Capitol Fax.com - Your Illinois News Radar » Response to Illinois Times
SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
CapitolFax.com
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
Response to Illinois Times

Thursday, Feb 28, 2008

By Scott Reeder

SPRINGFIELD – A recent article in Illinois Times is more than a bit perplexing.

The writer, Peter Downs, repeats some old claims made by David Comerford, a publicist for a teachers union, the Illinois Federation of Teachers.

First of all, who is this writer Peter Downs?

Illinois Times describes him as a member of the St. Louis School Board and a freelance writer. That’s accurate as far as it goes.

If one does a quick Google search you’ll find that Mr. Downs worked extensively for teacher union publications and received substantial campaign contributions from American Federation of Teachers affiliates.

In fact, here is how Mr. Downs is described in a 2006 article in AFT’s magazine “American Teacher”

“Peter Downs and Donna Jones can thank the St. Louis Teachers & School Related Personnel Union for their election to the city’s school board earlier this year. It was the unwavering support of the AFT affiliate that helped these parents overcome the odds and beat their heavily favored—and funded—opponents.”

It’s clear that Mr. Downs should have disclosed his obvious conflict of interest instead of writing such a piece.

Unfortunately, responding to Mr. Comerford’s erroneous claims and counterclaims has become old hat.

For example, Mr. Comerford questioned in a magazine article, a news release and an internet posting a statement in “The Hidden Costs of Tenure” that a school district could reasonably expect to spend $100,000 in a tenure teacher dismissal case. He contended it rarely costs more than $50,000 and added:

“The point I’m making is that Reeder blew the dollar figure way out of proportion to add even greater slant to his hit piece.” (Capitol Fax, Dec. 7, 2005)

In response, I filed Freedom of Information Act requests for every attorney billing paid by an Illinois school district over a five-year period in a tenure teacher dismissal case. The average came out at $219,000. (44 percent of those were still under appeal, so the ultimate cost will be considerably higher.)

I invited Mr. Comerford to come over to my office and review these attorney billing documents. For some reason, he never took me on the offer – or publicly corrected his earlier assertions.

Now he’s making another flawed claim that somehow the investigation understated the number of tenured teachers fired each year.

Among the findings of the 2005 series “The Hidden Costs of Tenure” was that an average of seven tenured teachers are fired each year. How do I know this — by reading every tenure hearing officer ruling over an 18-year period.

As a practical matter, an Illinois school board can only recommend to a tenure hearing officer that a teacher be fired.

When a school board recommends the dismissal of a teacher, there are two choices: go before a hearing officer and fight to keep the job or quit. In theory, they could forego a chance to remain employed or the possibility of a severance package and do nothing. (But the investigation focused on realities, not legal theories or aberrations.)

“If someone is contending teachers are choosing to get fired rather than fight it or quit, there must be something in the water they are drinking,” said T.J. Wilson, an attorney specializing in education employment law.

Quotes used in the series were based on audio recordings, meticulous notes and emailed statements. At times when quotes were ambiguous, sources were re-contacted for further clarification.

In the case of Cicero superintendent Clyde Senters, specific quotes were discussed and approved prior to publication to ensure not only their accuracy but their context. (An unfortunate reality in journalism is that occasionally someone making controversial or inflammatory statements will try to back away from those comments.)

Mr. Comerford also claims the Illinois State Police investigator Dennis Kuba was misquoted. It’s an interesting assertion considering Kuba doesn’t contend he was misquoted.

I quoted Kuba saying: “In all the years I’ve investigated sex crimes I have never found a case of a child lying about being abused by non-family member.”

When I talked to Dennis recently, he acknowledged making the statement but added what he meant was: In all the years he’s investigated sex crimes he has never had a case prosecuted in which a child lied about being abused by non-family member.

The distinction may seem subtle, but we had no problem running the clarification in both our online and print editions.

He also said Mr. Comerford’s comments that children frequently lie about being sexually abused by non-family members as ridiculous. But don’t take my word for it, you can listen to a voicemail message he left in that regard at: www.hiddenviolations.com.

