Capitol Fax.com - Your Illinois News Radar » Bill pulled after high costs questioned
SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
Bill pulled after high costs questioned

Thursday, Mar 16, 2017

* From the synopsis of HB 695

Provides that within one-year after the effective date of this amendatory Act, the Legislative Information System shall create a Spanish-language version of its website to provide legislative information. Specifies the legislative information to be placed on the Spanish-language website, and allows for the placement of additional unspecified information.

* The bill came up for a floor vote yesterday

“There is a segment, especially in my district, that are Spanish speaking and that follow the General Assembly and as a state representative, I want to commit to continue to have this bill and make sure we provide the best possible constituent services,” [sponsoring Rep. Silvana Tabares, D-Chicago] said.

Tabares estimated the cost of the translation, if initial software could not do it alone, at between $60,000 and $100,000 to pay for another website or software company. But she added that if a third party was needed to add Spanish to the site, it would have an estimated cost of between $800,000 to $1.5 million.

That estimate prompted House Republicans to offer up free options, such as Google Translate. It also had [Rep. Keith Wheeler, R-Oswego] holding up his own tablet to Democrats to show that he translated the website for free using Google.

“Why are we against a great free bipartisan solution?” State Rep. Mark Batinick, R-Plainfield, said before the bill was pulled. “We should have a Kumbaya and have a beer afterwards. Let’s pull this bill out of the record, let’s amend it. Let’s do something that’s free and help people who speak every language.”

The bill is now on Postponed Consideration.

The problem with any translating software (free or paid) is whether it can pick up nuances. Statutes are usually written in precise ways. Things can literally be lost or misconstrued in translation.

- Posted by Rich Miller        

33 Comments
  1. - Last Bull Moose - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:08 am:

    No matter how good the translation, one language should be the controlling version. In Illinois that would be English.

    When I worked in Saudi Arabia, the Arabic language contract controlled. Their country, their rules.


  2. - Bothanspy - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:10 am:

    This last paragraph is important. I was an SPSA for an agency and helped oversee this for our org. The Google translate was generally fine for schedules, directions etc. When translating legal statutes, it, came up short. For us, the legal language spelled out appeal rights and approval and denial legal citations. Ambiguity or translation errors here make it easy for the agency to lose cases on appeal. So in the end, you are going to need someone to validate all of the language translation anyway.
    Another thing to realize is that Google translate is not static. It is an algorithm that is improved and refined. So how something is translated today is not necessarily how it will appear tomorrow. It is difficult to maintain a legal history.


  3. - Precinct Captain - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:13 am:

    The idea that Batinick and Wheeler seriously offered Google Translate as an option does not speak well to their intelligence. It’s embarrassing, frankly, but have either of them flipped through the bills or statutes on the ILGA site?


  4. - swIFT taylor - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:15 am:

    To the last point on the post: during debate the sponsor was asked directly if her bill would mean that all text of all bills would be translated as well and she said no.


  5. - m - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:15 am:

    =Things can literally be lost or misconstrued in translation.=

    Yes, but the same thing happens with human translators. Not every word translates directly. And most native english speakers (including many leg staffers) have a hard time understanding bill text.

    Just translating the synopsis would be far better, and I would assume google could handle that just fine (plain english and all). Could be problematic for bills that have been shelled and amended, but that’s another issue for native english speakers as well. The synopsis should represent the bill in current form, not as filed (except that no one actually wants that level of transparency).


  6. - Nick Name - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:18 am:

    “Statutes are usually written in precise ways.”

    If only.


  7. - Anon - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:19 am:

    Students of the classics know how agonizing it can be to translate not only words but intent. Visit a visit the King James Bible.


  8. - Swift - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:21 am:

    Looks like the bill initially limits the Spanish language to certain segments of the website and does not include bill language, public acts, or statutes.


  9. - Downstate - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:26 am:

    Could the Spanish translation (done by human or computer) then be used in court to argue that the statute was not the same as the English one? Hence, the citizen could chose to follow the translation of their choice?


  10. - SAP - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:27 am:

    Rep. Hernandez tried this a few years ago for all forms used by any state agency and the cost estimates ran into the millions for some agencies. Well-intentioned idea, but crazy complicated and crazy expensive.


  11. - swIFT taylor - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:29 am:

    Its this easy! Did it in 2 minutes for free.

    Spanish: https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=en&tl=es&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ilga.gov%2Fhouse%2Fjournals%2Fdefault.asp

    Traditional chinese: https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=en&tl=zh-TW&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ilga.gov%2Fhouse%2Fjournals%2Fdefault.asp


  12. - GV - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:41 am:

    I used Google Translate to translate the synopsis of a property tax bill that Rep. Batinick introduced from English to Spanish and back to English.

    Translated Version:

    Modifies the Tax Code on Property. Provides that, as of fiscal year 2017, the Property Tax Extension Limitation Act applies to all tax districts, including rule of origin units. Provides that, as of the tax year 2017, the extension limitation under the Property Tax Extension Limitation Act is 0% or the voter-approved rate of increase. Preempts the start rule. Modifies the Law of Mandates of the State to demand its implementation without reimbursement. Cash immediately.

    Original:

    Amends the Property Tax Code. Provides that, beginning with the 2017 levy year, the Property Tax Extension Limitation Law applies to all taxing districts, including home rule units. Provides that, beginning with the 2017 levy year, the extension limitation under the Property Tax Extension Limitation Law is 0% or the rate of increase approved by the voters. Preempts home rule. Amends the State Mandates Act to require implementation without reimbursement. Effective immediately.


  13. - wordslinger - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:42 am:

    Every day, all over the country, citizens, lawmakers, lawyers and judges disagree on the meanings of statutes written in English.

    You think GA members are going to agree on a Spanish translation?


  14. - Gooner - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:45 am:

    I’m not one of those ranting “ENGLISH ONLY” people, but as to this, I would prefer to see English only.

    As others have referenced, the question is whether there would be a precise translation.

    There could be a disclaimer on the Spanish version stating that the English version controls, but then you really are doing a disservice to Spanish-speaking people by offering something that may not be accurate.

    I have family members who routinely speak a foreign language. It is a wonderful aspect of American culture.

    However, when it comes to official documents and official records, it really should be in one language.


  15. - Saluki - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:49 am:

    Why not add Japanese, French, Hindi, Chinese, Arabic, and Portuguese while we are at it. Maybe throw in the other 7000 languages around the world too!


  16. - Lucky Pierre - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:50 am:

    Our broke state should not just stop at paying 7 figures to translate everything into Spanish. There are probably at least two dozen languages we should translate every bill into.

    Why should the Spanish speakers get special treatment?


  17. - CG - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:57 am:

    We live in America, English folks.


  18. - wordslinger - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 10:59 am:

    What would it cost to get a translator to make sense of the governor and his GOMB crew?

    The proposed budget is balanced, but he needs unilateral power to repeal laws to cut $7 billion to make the proposed balanced budget balanced, but they can’t identify a dime of what could be cut from the proposed balanced budget to make the proposed balanced budget balanced.

    If not a translator, a cryptographer, maybe? Or a psychiatrist?


  19. - bothanspy - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 11:16 am:

    –I used Google Translate to translate the synopsis of a property tax bill that Rep. Batinick introduced from English to Spanish and back to English.—

    GV’s exercise is exactly why the Google service will not work. While the translation is generally close, close doesn’t really cut it for legal language. Home rule units =/= rule of origin units. Effective immediately =/= cash immediately :)
    Its a great idea to save money, though. There is no reason to start with the Google translated version and edit it from there. Surely, than can save money instead of starting from scratch.


  20. - downstate commissioner - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 11:19 am:

    While I wish that I had taken Spanish in high school, My German immigrant grandfather refused to teach his sons German. “We speak English in America.” And that was that.
    While I am not anti-immigrant, I don’t understand why we have to label everything in Spanish.
    Take the money for this and hire more Spanish to English teachers: assimilate these people, don’t make special rules….


  21. - Ron Burgundy - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 11:21 am:

    I’m OK with some sort of translation if they can control the costs and it is for convenience only. Any legal challenges, etc. would have to be based upon the English text which would control.


  22. - Downstate - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 11:48 am:

    “Any legal challenges, etc. would have to be based upon the English text which would control.”

    Exactly! If that’s the case, then the exactness of the translation is not as important.


  23. - Last Bull Moose - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 11:55 am:

    Downstate Commissioner,

    My Prussian great-grandfather had a similar rule. He left Prussia for good reasons.


  24. - A guy - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 12:47 pm:

    These bills all have a summary. Maybe just translate the summary in Spanish. For nuance, the Latino people will have to do what everyone else does; hire a lawyer or a lobbyist or both.


  25. - Huh? - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 12:56 pm:

    I am sure a good lawyer could make a civil rights case out of this issue.


  26. - Iamthepita - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 1:41 pm:

    If the Deaf, DeafBlind and the Hard of Hearing popular has access to services in language translation (e.g. American Sign Language Interpreter Services), why shouldn’t any other language be deprived from information in the language that they understand best?


  27. - NorthsideNoMore - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 2:36 pm:

    Captain you couldn’t be more wrong… Why does broke Illinois need to spend more money we don’t have? Some folks are ready spend big bucks when the simple solution is right in front of us…Google translates dozens of languages…. this internet thingy is pretty cool more people of all languages should try it.


  28. - IllinoisBoi - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 2:45 pm:

    Not sure how relevant this is, but it’s interesting:

    ‘English is Illinois’s official language. Illinois was one of the first states in America to pass an official language law, though its first official language was not English but “American”. In 1923, Representative Washington J. McCormick of Montana had failed to pass a bill in the United States Congress declaring “American” to be the official language of the United States. Following the bill’s failure, Senator Frank Ryan introduced a similar bill to the Illinois General Assembly. The bill passed with the support of Irish and Jewish politicians in Chicago, who, by rejecting the term “English”, wanted to show their opposition to British policies in Ireland and Palestine, respectively. In 1969, another act of the General Assembly replaced “American” with “English.”‘

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_Illinois


  29. - Veil of Ignorance - Thursday, Mar 16, 17 @ 6:03 pm:

    Fyi google translate without human review will lead to pretty inaccurate translations.


  30. - 1: - Friday, Mar 17, 17 @ 6:03 am:

    I am really loving the theme/design of your website. Do you ever run into
    any browser compatibility issues? A number of my
    blog visitors have complained about my site not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Safari.
    Do you have any tips to help fix this issue? http://thurman58p65848041.wikidot.com/blog:3


  31. - 1: - Friday, Mar 17, 17 @ 6:14 am:

    If you would like to take a great deal from this article then you have to apply these methods to your won blog. http://carlsteinke558.myblog.de/carlsteinke558/art/9219493/Most-Noticeable-Jocuri-Mario-Si-Luigi


  32. - 1: - Friday, Mar 17, 17 @ 6:18 am:

    Fabulous, what a website it is! This webpage provides useful data to us, keep it up. https://eldenbolinger.wordpress.com/2017/02/14/finding-the-best-jocuri-mario-si-luigi/


  33. - Late to the Party - Friday, Mar 17, 17 @ 7:55 am:

    In Illinois the official language is English. this is by state law. Why create web sites or forms or anything else in another language?

    Spanish? OK German? sure. Navajo? Why not. Icelandic? welcome to the party.


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


* Reader comments closed for Thanksgiving
* Campaign miscellaneous
* Question of the day
* Rauner's appointees kept Illinois in Crosscheck
* Illinois Policy Institute's lobbying arm got $2.5 million last year from group that bankrolled Merrick Garland fight
* There's more to Springfield than horseshoes
* Pritzker unveils opioid plan
* *** UPDATED x1 - Mendoza responds *** Rauner admin: "There can be no assurance that a budget will be enacted in future fiscal years"
* New Proft TV ad claims Durkin and Madigan "like Illinois state government just as it is"
* Rauner: "Illinois is at the edge of disaster"
* Shimkus won't endorse in gubernatorial primary
* Pritzker is taking a page from Rauner's 2014 campaign (in a good way)
* Biss wants more tax return details
* *** UPDATED x5 - Pritzker, ILGOP, Pritzker, Rauner, ILGOP respond *** Pritzker clarifies tax stance after Crain's interview
* Sen. Murphy endorses Silverstein challenger
* State GOP again demands that Durbin and Duckworth give away their Franken money
* Yesterday's stories

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............
<


Loading


* Illinois governor's race: 'Are we going to have.....
* McCaleb: Reasons to be thankful in tax-and-spen.....
* Gubernatorial race coming to a polling place ne.....
* GUEST COLUMN: Legislating responsibly in regard.....
* Ex-Buffalo Grove Mayor Ends 59th District State.....
* GEORGE WILL: 2018's most important, expensive, .....


* Philanthropy earns Howard Buffett spot on Wall of Fame
* Police to target shoppers abusing handicapped parking spots
* Man stabbed to death in Carbondale, girlfriend charged
* TransCanada: Over 24K gallons of oil recovered from spill
* Court: Stress no grounds for rescinding guilty pleas
* Fire at Metra station in Wheaton
* Report says multiple DCFS workers in Illinois attacked
* 3 charged in April slaying of Chicago area Lyft driver
* Operative in Mexican drug cartel appears in Chicago court
* Sexual harassment lawsuit against Rutherford dismissed

* Laura Campbell suspended from IDOT job for interviewing friend for job
* Sex-harassment lawsuit against Rutherford dismissed
* Hunters take 51,365 deer during first firearm weekend
* House task force to review sexual harassment
* Electric cars, better fuel efficiency spell doom for Illinois gas tax
* Springfield wants out of legislation limiting payments for 5G antennas
* Fact check: Are Gov. Rauner's grandparents immigrants?
* Londrigan accused of attacking Davis for 'opposite' of remarks
* Gov. Rauner signs sex harassment legislation
* Under the Dome Podcast: Governor's race, sexual harassment, Rodney Davis

* Judge swears in new U.S. attorney for northern Illinois
* Get ready to pay more to keep the lights on . . .
* Get ready to pay more to keep the lights on—by turning power plants off
* Chicago is buying into bitcoin in a big way
* Correction


* Woman, 24, shot in Old Irving Park
* Georgia Nicols horoscopes for Nov. 24, 2017
* Dear Abby: Tenant misbehaves, blames sleepwalking
* 2 charged after running from stolen vehicle in Loop
* High school friends play 50th Turkey Bowl
* Lombard home uninhabitable after fire, no injuries reported
* Flynn lawyers make a break with Trump team
* Barton to go mum over disclosed photo, citing probe
* Sound heard in Argentine sub search was likely ‘explosion’
* Woman, 24, shot in Bronzeville drive-by


* Sound heard in Argentine sub search was likely 'explosion'
* Zimbabwe's ruling party assured Mugabe he wouldn't face prosecution
* 3 wounded in Chicago shootings, including 1 shot by security guard
* Man charged with robbing students in Grant Park, 2 others still sought
* Homeless man accused of stealing $50 from man who said he had no cash
* Man killed is among 6 shot: 'You have to hope that no one comes down the street shooting.'
* Odd holiday gifts for the Chicago sports fan in your life
* Man says, 'You deserved it,' shoots at slain man's grave: Prosecutors
* Blackhawks' John Hayden fined for second high-sticking penalty in three games
* Friday's matchup: Bulls at Warriors


» Cinderella Chicago Football Team Heads to State, Aiming For Repeat
» Senior Republican Congressman Declines To Endorse Gov. Rauner
» AT&T Pushing 'Small Cells,' But Some Cities Object
» Third-Party Candidates Want Rules Eased To Get On Ballot
» Third Party Candidates Want Rules Eased To Get On Ballot
» How Chicago’s New Budget Could Affect You In 2018 — And Beyond
» How A Chicago Cop Sentenced To Prison Could Affect The Jason Van Dyke Trial
» Illinois Lawmaker's Plan To Combat Opioid Abuse With Cannabis
» Black Lives Matter Takes On Hunger With New Food Box
» State Week: Are Voters Thinking About 2018?


* Laura Campbell suspended from IDOT job for interviewing friend for job
* Counterpoint: Car buyers lose when government tells them what to buy
* Point: US automakers are swept up in a global electric-vehicle rush
* Eugene Robinson: Congress should investigate Trump's alleged sexual misconduct
* Thumbs Up: To local football teams going to state tournaments
* Bernard Schoenburg: Lineup for 2018 to get going with filing
* Our View: Forget the excess, give thanks for simple needs being met
* Sex-harassment lawsuit against Rutherford dismissed
* Hunters take 51,365 deer during first firearm weekend
* Byron York: Six scenarios for GOP disaster in Roy Moore Senate race


* Belleville Thanksgiving 5K
* Belleville seeks to demolish 'dangerous' home
* Belleville woman gives emotional appeal to save home from demolition
* Crash claims another life
* Hundreds of volunteers, families turn out for busiest 'Mr. Thanksgiving' meal yet
* Carbondale native walks in 'Project Runway' season finale
* Third person dies after I-55 crash that killed Staunton sisters
* Belleville apartment building evacuated after Thanksgiving Day fire
* Holiday shopping kicks off in Decatur
* Road construction will mean detours in Davenport this week


* AP source: Flynn lawyers make a break with Trump team
* China reports breaking up gang that moved $3 billion abroad
* Bucket Bowl: Indiana, Purdue put postseason hopes on line
* Giants get 1 1st down, 47 yards in half, lose 20-10 to Skins
* Mississippi stuns No. 16 Mississippi State 31-28 in Egg Bowl

* US lawmakers urge Trump to prod Rody on dr...
* Republican tax overhaul plan gets mixed re...
* Mary Kramer is named group publisher of Cr...
* Geneva Chamber honors Gaines for 40 years ...
* DOJ to ban US lawmakers should Duterte ord...
* Panel encourages women to consider careers...
* US lawmakers to Duterte: 'Sovereignty does...
* Letter: Why I support Lauren Underwood - N...
* Hultgren and Ruppersberger: Protect infras...
* This RSS feed URL is deprecated

* This RSS feed URL is deprecated...

* This RSS feed URL is deprecated...

* Can Chicago support more pro soccer? Does North Side want its own team?
* Refugee Families Celebrate First Thanksgiving At St Thomas Of Canterbury
* The Week In Chicago Rock
* What You Need To Know About The FCC's Plan To End Net Neutrality
* Happy Thanksgiving & Happy Holidays
* Thanksgiving – a holiday diminished?
* Watch Hanbun chef David Park turn a spicy, fermented condiment into dessert
* Restaurant Slated For Lawrence House Retail Space
* Thanksgiving in Chicago: best things to do
* Is it time to reimagine justice and accountability for sexual misconduct?


* Illinois Awarded Funds to Offer Advanced Training on Detecting Impaired Driving
* Illinois EPA Announces Upcoming Household Hazardous Waste Collection Events
* IEMA Highlights Emergency Preparedness for People with Access and Functional Needs in May - Ready Illinois website offers preparedness tips for people, caregivers
* First Lady Launches Illinois Family Connects
* Governor and Lt. Governor Unveil 2016 Journal of Local Government Shared Service Best Practices

  
* Razer Phone’s camera deemed “a dealbreaker,” but it will get better
* The Pocketnow Black Friday 2017 deals watchlist
* The Moto Z’s Alexa Smart Speaker is mostly useless
* [TA Deals] The Treblab X11 headphones are discounted more than 80%
* [Deal] Pick up some cheap SD cards from Amazon’s Black Friday sales
* Verizon quietly launches $30 and up Ellipsis 10 HD, offers free ZenFone V with new lines
* Pixel phones get instant access to Google Lens through Google Assistant

* Terrerobytes: Hall of Fame letter obscures Hall of Fame ballot
* Sox team with Chicago comedian vs. cancer
* MLB clears two offseason obstacles
* Black Friday sale: Take 25 percent off in Shop
* Take 25 percent off Shop orders $25 or more
* Climb machine: Eloy working way up to MLB
* First year of White Sox rebuild closing with 40-man maneuvering


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Blagojevich Trial
Advertising
Updated Posts
Polls

Archives
November 2017
October 2017
September 2017
August 2017
July 2017
June 2017
May 2017
April 2017
March 2017
February 2017
January 2017
December 2016
November 2016
October 2016
September 2016
August 2016
July 2016
June 2016
May 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress




Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller