. - 47th Ward - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:15 am:

    ===47th - No, even with a private club, you cannot discriminate membership based on race, creed, religion===

    Don’t tell the white guys at Old Elm or Bob O’ Link, lol.


  19. - Ghost - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:18 am:

    The courts do not actually consider this, but to me its relevant.

    If you are saying you are enforicng a religious beleif, i.e not just a racist or homophobi belief, then demonstate unifrom appkication of religous rules.

    The bible states that one of the greatest sins against marriage is infidelity. it call for stoning. Sp how often does this establisment deny its favilities tonthose who have been unfaithful? or coverted their neirghbors possesions? or disrespected their parents?

    Its not religious belief if you just pick a single topic, it just homophobia.


  20. - wordslinger - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:21 am:

    –Tell that to some private golf courses in the south….–

    The south? Try the North Shore.

    It must be tough running a B-and-B based on Leviticus.

    The cleanliness and food preparation standards alone — talk about regulation.

    But I’m guessing the owners here are just cherry-picking lines from the Old Testament to justify what they want to do anyway.

    They should check out the New Testament one of these days, with the “love thy neighbor as thyself” and “he without sin cast the first stone…”


  21. - Bothanspied - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:21 am:

    haha, not saying it isn’t happening. Just saying that its not a “legal” way to get around the issue that is going to escape the ACLU, especially around this topic


  22. - Patty T - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:24 am:

    There have been designers refusing to work with Melania Trump. Although she is not a protected class, it does seem to be a double standard. I always thought the market & word of mouth would take care of bigoted vendors where competition exists.


  23. - Bothanspied - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:25 am:

    Patty T- The market may resolve it in a diverse area, but that’s not really the point. The law exists for a reason.


  24. - Signal and Noise - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:31 am:

    Bed and Breakfast refuses to cater to gay couples…In other news: Donut Shop Refuses to Serve Police Officers.


  25. - A guy - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 10:33 am:

    I guess Ground Zero for this fight has to be somewhere.

    It’s hard for me to imagine that this place could meet the magical expectation for staying there or hosting an event there.

    Wonder if business has suffered or advanced by virtue of this PR?

    The law is the law. This weekend event could have occurred and been over with without much notice. Doubt the service would be too great given the disposition of the service providers. Probably not tons of great referrals and Yelp reviews from this community would have been made.

    If a business doesn’t respect me or my money, I’d not go there and I’d tell others.

    In business, choosing your customers was never part of the bargain. This whole thing is a great big avoidable mess. It should have been.

    The greatest deadly sin is Pride. The INN owners were wrong. With or without the law.


  26. - JS Mill - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 11:02 am:

    How Christian of the owners.

    Me thinks they are not giving the good book a full read.

    Maybe the are reading the Bigot’s version of Bible Cliff’s Notes?


  27. - d.p.gumby - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 11:15 am:

    Tho attributed to OWHolmes, the oft cited “your freedom to swing your arm ends at the tip of my nose” seems equally applicable–your freedom to practice your religion ends when it is imposed upon another’s freedom to ignore/avoid your religion–especially if you are operating a business of public accommodation.


  28. - Anonymous - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 12:04 pm:

    “No shirt, no shoes,no service”. Is that legal?


  29. - truth squad - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 12:09 pm:

    Yet clothing designers can refuse to conduct business with Melania Trump and the Left applauds heartily!


  30. - Rich Miller - Wednesday, Nov 30, 16 @ 12:15 pm:

    truth squad, that was one of the dumbest comments ever.

    Are you familiar with the concept of public accommodations, and that they have absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with someone who brands her name on clothes?


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* Question of the day
* Illinois Primary Health Care Association CEO resigns under racial cloud
* Rauner escapes criticism in gun rights hotbed
* More revisionist history
* It's most definitely ribbon-cutting season
* Pritzker ad: "Rauner wasted a billion dollars and got nothing for it"
* Expect partisan fireworks at committee hearing next week
* Bost opponent launches first TV ad
* *** LIVE COVERAGE ***
* Yesterday's stories

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............

...............
<


Loading


* Chuck Sweeny: Erika Harold brings her GOP attor.....
* Gov. Rauner signs two bills to help Veterans.....
* It's most definitely ribbon-cutting season..
* Rauner signs legislation for Quincy Veterans Ho.....
* Pritzker ad: “Rauner wasted a billion dollars a.....
* Rauner signs laws to speed up Veterans Home con.....
* Illinois Governor Signs Laws for Vets' Home.....
* Rauner Disagrees With Trump's Statements On.....
* Jim Dey's Hot Corner: Mark Glennon..
* ROSKAM's conversation with 'defensive&#.....