Also in the Illinois Times article Mr. Comerford is quoted three times as saying Small Newspaper Group hired Eric Johnson and his company, Frontline Public Strategies, to promote interest in the investigations.

The only Eric Johnson I know played basketball at Galesburg High School back in 1983. Perhaps, Mr. Comerford is referring to Eric Robinson. We did indeed hire his firm.

The truth will fit any place.

- Posted by Rich Miller        

7 Comments »
  1. - Dave Comerford - Thursday, Feb 28, 08 @ 2:57 pm:

    First of all, the Illinois Times decided who would write that story and Mr. Downs contacted me, not the other way around.

    I have consistently said that the IFT’s average cost was $50,000 and I stand by that figure. Mr. Reeder knows that, but he continues to spin that. I did question why it costs districts so much moire than it costs the union. Mr. Reeder did not want to ask the attorney’s like TJ Wilson what they bill per hour or why the cost is so high. Attorney’s like Mr. Wilson make a very good living off of high bills for school districts. He is certainly going to support his clients wishes. Hardly an unbiased source. Yet Reeder quotes him like it’s gospel.
    Even still, Mr. Reeder’s stated average cost for school districts is very skewed because he uses a $1,000,000 cost for Cecil Roth, who represents himself, is not backed by the union or any attorney and is a very unique case. If you take away that one case, the average drops over $60,000. I pointed this out to Reeder, but he chose to use the more sensational number.

    I spoke with Superintendent. Senters and Mr. Kuba and my conversations were different from Mr Reeder’s. Kuba did acknowledge that there are cases where children make up stories about their teachers. He did say that an investigator “should” be able to see through that, but there’s no guarantee.

    The work of Dr. Manos clearly shows that false accusations can destroy teachers careers. Dr. Manos is a school administrator who Reeder spoke with, but chose to ignore in the series.

    Reeder supports the court system 100 percent if a teacher is found guilty, but he questions that same court system if a teacher is found innocent.

    Eric Robinson has been promoting Reeder’s series across the state and lining up interviews for him. One of Robinson’s clients is the school administrators among others. This is an obvious conflict of interest. Reeder did decline to speak to the reporter about this.

    Reeder also received a $10,000 “award” from the Institute on Political Journalism (IPJ)[1]. One of IPJ’s stated goals is to make sure reporters, “have the tools to accurately cover issues involving economic concepts and free market principles.”[2] One of IPJ’s more notable names on the Board of Visitors is former White House spokesperson Tony Snow.[3]

    IPJ is part of The Fund for American Studies (TFAS), an organization funded by large corporations including Northrup Grumman, Motorola, Caterpillar and Pfizer, just to name a few.[4] The fund is praised by Websites such as the Conservative Voice[5], while scrutinized by others such as Media Transparency.[6] One of TFAS’ honored Alumni is Clint Bolick, President of the Alliance for School Choice.[7]

    Obviously a group that wants award those who will write anti-union stories. Every other reporter I know goes out of their way to even have the slightest appearance of conflict… not Reeder.


  2. - Scott Reeder - Thursday, Feb 28, 08 @ 4:40 pm:

    Just for the record, here is results of FOIA requests for attorney billings. The story ran in June 2006.
    Illinois school districts that hired outside lawyers in an effort to dismiss these tenured teachers spent an average of $219,000 in legal fees.

    Robert Gilbert, Township $1,373,236

    Cecil Roth, Geneseo $450,000*

    Sandra Betts, Joliet $251,969

    Karen Horwitz, AVOCA $225,138

    Estherlene Holmes, Cook County $188,824

    Lauri Buchna, Illinois Valley Central $178,849

    James Leonard, Orland Park $149,337

    Susan Copeland, Northbrook $135,617

    Stephen Wright, Downers Grove $134,799

    Bruce Gilbert, Rich Township $102,601

    Kirk Barton, Auburn $95,117

    Georgeann Davis, SPEED $92,875

    Robert Kosten, Collinsville $66,629

    Carmelina Impellizeri, Leyden $37,158

    Joe Landis, Nokomis $24,601

    Curtis Portelli, Chicago Heights $5,319

    * Reflects an estimate of $160,000 spent by the school district in the dismissal case and $290,000 in attorney fees to handle subsequent litigation brought by Mr. Roth.

    ** Appeals are pending for 7 of the 16 individuals listed.


  3. - DumberThanYouTHink - Thursday, Feb 28, 08 @ 4:45 pm:

    You guys are having all the fun…One must wonder if the SpinSisters have adopted you as BoyToys to divert attention from POA?


  4. - Michelle Flaherty - Thursday, Feb 28, 08 @ 5:20 pm:

    That Eric Johnson was a guitar god in the early 90s. I still love Cliffs of Dover. I’d always wondered what happened to him. Guitar genius to pr flak — who knew?


  5. - Bruno - Thursday, Feb 28, 08 @ 7:48 pm:

    The idea that teachers deserve tenure, protection from competition, or any other form of benefit greater than the average employee has always been a wonder to me.

    The entire purpose of a union is to extract the maximum amount of money and benefits for the least amount of effort. (this is not debatable)

    So here is the question for all you citizens, parents, and taxpayers out there. If your goal is an educated populace, why would ever have acquiesced to paying the most money for the least education?

    DOH!!!

    Fund Children, not Bureaucracies.


  6. - Rich Miller - Thursday, Feb 28, 08 @ 7:52 pm:

    ===The entire purpose of a union is to extract the maximum amount of money and benefits for the least amount of effort. (this is not debatable)===

    Please.


  7. - Bruno - Friday, Feb 29, 08 @ 5:46 am:

    Rich,

    Let me clarify. The purpose of an employer/Corporation is to extract the most work out of every employee for the least amount of pay and benefits.

    So, one is true, and the other is not?

    There are many ways to shift the semantics, and no one would argue that people shouldn’t have the right to join a union and bargain collectively for better pay, benefits, and conditions.

    But really, if we want the most education for the least amount of taxes, then why should we (as taxpayers) put up with tenure, unwarranted pension benefits (which younger teachers simply must know can’t be sustained), and worst of all, strikes.

    Don’t get me wrong. Teachers should have the right to strike, but parents should have the right to fire them when they do.


TrackBack URI

Post your comment... And please take a half second to come up with a nickname. It makes following the posts easier for everyone... Thanks

In other words, do your best to be civilized and smart.


PREVIOUS POSTS »
* Madigan taps Maggie Hickey for independent investigation of House
* New photos of the Executive Mansion, and some vintage ones
* Question of the Day
* Wisconsin gerrymandering case punted by Supreme Court
* Morrison defends his handling of SVP arrested twice for child sex crimes
* Rauner campaign launches two new initiatives
* Adventures in data governing
* Higher ed group to continue working this summer
* *** UPDATED x4 *** State Senate candidate once dressed up in blackface for Halloween
* Brady says GOP leveraged balanced budget from nervous Dems
* *** LIVE COVERAGE ***
* Politifact rates Rauner Legionnaires' claim 'False'
* Former 'Chicago Tonight' host Elizabeth Brackett has died
* Yesterday's stories

Support CapitolFax.com
Visit our advertisers...

...............

...............

...............

...............
<


Loading


* Dale Gardner Veterans Memorial Bridge plaque un.....
* Rauner campaign launches two new initiatives..
* Illinois to fund Medicaid preventative dental s.....
* Vote in the Scott Stantis cartoon caption contest..
* State, Lake County Resolutions Critical Of Foxc.....
* History buffs may want to consider a trip to Sp.....
* Instagram posts from Aurora's first ever ga.....
* State, federal governments push for overdose pr.....
* Brady says GOP leveraged balanced budget from n.....
* Illinois Budget Bill Makes Few Tax Changes exce.....


* Canadian man identified in fatal Illinois skydiving accident
* Correction: Skydiver Death-Illinois story
* Records: Trump Tower failed to follow fish protection rules
* Illinois to fund Medicaid preventative dental services
* Mother of man fatally shot by central Illinois police sues
* Search continues for 2 after southern Illinois jail escape
* Indiana residents oppose development of waste facility
* Cleanup of massive central Illinois rock slide begins
* Midwestern states endure flash flooding, heat wave
* New organization that honors black firefighters to open

* Chatham man wins Illinois Bicentennial coin design contest
* Rauner to consider allowing medical cannabis for opioid patients
* Bipartisan work yields gun bills, fate rests with Rauner
* Rauner names Justin Blandford curator of Governor's Mansion
* Rauner names Williamsville woman interim HFS director
* Both Rauner and Pritzker have donated to Mansion renovations
* Both candidates for governor have donated to Mansion renovations
* Illiopolis boy helps push bill to cover hearing aids for kids
* Under the Dome Podcast: AFSCME lawsuits everywhere, #MeToo fallout, governor ad war
* Rauner says more ads coming like one featuring other Republican governors

* Here's what Walgreens' new downtown digs will look like
* Trump: Sanctuary cities order should be limited to Chicago
* Trump administration seeks Supreme Court order on sanctuary cities
* Michigan Avenue penthouse sells for $8 million
* Show us your office!


* At start of LeGrier trial, cop who fired fatal shot defended as ‘reasonable’
* Second driver identified in fatal wrong-way crash on I-57
* Barry Trotz resigns as Capitals’ coach after Stanley Cup win
* Rahm joins parade slamming Trump policy to separate families at US-Mexico border
* FBI’s Wray, Justice Dept. grilled over Clinton email investigation report
* Disney issues seizure warning about ‘Incredibles 2’ for fans with epilepsy
* Emanuel says Amazon ‘really liked’ two Chicago sites
* Chicago, look to the future and go ahead with Elon Musk’s tunnel to O’Hare
* Slave owners and Nazis quote Romans 13 to justify immorality, too
* Body found in burned vehicle in Gary


* Cubs' Javier Baez out against Dodgers, Kris Bryant bats leadoff
* Emanuel: Amazon 'really likes' two Chicago sites
* Hundreds of immigrant children are being held in fenced cages at border facility
* Divided District 64 board seeks committee to weigh in on school resource officer program
* JetBlue founder looks to start new low-cost U.S. airline, reports say
* Porter County cop accused of exposing himself to women
* Trial opens in 2015 police shooting in which bat-wielding teen and bystander killed
* Turano Baking seeks new office building in south Oak Park
* A day before his father sent to prison in Turkey, Knicks' Enes Kanter talked democracy in Mount Prospect
* Rocker Tommy Lee's drama with son Brandon gets ugly on Father's Day


» Illinois Bicentennial Coin Unveiled
» Austin Texas, Like Chicago, Is Struggling With Pedestrian Safety
» Push To Bridge Gender Wage Gap Continues
» Pediatrics For Transgender Kids; ‘Pay What You Can’ Yoga Studio; Illinois Politics
» Dad-isms: Jokes and Lessons Our Fathers Taught Us
» Parkland Survivors Join Chicago Youth, Celebrities At St. Sabina's Peace March
» Why Don’t Chicago Beaches Have A Poop Threshold?
» Furniture From Closed CPS Schools Ends Up In Surprising Places
» Students Go Back In Time To Record On Machine That Democratized Music
» State Week: AFSCME Contract; Abortion Court Fight; Former Madigan Staffer Responds To Accusations


* Chatham man wins Illinois Bicentennial coin design contest
* Rauner to consider allowing medical cannabis for opioid patients
* George Will: Congress suffers arthritic knees from genuflecting to presidential power
* Bipartisan work yields gun bills, fate rests with Rauner
* Bernard Schoenburg: Gov. Rauner owns Sangamon farmland — with somebody
* Bernard Schoenburg: Rauner owns Sangamon farmland — with somebody
* Angie Muhs: New reporter will focus on local business coverage
* Our View: City should not put competing township referendum on ballot
* Faith Coalition for the Common Good: Leaders impact lives of homeless
* Statehouse Insider: Illinois second to Missouri again


* St. Louis Children’s Hospital will show free screening of East St. Louis football doc
* Collinsville man charged with murder in fatal shooting of former neighbor
* Welcome to campus, Ayo
* Shots fired, body found, strange coincidence
* Chatham student designs winning Bicentennial coin
* Illinois to fund Medicaid preventative dental services
* Franklin County town hall to tackle opioid misuse
* BBB warns customers about Rural King, citing 'an underlying pattern of complaints'
* State police investigating after man shot dead by officer during domestic disturbance
* Fire calls


* What suburban members of Congress are saying about Trump immigration policy
* Correction: Skydiver Death-Illinois story
* Report: Shooting in Sweden leaves 4 injured
* H. Clinton: Separating families at border a 'moral crisis'
* Trump admin. asks high court to halt sanctuary cities ruling

* Apartment building with affordable units p...
* The Mothers and Offspring Mortality and Mo...
* Kelly likely to keep seat
* Conway Laments Migrant Family Separation &...
* Berthoud High School second semester honor...
* Luis Gutierrez: GOP Is Using Xenoph...
* How Donald Trump and Chuy Garcia Broke the...
* Lipinski to hold events for 3rd District r...
* Rep. Davis to host military family roundtable
* Peyton Reed Reveals If 'Ant-Man And Th...

* Rebellious Resistance Guide: How to Fight ......
* Monday, June 18, 2018...
* Lvm Capital Management LTD Decreased Its B......
* Great West Life Assurance Company Has Uppe......
* Trump tweets Dems and GOP should get toget......

* Rebellious Resistance Guide: How to Fight ......
* The Democrats' Myopic Reaction to the ......
* Tammy Duckworth for Senate Tammy......
* Our view: GOP group spot on in recent Blag......
* "Senator Tammy Duckworth …&quo......

* Windy City Ribfest Kicks Off July Fourth Holiday Weekend
* The nutty Trump trolls, the Korea agreement and Democrat cold-warriors.
* “They could be murderers and thieves.” Donald Trump.
* Survey: U.S. Public Skeptical That North Korea Will Get Rid of Nukes
* Judicial Watch Sues State Department for Obama-Era Records on Refugee Resettlement Site Locations
* LA Times: High cost of housing drives up homeless rates, UCLA study indicates
* Clark Co joins growing number of Illinois counties passing resolutions upholding Second Amendment
* Talking is better than war.
* Don Hellison.
* 50% oppose sanctuary communities in new Rasmussen poll


* 2017 Wabash County Tentative Multiplier Announced
* Liquor Control Commission Underage Compliance Report for Cook County
* Liquor Control Commission Underage Compliance Report for Will Count
* Multi-State Salmonella Outbreak Linked To Cereal
* PHIL VASSAR AND LOVE AND THEFT ROUND OUT THE DU QUOIN STATE FAIR GRANDSTAND

  
* Tronc to change name back to Tribune Publishing after years of ridicule
* YouTube Music and YouTube Premium are officially launching today, includes more countries
* KCC comes to confirm the existence of an LG smartwatch with Wear OS
* Microsoft says it’s ‘dismayed’ by child separations after criticism over ICE contract
* FCC filing hints at the Moto C2 Android Go smartphone from Motorola
* Google removes Uber integration in Maps with no explanation
* OnePlus’ Kyle Kiang talks OnePlus 6 and record sales

* Cleveland Indians vs. Chicago White Sox lineups for Monday, ...
* White Sox Minor League News and Notes, 6/11 to 6/17
* White Sox Weekly Minor League Update: Week 11
* White Sox Weekly Minor League Update: Week 11
* Robert returns from injury to make pro debut
* Dominguez leads DSL Orioles to 4-0 win over DSL White Sox
* Cleveland Indians: Previewing three-game series against the Whit...


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Blagojevich Trial
Advertising
Updated Posts
Polls

Archives
June 2018
May 2018
April 2018
March 2018
February 2018
January 2018
December 2017
November 2017
October 2017
September 2017
August 2017
July 2017
June 2017
May 2017
April 2017
March 2017
February 2017
January 2017
December 2016
November 2016
October 2016
September 2016
August 2016
July 2016
June 2016
May 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress




Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller