Capitol - Your Illinois News Radar » The partisan redistricting debate moves to SCOTUS
SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version     Exclusive Subscriber Content     Updated Posts    Contact
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here.
The partisan redistricting debate moves to SCOTUS

Wednesday, Oct 4, 2017

* AP

In a case that could reshape American politics, the Supreme Court appeared split Tuesday on whether Wisconsin Republicans gave themselves an unfair advantage when they drew political maps to last a decade.

If Justice Anthony Kennedy, whose vote almost certainly controls the outcome, is prepared to join his liberal colleagues, the court could rule for the first time that districting plans that entrench one party’s control of a legislature or congressional delegation can violate the constitutional rights of the other party’s voters. That could lead to changes in political maps across the country.

* As we’ve already discussed, this case revolves around the “efficiency gap,” which, the SCOTUS blog explains, “looks at the number of votes ‘wasted’ in each election, either because they are cast for the losing candidate or because the victorious candidate did not need them to win”

(M)uch of [the court’s time] was spent in the weeds, on what Justice Stephen Breyer described as another “hard issue” in the case: If courts are going to get involved with partisan-gerrymandering cases, what are manageable standards that they can apply to evaluate the claims? Breyer offered Tseytlin a five-part test that looked at, among other things, whether one party controls the legislature and the redistricting process; whether the redistricting maps create “partisan asymmetry” – that is, they do not treat the different political parties equally; and whether that asymmetry is “persistent” and extreme. “I suspect,” Breyer told Tseytlin, that the test is manageable. […]

[Erin Murphy, arguing for the Wisconsin State Senate] picked up this theme, reminding the justices that the kinds of standards that the plaintiffs have proposed have identified “false positives” – districts that appear to be the result of gerrymandering but are not – 50% of the time. What, she asked rhetorically, are legislatures supposed to do when confronted with problems like these? […]

[Justice Elena Kagan] seemed to be on board with Breyer’s standard, but looked for reassurance that the courts would not be inundated with challenges to other redistricting maps in the future. Smith suggested a variety of measures that seemed to placate Kagan, but not Roberts, who complained that the kind of statistics-based predictions that Smith’s measures would call for had “been a very hazardous exercise” for the court in the past. Alito also complained about the “dozens of uncertainties” in the process that Smith was proposing.

* The potential for a large number of cases disputing whether a state’s map is in compliance is real. For example, there are strongly differing opinions on whether Illinois would be ruled out of compliance

(A)ccording to Nick Stephanopolous, a law professor and lawyer for Wisconsin Democrats, it would leave Madigan’s partisan cartography undisturbed.

“At this point, no, (the Wisconsin case would not affect Illinois), simply because the ‘efficiency gap’ isn’t big enough for Illinois,” he said.

* On the other hand

In 2012, [Illinois] Democratic House candidates got 52 percent of the vote statewide but captured 60 percent of the seats, report political scientist Kent Redfield of the University of Illinois at Springfield and policy consultant Cynthia Canary. In 2014, Democrats got 50.5 percent of the vote and 60 percent of the seats. This year, Madigan’s party again won 60 percent of the races.

That’s why Illinois Republicans may side with Wisconsin Democrats on one issue: partisan gerrymandering.

* From a Change Illinois fundraising e-mail…

Yesterday, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in a landmark case that could change America’s political landscape and establish constitutional limits to partisan gerrymandering. If the Court establishes a new constitutional standard prohibiting partisan gerrymandering, this will apply nationwide and could be used to finally change Illinois seriously flawed redistricting process before new legislative maps are drawn after the 2020 census.

“Could” is the operative word there. Maybe, maybe not.

- Posted by Rich Miller        

  1. - Not Rich - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 1:43 pm:

    winners DRAW losers LITIGATE.. it is a founding principle of American government.

  2. - Anonymous - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 1:51 pm:

    Many people complain about Illinois’ maps, but the maps before the US Supreme Court are far worse. The ruling could easily declare Wisconsin’s gotta change, but in a way that means Illinois doesn’t.

  3. - So_Ill - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 1:54 pm:

    Nationally, this would help democrats a whole lot more than it would hurt them.

  4. - The Captain - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 1:57 pm:

    I think very highly of Redfield and Canary but adding up the total votes for State Rep and using that as the measurement has a major flaw, many races have no opponent even some that really should have been contested. For example they say that “In 2014, Democrats got 50.5 percent of the vote and 60 percent of the seats.” Fair, but look at the districts that had no opponent. For example John Bradley, Jerry Costello and Brandon Phelps all had no Republican opponent and Rauner won all of those districts by more than 30 points. The Republicans could have won any or all of those districts in a midterm election that was also a big Republican year locally and nationally. They didn’t win them so the Dems got 60% of the seats that year but this isn’t evidence of gerrymandering, it’s evidence of ineptitude.

  5. - COPN - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 2:23 pm:

    Hopefully the majority of the SC is looking for more than just a manageable standard and at least account for (1) certain demographics already being packed by geography and (2) equal protection rights don’t necessarily equate to a right to proportional partisanship in a state legislature.

  6. - Last Bull Moose - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 2:40 pm:

    I hope the Supreme Court stays out of this political issue. Membership in a political party does not make a person a member of a protected class.

    I advocate for 3 person districts like we had before the Cutback Amendment. Those are hard to Gerrymander.

    But I don’t want judges running this process. It damages their credibility.

  7. - JB13 - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 2:45 pm:

    Nothing quite like a gerrymandering discussion with Illinois Democrats.
    “C’mon, man, legislative maps don’t determine who wins. Well, except in Wisconsin.”
    “Then, give up control of the maps.”

  8. - FPJ - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 2:46 pm:

    A recent “explainer” in the Times goes into why Illinois (and New York) are kind of unique cases for this efficiency gap calculation. Both states have such concentrated populations centers that the political geography of urban Democrats and rural Republicans really throws the test for a loop. In fact, this test gives Illinois Republican a slight efficiency advantage!

  9. - DuPage Saint - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 2:54 pm:

    Read that two of the three worst maps are Democrat and that Maryland is the most partisan (Democrat) map. And another issue brought up is that Democrats and Republicans do not necessarily stay Democrat or Republican.
    Still think some guy with a computer could drawn rather square or rectangular lines with the correct number of people in the district and also trying to c=keep counties and or towns in same district.

  10. - FPJ - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 2:54 pm:

    Honestly, the only way around the political geography issue is some kind of state-wide proportional representation system. That doesn’t seem to be a likely outcome any time soon.

  11. - Sue - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 4:10 pm:

    At least in Illinois- this would be Madigans worst nightmare

  12. - Lamont - Wednesday, Oct 4, 17 @ 7:54 pm:

    The simple, and obvious, solution is statewide proportional representation. And we need to do away with the onerous restrictions on parties not named “Democratic” and “Republican”. Jeez, it’s 2017 already.

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.

* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
* Quinn's Obama ad shenanigan prompts rebuke: "Black voters won’t be bamboozled by him again"
* HRC does GOTV robo for JB
* Rauner says he will "work hard" to unify party after primary
* Yesterday's stories

Visit our advertisers...








* Lack of exciting Democratic candidates could gi.....
* Let's make Pritzker and Rauner pay more—a lot m.....
* Morning Spin: 8 things to watch when primary el.....
* Five Questions Illinois Voters Will Answer on T.....
* Illinois primary: 5 things to watch - Politico..
* Primary day in Illinois: Will moderates bite th.....
* Famous names face off in historically expensive.....
* On election eve, State Farm IT job cuts on the .....
* Cook County Assessor: Follow Democratic Primary.....
* Illinois primary could set up most expensive go.....

* New safety system will change schedule in BNSF Line trains
* Brother of murder suspect charged with gun trafficking
* Trial begins for man accused in shooting death of teacher
* Southern Illinois man pleads guilty to bank fraud charges
* Rockford proposing new video gaming fees
* Couple dies after crash into suburban Chicago retention pond
* Benedictine University seeks selling campus as 1 parcel
* For menopause sex discomfort, gel worked as well as hormone
* Illinois seeks plans for closed Lake Shelbyville resort
* Hikers find crashed car in suburban Chicago with body inside

* Candidates scramble to finish line as Election Day arrives
* Candidates for Illinois governor spend $65.7 million on TV ads –– just for the primaries
* Security of state voter rolls a concern as primaries begin
* As primaries loom, downstate Democrats look for a way back
* Pritzker defends putting $69.5 million of his fortune into campaign
* Illinois governor race more fierce, costly as primary nears
* Madigan backs Dem central committee incumbent in 13th
* Trump factor looms large in Illinois governor primary campaigns
* Ray LaHood brokers deal for O'Hare expansion

* Ferro accused of sexual misconduct: report
* McDonald's wants to end potential landmark workplace case
* Is tomorrow the day of reckoning for Mike Madigan?
* Ferro exits Trib parent after tumultuous tenure

* Ferro exits Trib parent after tumultuous tenure

* Drunk driver threatens police after arrest in Riverside
* St. Patrick’s Day sober driving campaign leads to 194 citations in Evanston
* Dear Abby: Man makes a habit of raping his wife
* Police involved in SWAT incident in Rogers Park
* Jon Lester pitches into seventh in spring win, looks ready for opener
* Horoscope for March 20, 2018
* Persons of interest being questioned about armed-robbery spree on Northwest Side
* Police warn of recent Belmont Central robberies
* Trial begins for man accused in shooting death of teacher
* Cubs reliever Pedro Strop makes spring debut, says he’ll be ready for season

* Package believed to be bound for Austin explodes at Texas FedEx facility, police say
* Morning Spin: 8 things to watch when primary election results come in Tuesday night
* Granddaughter's middle name leaves gram out
* Lack of exciting Democratic candidates could give us another four years of Rauner
* A break from politics after Tuesday? Get real. Rahm needs to find some votes
* Hourslong SWAT incident ongoing in Rogers Park
* Winter storm forces altered travel plans for NCAA Tournament
* Go Away With ... Alex and Maia Shibutani
* Jon Lester on Cubs' outlook as spring training winds down: 'I like where we're at'
* US alliance with Turkey is worth preserving

» March 19, 2018 - Full Show
» Two Woman Accuse Former Tronc Chairman Michael Ferro Of Sexual Misconduct
» Two Women Accuse Former Tronc Chairman Michael Ferro Of Sexual Misconduct
» New Book Highlights Important African American Women In Chicago History
» What’s A Democratic Ward Organization?
» Primary Day Is Tomorrow: The Gubernatorial Candidates, Fact-Checking, And Your Voting Rights
» A Feisty Debate, Offshore Accounts — And Some Side-Eye
» WBEZ’s Chicago and Illinois News Roundup: March 16, 2018
» The Week in Review: Pritzker Slammed Over Offshore Holdings
» Web Extra, The Week in Review: American Airlines Changes Stance

* Candidates scramble to finish line as Election Day arrives
* EJ Dionne: The principle behind anti-Trump pragmatism
* Candidates for Illinois governor spend $65.7 million on TV ads –– just for the primaries
* George Will: Freedom of speech includes the right to remain silent
* Security of state voter rolls a concern as primaries begin
* As primaries loom, downstate Democrats look for a way back
* Pritzker defends putting $69.5 million of his fortune into campaign
* Statehouse Insider: Sadly, the primary campaign is coming to an end
* Bernard Schoenburg: My predictions for Tuesday's primary election
* Our View: A recap of The State Journal-Register’s endorsements

* Rick's Six: Island restoration, Election Day in Illinois, and I-74 bridge update
* Area Calendar 3/20/18
* Reginal William Barrett
* Orvel Dean Layne
* Dennis Ray Serena
* Edith Adair Minckler
* Herbert Korando
* Mary Ellen Dare
* Charles Wayne Goforth
* Mary Belle Osman Morgan

* Emboldened Xi lays out vision for China, warning for Taiwan
* Islamabad still mulling Kabul's offer of talks, overtures
* Catholic Charities, Purdue extension harvest first crop
* Crash marks 1st death involving fully autonomous vehicle
* Dodgers 3B Justin Turner breaks left wrist on HBP

* Democrats say Trump associate may have mis...
* Clemson men's basketball a No. 5 seed in N...
* Letter: Time to oust LaHood
* Rodriguez would be good member of US House
* Security Video Shows Attackers Picking Thr...
* Who is with whom in the Illinois primaries?
* Aurora-area voters to decide on referendum...
* Progressives look to continue gains on Ill...
* Aurora-area voters to decide on referendum...
* Morning Spin: 8 things to watch when prima...

* 'Chain Migration' Used to Be a Benign Term......
* Shutdown looming, Congress and White House......
* Congress and White House seek budget deal ......
* Sens. Dick Durbin, Lindsey Graham Warn Tru......
* Sens. Dick Durbin, Lindsay Graham Warn Tru......

* Sen. Tammy Duckworth on being the first se......
* Sen. Tammy Duckworth on being 1st senator ......
* Zinke defends use of Japanese word: How co......
* Congolese mother and child finally reunite......
* Schatz to convene field hearing on false m......

* Let’s make Pritzker and Rauner pay more—a lot more—in state income taxes
* In honor of Pi(e) Day, here's a true, crusty classic
* A Reader guide to the 2018 primary: Just hold your nose and vote already
* Dayton electronic experimentalist Seth Graham combines the materials of musique concrete with the jumbled flow of glitch
* Event | Celebrating And Contextualizing Queer Fashion
* The Man Who Made March Madness A Monster Moneymaker
* Chicago's King Of Bar Mitzvahs
* Windy City Rollers Season Opener!
* What's going on in Austin, Texas
* Next election cycles already begun, even though this one ain’t over yet!

* February Flooding Information
* IEMA Urges People to Prepare for Severe Weather
* Governor issues state disaster proclamation for flooding in Iroquois, Kankakee, Vermilion Counties
* Winter Storm Warnings for Areas Along and North of I-80
* IEMA Encourages People to Prepare for Earthquakes

* How immersive technology will change the way we learn
* Official Xiaomi Mi Mix 2s photos: where’s the selfie camera?
* T-Mobile’s parent company lets customers opt-out of bloatware
* HTC Desire 12 comes with 2:1 5.5-inch screen, larger Desire 12+ also features dual cameras
* HTC Desire 12 and Desire 12+ debut with tall screens, attractive prices
* IBM’s Watson Assistant lets any company build Alexa-like voice interfaces
* Trump bans Venezuela's cryptocurrency Petro in the US

* Fulmer brimming with confidence
* White Sox pummel Diamondbacks just one day after, well, getting pum...
* Abreu embracing grind of Spring Training
* Fulmer's gem leads top prospects
* White Sox special event uniforms unveiled
* Spring Stats Glance
* Sox outclassed, 14-0, in howlingly bad effort at A’s

Main Menu
Pundit rankings
Subscriber Content
Blagojevich Trial
Updated Posts

March 2018
February 2018
January 2018
December 2017
November 2017
October 2017
September 2017
August 2017
July 2017
June 2017
May 2017
April 2017
March 2017
February 2017
January 2017
December 2016
November 2016
October 2016
September 2016
August 2016
July 2016
June 2016
May 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005


RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0

Hosted by MCS SUBSCRIBE to Capitol Fax Advertise Here Mobile Version Contact Rich Miller