* Funds available for monument honoring Ida B. Wells-Barnett
* Correction: Mental Health Grants story
* Trump says Air Force One to get red, white and blue makeover
* Test track proposed for Illinois transportation lab
* Chicago museum stops selling doll depicting Hindu god
* Activist sues for video of Chicago police shooting
* Correction: Legionnaires’ Disease-Illinois story
* Off-duty EMT, lifeguard save girls from Lake Michigan waves
* Giant pyramid tourist attraction burns in northern Illinois
* Board votes to demolish 123-year-old Rock Island courthouse

* Springfield man wins Illinois State Police logo contest
* Rauner 'deeply troubled' by Trump's Helsinki comments
* Rauner signs bill to ease physician assistant hiring
* Bill taking Illinois out of voter registration system vetoed
* Rauner signs laws to improve Quincy veterans' home
* Rauner: President Trump should blame Russians for hacking
* Rauner signs laws to speed up Quincy veterans' home construction
* U of I paying alum $7,500 to halt sales of Chief Illiniwek T-shirt
* Rauner's campaign spent nearly $8 million last quarter. Pritzker's spent more than double that.
* Gov. Rauner signs two gun control bills, says he'll veto another

* Jewel-Osco names president
* How Grubhub and Uber Eats can save restaurants from apocalypse
* Sinclair to keep WGN-TV in revised Trib Media bid
* Sinclair to keep WGN-TV in revised Tribune Media bid
* Can a 3-D printer solve Chicago's affordable housing problem?


* White Sox option Charlie Tilson to Class AAA Charlotte
* Auto industry cries foul as Trump moves toward car tariffs
* UNC coach says football is ‘under attack’ because of CTE allegations
* Lay’s new ‘Taste of America’ chips include Deep Dish Pizza flavor
* Really big pike for Fish of the Week: Not too young for a fish of a lifetime
* What to look for from White Sox after All-Star break
* LaVar Ball weighs suspending JBA’s Chicago coach who shoved Ballers player
* Transgender detainee renews fight for transfer to all-female prison
* Chief Judge Timothy Evans reaches settlement with county in lawsuit over layoffs
* Girl, 5, fatally struck by vehicle pulling into driveway in Little Village


* Richard Marx meant he 'wouldn't' be right here waiting for you, and other reactions to Trump's walk-back
* Bikini Bottom owner agrees to use doormen, install cameras and scanners to cut down on illegal activities at West Dundee bar
* After a brief lull, we now return to our regularly scheduled baseball season
* Field Museum halts sale of 'insensitive' Hindu deity doll
* Crews responding to massive fire in Prospect Heights, people urged to avoid surrounding area
* Jabari Parker's edge makes homecoming more pragmatic than romantic
* Tale of sex, deception emerges about suspected Russian agent Maria Butina
* Trump asserts Russia not still targeting U.S., contradicting his top intelligence chief
* Pitchfork 2018 guide: What to know if you go
* Pitchfork 2018: Greg Kot picks the best acts to see


» 'Carnaval’ Festival To Highlight Latinx Stories In Theater
» The Cook County Sheriff Is Launching A Podcast On Opioid Addiction
» July 17, 2018 - Full Show
» Rauner Vetos 'Crosscheck' Ban — Illinois' Participation Already On Hold
» Rauner: Trump Should Be Holding Russians Accountable
» Suit: Chicago Should Refund Drivers Hit With Expensive Tickets
» Vallas Returns Campaign Cash From Controversial Donor Tied To CPS Scandal
» Biometric Data Lawsuit Reaches IL Supreme Court; Electronic Monitoring Devices; HPV Vaccines
» Illinois Governor Bruce Rauner Signs Two Bills Aimed at Reducing Gun Violence
» July 16, 2018 - Full Show


* Springfield man wins Illinois State Police logo contest
* Rauner 'deeply troubled' by Trump's Helsinki comments
* Guest View: As politicians duke it out, we must remember that most children just want to go home
* Byron York: Trump's approach doesn't work for the Trump-Russia probe
* Marc Thiessen: Trump isn't the first president to embarrass America by cozying up to Putin
* Catherine Rampell: Why do Republicans hate consumers?
* Rauner signs bill to ease physician assistant hiring
* Bill taking Illinois out of voter registration system vetoed
* Rauner signs laws to improve Quincy veterans' home
* Rauner: President Trump should blame Russians for hacking


* BND reporter undergoes mock rape exam
* Legislation could improve care for sexual assault victims
* Codfish Hollow has a 'museum-like' way of displaying its history: Wooden show posters
* Watch the demolition of historic, 150-year-old log home in O’Fallon
* Family offers $10K reward for info in hit-and-run after dad struck in Collinsville
* Glen Carbon dad critically injured in hit-and-run
* Gary Metivier buys ad agency, launches Metivier Media
* Boil order issued in Harrisburg
* Judge: Ruling over Davenport fire chief's dismissal expected within 2 months
* Boil order in effect for all of Carterville


* Cyclists to return to West Dundee, Elgin for Intelligentsia Cup
* Batavia plans app for self-guided tours of windmills
* Judge denies NFL's investigator request in concussion case
* Batavia fireworks committee deserves double the thanks
* CFD diver who died on search for missing boater signaled he was OK -- then sank

* Illinois pols criticize Trump's contro...
* Rep. Roskam Speaks Out Against Trump-Putin...
* Trump huddling with lawmakers on tax refor...
* Congressman Roskam talks about Trump meeti...
* Roskam Tells Trump to Speak to Putin More ...
* ROSKAM's conversation with 'defens...
* Letter: Check out LGBTQ voting records
* At White House, GOP Rep. Roskam confronts ...
* ALS Patient, Activist Ady Barkan Lobbies f...
* Kelly helps steer two of his bipartisan he...

* After Durbin slam, Chicago nonprofit promi......
* Democrats fault Kavanaugh comment on indep......
* Schumer demands Kavanaugh recuse himself f......
* White House dismisses 'laughable' ......
* Nonprofit investigating "disturbing&q......

* Get Loud Now makes it easy to mail a postc......
* Wyden-Merkley bill to 'reunify, protec......
* Democrats Launch Bill To Reunite All Separ......
* Us military preparing for north korea...
* US Senators Harris, Merkley, Cortez Masto ......

* 26 IL Counties declare themselves sanctuary counties for gun owners; 14 more considering resolution
* The Weekend Desk Report
* Court Vacates Injunction Against Publishing The Law
* Pilcher Park Now A Dedicated Nature Preserve
* Scholarly Publishing Is Broken. Here's How To Fix It.
* Do You Recognize This (Alleged) Package Thief?
* Brazilian Asylum Seeker Released After 11 Months In Detention; Grandson Had Been Held In Chicago
* France: Worthy Winners. But Here's What The Statistics Say About Who's Best In World Cup History
* Debunking The Broadcast Industry's Claims About Sinclair's Tribune Takeover
* Jeff Bezos Just Became The Richest Person Ever. Amazon Workers Just Marked #PrimeDay With Strikes Against Low Pay And Brutal Conditions.


* Nursing Home Violations for Second Quarter 2018
* Illinois Department of Human Rights Releases Important New Guidebook for Housing Providers
* Illinois State Fire Marshal announces $2.2 million in grants for fire safety
* Gov. Rauner vetoes SB 2368
* Governor takes bill action

  
* Former soldiers use AI to wage war on convenience store lines
* The Nokia X5 predictably has a notch and dual cameras
* eBay satisfies Q2 earnings targets
* A brief history of the world’s most controversial emoji
* Acer Chromebook Tab 10 review: The start of something beautiful
* Reddit added chat rooms, and they’re about what you’d expect
* IBM delivers Q2 revenue growth, IBM Z leads hardware gains

* Top MLB Prospects: Updated Top 50 Rankings
* Six Pack of Stats: 2018 All-Star Game
* Six Pack of Stats: 2018 All-Star Game
* White Sox first-round pick Nick Madrigal was magical in his ...
* Guzman hits walk-off single, DSL Reds beats DSL White Sox 2-1
* Hanley & Rozner: Bulls interested in Okafor? Manfred's crit...
* 10 Must-Read Stories for This Week


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Blagojevich Trial
Advertising
Updated Posts
Polls

Archives
July 2018
June 2018
May 2018
April 2018
March 2018
February 2018
January 2018
December 2017
November 2017
October 2017
September 2017
August 2017
July 2017
June 2017
May 2017
April 2017
March 2017
February 2017
January 2017
December 2016
November 2016
October 2016
September 2016
August 2016
July 2016
June 2016
May 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress




Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller